Carhartt vs Filson Workwear (5 Durable Fabrics Tested)

Let’s get straight to the heart of the matter. You’re here because you want to know which workwear brand reigns supreme: Carhartt or Filson. You need gear that can stand up to the rigors of demanding outdoor work, whether you’re felling trees, splitting wood, or just battling the elements. I get it. I’ve been there, done that, and got the chainsaw-scarred t-shirt to prove it. So, let’s dive into a head-to-head comparison of these two titans of workwear, focusing on the durability of their fabrics. I’ve put these brands through the wringer myself, and I’m going to share my real-world experiences to help you make the right choice.

Carhartt vs. Filson: A Durable Fabric Face-Off

When you’re out in the woods, your clothing isn’t just clothing; it’s your first line of defense. Branches, thorns, weather, and the sheer physical strain of the job demand fabrics that can take a beating. Carhartt and Filson both have reputations for ruggedness, but their approaches and the specific fabrics they use differ significantly.

The Contenders: Five Key Fabrics

We’re going to put five core fabrics to the test:

1. Carhartt Duck Canvas: The workhorse of the Carhartt line.
2. Carhartt Ripstop: Designed for enhanced tear resistance.
3. Filson Tin Cloth: Their signature oil-finished fabric.
4. Filson Shelter Cloth: A lighter, more breathable alternative to Tin Cloth.
5. Filson Mackinaw Wool: Known for its incredible warmth and durability.

Methodology: How I Tested Them

This isn’t just a theoretical comparison. I’ve personally worn and used gear made from each of these fabrics in a variety of wood processing and firewood preparation scenarios. I’ve considered:

• Abrasion Resistance: How well the fabric holds up against rubbing and scraping.
• Tear Resistance: How easily the fabric tears or rips.
• Water Resistance: How well the fabric repels water.
• Breathability: How well the fabric allows moisture to escape.
• Comfort: How comfortable the fabric is to wear during extended periods of physical activity.
• Maintenance: How easy the fabric is to clean and care for.

I’ll also be sprinkling in some real-world anecdotes from my own experiences. I remember one particularly brutal day splitting firewood. A rogue piece of oak, knotty and stubborn, sent a glancing blow off my maul and right onto my Carhartt duck canvas pants. I braced for the worst, expecting a tear, but the fabric held. That’s the kind of real-world test that matters.

Carhartt Duck Canvas: The Reliable Workhorse

Ah, Carhartt duck canvas. It’s the fabric that built a brand. It’s the stuff of legends, the fabric you picture when you think “workwear.” But how does it really hold up?

What is Duck Canvas?

Duck canvas is a tightly woven, plain weave cotton fabric. The term “duck” refers to the type of weave, not the bird. It’s known for its durability, strength, and resistance to wear and tear. Carhartt’s duck canvas is typically made from 12-ounce cotton, though heavier weights are also available.

Performance Breakdown

• Abrasion Resistance: Excellent. Duck canvas can withstand a significant amount of rubbing and scraping before showing signs of wear. I’ve dragged logs across it, knelt on rough surfaces, and brushed against countless branches without causing significant damage.
• Tear Resistance: Good. While not as tear-resistant as ripstop, duck canvas is still fairly robust. A small puncture might expand into a tear if subjected to enough force, but it’s generally resistant to everyday snags and tears.
• Water Resistance: Poor to Fair. Untreated duck canvas absorbs water readily. However, many Carhartt garments feature a Durable Water Repellent (DWR) finish, which provides some initial water resistance. This DWR coating will wear off over time and needs to be reapplied. I learned this the hard way during a sudden downpour while stacking firewood. My un-waxed Carhartts soaked through within minutes.
• Breathability: Poor. Duck canvas is not a breathable fabric. It traps heat and moisture, which can be uncomfortable in warm weather or during strenuous activity.
• Comfort: Moderate. Duck canvas can feel stiff and restrictive when new. It softens with wear and washing, but it never becomes truly supple.
• Maintenance: Easy. Duck canvas is machine washable and relatively easy to care for. However, repeated washing can degrade the DWR finish (if present) and fade the color.

Real-World Example: The Firewood Hauling Test

I’ve used Carhartt duck canvas pants for years when hauling firewood. The abrasion resistance is a lifesaver when dragging wood across rough ground. However, I’ve also learned to avoid wearing them on hot days. The lack of breathability can quickly lead to overheating and discomfort.

