Cut Small Trees Safely (5 Pro Tips for Controlled Felling)

The Alluring Aroma of Black Locust: A Woodsman’s Guide to Safe and Controlled Small Tree Felling & Budgeting

There’s something undeniably satisfying about the scent of freshly cut wood. For me, that smell is often intertwined with the distinctive aroma of black locust. This wood, with its incredible rot resistance, is a treasure. I recall a time I was helping a friend reclaim some overgrown pastureland. We were clearing out a thicket of small black locust trees, each one about 6-8 inches in diameter. The wood was destined for fence posts, a perfect application given its durability. But getting those trees down safely and efficiently required a thoughtful approach, especially given the uneven terrain and the proximity to existing structures.

That experience, and many others like it, underscored the importance of controlled felling techniques. And, of course, the ever-present question: “How much will this really cost?” So, let’s delve into the world of felling small trees safely, and then meticulously dissect the budgeting process for such endeavors.

Mastering the Art of Felling Small Trees Safely: 5 Pro Tips for Controlled Felling

Felling small trees might seem straightforward, but complacency can lead to accidents. Here are five pro tips that I’ve learned over the years, aimed at ensuring a safe and controlled felling process:

1. Size Up the Situation: A Thorough Assessment is Key:

   • Tree Lean: Determine the natural lean of the tree. This is the direction it will naturally want to fall. Look for branches that are heavier on one side, or a trunk that bends noticeably.
   • Obstacles: Identify any obstacles in the potential fall zone. This includes power lines, buildings, fences, other trees, and, most importantly, people! I once nearly had a disaster when a seemingly insignificant sapling snagged on a higher branch of a neighboring tree, causing it to unexpectedly swing back in my direction. Always have an escape route planned.
   • Wind Conditions: Even a slight breeze can significantly alter the trajectory of a falling tree, especially smaller ones. Avoid felling trees in high winds.
   • Tree Health: Inspect the tree for signs of rot or decay. Weakened trees can behave unpredictably. Look for fungal growth, hollow spots, or excessive insect damage.
   • Terrain: Assess the slope and stability of the ground around the tree. Uneven terrain can make it difficult to maintain your footing or control the fall.

2. Gear Up for Success: Essential Equipment for Safe Felling:

   • Chainsaw: A well-maintained chainsaw is essential. Ensure it’s the appropriate size for the trees you’re felling. A smaller chainsaw (14-16 inch bar) is typically sufficient for trees under 12 inches in diameter. I prefer a gas-powered saw for its power and portability, but battery-powered models are becoming increasingly capable.
   • Personal Protective Equipment (PPE): This is non-negotiable. At a minimum, you need:
     • Helmet: With a face shield and hearing protection.
     • Eye Protection: Even with a face shield, wear safety glasses or goggles.
     • Gloves: To improve grip and protect your hands.
     • Chainsaw Chaps: These provide crucial protection for your legs.
     • Steel-Toed Boots: To protect your feet from falling objects.
   • Wedges: Plastic or aluminum wedges are used to help direct the fall of the tree.
   • Felling Lever or Peavey: Useful for maneuvering smaller trees or logs.
   • Measuring Tape: To accurately measure the tree’s diameter and determine the appropriate cut depth.
   • First-Aid Kit: Be prepared for minor injuries.

3. The Art of the Cut: Mastering Felling Techniques for Small Trees:

   • The Notch: The notch determines the direction of the fall. It’s typically cut on the side of the tree facing the desired fall direction. The notch should be about 1/3 of the tree’s diameter.
     • Open Face Notch: A common and effective notch for smaller trees. It consists of a top cut at a 60-degree angle and a bottom cut that meets the top cut, creating an open wedge.
     • Humboldt Notch: Similar to the open face notch, but the bottom cut is made first. This is useful for trees with a slight back lean.
   • The Back Cut: The back cut is made on the opposite side of the tree from the notch, slightly above the base of the notch. Leave a hinge of wood (about 1/10 of the tree’s diameter) to control the fall. Never cut completely through the tree.
   • Using Wedges: If the tree doesn’t start to fall on its own, insert wedges into the back cut and tap them in with a hammer or axe. This will help to push the tree over in the desired direction.

4. Escape Routes: Planning Your Exit Strategy:

   • Clear the Area: Before making any cuts, clear a path behind the tree at a 45-degree angle in both directions. This will be your escape route.
   • Keep an Eye on the Tree: As you’re making the cuts, constantly monitor the tree for any signs of movement. Be prepared to abandon your work and move to your escape route if necessary.
   • Communicate: If you’re working with others, establish clear communication signals.

