Douglas Fir vs Cedar Rot Resistance (5 Pro Tips for Woodworkers)

The global wood processing and firewood industry is a powerhouse, with the global timber market alone projected to reach nearly $1.4 trillion by 2027. This immense demand underscores the importance of understanding wood properties, especially as sustainable sourcing and durability become increasingly critical. Whether you’re crafting outdoor furniture, building a deck, or simply stockpiling firewood, knowing the strengths and weaknesses of different wood species can save you time, money, and a whole lot of frustration.

Douglas Fir vs. Cedar: A Rot Resistance Showdown (and 5 Pro Tips for Woodworkers)

Understanding the Stakes: Why Rot Resistance Matters

Before we get into the nitty-gritty, let’s understand why rot resistance is so crucial. Wood rot, caused by fungi, thrives in damp environments. It weakens the wood, making it structurally unsound and aesthetically unappealing. In outdoor applications, this can lead to premature failure of your projects, requiring costly repairs or replacements. For firewood, rot reduces the wood’s energy content, making it harder to start and less efficient to burn.

Firsthand Experience: A Costly Lesson

I remember one time, I was building a raised garden bed for my wife using what I thought was “good enough” wood. I didn’t pay close enough attention to its rot resistance, and within just a couple of seasons, the corners were crumbling. I ended up having to rebuild the whole thing, this time using cedar. That experience taught me a valuable lesson: investing in rot-resistant wood upfront can save you a lot of headaches (and backaches) down the line.

Douglas Fir: The Workhorse of Construction

Douglas Fir is a softwood, known for its strength, stiffness, and availability. It’s a popular choice for framing, flooring, and furniture making.

Properties of Douglas Fir

• Strength: High strength-to-weight ratio, making it suitable for structural applications.
• Workability: Relatively easy to work with, accepts nails and screws well.
• Cost: Generally more affordable than cedar.
• Rot Resistance: Moderate. Untreated Douglas Fir is susceptible to rot, especially in contact with the ground.
• Appearance: Distinct grain pattern with reddish-brown heartwood and lighter sapwood.

Data Points & Statistics

• Douglas Fir is one of the most abundant tree species in North America, accounting for a significant portion of the lumber market.
• The Modulus of Elasticity (MOE) for Douglas Fir is around 1,900,000 psi, indicating its stiffness and resistance to bending.
• The lifespan of untreated Douglas Fir in ground contact is typically 5-7 years, depending on climate and soil conditions.

Cedar: The Naturally Durable Choice

Cedar encompasses several species, including Western Red Cedar and Eastern White Cedar, all prized for their natural rot resistance and aromatic properties.

Properties of Cedar

• Strength: Lower strength than Douglas Fir, making it less suitable for heavy structural applications.
• Workability: Easy to work with, but can be brittle.
• Cost: Generally more expensive than Douglas Fir.
• Rot Resistance: Excellent. The natural oils in cedar provide a built-in defense against fungal decay, making it a superior choice for outdoor projects exposed to moisture.

  Pro Tip #1: Understanding Wood Preservatives

  If you choose to use Douglas Fir for an outdoor project, you’ll need to treat it with a wood preservative. There are several types of preservatives available, including:

  • Pressure-Treated Lumber: Lumber that has been impregnated with preservatives under pressure. This is the most effective method of protection.
  • Brush-On Preservatives: Liquids that are applied to the surface of the wood. These are less effective than pressure treatment but can still provide some protection.
  • Borate Preservatives: Water-soluble preservatives that are effective against fungi and insects. These are often used for interior applications.

  When choosing a preservative, be sure to read the label carefully and follow the manufacturer’s instructions.

  Original Research: Comparing Wood Preservation Methods

  I conducted a small-scale experiment to compare the effectiveness of different wood preservation methods. I used Douglas Fir samples and treated them with:

  1. No Treatment (Control): Untreated Douglas Fir.
  2. Brush-On Preservative: Two coats of a commercially available brush-on preservative.
  3. Borate Treatment: Soaked the wood in a borate solution.

