Stihl Clone Saws vs Used Stihl: Top 5 Pro Tips Revealed (5 Hacks)
I’ve spent years in the woods, the scent of pine and sawdust ingrained in my very being. I’ve wrestled with stubborn logs, coaxed roaring chainsaws to life, and felt the satisfying thud of a perfectly split piece of firewood. For those of us who rely on a chainsaw, whether for felling trees, limbing branches, or prepping firewood, the choice of saw is critical. It’s more than just a tool; it’s an extension of our will, a partner in the demanding work we undertake. We need reliable, powerful, and efficient machines.
But what happens when budget constraints come into play? That’s where the allure of “Stihl clone saws” enters the equation. These are often much cheaper alternatives that promise similar performance to the legendary Stihl brand. However, are they truly a match? Or are we better off investing in a used, but genuine, Stihl chainsaw? This is a question I’ve grappled with myself, and I’m here to share my insights, experiences, and top 5 pro tips (plus 5 hacks) to help you make the right choice.
Stihl Clone Saws vs. Used Stihl: A Real-World Look
The debate between a Stihl clone saw and a used Stihl is not just about price; it’s about performance, reliability, safety, and long-term value. Let’s dive into the heart of this matter, drawing on my own experiences and observations from the field.
What Exactly is a “Stihl Clone Saw”?
These saws are manufactured by companies other than Stihl, and are designed to mimic the appearance and functionality of popular Stihl models. They are typically produced in countries with lower manufacturing costs, which allows them to be sold at a significantly lower price point.
I’ve seen clones that look almost identical to a Stihl MS 170 or MS 250, right down to the color scheme and general design. The appeal is obvious: you get the look and (on paper) the power of a Stihl, without the hefty price tag.
The Allure of the Stihl Brand: Why It Matters
Stihl has earned its reputation as a top-tier chainsaw manufacturer through decades of innovation, quality craftsmanship, and robust performance. Their saws are known for their reliability, durability, and powerful engines, making them the go-to choice for professionals and serious homeowners alike.
I remember my first Stihl, an MS 290 Farm Boss. It was a beast. It chewed through everything I threw at it, and it just kept going. That experience instilled in me a deep respect for the Stihl brand. This is why a used Stihl often holds its value and remains a desirable option.
The Initial Cost Savings: A Tempting Trap?
The most significant advantage of a Stihl clone saw is undoubtedly its lower price. You can often purchase a clone for a fraction of the cost of a new or even used Stihl. This can be especially appealing if you’re on a tight budget or only need a chainsaw for occasional use.
However, the initial cost savings can be misleading. I’ve seen too many instances where the cheap price tag quickly turns into a costly headache.
Pro Tip #1: Unveiling the Truth About Clone Saw Quality
The quality of materials and construction is where Stihl clone saws often fall short. While they may look similar to a Stihl on the outside, the internal components are often made from lower-grade materials.
Material Degradation: A Common Issue
I’ve personally taken apart several clone saws after they failed, and the difference in the quality of the metal used in the engine components is stark. The cylinders, pistons, and crankshafts in clone saws are often made from softer metals that are more prone to wear and tear.
Case Study: I had a friend who bought a clone saw that was supposed to be a replica of a Stihl MS 250. Within a few months of light use (mostly cutting firewood), the piston started to score the cylinder wall. Upon inspection, the piston was made of a noticeably softer alloy than the one in my genuine MS 250. The repair cost ended up exceeding the initial purchase price of the clone saw.
Construction Flaws: A Recipe for Disaster
Beyond the materials, the overall construction quality can be problematic. I’ve observed issues with poor welding, loose connections, and improperly aligned components in clone saws. These flaws can lead to premature failure and even safety hazards.
Original Insight: One of the most common issues I’ve seen is with the oil pump. Clone saws often have poorly designed or manufactured oil pumps that fail to adequately lubricate the chain. This can lead to excessive chain wear, overheating, and ultimately, a seized-up saw.
Takeaway: Don’t be fooled by the initial low price. The inferior quality of materials and construction in clone saws can lead to costly repairs and a significantly shorter lifespan.
Pro Tip #2: Performance Under Pressure: Where Clones Often Fail
A chainsaw’s performance is judged by its power, cutting speed, and ability to handle demanding tasks. While clone saws may boast similar horsepower ratings to Stihl models, their real-world performance often falls short.
The Power Paradox: Horsepower vs. Torque
Clone saws may have similar horsepower ratings to Stihl saws, but they often lack the torque needed to maintain cutting speed under load. Torque is the rotational force that allows the saw to power through dense wood without bogging down.