5. Post-Felling Procedures: Dealing with the Aftermath:

   1. Timber Acquisition or Harvesting Costs

   The first cost you’ll encounter is the acquisition of the timber itself. This cost can vary dramatically depending on several factors:

   • Source of Timber:

     • Standing Timber Purchase: If you’re purchasing standing timber from a landowner, the price will depend on the species, size, quality, and accessibility of the trees. Timber prices fluctuate based on market demand and regional variations.
     • Harvesting from Your Own Land: If you’re harvesting trees from your own property, you won’t have a direct purchase cost, but you’ll still need to factor in the value of the timber. This is especially important if you’re planning to sell the processed wood.
     • Salvaged Timber: Sometimes, you can acquire timber for free or at a reduced cost by salvaging downed trees or clearing land for development. However, salvaged timber may require more processing and may be of lower quality.

   • Wood Species:

     • High-Value Species: Species like black walnut, cherry, and oak command higher prices due to their desirable properties for furniture making and other high-end applications.
     • Common Species: Species like pine, poplar, and maple are typically less expensive.
     • Firewood Species: For firewood, the species’ heat value (BTU content) is a primary factor. Hardwoods like oak, maple, and birch are preferred for their high BTU content and long burn times.

   • Tree Size and Quality:

     • Sawlogs: Larger, straighter trees with minimal defects are more valuable as sawlogs for lumber production.
     • Pulpwood: Smaller, lower-quality trees can be used for pulpwood, which is used in paper production.
     • Firewood: Smaller trees and branches are suitable for firewood.

   • Accessibility:

     • Easy Access: Timber that is easily accessible by roads and equipment will be less expensive to harvest.
     • Difficult Access: Timber in remote or difficult-to-reach areas will require more specialized equipment and labor, increasing the harvesting cost.

   Data and Benchmarks:

   • Timber Prices: According to the USDA Forest Service, stumpage prices (the price paid for standing timber) vary significantly by region and species. For example, in the Southern United States, pine stumpage prices can range from \$20 to \$50 per ton, while hardwood stumpage prices can range from \$50 to \$150 per ton. These are averages and can change with market volatility.
   • Firewood Prices: The average price of firewood in the United States is \$200-\$400 per cord, depending on the species and location. However, prices can fluctuate significantly based on supply and demand. I’ve seen prices climb as high as \$500 per cord during peak winter months in certain regions.

   Personalized Storytelling and Insights:

   I once purchased a small stand of black walnut trees from a local farmer. The price was significantly lower than market value because the trees were located in a swampy area that was difficult to access. I had to use a tracked skidder to extract the logs, which added to the overall cost. However, the high-quality walnut lumber I obtained was well worth the extra effort.

   Calculating Timber Volume:

   • Board Feet: For sawlogs, timber volume is typically measured in board feet. A board foot is a unit of volume equal to 144 cubic inches (12 inches x 12 inches x 1 inch).
     • Doyle Log Rule: A common method for estimating board foot volume is the Doyle Log Rule: Board Feet = (Diameter - 4)^2 * Length / 16 (where diameter is in inches and length is in feet). This rule tends to underestimate the volume of smaller logs and overestimate the volume of larger logs.
     • Scribner Log Rule: Another common method is the Scribner Log Rule, which is generally considered more accurate than the Doyle Log Rule.
     • International 1/4-inch Log Rule: Considered the most accurate log rule, but also more complex to calculate manually.
   • Cords: For firewood, timber volume is typically measured in cords. A cord is a unit of volume equal to 128 cubic feet (4 feet x 4 feet x 8 feet).
     • Estimating Cord Volume: To estimate the cord volume of a pile of logs, measure the length, width, and height of the pile in feet and multiply the dimensions. Then, divide the result by 128.

   Cost Optimization Tips:

   • Negotiate with Landowners: Don’t be afraid to negotiate the price of standing timber. Research market prices and be prepared to walk away if the price is too high.
   • Salvage Timber: Look for opportunities to salvage downed trees or clear land for development.
   • Harvest During Off-Peak Seasons: Timber prices may be lower during off-peak seasons.

   2. Labor Costs

   Labor costs are a significant component of any wood processing project. The cost of labor will depend on the following factors:

   • Hourly Rate: The hourly rate for logging or firewood handling labor can vary depending on experience, location, and the type of work being performed.
   • Crew Size: The number of workers required for the project will depend on the scale and complexity of the work.
   • Time Required: The amount of time required to complete the project will depend on the volume of timber, the accessibility of the site, and the efficiency of the workers.

