How to Pull Post Out of Ground (Pro Tips for Stubborn Fence Posts)

How to Pull Posts Out of Ground (Pro Tips for Stubborn Fence Posts)

Successfully removing fence posts involves more than just brute strength. It requires understanding the soil conditions, the type of post, and the best tools for the job. This article will cover a range of techniques, from manual methods to more sophisticated hydraulic systems, and will provide a detailed cost breakdown for each approach, including labor, equipment rental, and material considerations.

Understanding the Challenge: Why are Fence Posts So Hard to Remove?

Before diving into the “how,” it’s important to understand the “why.” Several factors contribute to the difficulty of removing fence posts.

• Soil Compaction: Over time, the soil around the post compacts, creating a tight grip. This is especially true in clay-rich soils. Think of it as the earth hugging the post, refusing to let go.
• Root Entanglement: Tree roots and other vegetation can grow around and through the post, adding another layer of resistance. I’ve personally wrestled with posts that were practically anchored by a network of roots, turning a simple removal into a mini-excavation project!
• Post Depth and Material: The deeper the post is buried, the more soil needs to be overcome. Also, different materials (wood, metal, concrete) react differently to extraction methods. A rotted wooden post might crumble under pressure, while a concrete-filled steel post will require serious muscle.
• Time: The longer a post has been in the ground, the harder it will be to remove. Corrosion, decay, and the aforementioned soil compaction all increase with time.
• Original Installation: How the post was originally installed plays a huge role. Was it simply hammered in? Was it set in concrete? Was gravel used for drainage? These factors significantly impact the difficulty of removal.

Assessing the Situation: Preparing for the Post-Pulling Adventure

Before you start yanking, take a moment to assess the situation. This will save you time, energy, and potentially some money.

1. Identify the Post Type: Is it wood, metal, or concrete? Is it set in concrete? Knowing this will dictate the tools and techniques you’ll need.
2. Inspect the Post: Look for signs of rot, corrosion, or damage. A weakened post might break during removal, making the job even harder.
3. Evaluate the Soil: Is it sandy, loamy, or clay-rich? Is it wet or dry? Different soil types require different approaches. Wet clay, for instance, can create a suction effect, making extraction incredibly difficult.
4. Clear the Area: Remove any vegetation, rocks, or other obstructions around the post. This will give you more room to work and prevent tripping hazards.
5. Consider Underground Utilities: Before digging or using any heavy machinery, call your local utility company to mark any underground lines. Hitting a gas or electrical line is not only dangerous but also incredibly expensive! This is a crucial step that I would never skip.

Method 1: The Manual Approach – Leverage and Persistence

This method relies on simple tools and good old-fashioned elbow grease. It’s best suited for smaller posts, relatively loose soil, and situations where you don’t have access to power tools or heavy equipment.

Tools Required:

• Post Puller/Fence Lifter: This is a long lever with a gripping mechanism that attaches to the post. Prices range from $50 to $200 depending on quality and features.
• Shovel: For digging around the post to loosen the soil. A good shovel costs around $20-$40.
• Digging Bar/Pry Bar: For breaking up compacted soil and prying the post loose. Expect to pay $30-$60 for a sturdy bar.
• Gloves: Protect your hands! A good pair of work gloves costs around $10-$20.
• Safety Glasses: Protect your eyes from flying debris. Safety glasses are usually under $10.
• Wedge (Optional): To drive between the post and the soil. A steel wedge costs around $15-$30.

Procedure:

1. Dig Around the Post: Use the shovel to dig around the post, removing as much soil as possible. Go down at least 12 inches.
2. Loosen the Soil: Use the digging bar or pry bar to break up any compacted soil around the post. Focus on the areas where the soil is most resistant.
3. Attach the Post Puller: Securely attach the post puller to the post, ensuring a firm grip.
4. Apply Leverage: Use the post puller to apply leverage, rocking the post back and forth. This will help to further loosen the soil.
5. Repeat and Persist: Continue digging, loosening, and applying leverage until the post comes loose. This may take some time and effort, so be patient.
6. Use a Wedge (If Needed): If the post is particularly stubborn, drive a wedge between the post and the soil to help break the bond.

Cost Breakdown (Manual Method):

• Tool Purchase (New): $125 – $320 (This is a one-time investment if you plan on doing future fence work.)
• Tool Rental (If Available): $20 – $40 per day (Post puller rental)
• Labor (Your Time): Priceless! But realistically, factor in the value of your time. Even at minimum wage ($15/hour), a 4-hour job is worth $60.
• Contingency (For Unexpected Issues): $20 – $50 (For broken tools, extra digging, etc.)

