PP900 Pole Saw Comparison: Fiskar vs Stihl (Pro Arborist Insights)

It’s a fact of life: every tool, no matter how well-crafted, eventually succumbs to the relentless march of wear-and-tear. This is especially true in the demanding world of wood processing, where tools are pushed to their limits day in and day out. And when you’re dangling from a harness, thirty feet in the air, trying to coax a stubborn branch to part ways with its parent tree, the tool in your hand isn’t just a tool – it’s your lifeline. Today, I’m diving deep into a head-to-head comparison of two popular pole saws vying for a spot in the arsenal of professional arborists and serious DIYers alike: the Fiskars PP900 and the Stihl pole saw offerings. We’ll dissect their strengths, weaknesses, and suitability for different tasks, all while drawing on my own experiences in the field.

PP900 Pole Saw Comparison: Fiskars vs Stihl (Pro Arborist Insights)

This article is for anyone who has ever wrestled with an unwieldy branch, dreamed of perfectly pruned trees, or simply wants to understand the nuances of pole saw selection. Whether you’re a seasoned arborist or a weekend warrior tackling overgrown hedges, I hope that sharing my insights will help you make an informed decision and get the most out of your tree care endeavors.

Understanding the User Intent

Before we even touch a saw, let’s understand what a user searching for “PP900 Pole Saw Comparison: Fiskars vs Stihl (Pro Arborist Insights)” is likely looking for. They want:

• A direct comparison: Strengths and weaknesses of each saw.
• Expert opinion: Insights from a professional arborist.
• Specific model information: Focus on the Fiskars PP900 and likely various Stihl models.
• Practical advice: Help in choosing the right saw for their needs.
• Reliable information: Trustworthy details to make an informed decision.

Fiskars PP900: The Lightweight Contender

The Fiskars PP900 is known for its lightweight design and ease of use. It’s a manual pole saw, meaning it relies on good old-fashioned elbow grease rather than a motor. This might seem like a disadvantage at first, but it offers some significant benefits.

Key Features of the Fiskars PP900

• Lightweight Design: Typically weighs around 6-7 pounds, making it easier to maneuver for extended periods.
• Power-Lever Technology: Fiskars claims this enhances cutting power by up to two times, reducing the effort required.
• Telescoping Pole: Usually extends up to 12-14 feet, providing a decent reach for most residential tasks.
• Oval-Shaped Pole: Designed for better control and stability.
• Replaceable Saw Head: Allows for easy replacement when the blade dulls or breaks.

My Experience with the Fiskars PP900

I’ve used the Fiskars PP900 for various tasks, from pruning small branches to clearing light brush. Its lightweight design is a definite plus, especially when working overhead. I’ve found that the Power-Lever technology does indeed make a noticeable difference, allowing me to cut through branches that would be challenging with a standard saw.

However, it’s not without its limitations. The manual operation can be tiring for larger jobs or when dealing with thicker branches. I’ve also noticed that the blade can sometimes bind, especially when cutting green wood. This is a common issue with manual saws, but it’s something to be aware of.

Data Points and Statistics

• Weight: Approximately 6.5 lbs (varies slightly depending on model).
• Reach: Up to 14 feet (telescoping).
• Blade Length: Typically around 15 inches.
• Price: Generally falls in the $60-$100 range.

Stihl Pole Saws: The Powerhouse Options

Stihl offers a range of pole saws, from gas-powered to battery-powered models. These saws are designed for professional use and offer significantly more power and cutting speed than the Fiskars PP900. I’ll focus on a few common Stihl models that are often considered by arborists and serious homeowners.

Common Stihl Pole Saw Models

• Stihl HT 56 C-E: A lightweight, gas-powered option ideal for homeowners and occasional users.
• Stihl HT 135: A more powerful, gas-powered model designed for professional arborists.
• Stihl HTA 85: A battery-powered option offering a balance of power and convenience.

Key Features of Stihl Pole Saws

• Gas-Powered or Battery-Powered: Offers significantly more power and cutting speed than manual saws.
• Professional-Grade Components: Built to withstand the rigors of daily use.
• Adjustable Length: Allows for customization to suit different tasks and heights.
• Automatic Chain Lubrication: Keeps the chain properly lubricated for optimal performance.
• Anti-Vibration System: Reduces fatigue and improves control.

