Will Ivy Kill Trees? (5 Key Arborist Tips for Safe Removal)

The scent of woodsmoke always takes me back. Back to crisp autumn days spent with my grandfather, a man whose hands knew the language of trees better than most folks know their own mother tongue. He taught me the value of a well-split log, the respect owed to a standing oak, and the quiet satisfaction of a winter’s woodpile stacked high and ready. He also taught me about the silent struggles that happen in the woods, the battles for sunlight and nutrients, the slow creep of ivy.

“Will ivy kill trees?” That’s a question I’ve heard asked countless times around the wood stove, in logging camps, and even in online forums. The short answer is: it can. But, like most things in the natural world, the reality is nuanced. As an arborist and someone who’s spent a good chunk of my life wrestling with wood, I’ve developed a few key strategies for dealing with ivy infestations. I want to share those with you, along with some technical know-how, to help you protect your trees and keep your woodlots healthy.

Understanding the Enemy: Ivy and Its Impact

Let’s get down to brass tacks. What is it about ivy that makes it a potential tree killer? It’s not that ivy is inherently malicious; it’s just playing the game of survival, but its strategies can have devastating consequences.

The Mechanics of Ivy Damage

• Smothering: Ivy, particularly English Ivy ( Hedera helix), is an aggressive climber. It uses aerial rootlets to latch onto tree bark, and as it grows, it forms a dense mat of foliage. This mat can block sunlight from reaching the tree’s leaves, especially in the lower canopy. Over time, this reduced sunlight exposure can weaken the tree, reducing its ability to photosynthesize and produce energy.

  • Data Point: Research from Oregon State University showed that heavy ivy infestations can reduce photosynthesis in the lower canopy of Douglas fir trees by up to 60%.

  • Weight Burden: A mature ivy vine can become incredibly heavy, especially when wet or covered in snow. This added weight puts stress on the tree’s branches, making them more susceptible to breakage, particularly during storms.

  • Specification: A single mature ivy vine can weigh hundreds of pounds.

  • Moisture Retention: The dense ivy foliage traps moisture against the tree bark, creating a humid environment that encourages fungal growth and decay. This can lead to wood rot and weaken the tree’s structural integrity.

  • Material Specification: Wood moisture content above 20% is considered ideal for fungal growth. Ivy can maintain moisture levels above this threshold for extended periods.

  • Competition for Resources: While ivy doesn’t directly steal nutrients from the tree’s roots, it does compete for water and minerals in the soil. In already stressed trees, this added competition can be the final straw.
  • Harboring Pests: Ivy provides shelter for various pests, including insects and rodents, which can further damage the tree.

Identifying the Culprit: Common Ivy Species

Knowing your enemy is half the battle. Here are some of the most common ivy species that pose a threat to trees:

• English Ivy (Hedera helix): The most notorious offender, known for its aggressive growth and dense foliage. It’s easily identified by its lobed leaves and aerial rootlets.
• Poison Ivy (Toxicodendron radicans): While not a true ivy, it’s often mistaken for one. Contact with its leaves, stems, or roots can cause a severe allergic reaction due to the presence of urushiol oil. Remember “leaves of three, let it be.”
• Boston Ivy (Parthenocissus tricuspidata): Less aggressive than English Ivy, but can still cause problems by adding weight and blocking sunlight. It’s identified by its three-lobed leaves and tendrils with adhesive pads.

Key Arborist Tips for Safe Ivy Removal

Now that we understand the threat, let’s get to the practical stuff. Here are my top five tips for safely and effectively removing ivy from trees, based on years of experience and a healthy respect for both trees and tools.

1. The Cut-and-Wait Method: A Slow and Steady Approach

This is my preferred method for most situations, especially when dealing with large, mature trees. It’s less stressful on the tree and minimizes the risk of damage.

• The Process:

  1. Cut the Ivy at the Base: Using loppers, pruning saws or even a chainsaw (carefully!), cut the ivy vines completely around the base of the tree. Aim for a section about 6-12 inches wide, removing all the ivy from this band.
     • Tool Requirement: Sharp loppers or a pruning saw are essential. For larger vines, a chainsaw might be necessary, but exercise extreme caution to avoid damaging the tree bark. I personally use a Stihl MS 261 C-M for this type of work; it’s powerful enough for most vines but still maneuverable.
  2. Remove a Section Higher Up: Repeat the cutting process higher up the tree, ideally 6-10 feet above the ground. This creates a “dead zone” of ivy that will eventually dry out and die.
  3. Wait and Observe: This is the crucial part. Over the next several months, the ivy above the cut will gradually die back. The leaves will turn brown, and the vines will become brittle.
  4. Remove Dead Ivy (Optional): Once the ivy is completely dead, you can choose to remove it from the tree. This is often easier than trying to remove live ivy, as the dead vines are less firmly attached. However, be careful not to damage the tree bark during removal. In some cases, it’s best to leave the dead ivy in place, as it will eventually decompose and provide habitat for insects and other wildlife.

