Chuck and Duck Chippers Comparison (Asplundh Drum Models Reviewed)

Introduction: The Grind of the Grind – Why Chipper Choice Matters

As anyone who’s spent a good chunk of their life wrestling with wood knows, wear-and-tear is the name of the game. Whether it’s the dulling of a chainsaw chain against stubborn oak or the gradual fatigue of your back after a long day of splitting, the woods demand resilience – from both man and machine.

Now, I’ve spent years in the trenches, felling trees, clearing land, and generally making a mess of the forest (in a productive way, of course!). I’ve seen chippers come and go, some lasting longer than others. That’s why I’m diving deep into the world of “chuck and duck” chippers, specifically focusing on Asplundh’s drum models. These workhorses are ubiquitous in the industry, favored for their power and ability to chew through some seriously gnarly stuff. But not all chippers are created equal, and understanding the nuances between models can save you a boatload of time, money, and frustration.

Understanding the “Chuck and Duck” Philosophy: Drum Chippers Demystified

Before we get model-specific, let’s understand the core principle behind “chuck and duck” chippers. The name itself is a bit of a playful, albeit slightly dangerous, description of the operating method. You “chuck” the material in, and you better “duck” out of the way in case something unexpected gets kicked back!

What Makes a Drum Chipper Tick?

Drum chippers, unlike their disc-based counterparts, utilize a large, rotating steel drum with knives mounted on its surface. As material is fed into the infeed chute, the rotating drum pulls it towards the knives, which shear the wood into chips. The chips are then expelled through a discharge chute, often with considerable force.

Here’s a breakdown of the key components:

• Infeed Chute: The opening where material is fed into the chipper. Its size and design significantly impact the size and type of material the chipper can handle.
• Feed Rollers: These rollers grip the material and feed it towards the drum at a controlled rate. Hydraulic pressure usually powers them, allowing for variable speed and direction.
• Chipping Drum: The heart of the machine. The drum’s diameter, weight, and rotational speed determine its chipping capacity and efficiency.
• Chipping Knives: Sharpened steel blades mounted on the drum that do the actual cutting. The number, angle, and type of knives influence the chip size and quality.
• Discharge Chute: Directs the chips away from the machine and into a collection truck or pile.
• Engine: The powerhouse that drives the entire operation. Diesel engines are the norm, offering high torque and fuel efficiency.
• Hydraulic System: Powers the feed rollers, knife adjustment, and other auxiliary functions.
• Control Panel: Houses the controls for starting, stopping, adjusting feed speed, and engaging safety features.

The Advantages of Drum Chippers

Drum chippers are popular for a reason. They offer several key advantages:

• High Throughput: Drum chippers can process large volumes of material quickly, making them ideal for commercial operations.
• Large Material Capacity: Many drum chippers can handle branches and small trees with diameters up to 18 inches or more.
• Durability: These machines are built tough to withstand the rigors of daily use in demanding environments.
• Relatively Simple Design: Compared to some other chipper designs, drum chippers are relatively straightforward to maintain and repair.

The Trade-Offs

Of course, no machine is perfect. Drum chippers also have some drawbacks:

• Higher Cost: Drum chippers typically cost more than disc chippers, especially larger models.
• Greater Weight: Their robust construction makes them heavier and less maneuverable.
• Potential for Kickback: The aggressive feeding action can lead to kickback if material is not fed properly or if the knives are dull. This is where the “duck” part of “chuck and duck” comes in.
• Chip Quality: While drum chippers produce usable chips, the chip quality is often less uniform than that produced by disc chippers, which can be a consideration for certain applications.

Asplundh Drum Chipper Models: A Deep Dive

Asplundh is a well-respected name in the tree care industry, and their drum chippers are known for their reliability and performance. Let’s take a closer look at some of their popular models:

Asplundh Whisper Chipper

• Overview: The Whisper Chipper is designed with noise reduction in mind, making it suitable for residential areas or locations with noise restrictions.
• Key Features:
  • Sound-dampening technology to reduce noise levels.
  • Typically equipped with a smaller engine and chipping capacity compared to other models.
  • User-friendly controls and safety features.
• Ideal Use Cases:
  • Tree care companies working in urban environments.
  • Municipalities with noise ordinances.
  • Landscapers who need a quieter chipping solution.
• My Take: I’ve encountered the Whisper Chipper on a few jobs near residential areas, and the difference in noise level is noticeable. It’s not silent, by any means, but it’s significantly less intrusive than a standard chipper. However, the reduced noise comes at the cost of power, so it’s best suited for smaller branches and less demanding jobs.

