Fisher Wood Stove Price Review (Durability & Efficiency Insights)

Let’s ignite our passion for wood heating with a deep dive into Fisher wood stoves!

Fisher Wood Stove Price Review (Durability & Efficiency Insights)

The scent of woodsmoke curling from a chimney on a crisp winter evening – it’s an image that evokes warmth, comfort, and a touch of self-sufficiency. For many, that image is intertwined with the iconic Fisher wood stove. But in today’s market, where efficiency and environmental concerns are paramount, how does the Fisher stack up? More importantly, is it worth the investment? I’ve spent years splitting wood, tending fires, and researching heating solutions, and I’m here to share my insights into the Fisher wood stove, examining its pricing, durability, and efficiency, so you can make an informed decision.

The Allure of Wood Heat: A Global Perspective

Before we get down to brass tacks about Fisher stoves, let’s take a step back and look at the bigger picture. Wood heating is experiencing a resurgence globally, driven by a desire for energy independence and a connection to simpler times.

• Global Statistics: According to the FAO (Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations), wood fuel accounts for a significant portion of energy consumption in many developing countries, and its use is even increasing in some developed nations due to rising energy costs and environmental awareness.
• Market Trends: The wood stove market is constantly evolving, with manufacturers focusing on cleaner burning technologies and higher efficiency ratings. Pellet stoves, EPA-certified wood stoves, and even wood-fired furnaces are all vying for a piece of the pie.
• The DIY Ethos: There’s a growing movement of people embracing the DIY lifestyle, seeking to reduce their reliance on traditional energy sources. Wood heating fits perfectly into this ethos, offering a tangible way to take control of your heating needs.

Understanding the Fisher Legacy: A Blast from the Past

Fisher wood stoves, originally designed and manufactured by Bob Fisher in Oregon, USA, beginning in the 1970s, quickly gained popularity for their robust construction and impressive heating capabilities. These stoves were built like tanks, often referred to as “The Grandpa Bear” or “The Mama Bear,” and were known for their ability to heat large spaces for extended periods.

A Personal Anecdote: I remember my grandfather’s old Fisher stove; it was a beast! It sat in the corner of his workshop, radiating a comforting heat that chased away the chill even on the coldest days. That stove was a workhorse, burning anything and everything he threw into it. It wasn’t the most efficient, but it was reliable and kept him warm, and that’s what mattered.

Key Features of Classic Fisher Stoves:

• Heavy-Duty Steel Construction: Thick steel plates were welded together to create a firebox that could withstand high temperatures and constant use.
• Simple Design: Fisher stoves were known for their straightforward design, with minimal moving parts, making them easy to maintain and repair.
• Large Firebox: The spacious firebox allowed for burning larger logs, reducing the frequency of refueling.
• Radiant Heat Output: Primarily radiant heaters, they transferred heat directly to objects and people in the room.
• Non-EPA Certified: Crucially, these older models predated strict EPA regulations, meaning they often produced higher emissions than modern stoves.

Dissecting the Price: What to Expect

The price of a Fisher wood stove is a complex issue because, since the original Fisher stoves are no longer in production, you’re primarily looking at used models. Here’s a breakdown of what you might encounter:

• Used Market Variations: Prices can vary wildly depending on the model, condition, location, and the seller’s motivation. I’ve seen them listed anywhere from $300 to $2,000. Always be wary of “too good to be true” deals.
• Factors Influencing Price:
  • Model: The larger “Papa Bear” and “Grandpa Bear” models tend to command higher prices due to their larger heating capacity.
  • Condition: A stove in excellent condition, with minimal rust and no cracks or warping, will be worth more than one that’s been neglected.
  • Completeness: Does it include all the original parts, such as the door, baffle, and legs? Missing parts can be costly to replace.
  • Location: Prices can vary depending on the region. Areas with a strong wood-heating culture may have higher demand, driving up prices.
  • Rarity: Certain less common Fisher models might fetch a premium from collectors.
• Refurbishment Costs: Factor in the cost of any necessary repairs or refurbishment. This might include:
  • Replacing Firebricks: Firebricks protect the steel firebox from extreme heat and eventually crack or crumble.
  • Replacing Door Gasket: A worn-out door gasket will allow air to leak into the firebox, reducing efficiency.
  • Removing Rust: Surface rust can be removed with a wire brush and elbow grease, but severe rust might require professional sandblasting.
  • Repainting: High-temperature stove paint can restore the stove’s appearance and protect it from further rust.
• Installation Costs: Don’t forget the cost of professional installation. This includes:
  • Chimney Inspection: A professional chimney sweep should inspect your chimney to ensure it’s clean and in good working order.
  • Chimney Liner Installation: If your chimney is damaged or doesn’t meet current safety standards, you may need to install a new liner.
  • Clearances: Wood stoves require specific clearances from combustible materials. A professional installer can ensure your stove meets these requirements.
• Cost Comparison: Consider how the total cost of a used Fisher, including refurbishment and installation, compares to the price of a new, EPA-certified wood stove. You might be surprised to find that a modern stove is a more cost-effective option in the long run.