• Why it Works: By cutting the ivy at the base, you sever its connection to the roots, effectively starving the upper portions of the vine. The “dead zone” prevents the ivy from re-establishing a connection with the ground.

• Technical Considerations:
  • Timing: The best time to cut ivy is during the dormant season (late fall or winter) when the tree is not actively growing. This minimizes stress on the tree.
  • Vine Size: For very large vines (over 2 inches in diameter), you may need to use a chainsaw. Always wear appropriate safety gear, including eye protection, hearing protection, and gloves.
  • Bark Protection: Be extremely careful not to damage the tree bark when cutting the ivy. Use a sharp tool and avoid applying excessive force.
• Personal Story: I remember one particular project where a massive English ivy vine had completely engulfed a beautiful old oak tree. The homeowner was understandably worried about the tree’s health. We used the cut-and-wait method, and after about a year, the ivy had completely died back. The oak tree rebounded beautifully, and its crown filled out with new growth. It was a testament to the power of patience and a gentle approach.

2. The Pull-Down Method: When Speed is of the Essence

This method involves physically pulling the ivy off the tree. It’s faster than the cut-and-wait method, but it also carries a higher risk of damaging the tree bark.

• The Process:

  1. Loosen the Ivy: Start by loosening the ivy vines from the tree bark. You can use a pry bar, a flathead screwdriver, or even your hands. Be careful not to damage the bark in the process.
  2. Pull Downward: Once the ivy is loosened, pull it downward, away from the tree. Use a steady, even force. Avoid jerking or yanking, as this can tear the bark.
  3. Remove Rootlets: After removing the ivy, you’ll likely be left with numerous aerial rootlets clinging to the bark. These can be difficult to remove, but it’s important to do so to prevent the ivy from re-establishing. Use a stiff brush or a scraper to remove the rootlets.
  4. Dispose of Ivy: Dispose of the ivy properly to prevent it from re-rooting and spreading. You can compost it, burn it (where permitted), or dispose of it in a landfill.

• When to Use It: This method is best suited for young trees with smooth bark or for situations where the ivy infestation is relatively light.

• Technical Considerations:
  • Bark Sensitivity: Avoid using this method on trees with thin or sensitive bark, such as birch or maple.
  • Tool Selection: Choose your tools carefully. A dull pry bar can do more harm than good.
  • Safety: Wear gloves to protect your hands from thorns and irritants.
• Cautionary Tale: I once tried to use the pull-down method on an old apple tree with very fragile bark. In my eagerness to get the ivy off quickly, I ended up tearing off large chunks of bark. The tree survived, but it was definitely a learning experience. I now approach this method with much more caution and respect.

3. The Chemical Warfare Approach: Herbicides as a Last Resort

I generally avoid using herbicides unless absolutely necessary. They can have unintended consequences on the environment and can harm beneficial insects and other wildlife. However, in some cases, herbicides may be the only effective way to control a severe ivy infestation.

• The Process:

  1. Choose the Right Herbicide: Select an herbicide that is specifically labeled for ivy control and is safe for use around trees. Glyphosate-based herbicides are often effective, but they can also harm non-target plants if applied carelessly. Triclopyr is another option that is more selective for woody plants.
     • Material Specification: Always read and follow the manufacturer’s instructions carefully. Use the recommended application rate and wear appropriate personal protective equipment (PPE), including gloves, eye protection, and a respirator.
  2. Apply the Herbicide: There are several ways to apply herbicides to ivy:
     • Foliar Spray: Spray the herbicide directly onto the ivy leaves. This is most effective when the ivy is actively growing.
     • Cut-Stem Treatment: Cut the ivy vines at the base and apply the herbicide directly to the cut stems. This is a more targeted approach that minimizes the risk of harming non-target plants.
     • Basal Bark Treatment: Apply the herbicide to the lower portion of the ivy vines, near the base of the tree. This is effective for controlling ivy that is growing close to the ground.
  3. Monitor and Reapply: Monitor the treated ivy for signs of dieback. You may need to reapply the herbicide several times to achieve complete control.

• When to Use It: This method is best suited for large, established ivy infestations that are difficult to control with manual methods.

• Technical Considerations:
  • Weather Conditions: Avoid applying herbicides on windy days or when rain is expected, as this can cause the herbicide to drift and harm non-target plants.
  • Tree Sensitivity: Be careful not to get herbicide on the tree’s bark or leaves, as this can damage the tree.
  • Environmental Impact: Consider the potential environmental impact of using herbicides. Choose the least toxic option and apply it carefully to minimize the risk of contamination.
• Ethical Dilemma: I once faced a situation where a homeowner insisted on using a very strong herbicide to kill the ivy on their property, despite my warnings about the potential risks. I ultimately refused to apply the herbicide, as I felt it was unethical to use a product that could harm the environment and potentially damage the trees. It was a difficult decision, but I stood by my principles.

