Creosote Poles Risks: Why Avoid Sawing Treated Power Poles (Safety Insights)

The user’s intent is to understand the dangers associated with sawing creosote-treated power poles, specifically focusing on the health and safety risks. They are looking for information on why this practice should be avoided, along with insights into the properties of creosote and the potential consequences of exposure.

Creosote Poles Risks: Why Avoid Sawing Treated Power Poles (Safety Insights)

Creosote-treated power poles stand as silent sentinels across our landscapes, testaments to durability. They’ve been protecting our power lines for decades, withstanding the elements and the relentless march of time. But what happens when these giants reach the end of their service life, or when we, perhaps driven by a desire for free lumber or a unique project, consider repurposing them? That’s where the danger lurks. Sawing creosote-treated power poles is not just another woodworking task; it’s a potential health hazard that demands respect and, frankly, complete avoidance.

I’ve spent years working with wood, from felling trees in the backwoods of Maine to crafting furniture in my workshop in Montana. I’ve seen firsthand the respect woodworkers have for their materials and, more importantly, for their own safety. But even with all that experience, I wouldn’t touch a creosote-treated pole with a ten-foot pole, let alone a chainsaw. The risks are simply too high.

What is Creosote and Why Is It Used?

Creosote is a complex mixture of chemicals created by high-temperature distillation of coal tar. It’s a powerful wood preservative, highly effective at preventing rot, decay, and insect infestation. That’s why it’s used extensively to treat utility poles, railroad ties, and marine pilings. The effectiveness of creosote stems from its toxicity to fungi, bacteria, and insects that degrade wood.

• Composition: Creosote is composed of hundreds of different chemical compounds, including polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), phenols, and cresols.
• Wood Preservation: Its ability to penetrate wood fibers and create a toxic barrier against biological degradation makes it ideal for preserving wood in harsh environments.
• Historical Use: Creosote has been used as a wood preservative for over a century. Its widespread adoption is due to its effectiveness and relatively low cost compared to other wood treatment methods.

The Dangers of Sawing Creosote-Treated Poles

The problem isn’t the pole itself, but what happens when you start cutting into it. Sawing creosote-treated wood releases creosote-laden dust and fumes into the air. These particles can be inhaled, ingested, or absorbed through the skin, leading to a range of health problems.

Health Risks Associated with Creosote Exposure

The health risks associated with creosote exposure are significant and well-documented. The severity of the risks depends on the duration and intensity of exposure, as well as individual susceptibility.

• Skin Irritation: Direct contact with creosote can cause skin irritation, burns, and photosensitivity (increased sensitivity to sunlight). Prolonged exposure can lead to dermatitis and other skin conditions. I remember a fellow woodworker who briefly handled a creosote-treated piece without gloves. He developed a nasty rash that took weeks to heal.
• Eye Irritation: Creosote fumes and dust can irritate the eyes, causing redness, burning, and blurred vision. In severe cases, exposure can lead to corneal damage.
• Respiratory Problems: Inhaling creosote fumes can irritate the respiratory tract, causing coughing, wheezing, and shortness of breath. Long-term exposure can lead to chronic bronchitis and other respiratory ailments.
• Gastrointestinal Issues: Ingesting creosote can cause nausea, vomiting, and abdominal pain.
• Cancer Risk: Creosote contains PAHs, which are known carcinogens. Long-term exposure to creosote has been linked to an increased risk of skin, lung, and bladder cancer. Studies have shown that workers in industries that handle creosote-treated wood, such as railroad workers and utility pole installers, have a higher incidence of these cancers. According to the EPA, creosote is classified as a probable human carcinogen.
• Other Potential Health Effects: Some studies suggest that creosote exposure may also be linked to liver and kidney damage, as well as neurological problems.

Why Sawing Increases the Risks

Sawing creosote-treated wood significantly increases the risk of exposure for several reasons:

• Dust Generation: Sawing creates a large amount of fine dust particles, which are easily inhaled and can penetrate deep into the lungs.
• Fume Release: The heat generated by sawing can cause creosote to vaporize, releasing harmful fumes into the air.
• Skin Contact: Direct contact with creosote-treated wood and contaminated sawdust is almost unavoidable when sawing.
• Confined Spaces: Sawing often takes place in enclosed or semi-enclosed spaces, which can concentrate the dust and fumes, increasing the risk of exposure.

