Is Elm Good for Burning? (5 Expert Insights on Firewood)

Is Elm Good for Burning? After all, nobody wants to spend hours splitting wood only to find it burns like tissue paper. Elm, with its distinctive grain and sometimes challenging reputation, often comes up in firewood discussions. So, is elm good for burning? Let’s dive into five expert insights, drawing on my years of experience in wood processing, logging, and firewood preparation, to give you the lowdown.

1. Elm’s Heat Output: A BTU Breakdown

The first question on anyone’s mind when considering firewood is, “How much heat will I get?” The answer lies in British Thermal Units (BTUs), a measurement of heat content. Elm, generally, falls in the middle of the pack compared to other hardwoods.

• Typical BTU Range: Elm usually provides between 20 to 24 million BTUs per cord.
• Comparison: This puts it slightly below oak (around 25-30 million BTUs/cord) but above softer woods like pine (15-20 million BTUs/cord).

Data Point: According to the U.S. Department of Energy, hardwoods with high density, like oak and maple, tend to have higher BTU values. Elm, while a hardwood, has a more moderate density, impacting its heat output.

My Experience: I’ve personally found that a mixed cord of elm and oak is a great compromise. The oak provides the long-lasting heat, while the elm offers a quicker, hotter burn to get the fire going.

2. Seasoning Elm: Patience is a Virtue

One of the biggest challenges with elm is its seasoning time. Elm is notorious for retaining moisture, making it difficult to dry properly.

• Typical Seasoning Time: Expect to season elm for at least 12-18 months, ideally longer, before burning.
• Why So Long? Elm’s interlocking grain structure makes it resistant to moisture evaporation.
• Moisture Content Goal: You want to achieve a moisture content of 20% or less for optimal burning.

Data Point: Research from the Forest Products Laboratory indicates that proper stacking and air circulation are critical for efficient seasoning.

My Experience: I once made the mistake of burning elm that I thought was seasoned after only a year. The result? A smoky fire, minimal heat, and creosote buildup in my chimney. Lesson learned: patience is key!

Cost Consideration: Improperly seasoned wood burns inefficiently, meaning you’ll need more of it to achieve the same level of heat. This translates directly into increased firewood costs. If you are buying wood, make sure to ask the seller about the seasoning time and moisture content. A moisture meter is a great investment to check yourself. These can be found for under $30.

3. Splitting Elm: Embrace the Challenge (or the Machine)

Another common complaint about elm is its splitting difficulty. That interlocking grain that makes it slow to season also makes it tough to split.

• Splitting Difficulty: Elm is generally considered a challenging wood to split by hand.
• Tool Recommendation: A hydraulic log splitter is highly recommended, especially for larger rounds.

Data Point: A study by the University of Maine found that the force required to split elm is significantly higher than that required for softer hardwoods like maple or birch.

My Experience: I’ve tackled elm with both a maul and a log splitter. While hand-splitting smaller pieces is doable, anything over 12 inches in diameter is best left to the machine. Trust me; your back will thank you.

Cost Breakdown: Splitting Options

• Hand Splitting:
  • Maul: \$30 – \$60 (one-time cost)
  • Wedges: \$15 – \$30 (one-time cost)
  • Labor: Your time (priceless… or is it?) Consider the physical effort and time commitment.
• Log Splitter Rental:
  • Daily Rental: \$75 – \$150 per day (depending on size and location)
  • Weekly Rental: \$300 – \$600 per week
• Log Splitter Purchase:
  • Electric Log Splitter: \$200 – \$500 (suitable for smaller rounds)
  • Gas-Powered Log Splitter: \$800 – \$2,000+ (for larger volumes and tougher wood)

Cost Optimization Tip: If you only have a small amount of elm to split, renting a log splitter for a day is likely the most cost-effective option. If you regularly process firewood, investing in a log splitter is a worthwhile expense.

4. Elm’s Smoke and Creosote Potential: Burn it Hot!

Like any wood, improper burning practices can lead to excessive smoke and creosote buildup. However, elm, especially if not fully seasoned, can be more prone to this issue.

