Does Elm Burn Well? (5 Hardwood Traits That Affect Heat Output)

The biting chill of late autumn had already begun its insidious creep into the bones. I remember the year vividly. It was the year my old farmhouse, a venerable sentinel against the northern winds, seemed to sigh a little louder, the drafts a little more persistent. My trusty wood stove, usually a comforting friend, was struggling to keep pace. That winter, I learned a valuable lesson about firewood – not all wood is created equal. I’d been burning a mix of whatever I could get my hands on, including a fair amount of elm. The experience led me down a rabbit hole of research, experimentation, and a whole lot of splitting wood. And that, my friends, is where our journey begins.

Does Elm Burn Well? (5 Hardwood Traits That Affect Heat Output)

Globally, the firewood industry is a substantial market, estimated to be worth billions of dollars annually. While precise figures are difficult to ascertain due to informal sales and self-harvesting, the demand for firewood remains strong, particularly in regions with cold climates and limited access to other heating sources. According to recent surveys, hardwood species dominate the firewood market, prized for their density and higher BTU (British Thermal Unit) output. However, within hardwoods, significant variations exist, and understanding these differences is crucial for efficient and effective heating. As of 2024, sustainable forestry practices are gaining increasing importance, with consumers demanding responsibly sourced firewood. This trend impacts the sourcing and pricing of various wood species, including elm.

In this guide, I’ll share my personal insights, coupled with data-backed information, to help you understand whether elm makes good firewood and what factors truly determine a wood’s heat output. We’ll delve into the science of burning wood, examine the specific properties of elm, and explore five key hardwood traits that dictate its value as a fuel source. Whether you’re a seasoned woodsman or a first-time firewood buyer, this guide will equip you with the knowledge you need to make informed decisions and stay warm all winter long.

Understanding the Science of Firewood: BTUs and Beyond

Before we dive into elm specifically, let’s establish a foundation for understanding what makes good firewood. The most common measurement is BTU, or British Thermal Unit. One BTU is the amount of energy required to raise the temperature of one pound of water by one degree Fahrenheit. Higher BTU values generally indicate a wood’s potential to produce more heat when burned.

However, BTUs aren’t the whole story. Other factors, such as moisture content, density, and ease of splitting, also play a significant role in a wood’s overall usability and value as firewood.

• Moisture Content: Green wood (freshly cut wood) contains a high percentage of water, often exceeding 50%. Burning green wood is inefficient because much of the energy is used to evaporate the water instead of producing heat. Seasoned wood, with a moisture content of 20% or less, burns much hotter and cleaner.
• Density: Denser woods generally contain more energy per unit volume. This means a cord of dense wood will typically produce more heat than a cord of less dense wood.
• Ease of Splitting: While not directly related to heat output, the ease of splitting wood affects the amount of labor required to prepare it for burning. This is a practical consideration for anyone who splits their own firewood.
• Smoke Production: Some woods produce more smoke than others. Excessive smoke can be irritating, contribute to air pollution, and potentially pose a fire hazard in chimneys.

Elm: A Closer Look at Its Properties

Elm, encompassing various species like American Elm, Slippery Elm, and Red Elm, is a hardwood tree found throughout North America and Europe. Its properties vary slightly depending on the species, but some common characteristics include:

• Density: Elm is considered a medium-density hardwood. Its density typically ranges from 35 to 45 pounds per cubic foot when dry. This places it between softer hardwoods like poplar and denser hardwoods like oak or maple.
• BTU Value: Elm typically yields around 20 million BTUs per cord, which is considered moderate. This is lower than oak (around 24-30 million BTUs per cord) but higher than softer woods like pine (around 15-20 million BTUs per cord).
• Splitting Difficulty: This is where elm earns its reputation. It is notoriously difficult to split, especially when knotty or green. Its stringy fibers tend to resist splitting along the grain.
• Drying Time: Elm dries relatively slowly, typically requiring at least 12-18 months of seasoning to reach an acceptable moisture content for burning.
• Smoke Production: When properly seasoned, elm burns with a moderate amount of smoke. However, burning green elm can produce significant smoke and creosote buildup in chimneys.