4. The Sunlight Strategy: Depriving Ivy of Its Life Source

This method focuses on depriving the ivy of sunlight by cutting it at the base and removing a section of the vine. It’s a variation of the cut-and-wait method, but with a greater emphasis on sunlight deprivation.

• The Process:

  1. Cut the Ivy at the Base: As with the cut-and-wait method, start by cutting the ivy vines completely around the base of the tree.
  2. Remove a Larger Section: Remove a larger section of the ivy vine, ideally several feet wide. This creates a larger “dead zone” and allows more sunlight to reach the tree’s leaves.
  3. Prune Overhanging Branches: If the ivy is growing up into the tree’s crown, prune any overhanging branches that are blocking sunlight.
  4. Monitor and Maintain: Monitor the ivy for signs of regrowth. If necessary, reapply the cut-and-wait method or use herbicides to control any new growth.

• Why it Works: By cutting the ivy at the base and removing a larger section of the vine, you deprive the ivy of both water and sunlight. This weakens the ivy and makes it more susceptible to other control methods.

• Technical Considerations:
  • Tree Species: This method is particularly effective for trees that are shade-intolerant, such as pines and larches.
  • Sunlight Exposure: Consider the amount of sunlight that the tree receives. If the tree is already growing in a shady location, this method may not be as effective.
  • Pruning Techniques: Use proper pruning techniques to avoid damaging the tree. Make clean cuts at the branch collar and avoid removing more than 25% of the tree’s crown in a single year.
    • Industry Standard: ANSI A300 pruning standards provide detailed guidelines for proper pruning practices.
• AHA Moment: I realized the power of the sunlight strategy when I noticed that ivy growing on the south side of a tree was much more vigorous than ivy growing on the north side. The difference was simply the amount of sunlight that the ivy received.

5. The Community Approach: Enlisting Help and Sharing Knowledge

Removing ivy from trees can be a daunting task, especially if you have a large property or a severe infestation. Enlisting the help of your neighbors, friends, or local community groups can make the job much easier.

• The Process:

  1. Organize a Work Party: Invite your neighbors, friends, or members of a local community group to help you remove ivy from your trees.
  2. Provide Training and Equipment: Provide training on safe and effective ivy removal techniques. Supply the necessary equipment, such as loppers, pruning saws, gloves, and eye protection.
  3. Share Knowledge and Resources: Share your knowledge and resources with others. This can help to raise awareness about the dangers of ivy and encourage others to take action.
  4. Celebrate Success: Celebrate your success with a potluck or other social gathering. This can help to build community and foster a sense of shared accomplishment.

• Why it Works: By working together, you can accomplish much more than you could alone. You can also share the burden of the work and make it more enjoyable.

• Technical Considerations:
  • Liability: Be sure to have adequate insurance coverage to protect yourself from liability in case someone is injured during the work party.
  • Communication: Communicate clearly with your volunteers about the goals of the project and the safety precautions that need to be followed.
  • Coordination: Coordinate the work party to ensure that everyone is working together effectively.
• Community Project: I was involved in a community project to remove ivy from a local park. We organized a series of work parties, and over the course of several months, we were able to clear the ivy from hundreds of trees. It was a great example of how a community can come together to protect its natural resources.

Beyond Removal: Preventing Future Infestations

The best way to deal with ivy is to prevent it from becoming a problem in the first place. Here are a few tips for preventing future ivy infestations:

• Monitor Your Trees Regularly: Inspect your trees regularly for signs of ivy growth. The earlier you catch an infestation, the easier it will be to control.
• Remove Ivy Seedlings: Remove any ivy seedlings that you find growing near your trees. This will prevent them from establishing and climbing up the trees.
• Create a Barrier: Create a physical barrier around the base of your trees to prevent ivy from climbing up. You can use a section of metal flashing or plastic sheeting.
• Plant Native Groundcovers: Plant native groundcovers around your trees to compete with the ivy. This will help to suppress ivy growth and provide habitat for beneficial insects and other wildlife.
  • Data Point: Studies have shown that native groundcovers can reduce ivy growth by up to 50%.

The Enduring Lesson

Dealing with ivy is a constant battle, but it’s a battle worth fighting. Protecting our trees is essential for maintaining healthy ecosystems and preserving the beauty of our natural world. And, like my grandfather always said, “A little elbow grease and a sharp axe can move mountains, or at least keep the ivy at bay.” His words, and the lessons learned beside him in the woods, continue to guide me in my work today. Remember to respect the power of nature, use your tools wisely, and never underestimate the importance of a good pair of gloves. Now, get out there and give those trees a fighting chance!

Learn more