Echo 620P vs 620PW: 60cc Saw Comparison for Firewood Pros (Power Tested)

As the frosty breath of late autumn nips at the air, there’s a familiar scent that begins to dominate the landscape around my small woodlot: the sharp tang of freshly cut wood, mixed with the sweet, earthy aroma of split logs seasoning in the sun. It’s firewood season, and for folks like me, that means long days spent felling, bucking, splitting, and stacking. The right tools can make or break your back – and your bank account – during these critical months. That’s why the question of which chainsaw to trust is always top of mind.

For years, I’ve relied on chainsaws to get the job done, and I’ve learned a thing or two about what separates a good saw from a great one. Two contenders consistently rise to the top of the conversation: the Echo CS-620P and the Echo CS-620PW.

Today, I’m going to dive deep into these two saws, comparing them head-to-head, drawing on my own experiences and insights from other professionals in the field. We’ll look beyond the marketing hype and focus on real-world performance, durability, and overall value. I’ll share the nitty-gritty details to help you decide which saw is the right fit for your firewood needs. Trust me, choosing the right tool for the job can mean the difference between a productive season and a frustrating one.

Echo 620P vs 620PW: A 60cc Saw Showdown for Firewood Pros

The Echo CS-620P and CS-620PW are both formidable machines, built for demanding tasks. But subtle differences in their design and features can significantly impact their suitability for different users and applications. Let’s break down what makes each saw tick.

Understanding the Core Specs: Power and Performance

At their heart, both saws share the same 59.8cc two-stroke engine. This engine is the powerhouse behind these machines, delivering the torque needed to rip through hardwoods. While the displacement is identical, Echo claims a slight power advantage for the CS-620PW. Let’s explore why that might be and what it means in practice.

• Engine Displacement: 59.8cc (both models)
• Horsepower: The CS-620PW is often advertised as having slightly higher horsepower, though specific figures can vary depending on the source and testing conditions. I’ve seen figures ranging from 4.5 to 4.7 hp for the PW, while the P model typically hovers around 4.4 hp.
• Torque: Torque is the twisting force that allows the saw to maintain cutting speed under load. Both saws generate ample torque, but the PW’s slightly higher horsepower could translate to a marginal increase in torque as well.
• Weight: The CS-620P is typically a bit lighter than the CS-620PW, which can make a difference during long days of cutting.

My Take: In my experience, the power difference between the two saws is noticeable, but not dramatic. The CS-620PW does feel a bit more responsive, especially when cutting through larger diameter logs or particularly dense wood.

The Handle Debate: P vs. PW

The most significant difference between the two saws lies in their handle configuration. The “P” in CS-620P stands for “Pro,” referring to its traditional, full-wrap handle. The “PW,” on the other hand, features a standard, non-wrap handle. This difference has a major impact on how the saw handles in various situations.

• CS-620P (Pro Handle): The full-wrap handle extends around the entire saw body, providing multiple grip positions. This is particularly useful for felling trees, as it allows you to maintain a secure grip while cutting at different angles. It also offers more leverage when limbing or bucking logs.
• CS-620PW (Standard Handle): The standard handle is more compact and streamlined. Some users find it more comfortable for general-purpose cutting and bucking firewood. It can also be advantageous in tight spaces where a full-wrap handle might be cumbersome.

My Experience: Personally, I prefer the full-wrap handle of the CS-620P for most of my firewood work. I often find myself felling trees in awkward positions, and the extra grip options provide added stability and control. However, I can see the appeal of the standard handle for users who primarily buck logs on the ground or who work in confined areas.

Bar and Chain: Cutting Through the Confusion

Both saws come standard with Oregon bars and chains, but the bar length can vary depending on the specific configuration.

• Bar Length: Common bar lengths for both models range from 20 to 24 inches. The optimal bar length depends on the size of the trees you typically fell and the diameter of the logs you buck.
• Chain Type: Both saws typically come with a .325″ pitch chain, which is a good compromise between cutting speed and durability.
• Chain Tensioning: Both saws feature a side-access chain tensioner, making it easy to adjust the chain tension without disassembling the saw.

Pro Tip: I always recommend investing in high-quality replacement chains. A sharp, well-maintained chain will significantly improve cutting performance and reduce wear and tear on the saw. I’ve had good luck with Oregon, Stihl, and Husqvarna chains.

Key Features and Design Elements

Beyond the handle and bar, several other features differentiate the two saws.

