Rough Cut Board and Batten Siding (7 Expert Wood Pricing Tips)

Ever looked at a beautifully sided house and thought, “I could do that”? Maybe you’ve even envisioned your own home clad in rustic, charming board and batten siding. But then reality hits: the cost of materials. Don’t let that dream fade just yet! I’m here to tell you that rough-cut board and batten siding is not only achievable on a budget, but it can also add a unique, handcrafted character to your home.

Key Takeaways You’ll Learn:

• Understand the factors driving rough-cut lumber prices: Species, grade, dimensions, and market conditions all play a role.
• Master cost-saving strategies: From sourcing directly from mills to utilizing less common species, I’ll show you how to save money without sacrificing quality.
• Learn how to accurately estimate your lumber needs: Avoid overbuying (and overspending) with my proven calculation methods.
• Develop negotiation skills: Know what to ask and how to get the best possible price from your lumber supplier.
• Explore alternative materials: Consider reclaimed lumber or even milling your own timber for maximum savings.

Get ready to roll up your sleeves and transform your home with stunning, budget-friendly rough-cut board and batten siding!

Rough Cut Board and Batten Siding: 7 Expert Wood Pricing Tips

My Board and Batten Journey: From Dream to Reality

My own journey with board and batten siding started much like yours, I suspect. I had a vision of a cozy, rustic cabin nestled in the woods, clad in that classic, timeless siding. The problem? The initial quotes I received from contractors and lumber yards were enough to make my wallet weep.

That’s when I decided to take matters into my own hands. I started researching, learning about different wood species, milling techniques, and pricing strategies. I spent countless hours visiting local sawmills, talking to experienced woodworkers, and experimenting with different finishes.

What I discovered was that rough-cut lumber, often overlooked in favor of its smoother, more refined counterpart, was the key to achieving my dream without breaking the bank. It offered a unique texture and character that perfectly complemented the rustic aesthetic I was aiming for. And, most importantly, it was significantly more affordable.

Through trial and error, I developed a system for sourcing, pricing, and working with rough-cut lumber that allowed me to complete my board and batten siding project for a fraction of the cost of traditional methods. Now, I’m excited to share my knowledge with you so you can embark on your own successful siding adventure.

1. Understanding the Rough-Cut Lumber Landscape: Factors Affecting Price

Before you even start thinking about your board and batten design, it’s crucial to understand the factors that influence the price of rough-cut lumber. Think of it as learning the rules of the game before you start playing.

• Wood Species: This is the biggest driver of lumber cost. Some species, like cedar and redwood, are naturally rot-resistant and highly sought after for exterior applications. Others, like pine and spruce, are more affordable but may require additional treatment for durability.

  • Softwoods vs. Hardwoods: Generally, softwoods (pine, fir, cedar) are less expensive than hardwoods (oak, maple, walnut). For siding, you’ll typically be working with softwoods.
  • Local Availability: Locally sourced wood will almost always be cheaper due to lower transportation costs. Ask your local mills what they have available.
  • Example: In my region (Pacific Northwest), Western Red Cedar is a popular choice for siding, but its price fluctuates significantly based on demand and harvest yields. I’ve found that exploring alternatives like Alaskan Yellow Cedar or even locally sourced Douglas Fir (with proper treatment) can save a bundle.

• Grade: Lumber is graded based on its appearance and structural integrity. Higher grades (like “Select” or “Clear”) have fewer knots and imperfections, making them more expensive. For rough-cut board and batten, you can often get away with lower grades (“Common” or “Construction”) as the rustic aesthetic embraces imperfections.

  • Knots: Large, loose knots can weaken the board and are generally undesirable. However, smaller, tight knots can add character to rough-cut siding.
  • Wane: Wane refers to the presence of bark or missing wood along the edge of the board. A little wane can add to the rustic look, but excessive wane can make the board difficult to work with.
  • Example: I once saved a significant amount of money by purchasing “Number 2 Common” grade pine for a board and batten project. While it had more knots than higher grades, I was able to strategically position the boards to minimize the visual impact of the knots, and the overall effect was exactly what I was looking for.