   Data and Benchmarks:

   • Logging Labor Rates: According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the median hourly wage for logging workers in the United States was \$45,760 annually as of May 2022. However, wages can vary significantly by region and experience level.
   • Firewood Handling Labor Rates: The hourly rate for firewood handling labor is typically lower than that of logging labor, ranging from \$15 to \$25 per hour.

   Personalized Storytelling and Insights:

   I once hired a local logging crew to harvest a stand of pine trees. The crew consisted of three workers: a feller, a skidder operator, and a loader operator. The crew charged \$75 per hour, and it took them three days to harvest the trees. The total labor cost was \$1800. In hindsight, I could have saved money by doing some of the work myself, such as limbing and bucking the trees.

   Cost Optimization Tips:

   • Do-It-Yourself (DIY): If you have the skills and equipment, consider doing some of the work yourself to save on labor costs.
   • Hire Experienced Workers: Experienced workers can complete the job more quickly and efficiently, reducing overall labor costs.
   • Negotiate Labor Rates: Don’t be afraid to negotiate labor rates with contractors.
   • Consider Piecework: For some tasks, such as firewood splitting, you may be able to pay workers on a piecework basis (e.g., \$X per cord).

   3. Tool and Equipment Costs

   The cost of tools and equipment can be a significant investment, especially if you’re starting from scratch. The following are some of the essential tools and equipment for felling small trees and processing wood:

   • Chainsaw: The cost of a chainsaw can range from \$200 to \$1000 or more, depending on the size, power, and features. Consider both gas-powered and electric models. I personally own a Stihl MS 271 Farm Boss, which has proven to be a reliable workhorse for a variety of tasks.
   • Chainsaw Accessories: This includes items such as chainsaw chains, bars, files, and sharpening tools.
   • Personal Protective Equipment (PPE): As mentioned earlier, PPE is essential for safety. The cost of PPE can range from \$100 to \$500 or more.
   • Wedges: The cost of wedges is relatively low, typically around \$10 to \$20 per wedge.
   • Felling Lever or Peavey: The cost of a felling lever or peavey can range from \$50 to \$200.
   • Log Splitter: If you’re processing firewood, a log splitter can save you a lot of time and effort. The cost of a log splitter can range from \$500 to \$5000 or more, depending on the size and power.
   • Skidding Equipment: If you’re harvesting timber in a remote area, you may need skidding equipment to move the logs to a landing. This can include a tractor, skidder, or winch.
   • Milling Equipment: If you’re milling lumber, you’ll need a sawmill or a portable sawmill. The cost of a sawmill can range from \$5000 to \$50,000 or more.

   Data and Benchmarks:

   • Chainsaw Prices: According to Consumer Reports, the average price of a gas-powered chainsaw is \$400, while the average price of an electric chainsaw is \$300.
   • Log Splitter Prices: The average price of a gas-powered log splitter is \$1500, while the average price of an electric log splitter is \$800.
   • Equipment Rental Fees: Renting equipment can be a cost-effective alternative to purchasing it, especially for occasional use. The rental fees for equipment such as log splitters and skidders can range from \$50 to \$200 per day.

   Personalized Storytelling and Insights:

   I initially balked at the price of a good quality log splitter. I thought I could save money by splitting wood manually with an axe. However, after a few days of back-breaking labor, I realized that the log splitter was a worthwhile investment. It saved me time, energy, and prevented potential injuries.

   Cost Optimization Tips:

   • Buy Used Equipment: Consider purchasing used equipment to save money.
   • Rent Equipment: Rent equipment for occasional use.
   • Maintain Your Equipment: Regularly maintain your equipment to prolong its lifespan and prevent costly repairs. I make it a point to sharpen my chainsaw chain after every few hours of use. A dull chain is not only less efficient but also more dangerous.
   • Share Equipment: Consider sharing equipment with neighbors or friends to reduce the cost of ownership.

   4. Tool Maintenance Costs

   Maintaining your tools is essential for safety, efficiency, and longevity. These costs often get overlooked when budgeting. Here’s a breakdown:

   • Chainsaw Maintenance: This includes sharpening chains, replacing bars and chains, cleaning air filters, changing spark plugs, and lubricating moving parts. I budget about \$50-\$100 per year for chainsaw maintenance, depending on usage.
   • Log Splitter Maintenance: This includes changing the hydraulic fluid, lubricating moving parts, and replacing worn parts. I budget about \$30-\$50 per year for log splitter maintenance.
   • Other Tool Maintenance: This includes sharpening axes, cleaning and lubricating hand tools, and repairing damaged equipment.

   Data and Benchmarks:

   • Chainsaw Chain Sharpening Costs: The cost of professionally sharpening a chainsaw chain can range from \$10 to \$20.
   • Hydraulic Fluid Costs: The cost of hydraulic fluid for a log splitter can range from \$20 to \$50 per gallon.