• Smoke Potential: Burning unseasoned elm produces more smoke due to the higher moisture content.
• Creosote Risk: This smoke contains volatile compounds that can condense in your chimney, forming creosote, a fire hazard.
• Burning Recommendation: Burn elm hot and with a good draft to minimize smoke and creosote buildup.

Data Point: The Chimney Safety Institute of America (CSIA) emphasizes the importance of regular chimney inspections and cleaning to prevent creosote-related fires.

My Experience: I always burn elm in a well-established fire with plenty of airflow. This helps ensure complete combustion and reduces the risk of creosote buildup. I also make sure to have my chimney inspected and cleaned annually.

Maintenance Cost: * Chimney Inspection: \$80 – \$200 per inspection * Chimney Cleaning: \$125 – \$300 per cleaning

Cost Saving Tip: Burning fully seasoned wood and maintaining a hot fire are the best ways to minimize creosote buildup and reduce the frequency of chimney cleaning.

5. Elm’s Availability and Cost: Location, Location, Location

The cost and availability of elm firewood vary significantly depending on your location.

• Regional Variation: In some areas, elm is abundant and relatively inexpensive, while in others, it may be scarce and more costly.
• Local Market Research: Check with local firewood suppliers and online marketplaces to get an idea of current prices in your area.

Data Point: According to the USDA Forest Service, the price of firewood can fluctuate based on factors such as local demand, transportation costs, and the availability of other fuel sources.

My Experience: In my region, elm is often offered at a lower price than oak or maple due to its splitting challenges and seasoning time. This can make it a good value option for those willing to put in the extra effort.

Cost Comparison: Firewood Prices (Example)

Note: These prices are examples and can vary greatly depending on location and supplier.

Negotiation Tip: Don’t be afraid to negotiate with firewood suppliers, especially if you are buying in bulk or are willing to take “less desirable” woods like elm.

Elm Firewood: The Verdict

So, is elm good for burning? The answer is a qualified “yes.” While it may not be the easiest wood to process or the highest in BTU output, elm can be a good value option for those willing to put in the extra effort. Just remember to:

• Season it properly: Give it at least 12-18 months to dry.
• Split it with the right tools: A log splitter is your best friend.
• Burn it hot: Ensure good airflow to minimize smoke and creosote.
• Shop around: Compare prices from local suppliers.

Ultimately, the best firewood is the one that fits your needs and budget. With a little knowledge and effort, elm can be a worthwhile addition to your woodpile.

Diving Deeper: The Economics of Elm Firewood

Now that we’ve covered the basics, let’s delve deeper into the economics of elm firewood, looking at the various cost factors involved in harvesting, processing, and burning it. I’ll share some real-world examples and data-backed insights to help you make informed decisions and maximize your value for money.

Timber Acquisition Costs: From Standing Tree to Firewood Round

The first step in obtaining elm firewood is acquiring the timber. This can involve purchasing standing trees, buying logs from a sawmill, or harvesting trees from your own property (if permitted).

• Standing Timber Prices: The price of standing timber varies greatly depending on species, quality, location, and market demand. Elm, generally, is priced lower than premium hardwoods like oak or cherry.
  • Price Range: \$50 – \$200 per thousand board feet (MBF) for standing elm timber.
• Log Prices at Sawmills: Buying logs from a sawmill can be a more convenient option, but it typically comes at a higher cost.
  • Price Range: \$150 – \$400 per MBF for elm logs.
• Harvesting Your Own Timber: If you have the resources and permission to harvest your own timber, you’ll need to factor in the costs of equipment, labor, and permits (if required).

Data Point: According to Forest2Market, a timber market analysis firm, timber prices are influenced by factors such as mill demand, export markets, and weather conditions.

My Experience: I’ve harvested elm timber from my own property on several occasions. While it requires significant upfront investment in equipment and time, it can be a cost-effective option in the long run, especially if you have a readily available source of timber.

Cost Breakdown: Harvesting Your Own Elm Timber (Example)

| Item | Cost | Notes | | Felling and Bucking (Chainsaw, fuel, oil) | \$50 – \$150 per day | Assumes you own the chainsaw. Includes fuel, oil, and maintenance.

