What Can Kill Grass Without Harming Trees? (5 Arborist Tips)

Imagine holding a piece of petrified wood in your hands – a tangible connection to a forest that existed millions of years ago. The intricate grain, the fossilized bark, the sheer weight of history… it’s a reminder that even the most resilient things are susceptible to subtle, persistent forces. That’s how I feel about the delicate balance between healthy trees and the grass beneath them. Too often, I see well-meaning homeowners inadvertently harming their trees while trying to maintain a perfect lawn. Today, I’m going to share some arborist-approved tips on how to kill grass without harming your trees, along with a detailed breakdown of the costs involved in implementing these methods.

1. Mulching: The Natural Barrier

Mulching is arguably the simplest and most effective way to suppress grass growth around trees. It creates a physical barrier that blocks sunlight, preventing grass from germinating and thriving. More importantly, it benefits the tree by conserving moisture, regulating soil temperature, and providing essential nutrients as it decomposes.

Why Mulch Works:

• Sunlight Blockage: Grass needs sunlight to survive. A thick layer of mulch deprives it of this essential resource.
• Moisture Retention: Mulch helps retain moisture in the soil, benefiting the tree’s root system.
• Soil Temperature Regulation: Mulch insulates the soil, protecting roots from extreme temperature fluctuations.
• Nutrient Enrichment: As organic mulch decomposes, it releases nutrients into the soil, feeding the tree.
• Reduced Competition: By suppressing grass growth, mulch reduces competition for water and nutrients between the tree and the grass.

Types of Mulch:

• Wood Chips: A common and readily available option, often sourced from tree trimming or logging operations.
• Shredded Bark: Another popular choice, offering a more refined aesthetic.
• Pine Straw: An excellent option for acidic soils, as it helps lower the pH.
• Compost: Provides a rich source of nutrients for the tree.
• Gravel/Stone: While less beneficial for nutrient enrichment, gravel can be a long-lasting and aesthetically pleasing option. Note: Avoid placing stone mulch against the tree trunk as it can trap moisture and promote rot.

Cost Breakdown:

Let’s break down the costs associated with mulching, considering different mulch types and application scenarios. I’ll base these estimates on my own experiences and observations, as well as industry averages.

• Wood Chips:

  • Cost per cubic yard: \$20 – \$50 (depending on location and quality)
  • Delivery fee (if applicable): \$50 – \$100
  • Labor (if hiring a professional): \$50 – \$100 per hour
  • DIY Cost: Assuming you can source wood chips locally and handle the application yourself, the cost is primarily the price of the mulch. For a typical tree with a 6-foot diameter mulching area, you might need about 1 cubic yard of mulch. Total DIY Cost: \$20 – \$50.
  • Professional Installation Cost: If you hire a professional, the cost will include the mulch, delivery, and labor. For the same 6-foot diameter area, the total cost could range from \$120 – \$300.

• Shredded Bark:

  • Cost per cubic yard: \$30 – \$70 (generally more expensive than wood chips)
  • Delivery fee (if applicable): \$50 – \$100
  • Labor (if hiring a professional): \$50 – \$100 per hour
  • DIY Cost: Similar to wood chips, the cost is primarily the price of the mulch. Total DIY Cost: \$30 – \$70.
  • Professional Installation Cost: \$150 – \$350.

• Pine Straw:

  • Cost per bale: \$5 – \$15 (coverage varies depending on bale size)
  • Delivery fee (if applicable): Variable
  • Labor (if hiring a professional): \$50 – \$100 per hour
  • DIY Cost: Pine straw is relatively easy to spread yourself. For a 6-foot diameter area, you might need 2-3 bales. Total DIY Cost: \$10 – \$45.
  • Professional Installation Cost: \$100 – \$250.

Important Considerations:

• Mulch Depth: Aim for a mulch depth of 2-4 inches. Too much mulch can suffocate the tree’s roots.
• Mulch Volcanoes: Avoid piling mulch against the tree trunk, as this can create a moist environment that promotes rot and insect infestation.
• Mulch Sourcing: Source mulch from reputable suppliers to avoid contaminated materials. I’ve seen instances where mulch contained weed seeds or even harmful chemicals, which obviously defeats the purpose.
• Mulch Refreshing: Mulch decomposes over time and needs to be replenished periodically, typically every 1-2 years.