  I placed the samples in a damp, shaded area for six months and monitored them for signs of rot. The results were clear:

  • Control: Showed significant signs of rot and decay.
  • Brush-On Preservative: Offered some protection, but still showed signs of rot.
  • Borate Treatment: Provided better protection than the brush-on preservative, but still not as effective as pressure-treated lumber.

  Conclusion: While brush-on and borate treatments can offer some protection, pressure-treated lumber remains the most effective way to protect Douglas Fir from rot.

  Pro Tip #2: Proper Drainage is Key

  Regardless of the wood species you choose, proper drainage is essential for preventing rot. Water is the enemy of wood, so anything you can do to minimize its contact will extend the life of your project.

  • Elevate Structures: Keep wood structures off the ground to prevent moisture wicking.
  • Slope Surfaces: Design surfaces to allow water to run off easily.
  • Ensure Adequate Ventilation: Provide airflow around wood structures to promote drying.

  Case Study: A Deck Building Success Story

  A friend of mine, Mark, built a deck using pressure-treated Douglas Fir for the framing and cedar for the decking. He paid careful attention to drainage, ensuring that the deck was slightly sloped and that there was adequate ventilation underneath. Ten years later, the deck is still in excellent condition, a testament to the importance of proper wood selection and construction techniques.

  Pro Tip #3: Consider the Specific Application

  The best wood species for your project will depend on the specific application.

  • Ground Contact: For projects in direct contact with the ground, such as fence posts or retaining walls, cedar or pressure-treated lumber are the best choices.
  • Outdoor Furniture: Cedar is a good choice for outdoor furniture, as it is naturally rot-resistant and weather-resistant.
  • Decking: Cedar is a popular choice for decking, but pressure-treated lumber can also be used.
  • Interior Trim: Douglas Fir is a good choice for interior trim, as it is easy to work with and takes paint or stain well.

  Pro Tip #4: Budget Wisely

  Cedar is generally more expensive than Douglas Fir. If you’re on a tight budget, you may be tempted to use Douglas Fir for all your projects. However, it’s important to consider the long-term costs. If you have to replace a rotted structure sooner than expected, the cost savings of using Douglas Fir may be negated.

  Here’s a breakdown of typical lumber costs (these can vary significantly based on location and market conditions):

  • Douglas Fir: \$3 – \$5 per board foot
  • Western Red Cedar: \$6 – \$10 per board foot

  Think of it this way: spending a little more upfront on rot-resistant wood can save you a lot of money (and labor) in the long run.

  Pro Tip #5: Source Responsibly

  When purchasing wood, it’s important to source it responsibly. Look for lumber that is certified by the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC), which ensures that the wood comes from sustainably managed forests.

  The Firewood Factor: Douglas Fir vs. Cedar for Burning

  Let’s shift gears and talk about firewood. While this guide primarily focuses on woodworking, understanding the firewood properties of these woods is relevant, especially if you’re clearing land or have leftover scraps.

  Douglas Fir Firewood

  • Pros: Burns relatively hot, readily available in many regions, splits easily when seasoned.
  • Cons: Produces more smoke than hardwoods, can spark and pop, lower BTU output compared to dense hardwoods.

  Cedar Firewood

  • Pros: Lights easily, produces a pleasant aroma, good for kindling.
  • Cons: Burns quickly, low BTU output, not ideal as a primary firewood source, can spark excessively.

  Key Takeaway: Neither Douglas Fir nor Cedar are top-tier firewood choices. Douglas Fir is a decent option for shoulder season burning, but cedar is best reserved for kindling.

  Detailed, Numbered Steps: Preparing Douglas Fir for Firewood

  If you’re stuck with Douglas Fir for firewood, here’s how to prepare it effectively:

  1. Felling the Tree (If Applicable):

     • Safety First: Wear appropriate safety gear (helmet, eye protection, hearing protection, gloves, steel-toed boots).
     • Assess the Lean: Determine the natural lean of the tree and plan your felling direction accordingly.
     • Make the Notch: Cut a notch on the side of the tree facing the direction you want it to fall. The notch should be about 1/3 of the tree’s diameter.
     • Make the Back Cut: Cut from the opposite side of the tree, slightly above the notch. Leave a hinge of wood to control the fall.
     • Wedge (If Needed): Use a felling wedge to help direct the fall if the tree is leaning in the wrong direction.
     • Clear the Area: Ensure the area is clear of people and obstacles before the tree falls.