Durability: Built to Last, But With Caveats

Fisher stoves earned their reputation for durability for a reason. The heavy-duty steel construction made them incredibly robust, capable of withstanding decades of use.

• Steel Thickness: The thickness of the steel used in Fisher stoves (typically ¼” or thicker) is significantly greater than that used in many modern stoves. This extra thickness provides exceptional resistance to warping and cracking.
• Welded Construction: The welded seams on Fisher stoves are generally very strong and durable. However, it’s important to inspect the welds for any signs of cracking or weakness.
• Longevity: With proper maintenance, a Fisher stove can last for many years, even decades. I’ve seen them still in use after 40+ years.
• Potential Weak Points:
  • Rust: Rust is the biggest enemy of any steel stove. Pay close attention to areas that are prone to moisture, such as the base and the flue collar.
  • Cracked Welds: Over time, the extreme heat can cause welds to crack. Inspect the welds carefully, especially around the door and the flue collar.
  • Warped Firebox: Excessive overheating can cause the firebox to warp, which can affect the stove’s efficiency and safety.
  • Damaged Baffle: The baffle helps to improve combustion efficiency and reduce emissions. A damaged or missing baffle will negatively impact the stove’s performance.

Efficiency: Where Fisher Stoves Fall Short

While Fisher stoves are renowned for their durability, their efficiency is where they fall short compared to modern, EPA-certified stoves.

• Lack of EPA Certification: Fisher stoves were designed and manufactured before the EPA established strict emissions standards for wood stoves. As a result, they typically have lower efficiency ratings and higher emissions than modern stoves.
• Combustion Technology: Fisher stoves use a relatively simple combustion process, relying on natural draft to supply air to the fire. Modern stoves, on the other hand, often incorporate advanced combustion technologies, such as secondary air systems and catalytic combustors, to burn wood more completely and efficiently.
• Air Leaks: Air leaks around the door and flue collar can reduce efficiency by allowing uncontrolled air to enter the firebox.
• Heat Output: While Fisher stoves can produce a significant amount of heat, much of that heat is lost up the chimney due to incomplete combustion.
• Efficiency Ratings: While precise efficiency ratings for specific Fisher models are difficult to obtain, they are generally estimated to be in the 40-50% range. Modern EPA-certified stoves, in contrast, often achieve efficiency ratings of 70% or higher.
• Fuel Consumption: Due to their lower efficiency, Fisher stoves typically consume more wood than modern stoves to produce the same amount of heat. This can translate into higher fuel costs and more frequent refueling.
• Environmental Impact: The higher emissions from Fisher stoves contribute to air pollution, including particulate matter and carbon monoxide. This can have negative impacts on human health and the environment.

The EPA and Wood Stoves: A Regulatory Landscape

The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) plays a crucial role in regulating wood stove emissions in the United States.