• Dimensions: The thickness, width, and length of the lumber will all affect the price. Thicker boards are generally more expensive than thinner boards. Wider boards require more of the tree to be used, increasing their cost. Longer boards are also pricier due to handling and transportation challenges.

  • Standard Sizes: Lumber is typically sold in standard dimensions (e.g., 1×6, 1×8, 1×10). However, rough-cut lumber may come in slightly different sizes, so be sure to confirm the actual dimensions before you buy.
  • Custom Cutting: Some mills offer custom cutting services, which can be helpful if you need specific dimensions for your project. However, custom cutting usually comes at a premium.
  • Example: For my board and batten siding, I opted for 1×8 boards for the “boards” and 1×3 boards for the “battens.” This combination provided a good balance of aesthetics and affordability.

• Market Conditions: Lumber prices are subject to fluctuations based on supply and demand. Economic factors, natural disasters, and even seasonal trends can all impact prices.

  • Housing Market: A strong housing market typically leads to higher lumber prices.
  • Weather: Extreme weather events can disrupt logging operations and increase lumber prices.
  • Seasonality: Lumber prices tend to be higher in the spring and summer, when construction activity is at its peak.
  • Example: During the COVID-19 pandemic, lumber prices skyrocketed due to increased demand for home improvement projects and disruptions to supply chains. I learned the hard way that it’s essential to monitor market trends and plan your purchases accordingly.

• Moisture Content: Kiln-dried lumber, which has been dried in a kiln to reduce its moisture content, is generally more expensive than green (undried) lumber. However, kiln-dried lumber is more stable and less likely to warp or twist after installation.

  • Kiln-Dried vs. Air-Dried: Kiln-drying is a faster and more controlled process than air-drying, but it can also be more expensive.
  • Moisture Content Levels: The ideal moisture content for siding is typically between 12% and 15%.
  • Example: I’ve used both kiln-dried and air-dried lumber for board and batten siding. While kiln-dried lumber is easier to work with and more stable, air-dried lumber can be a more affordable option if you’re willing to let it acclimate to the local climate before installation.

• Transportation Costs: The distance between the sawmill and your job site will affect the cost of transportation. The further the lumber has to travel, the more expensive it will be.

  • Local Sourcing: Sourcing lumber from a local mill is the best way to minimize transportation costs.
  • Delivery Fees: Be sure to factor in delivery fees when comparing prices from different suppliers.
  • Example: I once drove several hours to pick up a load of rough-cut lumber from a small, family-owned sawmill. While the drive was a bit of a hassle, the savings were well worth it.

2. Sourcing Strategies: Finding the Best Deals on Rough-Cut Lumber

Now that you understand the factors that influence lumber prices, let’s explore some strategies for finding the best deals on rough-cut lumber.

• Direct from the Mill: This is often the most cost-effective option. By cutting out the middleman (the lumber yard), you can save a significant amount of money.

  • Finding Local Mills: Use online directories, local business listings, or even word-of-mouth to find sawmills in your area.
  • Mill Tours: Visit local mills to see their operations and learn about their lumber offerings.
  • Building Relationships: Establish a relationship with the mill owner or manager. This can lead to better prices and access to unique lumber.
  • Example: I’ve developed a strong relationship with a local sawmill owner over the years. He often gives me preferential pricing and lets me pick through his lumber pile to find the best pieces for my projects.

• Lumber Yards: Lumber yards offer a wider selection of lumber and often provide additional services like cutting and delivery. However, their prices are typically higher than those of sawmills.

  • Comparing Prices: Get quotes from multiple lumber yards before making a purchase.
  • Negotiating: Don’t be afraid to negotiate the price, especially if you’re buying a large quantity of lumber.
  • Clearance Sales: Keep an eye out for clearance sales on lumber that is slightly damaged or has been sitting in the yard for a while.
  • Example: I once found a lumber yard that was clearing out a batch of slightly warped cedar siding. I was able to negotiate a significant discount on the lumber, and the warping was minimal enough that I could still use it for my board and batten project.

