Tree Roots Killer Techniques (3 Pro Tips for Complete Removal)

As autumn leaves begin to fall and the scent of woodsmoke fills the air, many of us find ourselves contemplating the aftermath of summer’s growth. One persistent problem I’ve encountered time and again in my years of working with woodlots and landscaping is the stubborn persistence of tree roots. Whether you’re clearing land for a new project, dealing with the unsightly remnants of a felled tree, or battling invasive species, effective tree root removal is crucial. I’ve seen projects stall and landscapes marred by neglecting this vital step. That’s why I want to share my top three pro tips for complete tree root removal, techniques I’ve honed through years of hands-on experience.

Tree Roots Killer Techniques: 3 Pro Tips for Complete Removal

Tree roots can be a significant nuisance, causing damage to property, obstructing construction, and promoting regrowth. Effective removal is essential for long-term solutions, and these techniques will help you achieve just that.

Understanding the Enemy: Tree Root Biology and Why Removal Matters

Before diving into the “how,” let’s quickly touch on the “why” and the “what.” Knowing your enemy is half the battle, and understanding the biology of tree roots will significantly improve your removal efforts.

• What are Tree Roots? Tree roots are the underground extension of a tree, responsible for anchoring the tree, absorbing water and nutrients from the soil, and storing energy. They are not just smaller versions of the trunk; their structure and function are quite different.

• Why Remove Tree Roots?

  • Prevent Regrowth: Some tree species are notorious for sending up new shoots from their roots, leading to unwanted saplings popping up everywhere.
  • Protect Infrastructure: Roots can damage foundations, sidewalks, and underground utilities. I once had to reroute a water line because a persistent willow root had wrapped itself around it.
  • Prepare Land for Construction: Building projects require clear, stable ground. Roots left in place can decompose and create voids, causing settling issues later on.
  • Improve Aesthetics: Unsightly root clumps can ruin the appearance of a landscape.
  • Control Invasive Species: Removing the roots of invasive trees is critical to prevent their spread.

• Root Structure Basics:

  • Taproot: A single, large root that grows straight down (common in some species, but often absent in mature trees).
  • Lateral Roots: Horizontal roots that spread out from the base of the tree. These are the most common and often the biggest problem.
  • Feeder Roots: Small, hair-like roots that absorb water and nutrients.
  • Crown: The area around the base of the tree where the main roots originate.

Pro Tip #1: The Mechanical Advantage: Excavation and Physical Removal

This is the most direct and often the most effective method, especially for larger roots. It involves physically digging out and removing the roots from the ground. I’ve found this method particularly useful when dealing with oak and maple roots, which tend to be quite strong and resilient.

Step-by-Step Guide to Excavation and Physical Removal:

1. Assessment and Planning: Before you start digging, take some time to assess the situation.

   • Identify the Root System: Determine the extent of the root system you need to remove. Look for surface roots and any visible signs of underground roots.
   • Mark the Area: Use marking paint or flags to delineate the area you will be excavating.
   • Check for Utilities: This is absolutely crucial! Call your local utility companies to locate any underground lines before you start digging. Hitting a gas or electrical line can be catastrophic. I cannot stress this enough.
   • Consider the Tree Species: Some species have more aggressive root systems than others. Knowing the species will help you anticipate the size and spread of the roots.
   • Determine Disposal Method: Plan how you will dispose of the removed roots. You can chip them, burn them (where permitted), or haul them away.

2. Gather Your Tools: You’ll need the right tools for the job.

   • Shovels: A variety of shovels is helpful. A pointed shovel is good for breaking ground, while a square shovel is useful for scooping and leveling.
   • Pickaxe or Mattock: For breaking up hard soil and cutting through smaller roots.
   • Root Saw: A specialized saw designed for cutting roots. These saws typically have long, narrow blades with aggressive teeth. I prefer a reciprocating saw with a demolition blade for quicker cuts.
   • Loppers or Pruning Shears: For cutting smaller roots and branches.
   • Chainsaw: For larger roots, a chainsaw is often necessary. Safety is paramount when using a chainsaw. Wear appropriate safety gear (helmet, eye protection, hearing protection, gloves, chaps, and steel-toed boots) and follow all safety guidelines. Choose a chainsaw with a bar length appropriate for the size of the roots you’ll be cutting. A 16-inch bar is usually sufficient for most root removal tasks.
   • Excavator or Backhoe (Optional): For very large root systems or extensive clearing projects, renting an excavator or backhoe can save a lot of time and effort.
   • Wheelbarrow or Cart: For hauling away the excavated soil and roots.
   • Gloves: Protect your hands from dirt, splinters, and blisters.
   • Eye Protection: Safety glasses or goggles are essential to protect your eyes from flying debris.
   • Hearing Protection: Earplugs or earmuffs can prevent hearing damage from power tools.
   • First-Aid Kit: Keep a well-stocked first-aid kit on hand in case of minor injuries.