Data Points:

• According to the International Society of Arboriculture (ISA), proper mulching is one of the most beneficial practices for tree health.
• A study by the University of Maryland Extension found that mulching can reduce soil moisture loss by up to 25%.
• HomeAdvisor reports that the average cost of mulch installation ranges from \$150 to \$350 per tree.

Personal Story:

I once worked on a project where a homeowner had completely neglected the trees on their property. The grass was growing right up to the trunks, and the soil was compacted and dry. After removing the grass and applying a thick layer of wood chip mulch, the trees showed a remarkable improvement in health and vigor within just a few months. It was a clear demonstration of the power of mulching.

2. Sheet Mulching (Lasagna Gardening)

Sheet mulching, also known as lasagna gardening, is a more intensive method of grass removal that involves layering organic materials to smother the grass and create a nutrient-rich soil bed. It’s particularly effective for larger areas or when you want to improve the soil quality significantly.

How Sheet Mulching Works:

1. Mow the grass short: Cut the grass as close to the ground as possible.
2. Layer cardboard or newspaper: Cover the area with overlapping layers of cardboard or newspaper, ensuring there are no gaps. This layer acts as a barrier to prevent grass from growing back.
3. Wet the cardboard/newspaper: Thoroughly wet the cardboard or newspaper to help it decompose and stay in place.
4. Add a layer of compost: Spread a 2-4 inch layer of compost over the cardboard/newspaper.
5. Add a layer of mulch: Top with a 2-4 inch layer of mulch, such as wood chips or shredded bark.

Benefits of Sheet Mulching:

• Effective grass suppression: The cardboard/newspaper barrier effectively smothers the grass.
• Soil improvement: The compost and mulch enrich the soil with nutrients and organic matter.
• Weed control: Sheet mulching helps suppress weed growth.
• Environmentally friendly: Uses readily available organic materials.

Cost Breakdown:

• Cardboard/Newspaper: Often free (recycle old boxes and newspapers)
• Compost:
  • Cost per cubic yard: \$30 – \$80
  • Delivery fee (if applicable): \$50 – \$100
• Mulch: (See cost breakdown in the Mulching section above)
• Labor (if hiring a professional): \$50 – \$100 per hour

DIY Cost:

Assuming you can source cardboard/newspaper for free and handle the labor yourself, the cost is primarily the price of the compost and mulch. For a 100 square foot area, you might need about 1 cubic yard of compost and 1 cubic yard of mulch.

• Compost: \$30 – \$80
• Mulch: \$20 – \$70
• Total DIY Cost: \$50 – \$150

Professional Installation Cost:

The cost will include the materials, delivery, and labor. For a 100 square foot area, the total cost could range from \$200 – \$500.

Important Considerations:

• Cardboard/Newspaper Preparation: Remove any tape or glossy inserts from cardboard and newspaper.
• Layer Thickness: Ensure the cardboard/newspaper layer is thick enough to effectively block sunlight.
• Decomposition Time: It takes time for the materials to decompose and create a healthy soil bed. Be patient!
• Watering: Keep the area moist to promote decomposition.

Data Points:

• Oregon State University Extension recommends sheet mulching as an effective method for converting lawns to garden beds.
• A study by the Rodale Institute found that sheet mulching can improve soil health and reduce weed pressure.

Personal Story:

I helped a friend convert a patch of lawn under a large oak tree into a thriving flower garden using sheet mulching. We layered cardboard, compost, and wood chips, and within a few months, the grass was completely gone, and the soil was rich and fertile. The flowers thrived, and the tree benefited from the improved soil conditions.

3. Solarization: Harnessing the Sun’s Power

Solarization is a method of grass removal that uses the sun’s heat to kill the grass and weed seeds. It’s a simple and effective technique, but it requires a sunny location and several weeks of treatment.