• EPA Regulations: The EPA has established emissions standards for wood stoves to reduce air pollution and improve public health. These standards have become increasingly stringent over time.
• Certified Stoves: EPA-certified wood stoves must meet specific emissions limits and are typically more efficient than non-certified stoves.
• Impact on Older Stoves: Many older wood stoves, including Fisher models, do not meet current EPA standards and may be subject to restrictions or even bans in certain areas.
• State and Local Regulations: In addition to federal regulations, many states and local municipalities have their own rules regarding wood stove emissions. It’s important to check your local regulations before installing or using a wood stove.
• Burn Bans: During periods of high air pollution, some areas may issue burn bans, prohibiting the use of wood stoves and other solid-fuel burning appliances.
• Tax Credits and Rebates: Some governments offer tax credits or rebates for the purchase of EPA-certified wood stoves.
• The Future of Wood Heating: The EPA is constantly evaluating and updating its regulations regarding wood stoves. The trend is toward cleaner burning technologies and stricter emissions standards.

Making an Informed Decision: Is a Fisher Right for You?

So, with all this in mind, is a Fisher wood stove the right choice for your needs? Here’s a breakdown to help you decide:

Consider a Fisher If:

• You Value Durability Above All Else: If you’re looking for a stove that’s built like a tank and can withstand years of heavy use, a Fisher might be a good option.
• You Have a Large Space to Heat: The larger Fisher models can produce a significant amount of heat, making them suitable for heating large homes or workshops.
• You’re on a Tight Budget (Initially): If you can find a used Fisher in good condition at a low price, it might be a more affordable option than buying a new stove. (Remember to factor in refurbishment and installation costs!)
• You’re Comfortable with DIY Repairs: Fisher stoves are relatively simple to repair, so if you’re handy with tools, you can save money on maintenance.
• Local Regulations Allow It: Make sure your local regulations allow the use of non-EPA-certified stoves.

Think Twice About a Fisher If:

• You Prioritize Efficiency and Low Emissions: If you’re concerned about fuel costs and environmental impact, a modern, EPA-certified stove is a better choice.
• You Live in an Area with Strict Air Quality Regulations: Many areas have restrictions or bans on the use of non-EPA-certified stoves.
• You’re Not Comfortable with DIY Repairs: If you’re not handy with tools, you might be better off with a new stove that comes with a warranty and service support.
• You Need Precise Temperature Control: Fisher stoves don’t offer the same level of temperature control as modern stoves.
• You’re Sensitive to Smoke: Fisher stoves tend to produce more smoke than modern stoves, which can be a concern for people with respiratory problems.

Actionable Steps Before Buying:

1. Research Local Regulations: Contact your local building department or air quality agency to find out if there are any restrictions on the use of non-EPA-certified stoves in your area.
2. Inspect the Stove Thoroughly: If you’re considering buying a used Fisher, inspect it carefully for rust, cracks, and other damage.
3. Get a Chimney Inspection: Have a professional chimney sweep inspect your chimney to ensure it’s clean and in good working order.
4. Compare Prices: Compare the total cost of a used Fisher, including refurbishment and installation, to the price of a new, EPA-certified stove.
5. Consider Long-Term Costs: Factor in the cost of fuel, maintenance, and potential repairs when comparing the long-term costs of different stoves.

Maximizing Efficiency (If You Choose a Fisher): Tips and Tricks

If you decide to go with a Fisher stove, here are some tips to help you maximize its efficiency and minimize its environmental impact:

• Burn Seasoned Wood: Burning dry, seasoned wood is crucial for efficient combustion. Aim for a moisture content of 20% or less.
• Use the Right Size Wood: Don’t overload the firebox. Use logs that are appropriately sized for the stove.
• Control Airflow: Experiment with the stove’s air controls to find the optimal setting for efficient combustion.
• Clean the Chimney Regularly: A clean chimney will improve draft and reduce the risk of chimney fires.
• Install a Baffle: If your stove doesn’t have a baffle, consider installing one. A baffle will help to improve combustion efficiency and reduce emissions.
• Seal Air Leaks: Seal any air leaks around the door and flue collar with high-temperature sealant.
• Consider a Catalytic Combustor (Aftermarket): While not originally designed for them, some users have retrofitted catalytic combustors to older stoves to improve efficiency and reduce emissions. This requires careful research and modification.
• Don’t Burn Trash or Treated Wood: Burning trash or treated wood can release harmful toxins into the air and damage your stove.
• Be Mindful of Weather Conditions: Wind and temperature can affect the stove’s performance. Adjust the airflow accordingly.