3. Start Digging:

   • Begin at the Stump or Known Root Area: Start digging around the stump or the area where you know the roots are concentrated.
   • Expose the Roots: Carefully excavate the soil around the roots, exposing them as much as possible.
   • Cut the Roots: Use your root saw, chainsaw, or loppers to cut the roots. Make sure to cut them cleanly to prevent regrowth.
   • Work in Sections: Divide the root system into manageable sections and work on removing one section at a time.
   • Remove the Roots: Once the roots are cut, carefully remove them from the ground. You may need to use a shovel or pickaxe to pry them loose.

4. Dealing with Large Roots:

   • Chainsaw Safety: When using a chainsaw to cut large roots, be extremely careful to avoid kickback. Keep the chain sharp and the saw properly maintained.
   • Cut in Stages: For very large roots, cut them in stages to reduce the risk of the root binding the saw.
   • Use Wedges: If a root is likely to pinch the saw blade, use wedges to keep the cut open.

5. Backfilling and Cleanup:

   • Remove Debris: Remove any remaining roots, rocks, or debris from the excavated area.
   • Backfill with Soil: Backfill the hole with topsoil or fill dirt, compacting it as you go.
   • Level the Ground: Level the ground to match the surrounding area.
   • Dispose of Roots: Dispose of the removed roots according to your plan.

Case Study: My Battle with a Giant Cottonwood

I once had a project where I needed to remove a massive cottonwood tree that had died from disease. The tree itself was a challenge, but the root system was a nightmare. It had spread out over a 30-foot radius and was interwoven with underground utilities.

I started by carefully excavating around the stump, exposing the major roots. Because of the proximity to the utilities, I had to do much of the digging by hand. I used a combination of a pickaxe, shovel, and root saw to cut through the roots. The largest roots were nearly 2 feet in diameter, requiring careful chainsaw work.

To avoid damaging the utilities, I used a technique called “air spading.” This involves using compressed air to blow away the soil around the roots, exposing them without damaging underground lines. It’s a slow process, but it’s much safer than using heavy machinery near utilities.

It took me and a small team nearly a week to completely remove the root system. In the end, we hauled away over 20 cubic yards of roots and soil. The lesson I learned from that project was the importance of patience and meticulous planning when dealing with large tree roots.

Benefits of Excavation and Physical Removal:

• Complete Removal: This method ensures that all roots are removed, preventing regrowth.
• Immediate Results: You’ll see immediate results, as the roots are physically gone.
• Suitable for All Tree Species: This method works for all tree species, regardless of their root structure.

Drawbacks of Excavation and Physical Removal:

• Labor-Intensive: This method can be physically demanding, especially for large root systems.
• Time-Consuming: It can take a significant amount of time to excavate and remove all the roots.
• Potential for Damage: There is a risk of damaging underground utilities if you are not careful.
• Disturbance to the Soil: Excavation can disrupt the soil structure and ecosystem.

Pro Tip #2: Chemical Warfare: Using Herbicides to Kill Roots

While I generally advocate for physical removal, sometimes chemical herbicides are the most practical option, especially for roots that are difficult to reach or when dealing with resprouting species. This involves applying herbicides to the roots to kill them. Always follow the manufacturer’s instructions and safety precautions when using herbicides.

Understanding Herbicides for Root Control:

• Systemic Herbicides: These are absorbed by the plant and translocated throughout the root system, killing the entire plant. Glyphosate and Triclopyr are common systemic herbicides used for root control.
• Contact Herbicides: These kill only the parts of the plant they come into contact with. They are less effective for root control because they don’t translocate throughout the root system.

Step-by-Step Guide to Using Herbicides for Root Control:

1. Choose the Right Herbicide:

   • Glyphosate: Effective for a wide range of tree species. It’s a non-selective herbicide, meaning it will kill any plant it comes into contact with.
   • Triclopyr: More selective than glyphosate, targeting woody plants. It’s a good choice for controlling tree roots in areas where you want to preserve other vegetation.