Asplundh JEY Chipper

• Overview: The JEY Chipper is a versatile and robust drum chipper designed for a wide range of tree care and land clearing tasks.
• Key Features:
  • Powerful engine for efficient chipping of various wood types.
  • Hydraulic feed system with adjustable speed and pressure.
  • Durable construction for long-lasting performance.
  • Available in different sizes and configurations to meet specific needs.
• Ideal Use Cases:
  • Professional tree care companies.
  • Land clearing contractors.
  • Municipalities for roadside maintenance.
• My Take: The JEY Chipper is a true workhorse. I’ve seen these machines handle everything from pine to oak with ease. The hydraulic feed system is responsive and allows for precise control over the chipping process. It’s a solid all-around choice for anyone who needs a reliable and powerful drum chipper.

Asplundh Forestry Chipper

• Overview: The Forestry Chipper is a heavy-duty machine designed for large-scale land clearing and forestry operations.
• Key Features:
  • Massive engine and chipping capacity.
  • Aggressive feed system for processing large, bulky materials.
  • Reinforced construction to withstand the rigors of forestry work.
  • Often equipped with a grapple loader for efficient material handling.
• Ideal Use Cases:
  • Large-scale land clearing projects.
  • Forestry operations.
  • Wood processing facilities.
• My Take: The Forestry Chipper is in a league of its own. These machines are built to handle the toughest jobs imaginable. I once saw one devour an entire tree, trunk and all, in a matter of minutes. If you’re dealing with massive amounts of wood and need maximum chipping power, the Forestry Chipper is the way to go.

Comparing the Models: A Side-by-Side Analysis

To help you make a more informed decision, here’s a comparison table highlighting the key differences between the Asplundh models:

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Model

Choosing the right Asplundh drum chipper depends on a variety of factors, including:

• The type and volume of material you’ll be chipping: Are you primarily dealing with small branches, or are you handling larger trees?
• Your budget: Drum chippers can be a significant investment, so it’s important to set a realistic budget.
• Your operating environment: Will you be working in residential areas with noise restrictions?
• Your transportation and storage capabilities: Consider the size and weight of the chipper and whether you have the equipment to transport and store it safely.
• Your maintenance capabilities: Are you comfortable performing routine maintenance tasks, or will you need to rely on a professional mechanic?

Wood Anatomy and Properties: Understanding Your Material

Before you start feeding wood into your chipper, it’s crucial to understand the properties of the material you’re working with. Different types of wood behave differently under the chipper’s knives, and knowing the basics of wood anatomy can help you optimize your chipping process and avoid potential problems.

Hardwood vs. Softwood: A Fundamental Distinction

The terms “hardwood” and “softwood” refer to the type of tree the wood comes from, not necessarily its actual hardness. Hardwoods are typically deciduous trees (trees that lose their leaves in the fall), while softwoods are typically coniferous trees (trees with needles).

• Hardwoods: Generally denser and more difficult to chip than softwoods. Examples include oak, maple, ash, and hickory.
• Softwoods: Typically less dense and easier to chip than hardwoods. Examples include pine, fir, spruce, and cedar.

The density of the wood affects the amount of power required to chip it. Hardwoods require more force to cut, which can put a strain on the chipper’s engine and knives.

Moisture Content: A Critical Factor

The moisture content of wood plays a significant role in its chipping characteristics.

• Green Wood: Wood that has recently been cut and still contains a high amount of moisture. Green wood is generally easier to chip than dry wood because it is more pliable. However, it can also be heavier and more difficult to handle.
• Dry Wood: Wood that has been seasoned or dried to a lower moisture content. Dry wood is more brittle and can be more difficult to chip cleanly. It can also produce more dust.

Ideally, you want to chip wood that is somewhere in between green and dry. Wood that has been allowed to air-dry for a few months is often the easiest to chip.

