Cypress vs Cedar Trees: Wood ID Tips for Arborists (Pro Tips)

Let’s talk about Cypress vs. Cedar.

Cypress vs. Cedar: Wood ID Tips for Arborists (Pro Tips)

The allure of wood, the way it feels beneath my hands, the stories it whispers of forests and time – that’s what drew me to this craft. For years, I’ve been felling trees, milling lumber, and crafting with wood, and the ability to distinguish between different species has become more than a skill; it’s an art. Today, let’s delve into the world of cypress and cedar, two wood types that often get mistaken for one another. While they share some similarities, knowing the nuances can make all the difference, especially for us arborists and woodworkers.

Visual Appeal: First Impressions

Before we dive into the nitty-gritty technical details, let’s appreciate the aesthetic qualities of cypress and cedar. Think of it as judging a book by its cover – a good starting point, but not the whole story.

• Cypress: Freshly cut cypress often exhibits a light yellowish-brown hue, sometimes with reddish undertones. As it ages, it can deepen to a rich, almost golden brown. The grain patterns are generally straight, but knots are common, adding character to the wood. One of the things I appreciate most about cypress is its unique “pecky” variations, caused by a fungus that creates pockets and voids in the wood, giving it a rustic, weathered look.
• Cedar: Cedar, on the other hand, tends to boast warmer, reddish-brown tones from the start. The grain is typically straight and tight, lending itself to a smoother, more refined appearance. Cedar is known for its aromatic qualities, which adds to its appeal.

Distinguishing Cypress and Cedar: A Detailed Guide

Now, let’s get down to the technical aspects of identifying cypress and cedar. These are the details that truly matter when selecting the right wood for a project.

1. The Smell Test: More Than Just a Sniff

Cedar is renowned for its distinct, aromatic scent. This fragrance comes from natural oils present in the wood, which also contribute to its insect-repellent properties. Cypress, while possessing a subtle fragrance, lacks the strong, characteristic aroma of cedar.

• Pro Tip: Rubbing the wood surface with sandpaper can intensify the scent, making it easier to identify.

I remember one time I was helping a friend dismantle an old shed. He was convinced all the wood was cedar, but the moment I took a closer look and gave it the “smell test,” it was clear that a good portion of it was actually cypress. The subtle, almost earthy smell of cypress was a dead giveaway.

2. Grain and Texture: A Closer Look

Examining the grain and texture is crucial in distinguishing cypress and cedar.

• Cypress: Typically features a coarser texture compared to cedar. The grain can be straight, but it often exhibits variations and irregularities, especially around knots. Bald cypress, in particular, is known for its prominent growth rings.
• Cedar: Generally has a finer, more uniform texture. The grain is usually straight and tight, resulting in a smoother surface.

Data Point: On average, cedar has a grain density of around 6-8 growth rings per inch, while cypress may have 4-6 growth rings per inch.

3. Color Variations: A Subtle Palette

While both woods can exhibit reddish-brown hues, the specific shades and color variations differ.

• Cypress: Ranges from light yellowish-brown to reddish-brown, often with noticeable color variations within the same piece of wood. Pecky cypress, as mentioned earlier, has distinct pockets and voids that add to its visual complexity.
• Cedar: Typically displays a consistent reddish-brown color throughout. The heartwood tends to be darker than the sapwood, but the overall color variation is less pronounced than in cypress.

4. Weight and Density: Feel the Difference

Weight and density can provide valuable clues, especially when dealing with larger pieces of wood.

• Cypress: Generally heavier and denser than cedar. This is due to its higher moisture content and tighter grain structure.
• Cedar: Lighter and less dense, making it easier to work with and transport.

Data Point: The average density of cypress is around 32 lbs/cubic foot, while cedar ranges from 22-28 lbs/cubic foot.

5. Durability and Resistance: Standing the Test of Time

Both cypress and cedar are known for their natural resistance to decay and insects, but there are subtle differences.