2. Application Methods:

   • Cut-Stump Treatment: This involves cutting the tree down and applying the herbicide directly to the freshly cut stump. This is a very effective method for preventing regrowth.
     • Cut the Tree: Cut the tree down as close to the ground as possible.
     • Apply Herbicide: Immediately apply the herbicide to the entire cut surface of the stump, focusing on the outer edges (cambium layer).
     • Timing: Apply the herbicide within minutes of cutting the tree, before the stump dries out.
   • Frill-Cut Treatment: This involves making a series of overlapping cuts around the base of the tree and applying the herbicide to the cuts. This method is useful for larger trees that are difficult to cut down.
     • Make Cuts: Use an axe or hatchet to make a series of overlapping cuts around the base of the tree, penetrating the bark and cambium layer.
     • Apply Herbicide: Immediately apply the herbicide to the cuts, saturating the exposed cambium.
     • Spacing: Space the cuts a few inches apart.
   • Basal Bark Treatment: This involves spraying the herbicide directly onto the lower portion of the tree trunk. This method is effective for smaller trees with thin bark.
     • Mix Herbicide: Mix the herbicide with a penetrating oil according to the manufacturer’s instructions.
     • Spray Trunk: Spray the lower 12-18 inches of the tree trunk, ensuring complete coverage.
     • Timing: Apply the herbicide during the dormant season for best results.
   • Soil Application: This involves applying the herbicide directly to the soil around the roots. This method is less precise and can potentially harm other plants in the area. I generally avoid this method unless absolutely necessary.

3. Safety Precautions:

   • Read the Label: Always read and follow the manufacturer’s instructions and safety precautions.
   • Wear Protective Gear: Wear gloves, eye protection, and a respirator when applying herbicides.
   • Avoid Spraying on Windy Days: Wind can carry the herbicide to unintended targets.
   • Protect Water Sources: Avoid applying herbicides near water sources.
   • Store Herbicides Safely: Store herbicides in a secure location, out of reach of children and pets.

Case Study: Battling Buckthorn with Triclopyr

I once worked on a project to restore a woodland area that had been heavily invaded by buckthorn, a highly invasive shrub. Mechanical removal was not feasible due to the density of the infestation and the risk of soil erosion. We decided to use triclopyr herbicide to control the buckthorn.

We used the cut-stump treatment method, cutting down the buckthorn shrubs and immediately applying triclopyr to the cut stumps. We followed the manufacturer’s instructions carefully and wore appropriate protective gear.

Within a few weeks, the treated buckthorn stumps showed signs of dieback. Over the following months, we monitored the area and retreated any stumps that showed signs of regrowth. After a year, the buckthorn infestation was significantly reduced, allowing native plants to recover.

The key to success was the timely application of the herbicide and the consistent monitoring and retreatment of any regrowth.

Benefits of Using Herbicides for Root Control:

• Effective for Resprouting Species: Herbicides can effectively kill roots that are likely to resprout.
• Less Labor-Intensive: Chemical control can be less physically demanding than mechanical removal.
• Suitable for Hard-to-Reach Roots: Herbicides can reach roots that are difficult to excavate.

Drawbacks of Using Herbicides for Root Control:

• Environmental Concerns: Herbicides can have negative impacts on the environment and non-target plants.
• Safety Risks: Herbicides can be harmful to humans and animals if not used properly.
• Delayed Results: It can take weeks or months for the herbicide to kill the roots.
• Resistance: Some tree species can develop resistance to herbicides over time.

Pro Tip #3: The Natural Approach: Decomposition and Biological Control

This method involves encouraging the natural decomposition of the roots or using biological agents to kill them. This is a slower process but can be a more environmentally friendly option. I’ve found it particularly useful for dealing with smaller roots and for improving soil health.

Techniques for Encouraging Decomposition:

1. Adding Nitrogen: Nitrogen is essential for decomposition. Adding nitrogen-rich materials to the soil around the roots can speed up the process.

   • Compost: Compost is a great source of nitrogen and other nutrients.
   • Manure: Aged manure can also be used to add nitrogen to the soil.
   • Nitrogen Fertilizer: A small amount of nitrogen fertilizer can be used, but be careful not to over-fertilize.

2. Improving Soil Moisture: Moisture is also essential for decomposition. Keeping the soil moist around the roots will encourage microbial activity.

   • Watering: Water the area regularly, especially during dry periods.
   • Mulching: Mulching helps to retain moisture in the soil.

3. Aerating the Soil: Aerating the soil improves oxygen availability, which is also important for decomposition.

   • Tilling: Tilling the soil can improve aeration, but be careful not to damage any remaining roots.
   • Aerating Tools: There are specialized tools for aerating the soil without tilling.