• Decompression Valve: Both saws feature a decompression valve, which makes starting easier, especially when the engine is cold.
• Air Filtration System: Both saws utilize a heavy-duty air filtration system to protect the engine from dust and debris. This is crucial for maintaining performance and extending the engine’s lifespan.
• Automatic Oiler: Both saws have an automatic oiler that keeps the bar and chain lubricated. I always check the oil level before each use and adjust the oiler output as needed.
• Vibration Reduction System: Both saws incorporate vibration reduction technology to minimize operator fatigue. This is especially important during long days of cutting.

My Observation: The air filtration system on both Echo saws is top-notch. I’ve worked in dusty conditions, and the filter has consistently kept the engine clean. This is a major advantage over some other saws I’ve used in the past.

Durability and Reliability: Built to Last?

Echo chainsaws have a reputation for being durable and reliable, and the CS-620P and CS-620PW are no exception. However, proper maintenance is essential for maximizing their lifespan.

• Engine Construction: Both saws feature a durable engine construction with high-quality components.
• Chassis and Components: The chassis and other components are also built to withstand the rigors of professional use.
• Maintenance Requirements: Regular maintenance, including cleaning the air filter, sharpening the chain, and lubricating moving parts, is crucial for keeping the saws in top condition.

Real-World Example: I’ve seen Echo chainsaws that have been used commercially for years with minimal problems. One local logger I know has been running a CS-620P for over five years, and it’s still going strong. He attributes its longevity to regular maintenance and careful operation.

Cost Considerations: Bang for Your Buck

The price of the Echo CS-620P and CS-620PW can vary depending on the retailer and any current promotions. Generally, the CS-620P is slightly more expensive due to its full-wrap handle.

• Initial Purchase Price: Expect to pay a bit more for the CS-620P compared to the CS-620PW.
• Long-Term Costs: Consider the long-term costs of ownership, including fuel, oil, chain replacements, and maintenance.
• Warranty: Echo offers a solid warranty on their chainsaws, which can provide peace of mind.

Value Proposition: Both saws offer excellent value for the money. They provide professional-grade performance at a price point that is competitive with other saws in their class.

The Firewood Pro’s Perspective: Real-World Applications

Now that we’ve covered the technical details, let’s explore how these saws perform in real-world firewood preparation scenarios.

Felling Trees: Power and Control

Felling trees is a critical step in firewood preparation, and the right chainsaw can make the job much easier and safer.

• CS-620P: The full-wrap handle provides excellent control and leverage when felling trees at different angles.
• CS-620PW: The standard handle can be a bit more challenging to use when felling trees, especially in awkward positions.

Safety First: Always wear appropriate safety gear, including a helmet, eye protection, hearing protection, and chaps, when felling trees.

Bucking Logs: Efficiency and Speed

Bucking logs into firewood-sized pieces is another essential task.

• CS-620P: The full-wrap handle can be useful for bucking logs on uneven terrain, as it allows you to maintain a secure grip.
• CS-620PW: The standard handle is well-suited for bucking logs on the ground or on a sawbuck.

Efficiency Tip: Use a sawbuck to elevate the logs off the ground, making bucking easier and reducing strain on your back.

Limbing Branches: Maneuverability and Precision

Limbing branches can be a tedious task, but a good chainsaw can make it more efficient.

• CS-620P: The full-wrap handle provides added leverage and control when limbing branches at different angles.
• CS-620PW: The standard handle can be more maneuverable in tight spaces.

My Method: When limbing, I start by removing the larger branches and then work my way down to the smaller ones. This helps to prevent the saw from binding and makes the job safer.

Wood Species: Matching the Saw to the Material

The type of wood you’re cutting can significantly impact the performance of your chainsaw.

• Hardwoods: Hardwoods like oak, maple, and hickory require more power to cut than softwoods.
• Softwoods: Softwoods like pine, fir, and spruce are easier to cut but can be more prone to splintering.

Data Point: I’ve found that the CS-620P and CS-620PW can handle hardwoods up to about 24 inches in diameter without struggling. For larger diameter hardwoods, you might want to consider a more powerful saw.

Case Study: Firewood Production on a Small Scale

Let’s look at a real-world example of how these saws can be used in a small-scale firewood production operation.

Project: A local firewood producer uses a CS-620P and a CS-620PW to fell trees, buck logs, and limb branches.

Equipment:

• Echo CS-620P (with a 20-inch bar)
• Echo CS-620PW (with a 20-inch bar)
• Sawbuck
• Log splitter
• Safety gear

Wood Types: Oak, maple, and hickory

Process:

1. The CS-620P is used to fell trees.
2. The CS-620PW is used to buck the logs into firewood-sized pieces.
3. The logs are split using a log splitter.
4. The firewood is stacked and seasoned for at least six months.

