Is Box Elder a Good Tree for Lumber? (5 Milling Tips)

Alright, let’s dive into the world of Box Elder and see if it’s a lumber jack-of-all-trades or better left to its own devices.

Is Box Elder a Good Tree for Lumber? (5 Milling Tips)

We’re seeing a surge in interest in alternative wood species. The usual suspects—oak, maple, cherry—are getting pricier, and folks are looking for cost-effective and readily available options. Box Elder (Acer negundo) often pops up in these conversations. Now, I’ve spent a good chunk of my life around sawmills and woodlots, and I’ve got some opinions – backed by experience – on this often-overlooked tree. So, is Box Elder a good tree for lumber? The answer, as with most things in woodworking, is: it depends.

Let’s get into the nitty-gritty.

Box Elder: The Underdog of the Acer Family

Box Elder is a maple, technically. But don’t let that fool you into thinking it’s going to behave like its cousins, the hard maples. It’s the black sheep of the family, often considered a “trash tree” because of its fast growth, tendency to self-prune (read: drop branches), and relatively short lifespan. But that reputation isn’t entirely fair.

I remember one time, back when I was just starting out, I needed lumber for a quick project – some shelving in my shed. I was broke as a joke, and a friend offered me a Box Elder log he’d taken down in his yard. I was skeptical, but desperate. And that’s how I got my first real experience milling Box Elder.

The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly: Box Elder Characteristics

Before you even think about firing up your chainsaw mill, you need to know what you’re dealing with.

The Good:

• Availability: Box Elder is widespread across North America and even parts of Europe. It grows like a weed in disturbed areas, making it readily accessible. Finding it is rarely an issue.
• Workability: It’s relatively soft and easy to work with hand tools and power tools alike. It planes, sands, and shapes without too much fuss.
• Unique Figure: Some Box Elder trees exhibit a stunning red streaking caused by a fungus. This “red stain” Box Elder is highly prized for its unique aesthetic and can fetch a decent price.
• Cost: Because it’s often considered a nuisance tree, Box Elder logs can sometimes be had for next to nothing. This makes it an attractive option for budget-conscious woodworkers.

The Bad:

• Durability: Box Elder is not rot-resistant. It’s best suited for indoor projects where it won’t be exposed to moisture or the elements. Forget about using it for decking, siding, or anything that lives outside.
• Strength: It’s not a strong wood. It’s softer and less dense than most other hardwoods. This means it’s not ideal for structural applications or projects that require high strength.
• Warping and Twisting: Box Elder is prone to warping and twisting as it dries. Proper drying techniques are crucial to minimize these issues.
• Insect Attraction: Box Elder bugs are drawn to the tree, and while they don’t typically damage the wood itself, they can be a nuisance during processing.

The Ugly:

• Short Lifespan: Box Elder trees don’t live as long as other hardwoods. This means the logs you find may be smaller and have more knots and imperfections.
• Inconsistent Grain: The grain can be irregular and unpredictable, making it challenging to work with at times.
• Staining: Box Elder is susceptible to staining from metal contact, so you need to be careful when handling it.

Data-Backed Insights: Box Elder vs. The Competition

Let’s look at some hard numbers to put Box Elder in perspective:

As you can see, Box Elder lags behind in both hardness and density compared to other common hardwoods. This confirms what I’ve experienced firsthand: it’s a softer, less durable wood.

5 Milling Tips for Box Elder Success

Okay, so you’re still interested in milling Box Elder. Good on you for being adventurous! Here are five tips to help you make the most of this often-maligned wood:

1. Selection is Key: Choose Wisely

This is where it all starts. Don’t just grab the first Box Elder log you see. Look for:

• Size: Larger logs are always better. They’ll give you more usable lumber and fewer knots. Aim for logs at least 12 inches in diameter.
• Straightness: Avoid logs with severe bends or crooks. These will be difficult to mill and are more likely to warp.
• Soundness: Check for signs of rot or decay. Avoid logs with soft spots, fungal growth, or excessive insect damage. A solid, heavy log is a good sign.
• Red Stain: If you’re after that unique red coloration, look for logs with visible streaking. The more red, the better!

I once passed up a massive Box Elder log because it had a slight crook in it. Regretted it ever since! The potential yield of clear, wide boards would have been worth the extra effort. Learn from my mistake.

2. Milling Strategy: Think Ahead

Box Elder has a tendency to move as it dries, so your milling strategy is crucial.

• Quarter-Sawing: This method produces more stable lumber that is less prone to warping. It’s more time-consuming and generates more waste, but it’s worth it for Box Elder.
• Thick Slabs: Cut your lumber thicker than you normally would. This will give you more material to work with after the inevitable warping and twisting. I recommend milling at least 8/4 (2 inches) for most projects.
• Seal the Ends: As soon as you’ve milled your lumber, seal the ends with a wax-based sealant. This will slow down the drying process and prevent end-checking (cracking).
• Consider a Chainsaw Mill: Given the often-unpredictable nature of Box Elder logs, a chainsaw mill can be a great option for processing them on-site. This allows you to mill logs that might be too awkward or large to transport to a traditional sawmill.

I’ve found that using a chainsaw mill with a ripping chain gives me the most control over the milling process, especially when dealing with oddly shaped Box Elder logs.