Total Estimated Cost (Manual Method):

• DIY (Tool Purchase): $205 – $430 (Includes value of your time)
• DIY (Tool Rental): $80 – $150 (Includes value of your time)

Pros:

• Inexpensive: Relatively low upfront cost, especially if you already own some of the tools.
• Environmentally Friendly: No need for fuel or electricity.
• Good Exercise: A great workout!
• Suitable for Tight Spaces: Can be used in areas where larger equipment can’t access.

Cons:

• Labor-Intensive: Requires significant physical effort.
• Time-Consuming: Can take a long time to remove stubborn posts.
• Limited Leverage: May not be effective for deeply buried or concrete-set posts.
• Risk of Injury: Potential for back strain, cuts, and bruises.

Personal Story: I once spent an entire afternoon wrestling with a single fence post using just a shovel and a pry bar. The soil was incredibly compacted, and the post was surrounded by tree roots. By the time I finally got it out, I was exhausted and covered in dirt, but the satisfaction of finally winning the battle was immense!

Method 2: The Jack and Chain Method – Increased Leverage

This method utilizes a hydraulic jack and chain to provide significantly more leverage than the manual approach. It’s suitable for larger posts, moderately compacted soil, and situations where you need more power but don’t want to rent heavy equipment.

Tools Required:

• Hydraulic Jack: A bottle jack or floor jack with a lifting capacity of at least 4 tons. Prices range from $50 to $200.
• Heavy-Duty Chain: A chain with a working load limit of at least 2 tons. Expect to pay $30-$60 for a good quality chain.
• Chain Binder (Optional): For tightening the chain around the post. A chain binder costs around $20-$40.
• Shovel: For digging around the post.
• Digging Bar/Pry Bar: For breaking up compacted soil.
• Gloves: Protect your hands!
• Safety Glasses: Protect your eyes from flying debris.
• Wooden Blocks/Cribbing: To support the jack and chain.

Procedure:

1. Dig Around the Post: Use the shovel to dig around the post, removing as much soil as possible. Go down at least 12 inches.
2. Loosen the Soil: Use the digging bar or pry bar to break up any compacted soil around the post.
3. Wrap the Chain: Wrap the chain around the base of the post, as close to the ground as possible. Use the chain binder to tighten the chain if desired.
4. Position the Jack: Place the hydraulic jack on a stable surface (using wooden blocks if necessary) and position it so that it can lift the chain.
5. Lift the Post: Slowly and carefully use the jack to lift the chain, pulling the post upwards.
6. Repeat and Adjust: Repeat the lifting process, repositioning the chain and jack as needed, until the post comes loose.
7. Maintain Stability: Ensure the post remains stable throughout the process to prevent it from falling and causing injury.

Cost Breakdown (Jack and Chain Method):

• Tool Purchase (New): $100 – $300 (Assuming you don’t already own a hydraulic jack)
• Tool Rental (If Available): $30 – $50 per day (Hydraulic jack and chain rental)
• Labor (Your Time): Again, factor in the value of your time. A 3-hour job at $15/hour is worth $45.
• Contingency (For Unexpected Issues): $20 – $50

Total Estimated Cost (Jack and Chain Method):

• DIY (Tool Purchase): $165 – $395 (Includes value of your time)
• DIY (Tool Rental): $95 – $145 (Includes value of your time)

Pros:

• Increased Leverage: Provides significantly more pulling power than the manual method.
• Relatively Affordable: Less expensive than renting heavy equipment.
• Versatile: Can be used for a variety of post sizes and soil conditions.
• Portable: Easy to transport and use in remote locations.

Cons:

• Requires Some Technical Skill: Need to understand how to safely operate a hydraulic jack and chain.
• Can Be Slow: Requires careful positioning and adjustment.
• Potential for Damage: Risk of damaging the post or surrounding area if not used properly.
• Safety Concerns: Risk of the chain slipping or the jack failing.

Personal Story: I once used a jack and chain to remove a series of old fence posts that were set in concrete. It was a slow and methodical process, but the increased leverage made it possible to extract the posts without having to break up the concrete with a sledgehammer. The key was to take my time and ensure that the jack and chain were properly positioned and secured.

Method 3: The Tractor/Skid Steer Method – Heavy-Duty Power

This method utilizes a tractor or skid steer with a post puller attachment. It’s the most efficient and effective method for removing large numbers of posts, posts set in concrete, or posts in extremely compacted soil. However, it’s also the most expensive.