Fueling Your Fire: The Science of Firewood

No discussion of wood stoves is complete without delving into the art and science of firewood.

• Wood Species: Different wood species have different heating values. Hardwoods, such as oak, maple, and ash, have higher heating values than softwoods, such as pine and fir.
• Seasoning: Seasoning wood is the process of drying it to reduce its moisture content. Seasoned wood burns hotter, cleaner, and more efficiently.
• Moisture Content: The ideal moisture content for firewood is 20% or less. You can measure moisture content with a wood moisture meter.
• Splitting: Splitting wood increases its surface area, allowing it to dry more quickly.
• Stacking: Stacking wood properly allows for good air circulation, which is essential for seasoning.
• Drying Time: The amount of time it takes to season wood depends on the species, the climate, and the stacking method. Generally, it takes at least six months, and preferably a year or more, to properly season firewood.
• Storage: Store seasoned firewood in a dry, well-ventilated area.
• Firewood Calculators: Use online firewood calculators to estimate how much wood you’ll need to heat your home for the winter.
• Sustainable Harvesting: Practice sustainable harvesting methods to ensure that forests remain healthy and productive.

Personal Tip: I always try to get my firewood a year in advance. It gives me plenty of time to split and stack it properly, ensuring it’s perfectly seasoned by the time winter rolls around. I also prefer to mix hardwoods and softwoods. The hardwoods provide long-lasting heat, while the softwoods ignite easily and get the fire going quickly.

Chainsaws and Axes: The Logger’s Toolkit

Preparing firewood often involves felling trees and splitting logs. Here’s a look at the essential tools for the job:

• Chainsaws: Chainsaws are essential for felling trees and cutting logs to length.
  • Types of Chainsaws: Gas-powered, electric, and battery-powered.
  • Bar Length: Choose a bar length that’s appropriate for the size of the trees you’ll be felling.
  • Safety Features: Look for safety features such as chain brakes, anti-vibration systems, and throttle interlocks.
  • Maintenance: Regular maintenance is essential for keeping your chainsaw in good working order. This includes sharpening the chain, cleaning the air filter, and checking the oil levels.
• Axes and Splitting Mauls: Axes and splitting mauls are used for splitting logs.
  • Types of Axes: Felling axes, splitting axes, and hatchets.
  • Weight: Choose a weight that’s comfortable for you to swing.
  • Handle Length: Choose a handle length that’s appropriate for your height.
  • Splitting Wedges: Splitting wedges can be used to split particularly tough logs.
• Safety Gear: Always wear appropriate safety gear when felling trees or splitting logs. This includes:
  • Helmet: Protects your head from falling branches.
  • Eye Protection: Protects your eyes from flying debris.
  • Hearing Protection: Protects your ears from the noise of the chainsaw.
  • Gloves: Protect your hands from cuts and abrasions.
  • Steel-Toed Boots: Protect your feet from falling logs.
  • Chainsaw Chaps: Protect your legs from chainsaw cuts.

Safety First: Felling trees and splitting logs can be dangerous. Always follow proper safety procedures and wear appropriate safety gear. If you’re not comfortable felling trees yourself, hire a professional.

Case Study: Revitalizing an Old Fisher

I once helped a friend restore an old “Mama Bear” Fisher stove that had been sitting in his barn for years. It was covered in rust and the firebricks were crumbling. Here’s what we did:

1. Disassembly: We carefully disassembled the stove, removing the door, baffle, and firebricks.
2. Rust Removal: We used a wire brush and a grinder to remove the rust from the steel plates.
3. Welding Repairs: We had a professional welder repair a few small cracks in the welds around the door.
4. Firebrick Replacement: We replaced the crumbling firebricks with new ones.
5. Gasket Replacement: We replaced the worn-out door gasket with a new one.
6. Painting: We repainted the stove with high-temperature stove paint.
7. Reassembly: We carefully reassembled the stove.

The restored stove looked and worked like new. My friend was thrilled with the results. However, we both knew that while the stove looked great and provided heat, it still wasn’t as efficient or clean-burning as a modern EPA-certified stove. He ultimately decided to use it as a supplemental heat source in his workshop, where emissions were less of a concern.