• Reclaimed Lumber: Reclaimed lumber, salvaged from old buildings or structures, can add a unique character to your board and batten siding project. It’s also an environmentally friendly option.

  • Sourcing Reclaimed Lumber: Look for architectural salvage yards, demolition companies, or even online marketplaces that specialize in reclaimed lumber.
  • Inspection: Carefully inspect reclaimed lumber for nails, screws, and other debris.
  • Cleaning: Clean reclaimed lumber thoroughly before using it.
  • Example: I used reclaimed barn wood for the battens on my board and batten siding. The weathered texture and nail holes added a rustic charm that I couldn’t have achieved with new lumber.

• Milling Your Own Timber: If you have access to a woodlot or can source logs from local landowners, you can mill your own lumber using a portable sawmill. This can be a very cost-effective option, but it requires a significant investment of time and effort.

  • Portable Sawmills: Portable sawmills come in a variety of sizes and configurations.
  • Sawmilling Skills: Learn the basics of sawmilling before attempting to mill your own lumber.
  • Safety: Always wear appropriate safety gear when operating a sawmill.
  • Example: I invested in a small portable sawmill a few years ago. While it took some time to learn how to use it properly, I’ve been able to mill lumber for a variety of projects, including board and batten siding, fencing, and even furniture.

3. Lumber Estimation: Accurately Calculating Your Needs

One of the biggest mistakes you can make when buying lumber is overestimating your needs. This can lead to unnecessary expenses and wasted materials. Here’s how to accurately estimate your lumber needs for your board and batten siding project:

• Measure Your Walls: Accurately measure the height and width of each wall that will be covered with board and batten siding.

  • Accounting for Openings: Subtract the area of any windows or doors from the total wall area.
  • Accuracy is Key: Double-check your measurements to ensure accuracy.

• Calculate Board Footage: Board footage is a unit of measurement used to quantify the volume of lumber. It’s calculated by multiplying the thickness (in inches) by the width (in inches) by the length (in feet) and dividing by 12.

  • Formula: (Thickness x Width x Length) / 12 = Board Feet
  • Example: A 1-inch thick board that is 6 inches wide and 8 feet long contains 4 board feet of lumber (1 x 6 x 8) / 12 = 4.

• Determine Board and Batten Spacing: Decide on the desired spacing between the boards and the battens. This will affect the amount of lumber you need.

  • Typical Spacing: A common spacing for board and batten siding is 12 inches between the boards.
  • Aesthetic Considerations: Consider the overall look you’re trying to achieve when determining the spacing.

• Calculate the Number of Boards and Battens: Use your measurements and spacing to calculate the number of boards and battens needed to cover each wall.

  • Board Calculation: Divide the total wall width by the board width plus the spacing between the boards.
  • Batten Calculation: The number of battens will depend on the number of boards and the spacing between the battens.
  • Example: If you’re using 8-inch wide boards with 12-inch spacing, you’ll need one board for every 20 inches of wall width (8 + 12 = 20).

• Add Waste Factor: Always add a waste factor to your lumber estimate to account for cuts, mistakes, and imperfections in the wood.

  • Typical Waste Factor: A waste factor of 10% to 15% is generally sufficient for board and batten siding.
  • Project Complexity: Increase the waste factor for more complex projects with intricate designs.

• Create a Lumber List: Compile a detailed lumber list that includes the species, grade, dimensions, and quantity of each type of lumber you need.

  • Organization is Key: A well-organized lumber list will help you stay on track and avoid mistakes.
  • Sharing with Suppliers: Share your lumber list with potential suppliers to get accurate quotes.

4. Negotiation Tactics: Getting the Best Price from Suppliers

Once you have a lumber list, it’s time to start contacting suppliers and negotiating the best possible price. Here are some tactics to help you get the most for your money:

• Get Multiple Quotes: Don’t settle for the first quote you receive. Contact multiple suppliers and compare their prices.