   Personalized Storytelling and Insights:

   I learned the hard way about the importance of regular chainsaw maintenance. I neglected to clean the air filter on my chainsaw, which caused it to overheat and eventually seize up. The repair cost was nearly as much as the cost of a new chainsaw. Now, I make it a point to clean the air filter after every use.

   Cost Optimization Tips:

   • Learn to Maintain Your Own Tools: Learning to maintain your own tools can save you a lot of money on repair costs.
   • Follow the Manufacturer’s Recommendations: Follow the manufacturer’s recommendations for maintenance and lubrication.
   • Store Your Tools Properly: Store your tools in a dry, clean place to prevent rust and corrosion.

   5. Transportation Costs

   Transportation costs can be a significant expense, especially if you’re harvesting timber in a remote area or transporting firewood over long distances.

   • Fuel Costs: Fuel costs can vary depending on the distance traveled, the type of vehicle used, and the price of fuel.
   • Vehicle Maintenance: Vehicle maintenance costs can include oil changes, tire rotations, and repairs.
   • Trucking Fees: If you’re hiring a trucking company to transport timber or firewood, you’ll need to factor in trucking fees.

   Data and Benchmarks:

   • Fuel Prices: The average price of gasoline and diesel fuel fluctuates constantly. Consult current fuel price data sources when budgeting.
   • Trucking Rates: Trucking rates can vary depending on the distance traveled, the type of load, and the availability of trucks.

   Personalized Storytelling and Insights:

   I once underestimated the cost of transporting firewood from a remote location to my home. The fuel costs alone were nearly as much as the cost of the firewood itself. Now, I make sure to factor in transportation costs when budgeting for firewood projects.

   Cost Optimization Tips:

   • Use Fuel-Efficient Vehicles: Use fuel-efficient vehicles to reduce fuel costs.
   • Combine Trips: Combine trips to reduce the number of miles traveled.
   • Negotiate Trucking Rates: Don’t be afraid to negotiate trucking rates with trucking companies.
   • Consider Local Sources: Whenever possible, source timber or firewood from local suppliers to reduce transportation costs.

   6. Permit and Regulatory Costs

   Depending on your location and the scale of your project, you may need to obtain permits or comply with regulations.

   • Logging Permits: Some states and counties require logging permits for commercial timber harvesting.
   • Firewood Permits: Some areas require permits for selling firewood.
   • Environmental Regulations: You may need to comply with environmental regulations related to water quality, erosion control, and wildlife habitat protection.

   Data and Benchmarks:

   • Permit Fees: Permit fees can vary depending on the type of permit and the location.

   Personalized Storytelling and Insights:

   I once failed to obtain the necessary logging permits before starting a timber harvesting project. I was fined by the state environmental agency and had to halt the project until I obtained the permits. Now, I always make sure to research and comply with all applicable regulations before starting any wood processing project.

   Cost Optimization Tips:

   • Research Regulations: Research all applicable regulations before starting your project.
   • Obtain Permits Early: Obtain the necessary permits early in the planning process to avoid delays.
   • Comply with Regulations: Comply with all applicable regulations to avoid fines and penalties.

   7. Drying and Storage Costs

   If you’re processing lumber or firewood, you’ll need to factor in the cost of drying and storing the wood.

   • Drying Time: The amount of time required to dry wood will depend on the species, thickness, and drying method.
   • Storage Space: You’ll need to have adequate storage space to protect the wood from the elements.
   • Kiln Drying Costs: If you’re kiln drying lumber, you’ll need to factor in the cost of operating the kiln.

   Data and Benchmarks:

   • Drying Time for Firewood: Firewood typically needs to dry for at least six months to reduce its moisture content to an acceptable level (below 20%).
   • Kiln Drying Costs: The cost of kiln drying lumber can range from \$0.20 to \$0.50 per board foot.

   Personalized Storytelling and Insights:

   I once tried to burn firewood that was not properly dried. It was difficult to light, produced a lot of smoke, and didn’t generate much heat. Now, I always make sure to dry my firewood for at least six months before burning it.

   Cost Optimization Tips:

   • Air Dry Wood: Air drying wood is a cost-effective alternative to kiln drying.
   • Choose the Right Storage Location: Choose a storage location that is well-ventilated and protected from the rain and snow.
   • Stack Wood Properly: Stack wood properly to allow for good air circulation.

   8. Contingency Costs

   It’s always a good idea to factor in a contingency for unexpected costs. I typically add 10-15% to my budget for contingency costs.