Results: The firewood producer is able to produce approximately 20 cords of firewood per year using this setup.

Tips and Tricks for Maximizing Chainsaw Performance

Here are some tips and tricks that I’ve learned over the years to help you maximize the performance of your chainsaw.

Chain Sharpening: The Key to Efficient Cutting

A sharp chain is essential for efficient cutting.

• Regular Sharpening: Sharpen your chain regularly, ideally after every few tanks of fuel.
• Proper Technique: Use a chainsaw file and follow the manufacturer’s instructions for proper sharpening technique.
• Professional Sharpening: Consider having your chain professionally sharpened periodically.

My Rule of Thumb: If your saw is producing fine sawdust instead of wood chips, it’s time to sharpen the chain.

Fuel and Oil: The Lifeblood of Your Saw

Using the correct fuel and oil is crucial for maintaining the health of your engine.

• Fuel Mixture: Use a high-quality two-stroke oil and mix it with gasoline according to the manufacturer’s recommendations.
• Bar and Chain Oil: Use a high-quality bar and chain oil to keep the bar and chain lubricated.

Insight: I always use ethanol-free gasoline in my chainsaws to prevent fuel-related problems.

Air Filter Maintenance: Keeping the Engine Breathing

A clean air filter is essential for maintaining engine performance.

• Regular Cleaning: Clean the air filter regularly, especially when working in dusty conditions.
• Replacement: Replace the air filter when it becomes excessively dirty or damaged.

Best Practice: I clean my air filter after every day of use.

Storage: Protecting Your Investment

Proper storage is essential for protecting your chainsaw when it’s not in use.

• Empty the Fuel Tank: Empty the fuel tank before storing the saw for an extended period.
• Clean the Saw: Clean the saw thoroughly before storing it.
• Store in a Dry Place: Store the saw in a dry place to prevent rust and corrosion.

My Storage Routine: I always drain the fuel, clean the saw, and store it in a case when it’s not in use.

Addressing Common Challenges

Let’s discuss some common challenges faced by chainsaw users and how to overcome them.

Chainsaw Won’t Start

A chainsaw that won’t start can be frustrating. Here are some possible causes and solutions.

• Fuel Issues: Check the fuel level and make sure the fuel is fresh.
• Spark Plug: Check the spark plug for fouling or damage.
• Air Filter: Check the air filter for excessive dirt.
• Carburetor: The carburetor may need to be cleaned or adjusted.

Troubleshooting Tip: If your saw won’t start, start by checking the simplest things first, like the fuel level and the spark plug.

Chainsaw Cuts Slowly

A chainsaw that cuts slowly can be a sign of a dull chain or other problems.

• Dull Chain: Sharpen the chain.
• Incorrect Chain Tension: Adjust the chain tension.
• Bar Issues: Check the bar for damage or wear.

Performance Check: If your saw is cutting slowly, check the chain sharpness first.

Chainsaw Vibrates Excessively

Excessive vibration can be a sign of a problem with the saw.

• Loose Components: Check for loose components.
• Damaged Vibration Mounts: Check the vibration mounts for damage.
• Bar Issues: Check the bar for damage or wear.

Safety Note: Excessive vibration can lead to operator fatigue and injury. If your saw is vibrating excessively, stop using it and have it inspected by a qualified technician.

Conclusion: Which Saw is Right for You?

So, after all this analysis, which saw should you choose: the Echo CS-620P or the CS-620PW? The answer, as always, depends on your specific needs and preferences.

• Choose the CS-620P (Pro Handle) if:

  • You frequently fell trees in awkward positions.
  • You need the added leverage and control of a full-wrap handle.
  • You work on uneven terrain.

  • Choose the CS-620PW (Standard Handle) if:

  • You primarily buck logs on the ground or on a sawbuck.

  • You work in tight spaces.
  • You prefer a more compact and streamlined handle.

My Recommendation: For most firewood producers, I recommend the CS-620P. The full-wrap handle provides added versatility and control, making it a better choice for a wider range of tasks. However, if you primarily buck logs on the ground, the CS-620PW might be a better fit.

Ultimately, the best way to decide which saw is right for you is to try them both out if possible. See which one feels more comfortable in your hands and which one better suits your cutting style. Whichever saw you choose, remember to always wear appropriate safety gear and follow the manufacturer’s instructions for safe operation.

With the right chainsaw and a little hard work, you’ll be well on your way to building a warm and cozy fire this winter. And that, my friends, is a reward worth working for.

Learn more