Tools Required:

• Tractor or Skid Steer: With sufficient horsepower and lifting capacity. Rental rates vary widely depending on location and machine size, but expect to pay $150-$500 per day.
• Post Puller Attachment: A specialized attachment that grips the post and uses hydraulic power to extract it. Rental rates range from $50-$150 per day.
• Operator (If Renting): If you’re not comfortable operating a tractor or skid steer, you’ll need to hire an experienced operator. Labor rates typically range from $50-$100 per hour.
• Safety Gear: Including a hard hat, safety glasses, and steel-toed boots.

Procedure:

1. Attach the Post Puller: Securely attach the post puller attachment to the tractor or skid steer.
2. Position the Machine: Carefully position the machine so that the post puller can grip the post.
3. Grip the Post: Use the hydraulic controls to grip the post firmly.
4. Extract the Post: Slowly and carefully use the hydraulic power to extract the post.
5. Dispose of the Post: Once the post is removed, safely dispose of it.

Cost Breakdown (Tractor/Skid Steer Method):

• Equipment Rental: $200 – $650 per day (Tractor/Skid Steer + Post Puller)
• Operator (If Needed): $50 – $100 per hour (Minimum 4-hour rental)
• Fuel: $20 – $50 per day
• Transportation: $50 – $100 (To transport the equipment to and from the job site)
• Contingency (For Unexpected Issues): $50 – $100

Total Estimated Cost (Tractor/Skid Steer Method):

• DIY (Equipment Rental Only): $320 – $900 per day (Includes fuel and transportation)
• Professional (Equipment Rental + Operator): $520 – $1600 per day (Includes fuel, transportation, and 4 hours of labor)

Pros:

• Fast and Efficient: Can remove a large number of posts in a short amount of time.
• Powerful: Can extract even the most stubborn posts, including those set in concrete.
• Reduces Labor: Minimizes physical effort.
• Safe: When operated properly, it’s a relatively safe method.

Cons:

• Expensive: The most expensive option.
• Requires Expertise: Need to be proficient in operating heavy equipment.
• Limited Access: May not be suitable for tight spaces or areas with limited access.
• Potential for Damage: Risk of damaging the surrounding area if not operated carefully.

Personal Story: I once used a skid steer with a post puller attachment to remove an entire fence line that was set in concrete. What would have taken me weeks to do manually, I was able to accomplish in a single day. The cost was significant, but the time savings and reduced physical strain were well worth it.

Method 4: The High-Lift Jack Method – A Controlled Approach

This method uses a high-lift jack, also known as a farm jack, to provide a controlled and powerful lifting force. It’s a good option for posts that are deeply embedded or set in concrete, but where you want more control than a tractor offers.

Tools Required:

• High-Lift Jack (Farm Jack): A versatile tool with a lifting capacity of several tons. Prices range from $75 to $250.
• Chain or Heavy-Duty Strap: To wrap around the post.
• Shovel: For digging around the post.
• Digging Bar/Pry Bar: For breaking up compacted soil.
• Gloves: Protect your hands!
• Safety Glasses: Protect your eyes from flying debris.
• Wooden Blocks/Cribbing: To provide a stable base for the jack.

Procedure:

1. Dig Around the Post: Use the shovel to dig around the post, removing as much soil as possible. Go down at least 12 inches.
2. Loosen the Soil: Use the digging bar or pry bar to break up any compacted soil around the post.
3. Wrap the Chain/Strap: Wrap the chain or strap around the base of the post, as close to the ground as possible.
4. Position the Jack: Place the high-lift jack on a stable surface (using wooden blocks if necessary) and position it so that it can lift the chain/strap.
5. Lift the Post: Slowly and carefully use the jack to lift the chain/strap, pulling the post upwards.
6. Repeat and Adjust: Repeat the lifting process, repositioning the chain/strap and jack as needed, until the post comes loose.
7. Maintain Stability: Ensure the post remains stable throughout the process to prevent it from falling and causing injury.

Cost Breakdown (High-Lift Jack Method):

• Tool Purchase (New): $75 – $250 (Assuming you don’t already own a high-lift jack)
• Labor (Your Time): A 3-hour job at $15/hour is worth $45.
• Contingency (For Unexpected Issues): $20 – $50

Total Estimated Cost (High-Lift Jack Method):

• DIY (Tool Purchase): $140 – $345 (Includes value of your time)

Pros:

• Powerful Lifting Force: Provides significant lifting power for stubborn posts.
• Controlled Lifting: Allows for precise control over the lifting process.
• Versatile: Can be used for a variety of post sizes and soil conditions.
• Relatively Affordable: Less expensive than renting heavy equipment.