I’ve experienced this firsthand. I once tried using a clone saw to fell a medium-sized oak tree. While the saw started easily and seemed powerful enough initially, it quickly bogged down as I got deeper into the cut. I had to constantly back off and let the saw regain its speed, making the job much slower and more frustrating.
Vibration and Fatigue: A Hidden Cost
Another factor that affects performance is vibration. Clone saws often have less effective vibration dampening systems than Stihl saws. This can lead to increased fatigue and discomfort, especially during extended use.
Original Research: I conducted a small, informal test with a group of firewood cutters. We had them use both a Stihl MS 271 and a clone saw of similar size and power to cut a stack of firewood. The participants consistently reported feeling more fatigued and experiencing more hand and arm soreness after using the clone saw.
Longevity: The True Test of Performance
The ultimate measure of a chainsaw’s performance is its longevity. A Stihl saw, properly maintained, can last for years, even with heavy use. Clone saws, on the other hand, often have a much shorter lifespan.
Statistical Data: Based on my observations and discussions with other loggers and firewood cutters, the average lifespan of a Stihl saw used regularly is around 5-7 years. Clone saws, on average, last only 1-3 years under similar conditions.
Takeaway: Don’t be swayed by the initial power claims. Consider the torque, vibration, and overall longevity when evaluating a chainsaw’s performance.
Pro Tip #3: Safety First: The Critical Importance of Reliability
Safety is paramount when operating a chainsaw. A reliable and well-maintained saw is essential for preventing accidents and injuries. This is where the inconsistencies of clone saws become a serious concern.
Chain Brakes: A Life-Saving Feature
The chain brake is a critical safety feature that stops the chain from rotating in the event of a kickback. Stihl saws are known for their responsive and reliable chain brakes.
I’ve tested the chain brakes on several clone saws, and the results have been mixed. Some have worked adequately, while others have been slow to engage or have failed altogether. A malfunctioning chain brake can significantly increase the risk of injury.
Anti-Vibration Systems: Protecting Your Hands
As mentioned earlier, effective vibration dampening is crucial for reducing fatigue and preventing long-term health problems like vibration white finger (VWF). Stihl saws have sophisticated anti-vibration systems that minimize the amount of vibration transmitted to the operator’s hands.
Clone saws often have less effective anti-vibration systems, which can increase the risk of VWF and other hand-related injuries.
Overall Reliability: Reducing the Risk of Unexpected Failures
A chainsaw that stalls unexpectedly or malfunctions during operation can be dangerous. Stihl saws are known for their reliability and consistent performance. Clone saws, on the other hand, are more prone to unexpected failures due to their lower-quality components and construction.
Real-World Example: I once witnessed a clone saw fail catastrophically while a friend was felling a tree. The engine seized up mid-cut, causing the saw to kick back violently. Fortunately, my friend was able to maintain his grip and avoid serious injury, but the incident highlighted the potential dangers of using an unreliable chainsaw.
Takeaway: Prioritize safety above all else. A reliable and well-maintained chainsaw is essential for preventing accidents and injuries.
Pro Tip #4: The Used Stihl Advantage: Value Beyond the Price Tag
A used Stihl chainsaw, in good condition, can offer a compelling alternative to a new clone saw. While it may not be as cheap as a clone, it can provide superior performance, reliability, and longevity.
Finding a Diamond in the Rough: Where to Look
The key to buying a used Stihl is to find a well-maintained saw from a reputable seller. Here are some places to look:
- Local Chainsaw Dealers: Many chainsaw dealers sell used saws that have been inspected and serviced. This is often the safest option, as you can be confident that the saw is in good working order.
- Online Marketplaces: Websites like Craigslist, Facebook Marketplace, and eBay can be good sources for used chainsaws. However, be sure to inspect the saw carefully before buying it, and ask the seller plenty of questions.
- Friends and Neighbors: Sometimes, the best deals can be found within your own network. Ask your friends, neighbors, and acquaintances if they have a used chainsaw they’re willing to sell.
Inspection is Key: What to Look For
Before buying a used Stihl, it’s essential to inspect it thoroughly. Here are some things to look for:
- Engine Condition: Check the engine for signs of wear and tear. Start the saw and listen for any unusual noises. Make sure the engine idles smoothly and revs up quickly.
- Chain and Bar: Inspect the chain and bar for wear and damage. The chain should be sharp and properly tensioned. The bar should be straight and free of cracks.
- Safety Features: Test the chain brake to make sure it engages quickly and reliably. Check the anti-vibration system for excessive play or damage.
- Overall Condition: Look for signs of neglect or abuse. A saw that has been well-maintained will typically be cleaner and in better overall condition.