3. Drying Techniques: Patience is a Virtue

Drying Box Elder properly is essential. Here’s what I recommend:

• Air Drying: This is the most common and cost-effective method. Stack your lumber with stickers (thin strips of wood) between each layer to allow for air circulation. Place the stack in a well-ventilated area, out of direct sunlight and rain.
• Kiln Drying: If you have access to a kiln, this is the fastest and most reliable way to dry Box Elder. Kiln drying reduces the risk of warping and twisting and ensures that the lumber is thoroughly dried.
• Slow and Steady: Don’t rush the drying process. Box Elder needs time to acclimate to its environment. Allow at least one year per inch of thickness for air drying.
• Monitor Moisture Content: Use a moisture meter to track the moisture content of your lumber. Aim for a moisture content of 6-8% for indoor projects.

I learned the hard way about the importance of slow drying. I rushed a batch of Box Elder lumber, and it ended up looking like a pretzel. Now I’m a firm believer in patience.

4. Working with the Wood: Sharp Tools are Your Friend

Box Elder is relatively soft, so sharp tools are essential for achieving clean cuts and smooth surfaces.

• Sharp Blades: Use sharp saw blades, planer knives, and chisels. Dull tools will tear the wood fibers and leave a rough finish.
• Shallow Cuts: Take shallow cuts when planing or routing Box Elder. This will prevent tear-out and ensure a smooth surface.
• Sand Carefully: Box Elder sands easily, but be careful not to over-sand. Use progressively finer grits of sandpaper, starting with 120-grit and working your way up to 220-grit.
• Pre-Drill: Box Elder is prone to splitting, so pre-drill pilot holes before driving screws or nails.

I always keep a honing steel handy when working with Box Elder. A few quick strokes on the steel can make a big difference in the quality of the cut.

5. Finishing Touches: Enhance the Beauty

Box Elder takes finishes well, but it’s important to choose the right finish for the project.

• Oil-Based Finishes: These finishes enhance the natural color and grain of the wood. They also provide good protection against moisture and wear.
• Water-Based Finishes: These finishes are more environmentally friendly and dry quickly. They are a good choice for projects that require a clear, non-yellowing finish.
• Dyes and Stains: Box Elder can be easily dyed or stained to achieve a variety of colors. This is a great way to enhance the red streaking in red stain Box Elder.
• Consider a Hardener: Because Box Elder is relatively soft, consider applying a wood hardener to increase its durability. This is especially important for projects that will see a lot of use.

I’ve had great success using a clear, oil-based finish on Box Elder. It really brings out the warmth and character of the wood.

Case Study: Box Elder Shelving Project

Let’s break down a real-world example: building shelves from Box Elder.

• Equipment Used: Chainsaw mill, moisture meter, planer, sander, table saw, drill, various hand tools.
• Wood Type: Locally sourced Box Elder log with moderate red staining.
• Process:
  1. The log was milled into 8/4 slabs using a chainsaw mill.
  2. The slabs were air-dried for one year, with moisture content monitored regularly.
  3. The dried slabs were planed to a uniform thickness.
  4. The shelves were cut to size on a table saw.
  5. The edges were sanded smooth.
  6. Pilot holes were drilled for shelf supports.
  7. The shelves were finished with a clear, oil-based finish.
• Safety Considerations: Chainsaw safety (PPE, proper technique), dust collection during sanding, eye protection.

The finished shelves looked fantastic and added a rustic charm to the space. While they wouldn’t hold extremely heavy items, they were perfect for books, plants, and decorative objects.

The Environmental Angle: Sustainable Choice?

From an environmental perspective, using Box Elder can be a good choice. Because it grows quickly and is often considered a nuisance tree, harvesting it can help to improve forest health and reduce the need to harvest slower-growing, more valuable species.

However, it’s important to source Box Elder responsibly. Make sure the logs come from sustainably managed forests or from trees that were removed for legitimate reasons (e.g., hazard trees, construction clearing).

Challenges Faced by Hobbyists and Small Operations

I know firsthand the challenges faced by hobbyists and small logging operations when working with less conventional wood species like Box Elder.

• Limited Information: There’s not as much information available about working with Box Elder compared to more common hardwoods. This can make it difficult to find reliable advice and techniques.
• Equipment Costs: Investing in the right equipment for milling and drying lumber can be expensive, especially for small operations.
• Time Commitment: Processing lumber from scratch is a time-consuming process. It requires a significant investment of time and effort.
• Space Constraints: Storing and drying lumber requires space, which can be a challenge for hobbyists with limited workshop space.

Despite these challenges, the rewards of working with Box Elder can be significant. It’s a unique and beautiful wood that can add character to any project.

Box Elder in the Global Context

While my experience is primarily based in North America, the challenges and opportunities associated with Box Elder are relevant in other parts of the world as well. In some regions, Box Elder is considered an invasive species, and efforts are being made to control its spread. Utilizing this wood for lumber could be a win-win situation, turning a problem species into a valuable resource.

Actionable Takeaways

• Don’t dismiss Box Elder out of hand. It has its limitations, but it also has potential.
• Focus on selection and proper drying. These are the keys to success with Box Elder.
• Experiment and learn from your mistakes. There’s no substitute for hands-on experience.
• Embrace the unique character of the wood. The red streaking and irregular grain are what make Box Elder special.

My Final Verdict

So, is Box Elder a good tree for lumber? My answer is still: it depends. It’s not a replacement for oak or maple in structural applications. But for decorative projects, shelving, and other applications where strength and durability are not paramount, Box Elder can be a beautiful and cost-effective choice.

Think of it as the quirky, artistic cousin in the hardwood family. It might not be the most reliable, but it’s definitely got character. And sometimes, that’s exactly what you need.

Now, go out there and give Box Elder a try. You might be surprised at what you can create. Just remember to be patient, use sharp tools, and have fun!

Learn more