Stihl MS390 Horsepower vs MS360: Repair Worth It? (Pro Insights)

Investing in a chainsaw, whether it’s for felling trees, bucking logs, or preparing firewood, is a significant decision. When your trusty Stihl MS390 or MS360 starts showing its age, the question of repair versus replacement looms large. The query “Stihl MS390 Horsepower vs MS360: Repair Worth It? (Pro Insights)” suggests a user is grappling with this very dilemma. They want to understand the performance differences between these two models, and more importantly, whether sinking money into repairing their existing saw is a sound financial decision. This article aims to dissect the performance aspects of the MS390 and MS360, delve into the common repair costs, and provide data-driven insights to help you make an informed choice.

Stihl MS390 Horsepower vs MS360: A Deep Dive

Before diving into repair costs, let’s understand the fundamental differences between the Stihl MS390 and MS360. This comparison will help you determine if the performance upgrade (or downgrade) is worth considering as part of your decision.

Horsepower and Engine Displacement

The heart of any chainsaw is its engine. Horsepower (HP) and engine displacement (cc) are key indicators of a saw’s cutting power.

• Stihl MS390: Typically features an engine around 64.1 cc, delivering roughly 4.4 bhp (brake horsepower).
• Stihl MS360: Boasts an engine around 59 cc, producing approximately 4.6 bhp.

Wait a minute! The MS360 has a smaller engine but slightly more horsepower? This is a crucial point. The MS360 is known for its superior power-to-weight ratio and more efficient engine design. While the MS390 packs a larger displacement, the MS360 is often considered the more professional-grade saw due to its responsiveness and overall performance.

Weight and Ergonomics

Weight plays a significant role, especially when you’re spending hours in the woods.

• Stihl MS390: Weighs approximately 13.4 lbs (without the bar and chain).
• Stihl MS360: Weighs around 12.3 lbs (without the bar and chain).

That pound difference might not seem like much, but over a full day of work, it can significantly reduce fatigue. The MS360’s lighter weight, combined with its better balance, often makes it the preferred choice for professionals.

Cutting Performance and Applications

Both saws are suitable for a variety of tasks, but their strengths lie in slightly different areas.

• Stihl MS390: A robust saw well-suited for felling medium-sized trees, cutting firewood, and general property maintenance. Its larger engine provides ample torque for tougher cuts.
• Stihl MS360: Excels in felling larger trees, limbing, and demanding cutting tasks. Its higher power-to-weight ratio and faster chain speed make it more efficient and responsive.

My Experience: I’ve used both saws extensively. For processing firewood from oak and hickory, the MS390 handled the larger diameter logs with ease. However, when felling a stand of pine trees, the MS360’s lighter weight and faster cutting speed made the job significantly less tiring.

Availability and Replacement Parts

The MS390 is generally easier to find as a used model, and parts are often more readily available and potentially cheaper. The MS360, being an older model, might have fewer new parts available, potentially increasing the cost of some repairs.

Common Stihl MS390 and MS360 Repairs: What to Expect

Understanding the typical problems these saws face is crucial for estimating repair costs.

Engine Issues

• Carburetor Problems: A common issue, especially with older saws. Symptoms include difficulty starting, rough idling, and poor performance. Carburetor rebuild kits typically cost between $15 and $30, while a new carburetor can range from $30 to $80.
• Piston and Cylinder Damage: This can occur due to overheating, using incorrect fuel mixtures, or lack of lubrication. Replacing a piston and cylinder can cost between $100 and $300, depending on the extent of the damage and whether you opt for OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) or aftermarket parts.
• Ignition System Problems: Issues with the spark plug, ignition coil, or flywheel can prevent the saw from starting or cause it to run poorly. A new spark plug is inexpensive (around $5), but a new ignition coil can cost between $30 and $70.

Fuel System Issues

• Fuel Line Cracks and Leaks: Fuel lines can become brittle and crack over time, leading to fuel leaks and poor engine performance. Replacing fuel lines is a relatively inexpensive repair, typically costing less than $20.
• Fuel Filter Clogging: A clogged fuel filter can restrict fuel flow to the carburetor, causing the saw to run lean or stall. Replacing a fuel filter is a simple and inexpensive maintenance task, costing only a few dollars.