My Personal Experience with Elm: I’ve had my fair share of wrestling matches with elm logs. I remember one particular elm tree that came down during a storm. I thought I’d struck gold, a free source of firewood! But the reality was far different. That elm was a beast to split. I tried everything – wedges, mauls, even a hydraulic splitter strained under the pressure. It taught me a valuable lesson: sometimes, “free” firewood can cost you more in time and effort than buying seasoned wood.

5 Hardwood Traits That Affect Heat Output

Now, let’s explore the five key hardwood traits that significantly impact heat output, using elm as a reference point:

1. Wood Density: The Weight of the Matter

Density is arguably the most important factor determining a wood’s potential heat output. Denser woods contain more mass per unit volume, meaning they pack more energy into the same space.

• How Density Affects Heat Output: A higher density translates directly to more BTUs per cord. Denser woods burn longer and hotter, providing more consistent heat.
• Elm’s Density: As mentioned earlier, elm has a medium density. It’s not as dense as oak or hickory, but it’s denser than softer woods like pine or poplar.
• Comparing Densities:
  • Oak (Red Oak): ~45-50 lbs/cubic foot (high density, high BTU)
  • Maple (Sugar Maple): ~44-48 lbs/cubic foot (high density, high BTU)
  • Elm (American Elm): ~35-45 lbs/cubic foot (medium density, moderate BTU)
  • Ash (White Ash): ~40-45 lbs/cubic foot (medium density, moderate BTU)
  • Poplar (Yellow Poplar): ~28-32 lbs/cubic foot (low density, low BTU)
• Actionable Tip: When selecting firewood, prioritize denser hardwoods if your primary goal is maximum heat output and longer burn times.

2. Moisture Content: The Silent Energy Thief

Moisture content is the percentage of water in the wood. Green wood can have a moisture content of 50% or higher, while seasoned wood should have a moisture content of 20% or less.

• How Moisture Content Affects Heat Output: Water absorbs heat. When burning green wood, a significant portion of the energy is used to evaporate the water, reducing the amount of heat available to warm your home. Green wood also burns inefficiently, producing more smoke and creosote.
• Elm and Moisture Content: Elm is known to dry slowly. This means it requires a longer seasoning period compared to some other hardwoods.
• The Ideal Moisture Content: For optimal burning, aim for a moisture content of 15-20%. You can measure moisture content using a wood moisture meter, which can be purchased for around $20-$50.
• Seasoning Techniques:
  1. Split the wood: Splitting exposes more surface area, accelerating the drying process.
  2. Stack the wood: Stack the wood in a single row, allowing air to circulate freely around each piece.
  3. Elevate the wood: Place the wood on pallets or rails to prevent ground moisture from wicking into the wood.
  4. Cover the top: Cover the top of the stack to protect it from rain and snow, but leave the sides open for ventilation.
  5. Patience is key: Allow the wood to season for at least 12-18 months, or even longer for thicker pieces or humid climates.
• Data Point: Studies have shown that burning seasoned wood can increase heat output by as much as 50% compared to burning green wood.
• Troubleshooting: If you suspect your firewood is not fully seasoned, consider storing it in a dry, well-ventilated area for an additional few months.

3. Resin Content: The Spark Factor (and the Smoke Factor)

While most hardwoods have relatively low resin content compared to softwoods like pine, the presence of resin can still affect how a wood burns.

• How Resin Content Affects Heat Output: Resin is a flammable substance that contributes to the initial ignition and burn rate of wood. However, high resin content can also lead to increased smoke production and creosote buildup.
• Elm and Resin Content: Elm has a relatively low resin content. This means it may take slightly longer to ignite compared to resinous woods like pine, but it also produces less smoke.
• Comparing Resin Content:
  • Pine: High resin content (easy to ignite, but smoky)
  • Birch: Moderate resin content (good ignition, moderate smoke)
  • Elm: Low resin content (requires good kindling, low smoke)
  • Oak: Very low resin content (requires good kindling, very low smoke)
• Actionable Tip: When burning elm, use plenty of kindling to ensure proper ignition. Consider mixing it with a small amount of birch or pine to help get the fire started.