   • Unexpected Repairs: Unexpected repairs to tools or equipment.
   • Weather Delays: Weather delays can increase labor costs and delay the project.
   • Changes in Material Prices: Material prices can fluctuate unexpectedly.

   Personalized Storytelling and Insights:

   I once had a project delayed by several weeks due to heavy rains. The delay increased labor costs and resulted in a loss of revenue. Now, I always factor in a contingency for weather delays.

   Cost Optimization Tips:

   • Be Prepared for Unexpected Costs: Be prepared for unexpected costs and have a plan for dealing with them.
   • Track Your Expenses: Track your expenses carefully to identify potential cost overruns.
   • Communicate with Contractors: Communicate with contractors regularly to stay informed about the progress of the project and any potential cost changes.

   Case Studies: Real-World Examples of Budgeting for Small Tree Felling

   Let’s look at a couple of hypothetical case studies to illustrate the budgeting process:

   Case Study 1: Firewood Harvesting Project

   • Objective: Harvest and process 5 cords of firewood from a stand of mixed hardwoods on your own property.
   • Assumptions:
     • You’ll do all the work yourself.
     • You already own a chainsaw and basic hand tools.
     • You’ll need to purchase a log splitter.
     • You’ll air dry the firewood for six months.
   • Cost Breakdown:
     • Timber Acquisition: \$0 (harvesting from your own property)
     • Labor: \$0 (DIY)
     • Log Splitter Rental: \$200 (2 days x \$100/day) or Purchase: $1500
     • Chainsaw Maintenance: \$50
     • Fuel: \$50
     • Transportation: \$50
     • Permits: \$0
     • Drying and Storage: \$0 (using existing space)
     • Contingency (10%): \$35
     • Total Estimated Cost: \$385 (Rental) or $1735 (Purchase)
   • Estimated Cost per Cord: \$77 (Rental) or $347 (Purchase)

   Case Study 2: Small-Scale Lumber Milling Project

   • Objective: Fell and mill 1000 board feet of black walnut lumber from a stand of trees purchased from a landowner.
   • Assumptions:
     • You’ll hire a logging crew to fell and skid the trees.
     • You’ll rent a portable sawmill.
     • You’ll air dry the lumber for one year.
   • Cost Breakdown:
     • Timber Acquisition: \$500
     • Logging Labor: \$500
     • Sawmill Rental: \$500 (3 days x \$167/day)
     • Chainsaw Maintenance: \$50
     • Fuel: \$100
     • Transportation: \$100
     • Permits: \$50
     • Drying and Storage: \$50 (using existing space)
     • Contingency (10%): \$195
     • Total Estimated Cost: \$2045
   • Estimated Cost per Board Foot: \$2.05

   Actionable Takeaways and Next Steps

   Budgeting for small tree felling and wood processing requires careful planning and attention to detail. By understanding the key cost components and implementing cost optimization strategies, you can successfully manage your project and achieve your desired outcome.

   Here are some actionable takeaways:

   1. Thoroughly Assess the Project: Before starting any project, thoroughly assess the scope of work, the available resources, and the potential challenges.
   2. Develop a Detailed Budget: Develop a detailed budget that includes all relevant cost components.
   3. Research Market Prices: Research market prices for timber, labor, equipment, and other materials.
   4. Negotiate Prices: Don’t be afraid to negotiate prices with landowners, contractors, and suppliers.
   5. Consider DIY Options: Consider doing some of the work yourself to save on labor costs.
   6. Rent Equipment: Rent equipment for occasional use.
   7. Maintain Your Equipment: Regularly maintain your equipment to prolong its lifespan.
   8. Track Your Expenses: Track your expenses carefully to identify potential cost overruns.
   9. Factor in a Contingency: Factor in a contingency for unexpected costs.
   10. Comply with Regulations: Comply with all applicable regulations.

   Next Steps:

   1. Identify a Project: Choose a small tree felling or wood processing project that you’re interested in undertaking.
   2. Conduct a Site Assessment: Conduct a site assessment to evaluate the resources and challenges.
   3. Develop a Detailed Budget: Develop a detailed budget using the guidelines outlined in this article.
   4. Gather Your Resources: Gather the necessary tools, equipment, and materials.
   5. Start Your Project: Start your project and track your progress.
   6. Learn from Your Experiences: Learn from your experiences and refine your budgeting process for future projects.

   Felling small trees safely and processing the wood can be a rewarding experience. By following the tips and guidelines outlined in this article, you can successfully manage your project and achieve your desired outcome, all while staying within budget. Remember, a little planning goes a long way. Now, go forth and create something beautiful!

   ---

Learn more