Grain Direction: A Matter of the Split

The grain direction of the wood also affects how it chips. Wood chips more easily along the grain than against it. When feeding branches into the chipper, try to orient them so that the grain is aligned with the knives.

Knots and Branches: Potential Hazards

Knots and branches can be challenging to chip because they are often denser and have irregular grain patterns. They can also cause the material to bind in the infeed chute or damage the chipper knives. It’s important to feed these materials carefully and avoid forcing them into the chipper.

The Science of Seasoning: Drying Wood for Optimal Chipping

Seasoning wood involves reducing its moisture content through air drying. This process not only makes the wood easier to chip but also reduces its weight and improves its fuel value if you plan to use the chips for mulch or biomass.

• Air Drying: The most common and cost-effective method of seasoning wood. It involves stacking the wood in a well-ventilated area and allowing it to dry naturally over time.
• Kiln Drying: A faster but more expensive method of seasoning wood. It involves placing the wood in a kiln and using heat and controlled humidity to accelerate the drying process.

The ideal moisture content for chipping depends on the type of wood and the intended use of the chips. Generally, a moisture content of 20-30% is considered optimal for most chipping applications.

Logging Tool Selection and Maintenance Best Practices

Your chipper is only as good as the tools you use to prepare the material you feed into it. Proper logging tool selection and maintenance are essential for safety, efficiency, and longevity.

Chainsaws: The Foundation of Wood Processing

The chainsaw is the primary tool for felling trees, limbing branches, and cutting wood into manageable lengths for the chipper.

• Choosing the Right Chainsaw: Select a chainsaw that is appropriate for the size and type of trees you’ll be working with. Consider the engine size, bar length, and weight of the saw.
• Chainsaw Safety: Always wear appropriate personal protective equipment (PPE), including a helmet, eye protection, hearing protection, gloves, and chaps. Follow safe operating procedures and never operate a chainsaw under the influence of drugs or alcohol.
• Chainsaw Maintenance: Keep your chainsaw clean, sharp, and properly lubricated. Regularly inspect the chain, bar, and other components for wear and damage.

Axes and Hatchets: For Splitting and Limbing

Axes and hatchets are useful for splitting smaller pieces of wood and limbing branches.

• Choosing the Right Axe: Select an axe that is appropriate for the size and type of wood you’ll be splitting. Consider the weight of the axe head and the length of the handle.
• Axe Safety: Always wear appropriate PPE, including eye protection and gloves. Use a chopping block and maintain a safe distance from others.
• Axe Maintenance: Keep your axe sharp and clean. Regularly inspect the head and handle for damage.

Log Splitters: For Handling Large Rounds

Log splitters are essential for splitting large rounds of wood that are too difficult to split with an axe.

• Choosing the Right Log Splitter: Consider the size and type of wood you’ll be splitting, as well as the amount of force required. Choose between manual, electric, and gas-powered models.
• Log Splitter Safety: Always wear appropriate PPE, including eye protection and gloves. Follow safe operating procedures and never operate a log splitter under the influence of drugs or alcohol.
• Log Splitter Maintenance: Keep your log splitter clean and properly lubricated. Regularly inspect the hydraulic fluid level and other components for wear and damage.

Beyond the Basics: Specialized Tools

There are a variety of specialized logging tools that can make your wood processing tasks easier and more efficient, including:

• Cant Hooks: For rolling and positioning logs.
• Peaveys: Similar to cant hooks but with a pivoting hook for better grip.
• Timber Jacks: For lifting logs off the ground for easier cutting.
• Skidding Winches: For pulling logs out of the woods.

The Importance of Tool Sharpening

Sharp tools are safer and more efficient than dull tools. Regularly sharpen your chainsaw chain, axe, and other cutting tools to maintain optimal performance.

• Chainsaw Chain Sharpening: Use a chainsaw file or a chain grinder to sharpen your chainsaw chain. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions for proper sharpening techniques.
• Axe Sharpening: Use a sharpening stone or a grinding wheel to sharpen your axe. Maintain the proper bevel angle and avoid overheating the steel.