Troubleshooting Common Issues

Even with proper maintenance, Fisher stoves can experience problems. Here are some common issues and how to troubleshoot them:

• Poor Draft: A poor draft can cause smoke to back up into the room. This can be caused by a dirty chimney, a blocked flue, or a downdraft.
  • Solution: Clean the chimney, clear any obstructions from the flue, and consider installing a chimney cap to prevent downdrafts.
• Excessive Smoke: Excessive smoke can be caused by burning wet wood, a dirty chimney, or a lack of airflow.
  • Solution: Burn dry, seasoned wood, clean the chimney, and adjust the airflow controls.
• Creosote Buildup: Creosote is a flammable substance that can build up in the chimney. Excessive creosote buildup can increase the risk of chimney fires.
  • Solution: Burn dry, seasoned wood, clean the chimney regularly, and consider using a creosote-reducing additive.
• Warped Firebox: A warped firebox can be caused by excessive overheating.
  • Solution: Avoid overheating the stove. If the firebox is severely warped, it may need to be replaced.
• Cracked Welds: Cracked welds can be caused by stress and fatigue.
  • Solution: Have a professional welder repair the cracked welds.

Budgeting for Wood Heat: A Cost-Benefit Analysis

Heating with wood can be a cost-effective alternative to traditional energy sources, but it’s important to factor in all the costs involved.

• Initial Investment: The cost of the stove, chimney, and installation.
• Fuel Costs: The cost of firewood.
• Maintenance Costs: The cost of chimney cleaning, repairs, and replacement parts.
• Labor Costs: The cost of felling trees, splitting logs, and stacking wood (if you hire someone to do it).
• Equipment Costs: The cost of chainsaws, axes, and other tools.
• Time Investment: The time it takes to prepare and burn firewood.
• Savings on Heating Bills: The amount you save on your heating bills by using wood as a heat source.

A Word of Caution: Don’t underestimate the amount of time and effort it takes to prepare and burn firewood. It’s a labor-intensive process.

Next Steps and Additional Resources

If you’re considering heating with wood, here are some next steps you can take:

• Research: Learn as much as you can about wood stoves, firewood, and safety.
• Consult with Experts: Talk to wood stove dealers, chimney sweeps, and other professionals.
• Visit Showrooms: Visit wood stove showrooms to see different models in person.
• Read Reviews: Read online reviews of different wood stoves.
• Contact Local Authorities: Check your local regulations regarding wood stoves.

Additional Resources:

• EPA Website: The EPA website provides information about wood stove regulations and certified stoves.
• National Fire Protection Association (NFPA): The NFPA provides information about fire safety.
• Chimney Safety Institute of America (CSIA): The CSIA provides information about chimney safety and chimney sweeps.
• Local Wood Stove Dealers: Local wood stove dealers can provide information about different stoves and installation services.
• Firewood Suppliers: Local firewood suppliers can provide seasoned firewood.
• Logging Tool Suppliers: Forestry suppliers like Baileys or Northern Tool + Equipment.

The Future of Heating: Balancing Tradition and Innovation

As we look to the future, the role of wood heating will likely continue to evolve. While the charm and self-sufficiency of a wood fire remain appealing, the need for cleaner and more efficient technologies is undeniable.

• Advanced Wood Stoves: Expect to see continued innovation in wood stove technology, with manufacturers focusing on cleaner burning and higher efficiency.
• Pellet Stoves: Pellet stoves offer a convenient and efficient alternative to traditional wood stoves.
• Wood-Fired Furnaces: Wood-fired furnaces can heat entire homes and even provide hot water.
• Renewable Energy Integration: Wood heating can be integrated with other renewable energy sources, such as solar and wind, to create a more sustainable energy system.
• Sustainable Forestry Practices: Sustainable forestry practices are essential for ensuring that forests remain healthy and productive for future generations.

Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to heat with wood is a personal one. Weigh the pros and cons carefully and choose the option that’s right for your needs and circumstances. Whether you choose a classic Fisher stove or a modern EPA-certified model, remember to prioritize safety, efficiency, and environmental responsibility. And most importantly, enjoy the warmth and comfort of a wood fire on a cold winter day!

Learn more