• Cypress: Highly resistant to rot, decay, and insects, making it suitable for outdoor applications such as siding, decking, and boatbuilding. The heartwood of cypress is particularly durable.
• Cedar: Also resistant to decay and insects, thanks to its natural oils. It is commonly used for siding, shingles, and closet linings.

Industry Standard: According to the American Wood Protection Association (AWPA), both cypress and cedar are classified as naturally durable woods, meaning they can withstand exposure to the elements for extended periods without significant degradation.

6. Working Properties: A Woodworker’s Perspective

As a woodworker, I know that the ease of working with a particular wood species is a major consideration.

• Cypress: Can be challenging to work with due to its density and tendency to splinter. However, it glues and finishes well.
• Cedar: Generally easier to work with, as it is softer and less prone to splintering. It cuts, shapes, and sands easily.

Pro Tip: When working with cypress, use sharp tools and take light cuts to minimize splintering.

7. Moisture Content: A Critical Factor

Moisture content plays a crucial role in the stability and performance of wood.

• Cypress: Typically has a higher moisture content than cedar, especially when freshly cut. It requires proper drying to prevent warping and cracking.
• Cedar: Naturally has a lower moisture content, making it more stable and less prone to movement.

Technical Limitation: For firewood, the maximum moisture level should be below 20% to ensure efficient burning. Cypress can take longer to dry than cedar due to its higher initial moisture content.

8. Cost and Availability: Economic Considerations

Cost and availability can vary depending on location and market conditions.

• Cypress: Generally more expensive than cedar, especially in areas where it is not locally sourced.
• Cedar: More readily available and often more affordable, particularly in regions where cedar forests are abundant.

9. Bark Characteristics: A Final Clue

While we’re primarily focusing on the wood itself, the bark can also offer clues for identification.

• Cypress: Bark is thick, fibrous, and reddish-brown to gray in color. It has a distinctive furrowed texture.
• Cedar: Bark is relatively thin, reddish-brown, and peels off in long, shreddy strips.

Case Study: Cypress Decking Project

I once undertook a project to build a large deck using cypress. The client specifically requested cypress for its natural durability and resistance to decay, as the deck was located near a lake.

• Log Dimensions: I sourced cypress logs with an average diameter of 18 inches and a length of 12 feet.
• Material Specifications: The wood was air-dried to a moisture content of 15% before construction.
• Tool Requirements: I used a heavy-duty chainsaw with a 20-inch bar for milling the logs into lumber.
• Challenges: Working with cypress proved challenging due to its density and tendency to splinter. I had to use sharp blades and take light cuts to achieve smooth surfaces.
• Outcome: The resulting deck was beautiful and durable, showcasing the natural beauty of cypress. The client was extremely satisfied with the project.

Safety First: Essential Precautions

When working with any type of wood, safety should always be your top priority.

• Eye Protection: Wear safety glasses or goggles to protect your eyes from flying debris.
• Hearing Protection: Use earplugs or earmuffs to protect your hearing from the noise of power tools.
• Respiratory Protection: Wear a dust mask or respirator to avoid inhaling sawdust and other airborne particles.
• Gloves: Use work gloves to protect your hands from splinters and sharp edges.
• Proper Clothing: Wear appropriate clothing, including long sleeves and pants, to protect your skin.

Tool Calibration Standards: Chainsaws should be calibrated regularly to ensure optimal performance and safety. This includes checking the chain tension, sharpening the chain, and adjusting the carburetor.

Summary Table: Cypress vs. Cedar

Conclusion: Making the Right Choice

Choosing between cypress and cedar depends on your specific needs and preferences. Both woods offer unique aesthetic qualities and practical benefits. By understanding the key differences in their characteristics, you can make an informed decision and select the right wood for your project.

Remember, the best way to truly learn is through experience. Get your hands on samples of both cypress and cedar, and practice identifying them using the tips and techniques I’ve shared. Over time, you’ll develop a keen eye and an intuitive understanding of these wonderful woods.

Happy woodworking!

Learn more