4. Introducing Beneficial Microbes:

   • Compost Tea: Applying compost tea to the soil can introduce beneficial microbes that will help to break down the roots.
   • Mycorrhizal Fungi: These fungi form a symbiotic relationship with plant roots, helping them to absorb nutrients and water. They can also help to decompose dead roots.

Biological Control Methods:

1. Using Fungi: Some fungi are known to be pathogenic to tree roots. Introducing these fungi to the soil can help to kill the roots.

   • Armillaria mellea (Honey Fungus): This fungus is a common cause of root rot in many tree species.
   • Heterobasidion annosum (Annosum Root Rot): This fungus is a serious pathogen of conifers.

2. Using Nematodes: Some nematodes are parasitic to tree roots. Introducing these nematodes to the soil can help to control root growth.

Case Study: Composting a Willow Stump

I once had to remove a willow tree from my property. Willow trees are known for their aggressive root systems, and I wanted to find a natural way to deal with the stump and roots.

I decided to try composting the stump in place. I started by cutting the tree down as close to the ground as possible. Then, I drilled several holes into the stump to improve aeration and moisture penetration.

I surrounded the stump with a mixture of compost, manure, and wood chips. I kept the area moist by watering it regularly. Over the next few months, the stump began to decompose. The wood became softer and more easily broken down.

I continued to add compost and manure to the area, and after about a year, the stump had completely decomposed. The soil was rich and fertile, and I was able to plant a new tree in the same spot.

The key to success was providing the right conditions for decomposition: plenty of nitrogen, moisture, and aeration.

Benefits of Decomposition and Biological Control:

• Environmentally Friendly: These methods are generally more environmentally friendly than chemical control.
• Improves Soil Health: Decomposition adds organic matter to the soil, improving its fertility.
• Less Labor-Intensive: These methods require less physical labor than mechanical removal.

Drawbacks of Decomposition and Biological Control:

• Slow Process: Decomposition can take a long time, especially for large roots.
• Less Predictable: The results can be less predictable than with mechanical or chemical control.
• May Not Be Effective for All Tree Species: Some tree species are more resistant to decomposition than others.

Choosing the Right Technique: A Decision Matrix

The best method for tree root removal depends on several factors, including the size and type of roots, the location, the desired speed of removal, and your environmental concerns. Here’s a decision matrix to help you choose the right technique:

Safety First: Essential Precautions for Tree Root Removal

No matter which method you choose, safety should always be your top priority. Here are some essential safety precautions to follow:

• Wear Appropriate Protective Gear: Always wear gloves, eye protection, hearing protection, and sturdy footwear. When using a chainsaw, wear a helmet, chaps, and steel-toed boots.
• Check for Underground Utilities: Call your local utility companies to locate any underground lines before you start digging.
• Work in a Safe Environment: Clear the area of any obstacles or hazards. Make sure you have enough space to work safely.
• Use Tools Properly: Use tools only for their intended purpose and follow the manufacturer’s instructions.
• Be Aware of Your Surroundings: Pay attention to your surroundings and be aware of any potential hazards.
• Take Breaks: Root removal can be physically demanding. Take breaks to avoid fatigue.
• First Aid: Keep a well-stocked first-aid kit on hand in case of minor injuries.
• Emergency Plan: Have an emergency plan in place in case of a serious accident.

Strategic Insights: Long-Term Root Management

Beyond the immediate removal of tree roots, consider a long-term strategy for managing root growth and preventing future problems.

• Choose the Right Tree Species: When planting new trees, choose species that are less likely to cause root problems. Avoid planting trees with aggressive root systems near foundations, sidewalks, or underground utilities.
• Proper Planting Techniques: Plant trees at the correct depth and spacing. This will help to encourage healthy root growth and prevent roots from becoming overcrowded.
• Root Barriers: Install root barriers around trees to prevent their roots from spreading into unwanted areas.
• Regular Pruning: Prune trees regularly to remove dead or damaged branches. This will help to reduce the overall size of the tree and its root system.
• Monitor for Root Problems: Regularly inspect your property for signs of root problems, such as cracks in sidewalks, heaving foundations, or clogged drainpipes. Address any problems early to prevent them from becoming more serious.

A Final Thought: Patience and Persistence

Tree root removal can be a challenging and time-consuming task, but with the right techniques and a little patience, you can successfully remove even the most stubborn roots. Remember to prioritize safety, choose the right method for your situation, and be persistent in your efforts. The results will be well worth the effort, creating a safer, more attractive, and more functional landscape. And always remember, the best time to deal with tree roots is before they become a problem. Planning and prevention are key to long-term success.

Learn more