Safety Precautions (But Why They’re Not Enough)

While there are safety precautions you can take when handling creosote-treated wood, they are often insufficient to completely eliminate the risks associated with sawing. These precautions include:

• Personal Protective Equipment (PPE): Wearing gloves, eye protection, and a respirator can help reduce exposure to creosote. However, standard dust masks may not be effective at filtering out the fine particles produced during sawing. A respirator with a NIOSH-approved P100 filter is recommended.
• Ventilation: Working in a well-ventilated area can help disperse creosote fumes and dust. However, natural ventilation may not be sufficient, especially in enclosed spaces.
• Skin Protection: Wearing long sleeves, long pants, and boots can help prevent skin contact with creosote-treated wood and contaminated sawdust.
• Hygiene: Washing hands thoroughly after handling creosote-treated wood can help remove any creosote that may have come into contact with the skin.
• Containment: Using a dust collection system can help reduce the amount of dust released into the air during sawing.

However, even with these precautions, the risks remain significant. Respirators can be uncomfortable and may not provide a perfect seal, allowing some dust and fumes to be inhaled. Ventilation systems may not be adequate to remove all contaminants, especially in confined spaces. And even with careful handling, it’s difficult to completely avoid skin contact with creosote-treated wood and contaminated sawdust.

My Personal Stance: I believe that the risks associated with sawing creosote-treated poles, even with precautions, outweigh any potential benefits. The health consequences are too serious to justify the risk.

Legal and Environmental Considerations

Beyond the health risks, there are also legal and environmental considerations to keep in mind.

• Disposal: Creosote-treated wood is considered hazardous waste in many jurisdictions and must be disposed of properly. Burning creosote-treated wood is illegal in many areas due to the release of harmful pollutants into the air. The cost of proper disposal can be significant. I’ve seen estimates ranging from \$50 to \$200 per pole, depending on the location and disposal method.
• Regulations: There may be regulations governing the handling and use of creosote-treated wood in your area. Check with your local environmental protection agency for more information.
• Environmental Contamination: Improper disposal of creosote-treated wood can contaminate soil and water, posing a threat to human health and the environment.

Alternative Uses for Salvaged Wood (That Don’t Involve Sawing)

If you’re looking for ways to repurpose salvaged wood, there are many safer alternatives to sawing creosote-treated poles. Consider these options:

• Landscaping: Whole poles can be used for landscaping purposes, such as creating retaining walls or raised garden beds. However, be sure to line the inside of the beds with plastic to prevent soil contamination.
• Fencing: Poles can be used to create rustic fences. Again, avoid cutting them.
• Decorative Elements: Smaller pieces of creosote-treated wood can be used to create decorative elements, such as signs or sculptures. However, these should be kept outdoors and away from areas where people will come into frequent contact with them.
• Donation: Contact local organizations that may be able to use the poles for non-structural purposes, such as landscaping or erosion control.

Important Note: Even when using creosote-treated wood for these purposes, it’s important to take precautions to minimize exposure. Wear gloves when handling the wood, and avoid contact with skin. Keep the wood outdoors, and away from areas where children and pets may come into contact with it.

Cost Analysis: Risk vs. Reward

Let’s break down the cost of working with creosote-treated poles, not just in dollars and cents, but in terms of health and potential liability.

Direct Costs

• Acquisition: Obtaining used utility poles might seem “free,” but there are often hidden costs. You may need to pay for transportation, which can be expensive due to the size and weight of the poles. Expect to pay anywhere from \$100 to \$500 for transportation, depending on distance and the hauling company.
• Safety Equipment: As mentioned earlier, proper PPE is crucial. A good quality respirator with P100 filters will cost around \$50-\$100. Eye protection and gloves will add another \$20-\$30.
• Disposal: Proper disposal of creosote-treated wood is a significant cost. Expect to pay \$50-\$200 per pole for disposal at a hazardous waste facility.
• Tool Wear & Tear: Sawing through creosote-treated wood is hard on tools. Chainsaw chains dull quickly, and saw blades can become gummed up with creosote. Expect to spend more on chain sharpening or replacement, as well as cleaning supplies for your tools. I estimate a 20-30% increase in maintenance costs compared to working with untreated wood.