A Case Study in Tool Maintenance: My Near Miss

I learned the hard way about the importance of tool maintenance. I was felling a large oak tree with a dull chainsaw chain, and the saw kicked back unexpectedly. I narrowly avoided serious injury, but it was a wake-up call. From that day on, I made it a point to keep all of my tools in top condition.

Firewood Seasoning Techniques and Safety Considerations

If you’re planning to use your wood chips for mulch or biomass, proper seasoning is essential. Seasoning reduces the moisture content of the wood, making it lighter, easier to handle, and more resistant to rot and decay.

Stacking for Success: Maximizing Airflow

The way you stack your firewood can significantly impact its seasoning rate. Here are some tips for effective stacking:

• Choose a Sunny and Windy Location: This will help to promote air circulation and evaporation.
• Elevate the Wood Off the Ground: Use pallets or other materials to create a space between the wood and the ground.
• Stack the Wood Loosely: Allow for air to circulate between the pieces of wood.
• Cover the Top of the Stack: Use a tarp or other waterproof material to protect the wood from rain and snow.

The Role of Wood Species in Seasoning

Different wood species season at different rates. Softwoods generally dry faster than hardwoods.

• Fast-Drying Woods: Pine, fir, spruce, and cedar.
• Slow-Drying Woods: Oak, maple, ash, and hickory.

Monitoring Moisture Content: Know When It’s Ready

Use a moisture meter to monitor the moisture content of your firewood. The ideal moisture content for burning is below 20%.

Safety First: Preventing Accidents

Firewood processing can be a dangerous activity. Always follow safe operating procedures and wear appropriate PPE.

• Avoid Working Alone: Have someone nearby in case of an accident.
• Be Aware of Your Surroundings: Watch out for obstacles and uneven terrain.
• Take Breaks: Avoid fatigue by taking regular breaks.
• Store Firewood Safely: Keep firewood away from buildings and other flammable materials.

A Personal Anecdote: The Importance of PPE

I once witnessed a fellow logger suffer a serious eye injury while splitting firewood. He wasn’t wearing eye protection, and a piece of wood flew up and struck him in the eye. He was lucky to avoid permanent vision loss. This incident reinforced the importance of wearing PPE at all times.

Project Planning and Execution: From Tree to Chip

Before you start your next wood processing project, take the time to plan it out carefully. This will help you to ensure safety, efficiency, and success.

Defining Your Goals: What Do You Want to Achieve?

Start by defining your goals for the project. What type of wood are you processing? What will you do with the chips? How much material do you need to process?

Assessing the Site: Identifying Potential Hazards

Assess the site where you’ll be working. Look for potential hazards, such as power lines, fences, and uneven terrain.

Selecting the Right Equipment: Matching Tools to the Task

Choose the right equipment for the job. Consider the size and type of wood you’ll be processing, as well as your budget and experience level.

Developing a Timeline: Setting Realistic Expectations

Create a timeline for the project. How long will it take to fell the trees, limb the branches, split the wood, and chip the material? Be realistic about your capabilities and allow for unexpected delays.

Implementing Safety Procedures: Prioritizing Well-being

Implement strict safety procedures. Ensure that everyone involved in the project is properly trained and equipped with PPE.

Documenting the Process: Learning for the Future

Document the entire process. Take notes on what worked well and what didn’t. This will help you to improve your efficiency and safety in future projects.

A Real-World Example: Clearing a Small Woodlot

I recently cleared a small woodlot for a client who wanted to build a new home. I started by defining the goals of the project, which included removing all of the trees and brush from the site and chipping the material for use as mulch. I assessed the site and identified several potential hazards, including a power line and a nearby stream. I selected the appropriate equipment for the job, including a chainsaw, a log splitter, and an Asplundh JEY Chipper. I developed a timeline for the project and implemented strict safety procedures. The project went smoothly, and the client was very happy with the results.

Conclusion: Mastering the Art of Wood Processing

Wood processing is a challenging but rewarding activity. By understanding the principles of wood anatomy, tool selection, seasoning techniques, and project planning, you can improve your efficiency, safety, and success. Remember to always prioritize safety, maintain your equipment properly, and learn from your experiences. With practice and dedication, you can master the art of wood processing and transform raw wood into valuable resources.

Learn more