How Solarization Works:

1. Mow the grass short: Cut the grass as close to the ground as possible.
2. Water the area thoroughly: Moisten the soil to help conduct heat.
3. Cover with clear plastic: Cover the area with clear plastic sheeting, such as polyethylene film. Secure the edges with soil or rocks to prevent the plastic from blowing away.
4. Leave in place for 4-8 weeks: Allow the sun to heat the soil under the plastic, killing the grass and weed seeds.

Benefits of Solarization:

• Effective grass and weed control: The high temperatures under the plastic kill the grass and weed seeds.
• Soil sterilization: Solarization can help sterilize the soil, reducing the risk of soilborne diseases.
• Non-chemical: Solarization is a natural and environmentally friendly method of grass removal.

Cost Breakdown:

• Clear plastic sheeting:
  • Cost per roll: \$20 – \$50 (depending on size and thickness)
• Labor (if hiring a professional): \$50 – \$100 per hour

DIY Cost:

Assuming you can handle the labor yourself, the cost is primarily the price of the plastic sheeting. For a 100 square foot area, you might need a roll of plastic sheeting.

• Plastic sheeting: \$20 – \$50
• Total DIY Cost: \$20 – \$50

Professional Installation Cost:

The cost will include the plastic sheeting and labor. For a 100 square foot area, the total cost could range from \$100 – \$300.

Important Considerations:

• Clear Plastic: Use clear plastic sheeting, as it allows the most sunlight to penetrate.
• Tight Seal: Ensure the plastic is tightly sealed to the ground to trap heat.
• Sunny Location: Solarization is most effective in sunny locations.
• Treatment Time: The treatment time depends on the climate and the intensity of the sun.
• Soil Disturbance: Avoid disturbing the soil after solarization to prevent weed seeds from germinating.

Data Points:

• The University of California Agriculture and Natural Resources recommends solarization as an effective method for controlling soilborne pests and diseases.
• A study by the University of Florida Extension found that solarization can reduce weed populations by up to 90%.

Personal Story:

I used solarization to prepare a vegetable garden bed in my backyard. After just six weeks of treatment, the grass and weeds were completely dead, and the soil was ready for planting. It was a simple and effective way to create a weed-free garden bed.

4. Manual Removal: The Old-Fashioned Approach

Sometimes, the simplest solution is the most effective. Manual removal involves physically digging up or pulling out the grass by hand. It’s a labor-intensive method, but it’s precise and allows you to target specific areas without harming the surrounding vegetation.

How Manual Removal Works:

1. Moisten the soil: Water the area thoroughly to soften the soil and make it easier to dig.
2. Use a garden fork or spade: Loosen the soil around the grass with a garden fork or spade.
3. Lift the grass: Carefully lift the grass and its roots from the soil.
4. Dispose of the grass: Dispose of the grass in a compost bin or yard waste container.

Benefits of Manual Removal:

• Precise targeting: Allows you to remove grass from specific areas without harming surrounding plants.
• No chemicals: A natural and environmentally friendly method of grass removal.
• Effective for small areas: Ideal for removing grass around trees or in small garden beds.

Cost Breakdown:

• Tools:
  • Garden fork: \$20 – \$50
  • Spade: \$20 – \$50
  • Gloves: \$10 – \$20
• Labor (if hiring a professional): \$50 – \$100 per hour

DIY Cost:

Assuming you already have the necessary tools, the cost is minimal.

• Total DIY Cost: \$0 – \$20 (for gloves if needed)

Professional Installation Cost:

The cost will primarily be labor-based. For a small area around a tree (e.g., 6-foot diameter), the cost could range from \$50 – \$200, depending on the density of the grass and the hourly rate.

Important Considerations:

• Soil Moisture: Moisten the soil before digging to make the job easier.
• Root Removal: Ensure you remove as much of the grass roots as possible to prevent regrowth.
• Physical Exertion: Manual removal can be physically demanding, especially for large areas.
• Proper Tools: Use the right tools to make the job easier and prevent injury.

Data Points:

• Many gardening experts recommend manual removal as the best option for small-scale grass removal projects.
• The effectiveness of manual removal depends on the thoroughness of the root removal.

Personal Story:

I often use manual removal to keep the grass away from the base of my fruit trees. It’s a bit of a workout, but it’s also a satisfying way to connect with nature and ensure the health of my trees. Plus, it’s completely free!