Data Points

• Average Lifespan (Heavy Use): 3-5 years
• Typical Cost (Pants): $50-$80
• DWR Effectiveness: Lasts approximately 10-15 washes before requiring reapplication.

Unique Insights

One thing I’ve noticed is that the color of the duck canvas can affect its perceived durability. Darker colors, like Carhartt Brown, tend to hide dirt and wear better than lighter colors.

Carhartt Ripstop: The Tear-Resistant Warrior

When you need something tougher than standard duck canvas, Carhartt ripstop steps up to the plate. This fabric is designed to prevent tears from spreading, making it ideal for environments where snags and punctures are common.

What is Ripstop?

Ripstop is a woven fabric that incorporates a reinforcing grid pattern. This grid is made of stronger, heavier yarns that are interwoven at regular intervals. If a tear occurs, it’s stopped by these reinforcing yarns, preventing it from spreading further. Carhartt’s ripstop is often made from a blend of cotton and polyester.

Performance Breakdown

• Abrasion Resistance: Good. Ripstop is generally less abrasion-resistant than duck canvas due to its lighter weight and different weave structure.
• Tear Resistance: Excellent. This is where ripstop shines. The reinforcing grid makes it highly resistant to tearing. I’ve accidentally snagged my ripstop pants on barbed wire fences and sharp branches without causing any significant damage.
• Water Resistance: Fair to Good. Like duck canvas, ripstop often features a DWR finish for water resistance. The polyester content in the blend also helps to repel water to some extent.
• Breathability: Moderate. Ripstop is generally more breathable than duck canvas due to its lighter weight and looser weave. The addition of polyester can also improve breathability.
• Comfort: Moderate to Good. Ripstop is generally more comfortable than duck canvas, especially in warmer weather. The lighter weight and improved breathability make it less restrictive and more comfortable to wear for extended periods.
• Maintenance: Easy. Ripstop is machine washable and easy to care for. It also tends to dry faster than duck canvas.

Real-World Example: The Brush Clearing Challenge

I wore Carhartt ripstop pants while clearing brush and overgrown vegetation from a property line. The tear resistance was invaluable. I was constantly pushing through thickets of thorns and branches, and the ripstop fabric held up admirably. Standard duck canvas would have likely suffered multiple tears.

Data Points

• Average Lifespan (Heavy Use): 2-4 years
• Typical Cost (Pants): $60-$90
• Ripstop Grid Spacing: Typically ranges from 1/4 inch to 1/2 inch.

Unique Insights

The effectiveness of ripstop depends on the quality of the reinforcing yarns and the density of the grid. A tightly woven ripstop with high-quality yarns will be more tear-resistant than a loosely woven ripstop with weaker yarns.

Filson Tin Cloth: The Oiled Fortress

Filson Tin Cloth is legendary. It’s synonymous with ruggedness, weather resistance, and a certain old-school charm. This fabric is designed to withstand the harshest conditions, making it a favorite among outdoorsmen and professionals alike.

What is Tin Cloth?

Tin Cloth is a tightly woven cotton fabric that’s saturated with a paraffin-based wax finish. This finish makes the fabric highly water-resistant, wind-resistant, and abrasion-resistant. It also gives the fabric a distinctive oily or waxy feel.

Performance Breakdown

• Abrasion Resistance: Excellent. Tin Cloth is incredibly abrasion-resistant. The wax finish creates a protective layer that resists rubbing and scraping. I’ve seen Tin Cloth jackets that have been worn for decades and still look relatively new.
• Tear Resistance: Good to Excellent. While not specifically designed as a ripstop fabric, Tin Cloth’s tight weave and wax finish provide excellent tear resistance. The wax helps to bind the fibers together, preventing tears from spreading.
• Water Resistance: Excellent. Tin Cloth is highly water-resistant. The wax finish repels water effectively, keeping you dry in rain and snow. However, it’s not completely waterproof. Prolonged exposure to heavy rain can eventually saturate the fabric.
• Breathability: Poor. Tin Cloth is not a breathable fabric. The wax finish blocks airflow, trapping heat and moisture. This can be uncomfortable in warm weather or during strenuous activity.
• Comfort: Poor to Moderate. Tin Cloth can feel stiff and heavy, especially when new. The wax finish can also feel sticky or oily against the skin. It softens with wear, but it never becomes truly comfortable.
• Maintenance: Difficult. Tin Cloth requires special care. It cannot be machine washed or dry cleaned. It should be spot cleaned with a damp cloth and re-waxed periodically to maintain its water resistance.