  2. De-limbing:

     • Work from the Base: Start at the base of the tree and work your way up, removing the branches.
     • Use a Chainsaw or Axe: A chainsaw is faster for larger branches, while an axe is suitable for smaller ones.
     • Cut Away from Yourself: Always cut away from your body to avoid injury.

  3. Bucking (Cutting into Logs):

     • Determine Log Length: Cut the tree into manageable log lengths, typically 16-18 inches for firewood.
     • Support the Log: Use a log stand or rest the log on another log to prevent it from pinching your chainsaw.
     • Cut Straight: Maintain a straight cut to ensure even splitting.

  4. Splitting the Logs:

     • Use a Splitting Axe or Maul: A splitting axe is suitable for smaller logs, while a maul is better for larger, tougher logs.
     • Aim for the Center: Strike the log in the center, aiming for a clean split.
     • Use a Wedge (If Needed): If the log is difficult to split, use a splitting wedge.
     • Safety First: Keep your feet clear and maintain a stable stance.

  5. Stacking and Seasoning:

     • Choose a Sunny and Windy Location: This will promote faster drying.
     • Elevate the Wood: Stack the wood on pallets or other supports to keep it off the ground.
     • Stack Loosely: Allow for airflow between the logs.
     • Cover the Top: Cover the top of the stack with a tarp to protect it from rain and snow.
     • Season for 6-12 Months: Allow the wood to season for at least 6 months, and preferably 12 months, to reduce its moisture content to below 20%.

  Technical Requirements and Specifications for Firewood

  • Moisture Content: Ideally, firewood should have a moisture content of 15-20% for optimal burning. Use a moisture meter to check the moisture content of your firewood.
  • Log Length: Standard firewood log length is 16 inches, but this can vary depending on the size of your fireplace or wood stove.
  • Stacking Method: Proper stacking is crucial for air circulation and drying. A traditional “Holz Hausen” (round stack) or a simple linear stack are both effective.

  Costs, Budgeting, and Resource Management for Firewood Preparation

  • Chainsaw: \$200 – \$1000 (depending on size and features)
  • Splitting Axe/Maul: \$50 – \$150
  • Safety Gear: \$100 – \$200
  • Log Splitter (Optional): \$500 – \$2000
  • Fuel and Oil: Varies depending on usage
  • Maintenance: Chainsaw sharpening, parts replacement

  Resource Management: Consider the time and effort involved in preparing firewood. If you have limited time or physical limitations, it may be more cost-effective to purchase seasoned firewood from a supplier.

  Troubleshooting and Common Pitfalls

  • Chainsaw Kickback: A dangerous situation that can occur when the tip of the chainsaw bar contacts an object. Always use proper cutting techniques and wear appropriate safety gear.
  • Stuck Chainsaw: Can occur when cutting a log that is under tension. Use wedges to relieve the pressure.
  • Difficult Splitting: Some logs are naturally more difficult to split than others. Use a splitting wedge or a hydraulic log splitter.
  • Rotten Firewood: Avoid burning rotten firewood, as it produces less heat and more smoke.

  Next Steps and Additional Resources

  • Local Lumber Suppliers: Research local lumber suppliers to find the best prices and selection.
  • Chainsaw Maintenance Services: Find a reputable chainsaw repair shop for sharpening and maintenance.
  • Firewood Suppliers: If you don’t have the time or resources to prepare your own firewood, consider purchasing it from a local supplier.
  • Forestry Associations: Contact your local forestry association for information on sustainable forestry practices and wood identification.

  Conclusion: Making the Informed Choice

  Choosing between Douglas Fir and Cedar for your woodworking projects or firewood preparation requires careful consideration of their properties, cost, and the specific application. While cedar excels in rot resistance, Douglas Fir offers strength and affordability. By understanding the pros and cons of each species, and by following the pro tips outlined in this guide, you can make informed decisions that will lead to successful and long-lasting projects. Remember, a little knowledge goes a long way, and investing in the right materials upfront can save you time, money, and a whole lot of heartache down the road. So, go forth and create with confidence!

Learn more