Cons:

• Requires Some Technical Skill: Need to understand how to safely operate a high-lift jack.
• Can Be Slow: Requires careful positioning and adjustment.
• Potential for Instability: Risk of the jack slipping or the post falling if not used properly.
• Safety Concerns: High-lift jacks can be dangerous if not used correctly.

Personal Story: I once used a high-lift jack to remove a series of old fence posts that were set in concrete. The confined space made it difficult to use a tractor, and the manual methods were proving ineffective. The high-lift jack provided the perfect combination of power and control, allowing me to extract the posts safely and efficiently.

Method 5: The Water Displacement Method – A Gentle Approach

This method uses water to loosen the soil around the post, making it easier to remove. It’s best suited for sandy or loamy soils and posts that are not set in concrete.

Tools Required:

• Garden Hose: With a nozzle.
• Shovel: For digging around the post.
• Post Puller/Fence Lifter (Optional): For added leverage.
• Gloves: Protect your hands!
• Safety Glasses: Protect your eyes from flying debris.

Procedure:

1. Dig Around the Post: Use the shovel to dig around the post, removing as much soil as possible. Go down at least 12 inches.
2. Soak the Soil: Use the garden hose to thoroughly soak the soil around the post. Focus on the areas where the soil is most compacted.
3. Wait and Repeat: Allow the water to soak into the soil for several minutes. Repeat the soaking process several times.
4. Attempt to Remove the Post: Try to remove the post using the manual method (post puller or fence lifter).
5. Repeat as Needed: If the post is still stubborn, repeat the soaking and removal process until it comes loose.

Cost Breakdown (Water Displacement Method):

• Water Usage: Negligible (typically less than $5)
• Post Puller Rental (Optional): $20 – $40 per day
• Labor (Your Time): A 2-hour job at $15/hour is worth $30.
• Contingency (For Unexpected Issues): $10 – $20

Total Estimated Cost (Water Displacement Method):

• DIY (No Post Puller): $35 – $55 (Includes value of your time)
• DIY (With Post Puller Rental): $60 – $90 (Includes value of your time)

Pros:

• Inexpensive: Very low cost.
• Easy: Simple and straightforward process.
• Gentle: Minimizes the risk of damaging the post or surrounding area.
• Environmentally Friendly: Uses only water.

Cons:

• Limited Effectiveness: Only effective in certain soil types.
• Time-Consuming: Requires multiple soaking and removal attempts.
• Not Suitable for Concrete: Ineffective for posts set in concrete.
• Weather Dependent: Not ideal for use in rainy weather.

Personal Story: I once used the water displacement method to remove a series of small wooden fence posts from a sandy garden bed. The soil was loose and easy to work with, and the water quickly loosened the remaining soil around the posts. The entire process took less than an hour and required very little effort.

Dealing with Concrete: Breaking the Bond

If your posts are set in concrete, you’ll need to break the concrete before you can remove the post. Here’s how:

Tools Required:

• Sledgehammer: A heavy hammer for breaking concrete. Prices range from $30-$70.
• Cold Chisel: A hardened steel chisel for breaking concrete. Expect to pay $15-$30.
• Safety Glasses: Essential for protecting your eyes from flying debris.
• Gloves: Protect your hands!
• Jackhammer (Optional): For larger concrete footings, a jackhammer can save a lot of time and effort. Rental rates range from $50-$100 per day.

Procedure:

1. Expose the Concrete: Dig around the concrete footing to expose as much of it as possible.
2. Break the Concrete: Use the sledgehammer and cold chisel to break the concrete into smaller pieces. Start by chipping away at the edges of the footing. If using a jackhammer, follow the manufacturer’s instructions carefully.
3. Remove the Concrete: Once the concrete is broken into smaller pieces, remove them from the hole.
4. Remove the Post: Once the concrete is removed, you can use one of the methods described above to remove the post.

Cost Breakdown (Dealing with Concrete):

• Tool Purchase (Sledgehammer & Chisel): $45 – $100
• Jackhammer Rental (Optional): $50 – $100 per day
• Labor (Your Time): A 4-hour job at $15/hour is worth $60.
• Contingency (For Unexpected Issues): $20 – $50

Total Estimated Cost (Dealing with Concrete):

• DIY (Sledgehammer & Chisel): $125 – $210 (Includes value of your time)
• DIY (Jackhammer Rental): $130 – $210 (Includes value of your time)

Important Safety Tip: Always wear safety glasses and gloves when breaking concrete. Flying debris can cause serious injury.