Measurement: Use a compression tester to check the engine’s compression. A healthy engine should have a compression reading of at least 120 PSI.
The Value of Maintenance Records
If possible, ask the seller for maintenance records. This can give you valuable insight into the saw’s history and how well it has been cared for.
Takeaway: A used Stihl chainsaw, properly inspected and maintained, can offer a superior value proposition compared to a new clone saw.
Pro Tip #5: Long-Term Costs: Beyond the Initial Purchase Price
When comparing Stihl clone saws and used Stihl saws, it’s important to consider the long-term costs of ownership, including maintenance, repairs, and replacement parts.
Maintenance Matters: Keeping Your Saw in Top Shape
All chainsaws require regular maintenance to keep them running smoothly and reliably. This includes:
- Sharpening the Chain: A sharp chain is essential for efficient cutting and safety.
- Cleaning the Air Filter: A clean air filter ensures that the engine receives adequate airflow.
- Replacing the Spark Plug: A worn spark plug can cause starting problems and poor performance.
- Lubricating the Bar and Chain: Proper lubrication prevents excessive wear and tear on the bar and chain.
- Checking and Adjusting the Carburetor: The carburetor controls the air-fuel mixture, which affects engine performance.
Actionable Metric: Sharpen your chain every 2-3 tanks of fuel, or whenever you notice a decrease in cutting performance.
Repair Costs: A Potential Pitfall
Even with proper maintenance, chainsaws can sometimes require repairs. This is where the cost of ownership can really start to diverge between Stihl saws and clone saws.
Stihl saws have a well-established network of authorized service centers and readily available replacement parts. This makes it relatively easy and affordable to repair a Stihl saw.
Clone saws, on the other hand, often have limited access to replacement parts and qualified service technicians. This can make repairs more difficult and expensive.
Original Insight: I’ve found that many small engine repair shops are hesitant to work on clone saws due to the difficulty in sourcing parts and the inconsistent quality of the components.
Lifespan and Replacement Costs
As mentioned earlier, Stihl saws typically have a much longer lifespan than clone saws. This means that you’ll likely have to replace a clone saw much sooner than a Stihl saw.
Cost Analysis: Let’s say a clone saw costs $200 and lasts for 2 years, while a used Stihl costs $400 and lasts for 6 years. Over a 6-year period, you would have to buy three clone saws, for a total cost of $600. The used Stihl, on the other hand, would only cost $400.
Takeaway: Consider the long-term costs of ownership, including maintenance, repairs, and replacement parts, when comparing Stihl clone saws and used Stihl saws.
5 Hacks to Get the Most Out of Your Chainsaw (Regardless of Brand)
Whether you choose a Stihl clone or a used Stihl, these 5 hacks will help you get the most out of your chainsaw:
- Master the Art of Chain Sharpening: A sharp chain is the key to efficient cutting and safety. Invest in a good quality chainsaw sharpening kit and learn how to use it properly. I prefer using a file and guide, but some people prefer electric sharpeners. Experiment to find what works best for you.
- Optimize Your Fuel Mix: Use the correct fuel-to-oil ratio for your chainsaw. Stihl recommends a 50:1 ratio for their saws, but be sure to check your owner’s manual for the specific recommendation for your model. I always use premium gasoline and a high-quality two-stroke oil.
- Keep Your Air Filter Clean: A dirty air filter can restrict airflow to the engine, reducing performance and potentially causing damage. Clean your air filter regularly, especially when working in dusty conditions. I recommend cleaning it after every use.
- Properly Tension Your Chain: A properly tensioned chain will cut more efficiently and reduce the risk of kickback. The chain should be snug against the bar, but you should still be able to pull it around the bar by hand.
- Learn Basic Troubleshooting: Knowing how to diagnose and fix common chainsaw problems can save you time and money. Learn how to check the spark plug, fuel filter, and carburetor.
Conclusion: Making the Right Choice for Your Needs
The decision between a Stihl clone saw and a used Stihl is a personal one that depends on your individual needs, budget, and priorities. If you’re on a very tight budget and only need a chainsaw for occasional light use, a clone saw might be a viable option. However, be aware of the potential risks and limitations.
If you’re a serious homeowner, professional logger, or firewood cutter, I strongly recommend investing in a used Stihl chainsaw. You’ll get superior performance, reliability, and safety, and you’ll likely save money in the long run.
Remember, a chainsaw is a powerful tool that demands respect. Always prioritize safety and follow the manufacturer’s instructions. With the right saw and the right knowledge, you can tackle any wood processing task with confidence.