Chainsaw Costs: A Deeper Dive

Since we are talking about cost, let’s talk about chainsaw cost in detail.

Chainsaw Purchase Costs:

• Entry-Level Chainsaw (Gas or Electric): \$150 – \$300 (suitable for small jobs and occasional use)
• Mid-Range Chainsaw (Gas): \$300 – \$600 (more powerful, better for regular firewood cutting)
• Professional-Grade Chainsaw (Gas): \$600 – \$1,000+ (designed for heavy-duty use and demanding tasks)
• Battery Powered Chainsaw (40V-80V): \$250 – \$700 (These are becoming more powerful and can handle a good amount of work.)

Chainsaw Maintenance Costs (Annual):

• Bar Oil: \$20 – \$50 (depending on usage)
• Chain Sharpening: \$20 – \$40 (if done professionally, more if you buy your own tools)
• Air Filter: \$5 – \$15 (replace annually)
• Spark Plug: \$5 – \$10 (replace annually)
• Fuel Costs (Gas Chainsaws):
  • Average Fuel Consumption: 0.5 – 1 gallon per day of heavy use (varies with chainsaw size and workload).
  • Fuel Cost per Gallon: \$3 – \$5 (depending on location and fuel type).
• Repairs: \$50 – \$200+ (for major repairs, depending on the problem)

Depreciation: Chainsaws depreciate over time, especially with heavy use. Factor in the cost of replacing your chainsaw every 5-10 years, depending on its quality and how well you maintain it.

Example:

Let’s say you purchase a mid-range gas chainsaw for \$450.

• Annual Maintenance: \$100 (oil, sharpening, filter, plug)
• Fuel Cost: \$150 (30 gallons per year x \$5/gallon)
• Depreciation (10-year lifespan): \$45 per year
• Total Annual Cost: \$295

Cost Saving Tips:

• Buy a quality chainsaw: A well-built chainsaw will last longer and require less maintenance.
• Maintain your chainsaw regularly: Proper maintenance extends the life of your chainsaw and prevents costly repairs.
• Sharpen your chain yourself: Learning to sharpen your chain can save you money on professional sharpening services.
• Shop around for fuel and oil: Prices can vary significantly between retailers.
• Consider a used chainsaw: You can often find good deals on used chainsaws, but be sure to inspect them carefully before buying.

Permits and Regulations: Before harvesting timber, it’s crucial to check with your local authorities regarding permits and regulations. These can vary depending on your location and the type of harvesting you are planning.

• Permit Fees: \$25 – \$100+ (depending on location and scope of the project)
• Compliance Costs: Costs associated with complying with regulations, such as erosion control measures or replanting requirements.

Cost Optimization Tip: Research permit requirements and regulations thoroughly to avoid unexpected costs or delays.

Wood Processing Costs: From Rounds to Stacked Firewood

Once you have your timber, the next step is processing it into firewood. This involves bucking the logs into rounds, splitting the rounds into manageable pieces, and stacking the firewood for seasoning.

• Bucking Costs:
  • Chainsaw Fuel and Oil: As mentioned earlier, expect to spend \$3 – \$5 per gallon on fuel and oil for your chainsaw.
  • Chainsaw Maintenance: Regular maintenance, such as chain sharpening and air filter replacement, will also add to the cost.
• Splitting Costs:
  • Log Splitter Rental or Purchase: As discussed earlier, renting a log splitter costs \$75 – \$150 per day, while purchasing one can range from \$200 to \$2,000+.
  • Manual Splitting Tools: Maul and wedges cost \$50 – \$90.
• Stacking Costs:
  • Labor: Stacking firewood is labor-intensive, so factor in the cost of your time or the wages of hired help.
    • Labor Rate: \$15 – \$30 per hour.
  • Equipment: You may need a wheelbarrow or other equipment to transport the firewood to the stacking location.

Cost Breakdown: Processing Elm Firewood (per cord)

| Item | Cost | Notes

Learn more