Post Removal Costs: A Summary Table

To help you compare the costs of different post removal methods, here’s a summary table:

Note: Costs are estimates and may vary depending on location, tool quality, and other factors.

Cost Optimization Tips: Saving Money on Post Removal

• Rent Tools Instead of Buying: If you only need to remove posts occasionally, renting tools is a more cost-effective option than buying them.
• Shop Around for Rentals: Compare rental rates from different companies to find the best deal.
• Combine Projects: If you have multiple fence projects planned, consider doing them all at once to save on rental fees and transportation costs.
• Recycle or Reuse Posts: If the posts are in good condition, consider reusing them for another project.
• Sell Scrap Metal: If the posts are made of metal, you can sell them for scrap metal and recoup some of your costs.
• Get Help from Friends or Neighbors: Enlist the help of friends or neighbors to reduce labor costs. Offer them pizza and beer in exchange for their assistance!
• Plan Ahead: Proper planning can save you time and money. Assess the situation carefully, choose the right tools and techniques, and be prepared for unexpected challenges.
• Consider the Season: Soil conditions can vary depending on the season. Removing posts in the spring or fall, when the soil is moist, can be easier than removing them in the summer, when the soil is dry and compacted.
• Negotiate Prices: Don’t be afraid to negotiate prices with rental companies or contractors.

What To Do With The Old Fence Posts?

Once you have removed the old fence posts, you need to decide what to do with them. Here are some options:

• Reuse: If the posts are in good condition, you can reuse them for another fencing project.
• Repurpose: Old fence posts can be repurposed for a variety of other projects, such as garden beds, raised planters, or even furniture. I’ve seen some amazing rustic benches and tables made from reclaimed fence posts!
• Recycle: Metal posts can be recycled at a scrap metal yard.
• Donate: If the posts are in good condition, you can donate them to a local charity or community organization.
• Dispose: If the posts are damaged or unusable, you’ll need to dispose of them properly. Check with your local waste management company for disposal guidelines.
• Burn (If Allowed): In some areas, you may be allowed to burn untreated wood fence posts. Check with your local authorities for regulations and restrictions. Never burn treated wood.

Safety First: Protecting Yourself During Post Removal

Removing fence posts can be a dangerous task. Here are some important safety tips to keep in mind:

• Wear Safety Glasses: Protect your eyes from flying debris.
• Wear Gloves: Protect your hands from cuts and abrasions.
• Wear Steel-Toed Boots: Protect your feet from falling objects.
• Wear a Hard Hat: Protect your head from falling objects, especially when working with heavy equipment.
• Call Before You Dig: Always call your local utility company to mark any underground lines before digging.
• Be Aware of Your Surroundings: Watch out for obstacles, uneven terrain, and other hazards.
• Lift with Your Legs: Avoid back strain by lifting with your legs, not your back.
• Use Proper Lifting Techniques: Keep your back straight, bend your knees, and keep the load close to your body.
• Get Help When Needed: Don’t try to lift heavy objects alone. Get help from a friend or neighbor.
• Take Breaks: Avoid fatigue by taking frequent breaks.
• Use Equipment Properly: Follow the manufacturer’s instructions for all tools and equipment.
• Stay Hydrated: Drink plenty of water, especially on hot days.
• Never Work Under the Influence: Alcohol or drugs can impair your judgment and coordination, increasing the risk of accidents.

Conclusion: Conquering the Post-Pulling Challenge

Removing stubborn fence posts can be a challenging but rewarding task. By understanding the different methods available, assessing the situation carefully, and following proper safety precautions, you can successfully extract those deeply rooted posts without breaking your back (or the bank). Remember to factor in the costs of tools, equipment rental, labor, and disposal when budgeting for your project. And don’t be afraid to ask for help when you need it. Now go forth and conquer those posts!

Next Steps: Planning Your Fence Post Removal Project

1. Assess the Situation: Determine the type of posts, soil conditions, and any obstacles.
2. Choose the Right Method: Select the method that best suits your needs and budget.
3. Gather Your Tools and Equipment: Make sure you have all the necessary tools and equipment before you start.
4. Call Before You Dig: Contact your local utility company to mark any underground lines.
5. Follow Safety Precautions: Wear safety glasses, gloves, and other protective gear.
6. Get Started! Begin the post removal process, following the steps outlined in this article.
7. Dispose of the Posts Properly: Dispose of the old fence posts in an environmentally responsible manner.
8. Enjoy Your New Fence Line! Once the old posts are removed, you can start building your new fence.

Good luck with your project! Remember, patience and persistence are key to success. And don’t forget to celebrate your accomplishment when you’re finished. You’ve earned it!

Learn more