Bar and Chain Issues

• Worn Sprocket: A worn sprocket can cause the chain to slip or bind, reducing cutting efficiency. Replacing a sprocket typically costs between $15 and $30.
• Damaged Bar: A bent or damaged bar can cause the chain to wear unevenly and make cutting difficult. A new bar can range from $30 to $100, depending on the length and quality.
• Chain Wear: Chains need regular sharpening and eventual replacement. Sharpening can be done at home with a file or professionally for around $10-$15. A new chain typically costs between $20 and $50.

Other Common Repairs

• Recoil Starter Problems: The recoil starter mechanism can fail, making it difficult or impossible to start the saw. Repair kits are available for around $20-$40.
• AV (Anti-Vibration) Mounts: These mounts can wear out over time, increasing vibration and fatigue. Replacing AV mounts typically costs between $20 and $50.

Estimating Repair Costs: A Data-Driven Approach

To determine if repair is worthwhile, you need to estimate the total cost of repairs. This involves considering parts costs, labor costs (if you’re not doing the work yourself), and any potential hidden costs.

Parts Costs

As mentioned earlier, parts costs can vary widely depending on the type of repair and whether you opt for OEM or aftermarket parts. Here’s a breakdown of typical parts costs for common repairs:

Important Note: Aftermarket parts can be a cost-effective alternative to OEM parts, but their quality can vary. Research the brand and read reviews before purchasing aftermarket parts. I’ve had good luck with some aftermarket brands, but I’ve also had some that failed prematurely.

Labor Costs

If you’re not comfortable doing the repairs yourself, you’ll need to factor in labor costs. Chainsaw repair shops typically charge between $50 and $100 per hour for labor. The complexity of the repair will determine the amount of labor required.

• Simple Repairs (e.g., replacing fuel lines, spark plug): 0.5 – 1 hour of labor
• Moderate Repairs (e.g., carburetor rebuild, replacing sprocket): 1 – 2 hours of labor
• Complex Repairs (e.g., piston and cylinder replacement, engine rebuild): 3 – 5 hours of labor

Example: Let’s say you need to replace the piston and cylinder on your MS390. Using OEM parts, the parts cost would be around $200. If the repair shop charges $75 per hour and estimates the job will take 4 hours, the labor cost would be $300. The total repair cost would be $500.

Hidden Costs

Don’t forget to factor in potential hidden costs, such as:

• Diagnostic Fees: Some repair shops charge a diagnostic fee to assess the problem. This fee can range from $25 to $50.
• Taxes and Fees: Sales tax and other fees can add to the total repair cost.
• Unexpected Problems: During the repair process, the technician may discover additional problems that need to be addressed.

New Chainsaw Costs

To make a sound financial decision, you need to compare the estimated repair cost to the cost of a new chainsaw. Here’s a rough price guide:

• Stihl MS391: (The successor to the MS390) typically costs between $600 and $700.
• Stihl MS362 C-M: (A modern equivalent to the MS360) ranges from $750 to $850.
• Comparable Chainsaws from Other Brands: Models from Husqvarna, Echo, and other manufacturers with similar engine sizes and features can range from $500 to $800.

Case Studies: Repair vs. Replace Scenarios

Let’s examine a few hypothetical scenarios to illustrate the decision-making process.

Case Study 1: The Neglected MS390

• Problem: MS390 with a cracked fuel line, clogged carburetor, and worn sprocket.
• Estimated Repair Costs:
  • Fuel line: $15 (parts) + $50 (labor) = $65
  • Carburetor rebuild: $30 (parts) + $75 (labor) = $105
  • Sprocket replacement: $25 (parts) + $50 (labor) = $75
  • Total Repair Cost: $245
• Decision: In this case, repairing the MS390 is likely the more cost-effective option, as the total repair cost is significantly less than the cost of a new chainsaw.