  • Apples to Apples: Make sure you’re comparing prices for the same species, grade, and dimensions of lumber.
  • Written Quotes: Always get quotes in writing to avoid misunderstandings.

• Ask About Discounts: Don’t be afraid to ask about discounts. Many suppliers offer discounts for bulk purchases, cash payments, or repeat customers.

  • Bulk Discounts: Inquire about discounts for purchasing a large quantity of lumber.
  • Cash Discounts: Some suppliers offer discounts for paying with cash.
  • Customer Loyalty: If you’re a repeat customer, ask about loyalty discounts.

• Negotiate on Price: Even if a supplier doesn’t offer a discount, you can still try to negotiate on price.

  • Be Polite and Respectful: Always be polite and respectful when negotiating.
  • Know Your Budget: Set a budget for your lumber purchase and stick to it.
  • Highlight Competitor Pricing: Let the supplier know if you’ve received a lower quote from a competitor.
  • Be Willing to Walk Away: If the supplier isn’t willing to meet your price, be willing to walk away.

• Consider Less Common Species: As I mentioned earlier, exploring less common species can save you money.

  • Research Alternatives: Research alternative species that are similar in appearance and durability to the species you originally wanted.
  • Local Availability: Focus on species that are locally available to minimize transportation costs.
  • Example: I once saved a significant amount of money by using Alaskan Yellow Cedar instead of Western Red Cedar for a board and batten project. The two species are very similar in appearance, but Alaskan Yellow Cedar was more readily available and less expensive at the time.

• Be Flexible on Grade: If you’re willing to accept lumber with more knots or imperfections, you can save money by purchasing a lower grade.

  • Embrace Imperfections: Rough-cut board and batten siding is all about rustic charm, so don’t be afraid to embrace imperfections.
  • Strategic Placement: Strategically place boards with more knots in less visible areas.

• Pay Attention to the Details: Carefully review the quote to ensure that it includes all of the lumber you need and that the prices are accurate.

  • Double-Check Dimensions: Make sure the dimensions of the lumber are correct.
  • Verify Quantities: Verify that the quantities of each type of lumber are accurate.
  • Check for Hidden Fees: Be aware of any hidden fees, such as delivery charges or cutting fees.

5. Alternative Materials: Thinking Outside the Lumber Yard

While traditional lumber is the most common material for board and batten siding, there are several alternative materials you can consider. These materials may be more affordable, more durable, or more environmentally friendly.

• Engineered Wood Siding: Engineered wood siding is made from wood fibers that are bonded together with resins. It’s typically more affordable than solid wood siding and is also more resistant to rot and insects.

  • Types of Engineered Wood Siding: Common types of engineered wood siding include hardboard siding, oriented strand board (OSB) siding, and fiber cement siding.
  • Installation: Engineered wood siding is typically installed using nails or screws.
  • Example: I’ve used engineered wood siding on several projects, including a shed and a garage. It’s a cost-effective and durable alternative to solid wood siding.

• Vinyl Siding: Vinyl siding is a popular choice for homeowners due to its affordability, durability, and low maintenance requirements. It’s available in a variety of colors and styles, including board and batten.

  • Installation: Vinyl siding is typically installed using nails or screws.
  • Maintenance: Vinyl siding requires minimal maintenance.
  • Example: While not my personal favorite, I have installed vinyl board and batten siding on a rental property. It’s a practical and cost-effective option for homeowners who want a low-maintenance siding solution.

• Metal Siding: Metal siding is a durable and long-lasting option that is becoming increasingly popular. It’s available in a variety of colors and styles, including board and batten.

  • Materials: Common types of metal siding include steel siding and aluminum siding.
  • Installation: Metal siding is typically installed using screws.
  • Example: I’ve seen metal board and batten siding used on modern homes and commercial buildings. It offers a sleek and contemporary look.

• Composite Siding: Composite siding is made from a combination of wood fibers and recycled plastic. It’s a durable, low-maintenance, and environmentally friendly option.