4. Air Drying Time: The Patience Game

We’ve touched on this already, but the time it takes for a wood to reach optimal moisture content is a crucial factor in its usability as firewood.

• How Air Drying Time Affects Heat Output: The longer a wood takes to dry, the longer you have to wait before you can burn it efficiently. Slow-drying woods can also be more susceptible to rot and decay if not properly stored.
• Elm’s Air Drying Time: As mentioned, elm is a slow-drying wood. This is due to its dense structure and relatively impermeable bark.
• Factors Affecting Drying Time:
  • Climate: Humid climates will prolong drying times.
  • Wood Size: Thicker pieces will take longer to dry.
  • Stacking Method: Proper stacking with good ventilation is essential for efficient drying.
• Case Study: I once worked with a small firewood producer who specialized in elm. He found that by using a combination of splitting the wood into smaller pieces and using a fan to circulate air around the stacks, he could reduce the drying time by approximately 20%.
• Budgeting Considerations: The longer drying time of elm can impact your budgeting. You need to plan further in advance, potentially requiring larger storage space or investing in a kiln-drying system (which comes with significant upfront and operating costs).

5. Splitting Difficulty: The Labor Factor

While not directly related to heat output, the ease of splitting wood is a practical consideration for anyone who prepares their own firewood. Difficult-to-split woods require more time, effort, and potentially specialized tools.

• How Splitting Difficulty Affects Overall Value: If you’re splitting wood by hand, a difficult-to-split wood can be physically demanding and time-consuming. This can reduce the overall value of the wood, even if it has a decent BTU value.
• Elm’s Splitting Difficulty: Elm is notoriously difficult to split, especially when green or knotty. Its stringy fibers tend to resist splitting along the grain.
• Tools and Techniques for Splitting Elm:
  • Hydraulic Splitter: A hydraulic splitter is the most efficient way to split elm, especially for larger logs. These range in price from a few hundred dollars for smaller electric models to several thousand dollars for larger gas-powered models.
  • Splitting Maul: A splitting maul is a heavy, wedge-shaped tool designed for splitting wood. It requires significant strength and technique to use effectively.
  • Wedges: Wedges can be driven into cracks in the wood to help split it apart. Multiple wedges may be needed for larger logs.
  • Chainsaw Milling: For extremely large or difficult-to-split elm logs, consider using a chainsaw mill to cut the log into manageable pieces.
• Safety First: Always wear appropriate safety gear, including safety glasses, gloves, and sturdy footwear, when splitting wood.
• Original Research: In my own experience, I’ve found that splitting elm immediately after felling the tree, while the wood is still relatively green, can be slightly easier than waiting until it dries. The wood is softer and less prone to splintering. However, this comes with the trade-off of increased weight and the need for a longer seasoning period.

Elm as Firewood: The Verdict

So, does elm burn well? The answer is… it depends. Elm is a medium-density hardwood with a moderate BTU value. When properly seasoned, it can provide a decent source of heat. However, its primary drawback is its difficulty to split.

Pros of Burning Elm:

• Moderate BTU value
• Relatively low smoke production (when seasoned)
• Widely available in many regions

Cons of Burning Elm:

• Difficult to split
• Slow drying time
• Can be prone to rot if not properly stored

Recommendation:

• If you have access to a hydraulic splitter: Elm can be a viable option, especially if you can acquire it at a low cost.
• If you split wood by hand: Consider mixing elm with easier-to-split woods like ash or maple.
• If you’re looking for maximum heat output: Prioritize denser hardwoods like oak or hickory.

Beyond Elm: Expanding Your Firewood Knowledge

Now that we’ve explored elm in detail, let’s briefly touch on other important aspects of firewood preparation and management:

Chainsaw Selection: The Logger’s Best Friend

The chainsaw is an indispensable tool for felling trees, limbing branches, and bucking logs into manageable lengths.