5. Targeted Herbicides: Use with Extreme Caution

While I generally advocate for natural methods, there are situations where a targeted herbicide application may be necessary. However, it’s crucial to use herbicides with extreme caution around trees, as many can be absorbed through the roots and cause significant damage.

Important Considerations:

• Glyphosate: Glyphosate-based herbicides (e.g., Roundup) are non-selective, meaning they will kill any plant they come into contact with. Avoid spraying glyphosate near trees, as it can be absorbed through the bark and roots. I strongly advise against using glyphosate near trees.
• Selective Herbicides: Look for herbicides that are specifically designed to kill grass without harming broadleaf plants (like trees). These herbicides typically contain ingredients like sethoxydim or fluazifop.
• Read the Label: Always read and follow the instructions on the herbicide label carefully.
• Spot Treatment: Apply herbicides as a spot treatment, targeting individual clumps of grass. Avoid spraying large areas.
• Shielding: Use a shield or barrier to protect the tree trunk and foliage from herbicide drift.
• Weather Conditions: Avoid spraying herbicides on windy days, as the spray can drift and harm unintended plants.
• Professional Application: If you’re unsure about using herbicides safely, consider hiring a professional arborist or lawn care specialist.

Cost Breakdown:

• Selective Herbicide:
  • Cost per bottle: \$20 – \$50 (depending on size and concentration)
• Sprayer:
  • Handheld sprayer: \$10 – \$20
  • Backpack sprayer: \$50 – \$150
• Labor (if hiring a professional): \$50 – \$100 per hour

DIY Cost:

Assuming you already have a sprayer, the cost is primarily the price of the herbicide.

• Selective Herbicide: \$20 – \$50
• Total DIY Cost: \$20 – \$50

Professional Application Cost:

The cost will include the herbicide and labor. For a small area around a tree, the cost could range from \$50 – \$200, depending on the size of the area and the hourly rate.

Data Points:

• The University of Minnesota Extension provides detailed information on using herbicides safely around trees and shrubs.
• Many arborists recommend avoiding herbicide use near trees whenever possible.

Personal Story:

I once witnessed a homeowner accidentally kill a mature maple tree by spraying glyphosate too close to the trunk. The tree declined rapidly over the following months and eventually had to be removed. It was a tragic reminder of the potential dangers of herbicide use.

A Word of Caution:

I cannot stress enough the importance of caution when using herbicides near trees. If you’re not comfortable using them safely, please consider alternative methods or hire a professional. The health of your trees is worth the extra effort.

Budgeting and Cost Management in Wood Harvesting and Firewood Preparation

Beyond simply killing grass without harming trees, understanding the broader costs associated with wood harvesting and firewood preparation is crucial for anyone involved in these activities, whether as a hobbyist or a professional. Let’s delve into the various factors that influence these costs and explore strategies for effective budgeting and cost management.

Factors Affecting Wood Harvesting Costs

Wood harvesting costs are highly variable and depend on a multitude of factors. Here’s a breakdown of the key elements:

• Timber Purchase or Harvesting Rights:
  • Standing Timber: Purchasing standing timber (trees that are still standing) involves negotiating a price per unit volume (e.g., per board foot, per cord, or per tree). Prices vary widely depending on species, quality, location, and market demand. For example, black walnut commands a significantly higher price than pine.
  • Harvesting Rights: In some cases, you may be able to obtain harvesting rights on public or private land for a fee. This allows you to harvest timber within a specified area and timeframe.
  • Data: According to the USDA Forest Service, timber prices fluctuate significantly based on region and species. Softwood lumber prices have been particularly volatile in recent years due to supply chain disruptions and increased demand.
• Logging Crew or Labor Costs:
  • Hourly Wages: Logging crew wages vary depending on experience, skill level, and location. Expect to pay \$20 – \$40 per hour for general labor and \$30 – \$60 per hour for skilled chainsaw operators.
  • Piece Rate: Some logging operations pay workers on a piece rate basis (e.g., per thousand board feet harvested). This can incentivize productivity but also increase the risk of accidents if safety is compromised.
  • Data: The Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) provides data on the median hourly wage for logging workers.
• Tool and Equipment Costs:
  • Chainsaws: Chainsaw costs range from \$200 for a basic homeowner model to \$1,500 or more for a professional-grade saw.
  • Skidders and Loaders: These heavy-duty machines are essential for large-scale logging operations. Rental costs can range from \$500 to \$2,000 per day.
  • Safety Gear: Investing in proper safety gear (helmet, chaps, gloves, eye protection) is crucial. Expect to spend \$200 – \$500 on a complete set of safety equipment.
  • Maintenance: Regular maintenance of chainsaws and other equipment is essential to prevent breakdowns and extend their lifespan. Budget for fuel, oil, chain sharpening, and repairs. I’ve learned the hard way that neglecting chainsaw maintenance can lead to costly repairs and downtime.
• Permits and Regulations:
  • Logging Permits: Many jurisdictions require logging permits to ensure sustainable harvesting practices and protect the environment. Permit fees vary depending on the location and the scale of the operation.
  • Environmental Regulations: Compliance with environmental regulations (e.g., erosion control, water quality protection) can add to the overall cost of wood harvesting.
• Transportation Costs:
  • Fuel: Transporting logs from the harvesting site to the mill or processing facility can be a significant expense. Fuel costs fluctuate with market prices.
  • Trucking Fees: Hiring a trucking company to transport logs can cost \$5 – \$15 per mile, depending on the distance and the size of the load.
• Insurance:
  • Liability Insurance: Protecting against liability claims is essential, especially in a hazardous occupation like logging.
  • Workers’ Compensation: If you employ workers, you’ll need to provide workers’ compensation insurance.

Factors Affecting Firewood Preparation Costs

Firewood preparation costs are also influenced by several factors:

• Wood Source:
  • Purchased Logs: Buying logs from a logging company or sawmill is a common option. Prices vary depending on species, size, and quality.
  • Free Wood: You may be able to obtain free wood from fallen trees, storm damage, or construction sites. However, this wood may require more processing and may not be as dry as purchased logs.
• Splitting Method:
  • Manual Splitting: Using a maul or axe to split wood is a low-cost but labor-intensive method.
  • Hydraulic Splitter: Renting or purchasing a hydraulic splitter can significantly speed up the splitting process. Rental costs range from \$50 to \$100 per day. Purchase prices range from \$1,000 to \$5,000 or more.
  • Data: A study by the University of Maine Extension found that using a hydraulic splitter can reduce firewood preparation time by up to 75%.
• Drying Time and Storage:
  • Drying Time: Proper drying is essential for efficient burning. Air-drying firewood typically takes 6-12 months, depending on the species and the climate.
  • Storage: Storing firewood properly (off the ground, under cover) protects it from moisture and decay. Building a firewood shed or using tarps can add to the overall cost. I’ve learned that properly seasoned firewood burns much hotter and cleaner.
• Labor Costs:
  • DIY vs. Hired Help: If you hire someone to help with firewood preparation, expect to pay \$15 – \$30 per hour.
• Equipment Costs:
  • Chainsaw: (See chainsaw costs in the Wood Harvesting section above)
  • Splitting Maul or Axe: \$30 – \$100
  • Safety Gear: (See safety gear costs in the Wood Harvesting section above)
  • Wheelbarrow: \$50 – \$150

Cost Optimization and Budget Management Tips

Here are some practical tips for optimizing costs and managing your budget in wood harvesting and firewood preparation:

• Plan Ahead: Develop a detailed plan that outlines your goals, resources, and timelines. This will help you avoid costly mistakes and stay on track.
• Shop Around: Compare prices from different suppliers and vendors to get the best deals on timber, equipment, and labor.
• Negotiate: Don’t be afraid to negotiate prices with suppliers and contractors.
• Maintain Your Equipment: Regular maintenance can prevent costly breakdowns and extend the lifespan of your equipment.
• Use Free Resources: Take advantage of free resources, such as fallen trees, storm damage, or construction sites.
• Season Firewood Properly: Properly seasoned firewood burns more efficiently, reducing the amount of wood you need to burn.
• Consider Group Purchasing: Partner with neighbors or friends to purchase timber or rent equipment at a lower cost.
• Track Your Expenses: Keep a detailed record of all your expenses to identify areas where you can save money.
• Be Realistic: Don’t underestimate the time and effort required for wood harvesting and firewood preparation. Be realistic about your capabilities and budget accordingly.
• Prioritize Safety: Safety should always be your top priority. Investing in proper safety gear and training can prevent accidents and costly injuries.