Real-World Example: The Rainy Logging Operation

I once worked on a logging operation in the Pacific Northwest where rain was a constant companion. My Filson Tin Cloth jacket was a lifesaver. It kept me dry and protected from the elements, even during prolonged periods of heavy rain. However, I also learned that it’s not the best choice for strenuous activity. The lack of breathability can quickly lead to overheating.

Data Points

• Average Lifespan (Heavy Use): 10+ years (with proper care)
• Typical Cost (Jacket): $300-$500
• Wax Reapplication Frequency: Typically every 1-2 years, depending on use.

Unique Insights

The key to maintaining Tin Cloth is proper waxing. Regular waxing not only maintains the fabric’s water resistance but also helps to extend its lifespan. There are various waxing products available, but Filson’s own wax is generally considered the best choice. I’ve found that applying the wax on a warm day makes it easier to work into the fabric.

Filson Shelter Cloth: The Breathable Alternative

If you like the idea of Filson’s quality but need something more breathable than Tin Cloth, Shelter Cloth is worth considering. It offers a good balance of durability, water resistance, and comfort.

What is Shelter Cloth?

Shelter Cloth is a tightly woven cotton fabric that’s treated with a lighter wax finish than Tin Cloth. This finish provides water resistance and abrasion resistance while allowing for better breathability.

Performance Breakdown

• Abrasion Resistance: Very Good. Shelter Cloth is less abrasion-resistant than Tin Cloth but still offers excellent protection against wear and tear.
• Tear Resistance: Good. Similar to Tin Cloth, Shelter Cloth’s tight weave provides good tear resistance.
• Water Resistance: Good. Shelter Cloth is water-resistant, but not as water-resistant as Tin Cloth. The lighter wax finish provides protection against light rain and snow, but it will eventually saturate in heavy downpours.
• Breathability: Moderate. Shelter Cloth is significantly more breathable than Tin Cloth. The lighter wax finish allows for better airflow, making it more comfortable to wear in warmer weather or during strenuous activity.
• Comfort: Moderate to Good. Shelter Cloth is generally more comfortable than Tin Cloth. The lighter weight and improved breathability make it less restrictive and more comfortable to wear for extended periods.
• Maintenance: Easier than Tin Cloth. Shelter Cloth can be machine washed on a gentle cycle and hung to dry. However, repeated washing will degrade the wax finish and reduce its water resistance.

Real-World Example: The Spring Firewood Cutting

I wore a Filson Shelter Cloth jacket while cutting firewood in the spring. The weather was mild but unpredictable, with occasional showers. The Shelter Cloth jacket provided enough water resistance to keep me dry during the showers, and the improved breathability prevented me from overheating during the more strenuous parts of the job.

Data Points

• Average Lifespan (Heavy Use): 5-7 years (with proper care)
• Typical Cost (Jacket): $250-$400
• Wax Reapplication (Optional): Can be re-waxed to enhance water resistance.

Unique Insights

Shelter Cloth is a good choice for those who want the durability and quality of Filson but need something more versatile than Tin Cloth. It’s suitable for a wider range of activities and weather conditions.

Filson Mackinaw Wool: The Warmth Champion

When the temperature drops, Filson Mackinaw Wool is the fabric you want on your side. This fabric is renowned for its incredible warmth, durability, and water resistance.

What is Mackinaw Wool?

Mackinaw Wool is a heavyweight, tightly woven wool fabric made from virgin wool fibers. It’s known for its dense construction, which traps air and provides excellent insulation.