Hidden Costs

• Health Costs: This is the big one. The potential cost of developing health problems due to creosote exposure is difficult to quantify but could be substantial. Medical bills, lost wages, and long-term health care costs can quickly add up.
• Liability: If you sell or give away items made from creosote-treated wood, you could be held liable if someone is harmed by exposure to the creosote. This could result in costly lawsuits and damage to your reputation.
• Environmental Damage: Improper disposal of creosote-treated wood can lead to environmental contamination, which could result in fines and remediation costs.

Cost Comparison: Alternatives

Let’s compare the cost of working with creosote-treated poles to the cost of using alternative materials:

As you can see, while creosote-treated poles may seem like a cost-effective option at first glance, the hidden costs associated with health risks, disposal, and potential liability can quickly outweigh any initial savings. Choosing alternative materials may be more expensive upfront, but it’s a safer and more sustainable choice in the long run.

A Personal Story: I once considered using some old telephone poles for a fencing project on my property. I was attracted to the idea of using “free” materials and creating a rustic-looking fence. However, after researching the risks associated with creosote-treated wood and calculating the potential costs of disposal and liability, I decided to go with cedar instead. It was more expensive upfront, but I had peace of mind knowing that I wasn’t putting my health or the environment at risk.

Data and Statistics on Creosote Exposure

While precise figures on the number of people harmed by working with creosote-treated wood are difficult to obtain, several studies and reports highlight the risks:

• EPA Studies: The EPA has conducted numerous studies on the health effects of creosote exposure, which have consistently shown a link between creosote and cancer.
• NIOSH Reports: The National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) has published reports on the occupational hazards of working with creosote-treated wood, including recommendations for minimizing exposure.
• Industry Data: Data from the railroad and utility industries show a higher incidence of certain cancers among workers who handle creosote-treated wood.

According to a study published in the Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine, workers exposed to creosote had a 2-3 times higher risk of developing skin cancer compared to the general population.

These data points underscore the importance of avoiding exposure to creosote-treated wood whenever possible.

Budgeting for Safe Woodworking Projects

If you’re planning a woodworking project, it’s essential to budget for safety. This includes:

• Choosing Safe Materials: Opt for untreated lumber, recycled plastic lumber, or other safe alternatives to creosote-treated wood.
• Investing in PPE: Purchase high-quality respirators, eye protection, and gloves. Don’t skimp on safety equipment.
• Proper Ventilation: Ensure adequate ventilation in your workspace. Consider investing in a dust collection system.
• Safe Disposal: Budget for the proper disposal of any hazardous waste materials.
• Education: Take the time to educate yourself about the risks of working with different types of wood and wood treatments.

A Word of Caution: Don’t let the allure of “free” materials blind you to the potential risks. Your health and safety are worth more than any savings you might achieve by using creosote-treated wood.

Actionable Takeaways

• Avoid Sawing Creosote-Treated Poles: The risks outweigh any potential benefits.
• Choose Safe Alternatives: Opt for untreated lumber, recycled plastic lumber, or other safe materials.
• Invest in PPE: Protect yourself with high-quality respirators, eye protection, and gloves.
• Dispose of Creosote-Treated Wood Properly: Follow local regulations for hazardous waste disposal.
• Educate Yourself: Learn about the risks of working with different types of wood and wood treatments.
• Prioritize Safety: Make safety your top priority in all woodworking projects.

Conclusion: A Clear Choice for Safety

The allure of free or cheap materials can be strong, especially when undertaking woodworking projects on a budget. The health consequences, environmental concerns, and potential legal liabilities far outweigh any perceived benefits.

As someone who has spent a lifetime working with wood, I urge you to prioritize your health and safety. Choose safe materials, invest in proper PPE, and educate yourself about the risks of working with different types of wood. By making informed decisions and taking appropriate precautions, you can enjoy the satisfaction of woodworking without putting yourself or others at risk. Remember, a healthy and safe woodworking experience is always the most rewarding one.

Learn more