Case Study 2: The Abused MS360

• Problem: MS360 with a scored piston and cylinder, damaged bar, and worn AV mounts.
• Estimated Repair Costs:
  • Piston and cylinder replacement: $250 (parts) + $300 (labor) = $550
  • Bar replacement: $75 (parts) + $25 (labor) = $100
  • AV mount replacement: $40 (parts) + $50 (labor) = $90
  • Total Repair Cost: $740
• Decision: Given the high repair cost, it’s more economical to purchase a new chainsaw, especially considering the potential for other hidden problems.

Case Study 3: The Well-Maintained MS390

• Problem: MS390 with a failing ignition coil.
• Estimated Repair Costs:
  • Ignition coil replacement: $50 (parts) + $50 (labor) = $100
• Decision: Repairing the MS390 is the clear choice, as the repair cost is minimal compared to the cost of a new chainsaw.

Key Factors to Consider

Beyond the pure cost comparison, several other factors should influence your decision.

Your Skill Level and Time Availability

If you’re comfortable working on small engines and have the time, you can save a significant amount of money by doing the repairs yourself. However, if you’re not mechanically inclined or don’t have the time, it’s best to leave the repairs to a professional.

My Experience: I enjoy tinkering with small engines, so I often tackle chainsaw repairs myself. However, I know my limits. For complex repairs like engine rebuilds, I prefer to rely on a qualified technician.

The Saw’s Overall Condition

Consider the overall condition of the saw. If it’s old, worn, and has seen heavy use, it may be nearing the end of its lifespan. Even if you repair the current problem, other issues are likely to arise in the near future.

The Availability of Parts

For older models like the MS360, parts may be more difficult to find and more expensive. This can make repairs more challenging and time-consuming.

Your Future Needs

Think about your future chainsaw needs. If you’re planning on tackling larger or more demanding projects, it may be worth investing in a new, more powerful saw.

The Resale Value

A repaired chainsaw will typically have a lower resale value than a new chainsaw. This is a minor factor, but it’s something to keep in mind if you plan on selling the saw in the future.

Cost Optimization Strategies for Chainsaw Repairs

If you decide to repair your chainsaw, here are some tips for minimizing costs:

• Shop Around for Parts: Compare prices from different suppliers to find the best deals. Online retailers often offer lower prices than local shops.
• Consider Aftermarket Parts: Aftermarket parts can be a cost-effective alternative to OEM parts, but do your research to ensure quality.
• Do the Repairs Yourself (If Possible): Save on labor costs by tackling simple repairs yourself.
• Perform Regular Maintenance: Prevent costly repairs by performing regular maintenance, such as cleaning the air filter, sharpening the chain, and using the correct fuel mixture.
• Get Multiple Estimates: If you’re using a repair shop, get estimates from multiple shops to ensure you’re getting a fair price.

Budgeting for Firewood Preparation: A Holistic View

The question about chainsaw repair often arises in the context of firewood preparation. It’s essential to consider the broader costs involved in this process to make informed decisions.

Timber Costs

• Purchasing Firewood: The cost of purchasing firewood varies widely depending on your location, the type of wood, and the quantity. According to recent data, the average price per cord of seasoned firewood in the United States ranges from $150 to $400.
• Harvesting Your Own Timber: If you have access to land, you can harvest your own timber for firewood. However, you’ll need to factor in the cost of permits (if required), transportation, and any equipment rentals.

Equipment Costs

• Chainsaw: As we’ve discussed, the cost of a chainsaw can range from a few hundred dollars to over a thousand dollars.
• Wood Splitter: A wood splitter can significantly reduce the amount of time and effort required to split firewood. Manual wood splitters (mauls and wedges) are relatively inexpensive (under $100), while hydraulic wood splitters can range from $500 to $3,000.
• Safety Gear: Safety gear is essential for protecting yourself from injury. This includes a helmet, safety glasses, ear protection, gloves, and chaps. The cost of safety gear can range from $100 to $300.