My Experience with Stihl Pole Saws

I’ve used Stihl pole saws extensively in my work as an arborist. The gas-powered models, like the HT 135, are incredibly powerful and can cut through even the thickest branches with ease. The battery-powered HTA 85 is a great option for quieter jobs or when working in noise-sensitive areas.

One of the biggest advantages of Stihl pole saws is their durability. They’re built to last and can withstand the abuse of daily use. I’ve also found that the automatic chain lubrication system is a lifesaver, as it keeps the chain properly lubricated and prevents premature wear.

However, Stihl pole saws are also more expensive than the Fiskars PP900. They also require more maintenance, such as oil changes and spark plug replacements. The gas-powered models can also be quite noisy and produce exhaust fumes.

Data Points and Statistics

• Weight: Varies depending on model, ranging from 8 lbs (HT 56 C-E) to 17 lbs (HT 135).
• Reach: Varies depending on model and extension options.
• Engine Displacement (Gas Models): Ranges from 27.2 cc to 36.3 cc.
• Battery Voltage (Battery Models): Typically 36V.
• Price: Ranges from $300 to $1000+.

Head-to-Head Comparison: Fiskars PP900 vs Stihl

Let’s break down the key differences between the Fiskars PP900 and Stihl pole saws:

Real-World Case Studies

To illustrate the differences between these saws, let’s look at a few real-world scenarios:

Case Study 1: The Overgrown Hedge

Problem: A homeowner has an overgrown hedge that needs to be trimmed back. The branches are relatively thin (less than 2 inches in diameter).

Solution: The Fiskars PP900 would be a suitable option for this task. Its lightweight design and ease of use make it ideal for trimming smaller branches. The homeowner could easily maneuver the saw to reach the desired branches and trim them back without excessive effort.

Equipment Used: Fiskars PP900 pole saw, gloves, safety glasses.

Wood Types: Likely a soft wood species like privet or boxwood.

Safety Considerations: Ensure a stable footing, wear safety glasses to protect eyes from debris, and be aware of surroundings.

Case Study 2: Clearing Storm Damage

Problem: A storm has caused several large branches to break off a tree. The branches are thick (up to 6 inches in diameter) and need to be removed quickly and efficiently.

Solution: A Stihl gas-powered pole saw, such as the HT 135, would be the best option for this task. Its powerful engine and sharp chain can easily cut through the thick branches. The arborist could quickly and safely remove the damaged branches, minimizing the risk of further damage to the tree.

Equipment Used: Stihl HT 135 pole saw, chainsaw, climbing gear (if necessary), helmet, safety glasses, gloves, hearing protection.

Wood Types: Could be a variety of hardwoods or softwoods, depending on the tree species.

Safety Considerations: Wear appropriate personal protective equipment (PPE), be aware of overhead hazards, and use proper cutting techniques. If climbing is required, ensure proper training and certification.

Case Study 3: Pruning Fruit Trees

Problem: An orchard owner needs to prune their fruit trees to improve fruit production. The branches are relatively thin, but there are a large number of trees to prune.

Solution: A Stihl battery-powered pole saw, such as the HTA 85, would be a good option for this task. It offers a balance of power and convenience, allowing the orchard owner to prune the trees quickly and efficiently without the noise and fumes of a gas-powered saw. The battery-powered operation also makes it ideal for working in a sensitive environment.

Equipment Used: Stihl HTA 85 pole saw, pruning shears, gloves, safety glasses.

Wood Types: Typically fruit tree species like apple, pear, or cherry.

Safety Considerations: Wear safety glasses to protect eyes from debris, use proper pruning techniques to avoid damaging the trees, and be aware of surroundings.

Wood Species and Processing Techniques

The type of wood you’re cutting can also influence your choice of pole saw. Hardwoods, such as oak and maple, are denser and more difficult to cut than softwoods, such as pine and fir. For hardwoods, a more powerful saw, like a Stihl gas-powered model, is recommended. For softwoods, the Fiskars PP900 might be sufficient for smaller branches.

Processing Techniques:

• Limbing: Removing branches from a felled tree.
• Pruning: Removing dead or diseased branches from a live tree.
• Bucking: Cutting a log into shorter lengths.

For limbing and pruning, a pole saw is an invaluable tool. It allows you to reach high branches without having to climb the tree. When bucking logs, a chainsaw is generally the preferred tool.