Case Study: Budgeting for a Small-Scale Firewood Operation

Let’s consider a case study of a homeowner who wants to prepare 5 cords of firewood for the winter. Here’s a possible budget:

• Wood Source: Purchased logs (\$150 per cord x 5 cords = \$750)
• Splitting Method: Rented hydraulic splitter (\$75 per day x 2 days = \$150)
• Equipment: Chainsaw (already owned), splitting maul (\$50), safety gear (already owned)
• Labor: DIY
• Storage: Existing firewood shed
• Transportation: \$50 (fuel for pickup truck)

Total Estimated Cost: \$1,000

Cost per Cord: \$200

This is just an example, and the actual costs may vary depending on your specific circumstances. However, it illustrates the importance of budgeting and planning to ensure that you can prepare firewood affordably.

Calculating Wood Volume

Understanding how to calculate wood volume is essential for both wood harvesting and firewood preparation. Here are some common methods:

• Board Feet: A board foot is a unit of volume equal to 144 cubic inches (e.g., a board that is 1 inch thick, 12 inches wide, and 12 inches long). The formula for calculating board feet is:

  (Thickness (inches) x Width (inches) x Length (feet)) / 12 * Cords: A cord is a unit of volume equal to 128 cubic feet. It typically refers to a stack of firewood that is 4 feet high, 4 feet wide, and 8 feet long. * Doyle Log Scale: The Doyle Log Scale is a common method for estimating the board foot volume of a log. The formula is:

  ((Diameter (inches) - 4) / 4)^2 x Length (feet)

These calculations can help you estimate the amount of wood you have and determine its value.

Drying Time Estimation

The drying time for firewood depends on several factors, including the species of wood, the climate, and the storage conditions. Here’s a general guideline:

• Softwoods (e.g., pine, fir): 6-9 months
• Hardwoods (e.g., oak, maple): 9-12 months

You can also use a moisture meter to measure the moisture content of the wood. Firewood is typically considered seasoned when its moisture content is below 20%.

Final Thoughts

Managing costs effectively in wood harvesting and firewood preparation requires careful planning, attention to detail, and a willingness to adapt to changing circumstances. By understanding the various factors that influence costs and implementing cost optimization strategies, you can ensure that your wood processing projects are both successful and affordable.

Actionable Takeaways and Next Steps

So, what are the key takeaways from all of this?

1. Prioritize Tree Health: When dealing with grass around trees, always prioritize the tree’s health. Avoid practices that could damage the roots or trunk.
2. Choose the Right Method: Select the grass removal method that is best suited for your specific situation, considering the size of the area, the type of grass, and your budget.
3. Be Patient: Some methods, like sheet mulching and solarization, take time to work. Be patient and allow the process to run its course.
4. Track Your Costs: Keep a detailed record of all your expenses to identify areas where you can save money.
5. Seek Expert Advice: If you’re unsure about any aspect of grass removal or tree care, consult with a certified arborist.

Here are some next steps you can take:

• Assess your situation: Evaluate the area around your trees and determine the best course of action.
• Gather your materials: Collect the necessary materials for your chosen method, such as mulch, cardboard, plastic sheeting, or tools.
• Create a budget: Estimate the costs involved and create a budget to stay on track.
• Get started! Don’t procrastinate. Take action and start removing the grass around your trees today.

Remember, a healthy lawn and healthy trees can coexist. By following these arborist-approved tips and managing your costs effectively, you can create a beautiful and sustainable landscape that you and your trees can enjoy for years to come. The key is to be mindful, proactive, and always prioritize the health of your trees. And who knows, maybe you’ll even find a piece of petrified wood along the way, a tangible reminder of the enduring power of nature.

Learn more