Labor Costs

• Your Time: If you’re preparing firewood yourself, you need to factor in the value of your time. How much is your time worth per hour?
• Hiring Help: If you need help preparing firewood, you’ll need to pay for labor. The cost of labor can vary depending on your location and the skill level of the workers.

Other Costs

• Transportation: Transporting firewood can be costly, especially if you’re hauling it long distances.
• Storage: You’ll need a place to store your firewood, such as a shed or a covered area.
• Maintenance: Equipment maintenance costs can add up over time.

Budgeting Example: Let’s say you plan to prepare 5 cords of firewood. You have access to free timber, but you need to rent a wood splitter for $100 per day and purchase a new chainsaw for $700. You estimate that it will take you 3 days to prepare the firewood.

• Equipment Costs: $700 (chainsaw) + $300 (wood splitter rental) = $1000
• Your Time: 3 days x 8 hours/day x $20/hour = $480
• Other Costs: $100 (fuel, maintenance)
• Total Cost: $1580
• Cost Per Cord: $1580 / 5 cords = $316 per cord

This example illustrates the importance of considering all costs involved in firewood preparation, not just the cost of the chainsaw.

Chainsaw Maintenance: A Proactive Approach

Preventative maintenance is key to extending the life of your chainsaw and minimizing repair costs. Here are some essential maintenance tasks:

• Sharpen the Chain Regularly: A sharp chain is essential for efficient cutting and reducing strain on the engine.
• Clean the Air Filter: A dirty air filter can restrict airflow to the engine, causing it to run poorly.
• Use the Correct Fuel Mixture: Using the correct fuel mixture is crucial for preventing engine damage.
• Lubricate the Bar and Chain: Proper lubrication is essential for reducing wear and tear on the bar and chain.
• Inspect the Saw Regularly: Inspect the saw regularly for any signs of damage or wear.
• Store the Saw Properly: Store the saw in a clean, dry place to prevent corrosion and damage.

My Experience: I’ve found that regularly cleaning the air filter and sharpening the chain make a huge difference in the performance and longevity of my chainsaws. It’s a small investment of time that pays off in the long run.

Chainsaw Safety: A Non-Negotiable Priority

Chainsaw safety is paramount. Always wear appropriate safety gear and follow safe operating procedures.

• Read the Owner’s Manual: Familiarize yourself with the saw’s operating instructions and safety precautions.
• Wear Safety Gear: Always wear a helmet, safety glasses, ear protection, gloves, and chaps.
• Use Proper Cutting Techniques: Learn and practice safe cutting techniques to avoid kickback and other hazards.
• Maintain a Safe Work Area: Keep the work area clear of obstacles and bystanders.
• Never Operate a Chainsaw When Fatigued or Under the Influence: Fatigue and impairment can significantly increase the risk of accidents.

Actionable Takeaways and Next Steps

So, is repairing your Stihl MS390 or MS360 worth it? Here’s a summary of the key takeaways:

• Assess the Problem: Identify the specific problems with your chainsaw.
• Estimate Repair Costs: Get estimates for parts and labor.
• Compare to New Chainsaw Costs: Research the cost of comparable new chainsaws.
• Consider Other Factors: Evaluate your skill level, the saw’s overall condition, and your future needs.
• Make an Informed Decision: Weigh the costs and benefits of repair versus replacement and make a decision that’s right for you.

Next Steps:

1. Inspect your chainsaw thoroughly: Identify all the issues that need to be addressed.
2. Get estimates from local repair shops: Compare prices and services.
3. Research the cost of new chainsaws: Consider models from Stihl and other manufacturers.
4. Evaluate your budget and needs: Determine how much you’re willing to spend and what features are important to you.
5. Make a decision and take action: Either repair your existing chainsaw or purchase a new one.

Ultimately, the decision of whether to repair or replace your Stihl MS390 or MS360 depends on your individual circumstances. By carefully considering the factors outlined in this article, you can make an informed decision that saves you money and ensures you have a reliable chainsaw for years to come. Remember, a well-maintained chainsaw is an investment in efficiency, safety, and the satisfaction of a job well done. And that’s an investment worth making.

Learn more