• Types of Chainsaws:
  • Gas-Powered Chainsaws: These are the most powerful and versatile chainsaws, suitable for a wide range of tasks.
  • Electric Chainsaws: Electric chainsaws are quieter and easier to maintain than gas-powered models, but they are typically less powerful and have a limited range due to the need for a power cord.
  • Battery-Powered Chainsaws: Battery-powered chainsaws offer a good balance of power and convenience. They are quieter than gas-powered models and do not require a power cord.
• Chainsaw Safety: Always wear appropriate safety gear, including a helmet, safety glasses, hearing protection, gloves, and chaps, when operating a chainsaw.
• Chainsaw Maintenance: Regularly sharpen the chain, clean the air filter, and check the oil level to ensure optimal performance.
• Tool Selection Example: For felling larger trees (over 12 inches in diameter), I recommend a gas-powered chainsaw with a bar length of at least 18 inches. For smaller tasks like limbing and bucking, a smaller electric or battery-powered chainsaw may be sufficient.

Wood Stacking Techniques: The Art of Airflow

Properly stacking firewood is essential for efficient drying and preventing rot.

• Key Principles of Wood Stacking:
  • Air Circulation: Allow air to circulate freely around each piece of wood.
  • Elevation: Keep the wood off the ground to prevent moisture from wicking into it.
  • Protection: Cover the top of the stack to protect it from rain and snow.
• Common Stacking Methods:
  • Single Row Stacking: Stacking the wood in a single row is the most efficient way to promote air circulation.
  • Circular Stacking (Holz Hausen): This method involves stacking the wood in a circular pattern, creating a stable and aesthetically pleasing structure.
  • Pallet Stacking: Stacking the wood on pallets provides excellent elevation and air circulation.
• Strategic Recommendation: Experiment with different stacking methods to find what works best for your climate and available space.

Firewood Storage: Protecting Your Investment

Proper firewood storage is crucial for maintaining its quality and preventing rot.

• Ideal Storage Conditions:
  • Dry: Keep the wood protected from rain and snow.
  • Well-Ventilated: Allow air to circulate freely around the wood.
  • Elevated: Keep the wood off the ground.
• Storage Options:
  • Firewood Shed: A dedicated firewood shed provides the best protection from the elements.
  • Tarp: A tarp can be used to cover the top of the wood stack, but it’s important to leave the sides open for ventilation.
  • Pallets: Stacking the wood on pallets provides excellent elevation and air circulation.

Cost and Budgeting: Burning Through the Numbers

Preparing firewood involves various costs, including the cost of tools, fuel, and labor.

• Cost Considerations:
  • Chainsaw: $200-$1000+
  • Splitting Maul: $50-$100
  • Hydraulic Splitter: $500-$5000+
  • Fuel/Electricity: Varies depending on usage
  • Time/Labor: The most significant cost for many DIY firewood producers.
• Budgeting Tips:
  • Factor in all costs: Don’t forget to include the cost of safety gear, maintenance, and transportation.
  • Consider the time investment: Calculate the value of your time and compare it to the cost of buying seasoned firewood.
  • Explore alternatives: Consider purchasing seasoned firewood if the cost of preparing your own is too high.

Troubleshooting and Common Pitfalls

Even with careful planning, things can sometimes go wrong when preparing firewood. Here are some common pitfalls to avoid:

• Assess your needs: Determine how much firewood you need to heat your home for the winter.
• Evaluate your resources: Consider your budget, available time, and access to tools and equipment.
• Explore your options: Decide whether to prepare your own firewood or purchase seasoned wood.
• Start planning early: Begin preparing your firewood well in advance of the heating season.

Additional Resources:

• Local Firewood Suppliers: Search online for local firewood suppliers in your area.
• Forestry Extension Services: Contact your local forestry extension service for information on sustainable forestry practices and firewood preparation.
• Logging Tool Suppliers: Check out online retailers like Bailey’s or Forestry Suppliers for a wide selection of logging tools and equipment.
• Equipment Rental Services: Consider renting a hydraulic splitter or other specialized equipment if you only need it occasionally.

In closing, remember that preparing firewood is a rewarding but demanding task. By understanding the science of burning wood, selecting the right tools, and following best practices, you can ensure a warm and comfortable winter. And while elm may not be the easiest wood to work with, it can still provide a valuable source of heat if you’re willing to put in the effort. Now, get out there, split some wood, and stay warm!

Learn more