Safety Standards and Best Practices

Safety should always be a top priority when using a pole saw. Here are some essential safety tips:

• Wear appropriate PPE: This includes a helmet, safety glasses, gloves, and hearing protection.
• Maintain a safe distance: Keep bystanders at least 20 feet away from the work area.
• Be aware of overhead hazards: Look for power lines, branches, and other obstacles that could fall on you.
• Use proper cutting techniques: Avoid cutting above your head and keep the saw blade away from your body.
• Inspect the saw before each use: Check for loose parts, damaged blades, and other potential hazards.
• Follow the manufacturer’s instructions: Read and understand the owner’s manual before using the saw.

Data Points and Statistics Related to Safety:

• According to the Tree Care Industry Association (TCIA), falls from trees are a leading cause of injury and death among arborists. Using a pole saw can help reduce the need to climb trees, thereby reducing the risk of falls.
• The Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) estimates that chainsaws cause tens of thousands of injuries each year. Proper training and the use of PPE can significantly reduce the risk of injury.

Choosing the Right Pole Saw: A Decision Framework

To help you choose the right pole saw, consider the following factors:

• Frequency of Use: If you only need a pole saw occasionally, the Fiskars PP900 might be sufficient. If you plan to use it frequently, a Stihl model is a better investment.
• Branch Thickness: For smaller branches (less than 2 inches in diameter), the Fiskars PP900 might be adequate. For thicker branches, a Stihl model is recommended.
• Budget: The Fiskars PP900 is a more affordable option than Stihl pole saws.
• Power Source Preference: Do you prefer the convenience of a gas-powered saw or the quiet operation of a battery-powered saw?
• Physical Condition: If you have limited upper body strength, the lightweight Fiskars PP900 might be a better choice.

Here’s a simple decision framework:

1. Assess Your Needs: How often will you use the pole saw? What size branches will you be cutting? What is your budget?
2. Consider the Pros and Cons: Weigh the advantages and disadvantages of each type of saw.
3. Read Reviews: See what other users have to say about the saws you’re considering.
4. Try Before You Buy: If possible, try out the saws at a local hardware store or rental shop.
5. Make Your Decision: Choose the saw that best meets your needs and budget.

The Importance of Proper Maintenance

No matter which pole saw you choose, proper maintenance is essential for ensuring its longevity and performance. Here are some tips for maintaining your pole saw:

• Clean the saw after each use: Remove any debris, such as sawdust and sap.
• Sharpen the chain regularly: A dull chain will make it harder to cut and can also be dangerous.
• Lubricate the chain: Keep the chain properly lubricated to reduce friction and wear.
• Check the spark plug (gas-powered models): Replace the spark plug as needed.
• Change the oil (gas-powered models): Follow the manufacturer’s recommendations for oil changes.
• Store the saw properly: Store the saw in a dry, safe place.

Unique Insights and Industry Trends

The arborist industry is constantly evolving, with new technologies and techniques emerging all the time. One trend I’ve noticed is the increasing popularity of battery-powered equipment. Battery technology has improved significantly in recent years, and battery-powered tools are now able to deliver performance that is comparable to gas-powered tools. This is good news for the environment, as battery-powered tools produce zero emissions.

Another trend is the growing emphasis on safety. Arborists are becoming increasingly aware of the risks associated with tree work and are taking steps to mitigate those risks. This includes using proper PPE, following safe work practices, and participating in ongoing training.

Wood Processing Concepts and Best Practices

Here are some key wood processing concepts and best practices:

• Seasoning: Allowing wood to dry before using it. This reduces the risk of warping and cracking.
• Kiln Drying: A faster method of drying wood that involves using a kiln to control the temperature and humidity.
• Grading: Sorting wood according to its quality and appearance.
• Milling: Cutting logs into lumber.
• Preservation: Treating wood to protect it from decay and insects.

Actionable Takeaways

• Choose the right pole saw for your needs: Consider the frequency of use, branch thickness, budget, and power source preference.
• Prioritize safety: Wear appropriate PPE and follow safe work practices.
• Maintain your pole saw: Clean, sharpen, and lubricate the saw regularly.
• Stay informed: Keep up with the latest industry trends and best practices.

Conclusion

Choosing the right pole saw is an important decision that can impact your safety, efficiency, and the quality of your work. By understanding the strengths and weaknesses of different models, and by following the tips and advice outlined in this article, you can make an informed decision and get the most out of your tree care endeavors. Remember, whether you opt for the lightweight agility of the Fiskars PP900 or the raw power of a Stihl, the key is to choose a tool that fits your specific needs and allows you to work safely and effectively. And always, always prioritize safety. Now get out there and make some sawdust!

Learn more