  • Benefits: Composite siding is resistant to rot, insects, and fading.
  • Cost: Composite siding is typically more expensive than vinyl siding but less expensive than solid wood siding.

6. Drying and Storage: Protecting Your Lumber Investment

Once you’ve purchased your lumber, it’s important to properly dry and store it to prevent warping, cracking, and decay.

• Air Drying: Air drying is the most common method of drying lumber. It involves stacking the lumber in a well-ventilated area and allowing it to dry naturally over time.

  • Stacking: Stack the lumber on stickers (thin strips of wood) to allow air to circulate around each board.
  • Ventilation: Ensure that the stacking area is well-ventilated to promote drying.
  • Protection from Rain: Protect the lumber from rain and snow to prevent it from getting wet.
  • Drying Time: Air drying can take several months, depending on the species of wood and the climate.

• Kiln Drying: Kiln drying is a faster and more controlled method of drying lumber. It involves placing the lumber in a kiln and using heat and air circulation to remove moisture.

  • Professional Kiln Drying: If you don’t have access to a kiln, you can hire a professional kiln drying service.
  • Cost: Kiln drying is typically more expensive than air drying.

• Storage: Once the lumber is dry, store it in a dry, well-ventilated area.

  • Elevated Storage: Store the lumber off the ground to prevent it from getting wet.
  • Protection from Sunlight: Protect the lumber from direct sunlight to prevent it from fading.
  • Proper Stacking: Stack the lumber properly to prevent it from warping.

7. Finishing Touches: Protecting and Enhancing Your Siding

Once your board and batten siding is installed, it’s important to apply a finish to protect it from the elements and enhance its appearance.

• Types of Finishes: Common types of finishes for wood siding include paint, stain, and sealant.

  • Paint: Paint provides the best protection from the elements and is available in a wide variety of colors.
  • Stain: Stain allows the natural beauty of the wood to show through and provides some protection from the elements.
  • Sealant: Sealant provides a clear, protective coating that helps to prevent water damage.

• Application: Apply the finish according to the manufacturer’s instructions.

  • Preparation: Prepare the surface of the wood by cleaning it and sanding it smooth.
  • Multiple Coats: Apply multiple coats of finish for best results.

• Maintenance: Regularly inspect your siding for signs of damage and reapply the finish as needed.

  • Annual Inspection: Inspect your siding annually for cracks, chips, and fading.
  • Reapplication: Reapply the finish every few years to maintain its protective qualities.

Case Studies: Real-World Examples of Cost-Effective Board and Batten Siding

Let’s take a look at a few real-world examples of how homeowners have successfully completed board and batten siding projects on a budget:

• The Rustic Cabin: A homeowner in Montana built a rustic cabin using rough-cut pine siding sourced from a local sawmill. He used a lower grade of lumber and embraced the imperfections, resulting in a charming and affordable siding solution. He saved over 40% compared to using cedar siding.
• The Modern Farmhouse: A couple in California renovated their home with board and batten siding using engineered wood siding. They chose a pre-primed product, which saved them time and money on painting. The total cost of the siding was approximately $5 per square foot.
• The Reclaimed Barn: An artist in Vermont built a studio using reclaimed barn wood for the board and batten siding. The weathered texture and nail holes added a unique character to the building, and the reclaimed lumber was significantly cheaper than new lumber.

Final Thoughts: Making Your Board and Batten Dreams a Reality

Building your own rough-cut board and batten siding is a rewarding project that can add value and character to your home. By understanding the factors that influence lumber prices, sourcing materials strategically, and following the tips outlined in this guide, you can achieve your dream without breaking the bank.

Don’t be afraid to get your hands dirty, experiment with different techniques, and most importantly, have fun! Your vision of a beautifully sided home is within reach. Now, get out there and make it happen!

Call to Action:

Ready to start your board and batten siding project?

• Download our free lumber estimation worksheet to accurately calculate your material needs.
• Visit your local sawmill and explore the available lumber options.
• Share your progress with us on social media using #BoardAndBattenDIY!

Learn more