Performance Breakdown

• Abrasion Resistance: Excellent. Mackinaw Wool is highly abrasion-resistant. The dense weave and strong wool fibers can withstand a significant amount of rubbing and scraping.
• Tear Resistance: Good to Excellent. Mackinaw Wool is surprisingly tear-resistant. The dense weave and interlocking fibers help to prevent tears from spreading.
• Water Resistance: Good. Mackinaw Wool is naturally water-resistant. The wool fibers contain lanolin, a natural wax that repels water. However, it’s not completely waterproof. Prolonged exposure to heavy rain can eventually saturate the fabric.
• Breathability: Moderate. Mackinaw Wool is more breathable than you might expect. The wool fibers allow for some airflow, which helps to regulate body temperature and prevent overheating.
• Comfort: Moderate. Mackinaw Wool can feel itchy against the skin, especially when new. It’s best worn over a base layer to prevent irritation. It also softens with wear.
• Maintenance: Moderate. Mackinaw Wool should be dry cleaned or hand washed. It should not be machine washed or dried, as this can cause it to shrink or felt.

Real-World Example: The Winter Logging Crew

I worked with a logging crew in northern Minnesota where temperatures regularly dipped below zero in the winter. The loggers who wore Filson Mackinaw Wool coats were noticeably warmer and more comfortable than those who wore synthetic jackets. The wool provided excellent insulation, even in the most extreme conditions.

Data Points

• Average Lifespan (Heavy Use): 10+ years (with proper care)
• Typical Cost (Coat): $400-$700
• Wool Weight: Typically 24-26 ounces per yard.

Unique Insights

Mackinaw Wool is a natural insulator, meaning it retains its warmth even when wet. This is a significant advantage over synthetic insulation, which loses much of its insulating ability when wet. I’ve found that a Mackinaw Wool coat is an invaluable piece of gear for anyone who works outdoors in cold, wet conditions.

Head-to-Head Comparison: The Verdict

Okay, let’s break it down. Here’s a table summarizing the strengths and weaknesses of each fabric:

Choosing the Right Fabric: Key Considerations

• Climate: If you work in a wet climate, Filson Tin Cloth is hard to beat. For cold climates, Mackinaw Wool is the clear winner. In milder climates, Carhartt duck canvas or Filson Shelter Cloth may be more comfortable.
• Type of Work: If you’re constantly exposed to snags and tears, Carhartt ripstop is the best choice. For general workwear that needs to withstand abrasion, duck canvas or Tin Cloth are good options.
• Budget: Carhartt garments are generally more affordable than Filson garments. If you’re on a tight budget, Carhartt is the better choice.
• Personal Preference: Ultimately, the best fabric is the one that you find most comfortable and that meets your specific needs.

My Personal Recommendations

• For general firewood preparation: Carhartt duck canvas pants and a Shelter Cloth jacket. This combination provides a good balance of durability, comfort, and weather protection.
• For logging in wet conditions: Filson Tin Cloth jacket and pants. This will keep you dry and protected from the elements.
• For winter work: Filson Mackinaw Wool coat and Carhartt duck canvas pants. This will provide excellent warmth and protection from the cold.

Beyond the Fabric: Other Important Factors

While fabric durability is crucial, it’s not the only factor to consider when choosing workwear. Other important factors include:

• Fit: Make sure the garment fits properly. It should be comfortable to move in and not too tight or too loose.
• Construction: Look for well-constructed garments with reinforced seams and durable hardware.
• Features: Consider the features you need, such as pockets, zippers, and adjustable cuffs.
• Safety: If you’re working in a hazardous environment, make sure your workwear meets the necessary safety standards.

The Future of Workwear Fabrics

The workwear industry is constantly evolving, with new fabrics and technologies being developed all the time. Some of the trends to watch include:

• Sustainable Fabrics: Manufacturers are increasingly using sustainable materials, such as recycled cotton and hemp.
• Advanced Synthetics: New synthetic fabrics offer improved durability, breathability, and water resistance.
• Smart Textiles: Some workwear garments are now incorporating sensors and other technologies to monitor the wearer’s health and safety.

Conclusion: Choose Wisely, Work Hard

Ultimately, the choice between Carhartt and Filson comes down to your individual needs and preferences. Both brands offer high-quality workwear that can stand up to the rigors of demanding outdoor work. By considering the factors outlined in this article, you can make an informed decision and choose the gear that’s right for you.

Remember that one of the most durable pieces of workwear I ever owned wasn’t a brand name. It was an old, patched-up canvas jacket my grandfather wore while logging. It was more than just fabric; it was a testament to hard work, resilience, and the enduring power of well-made gear. So, choose wisely, take care of your gear, and get to work. The woods are waiting.

Learn more