Can a Fireplace Be Gas and Wood Burning? (5 Pro Tips)

Have you ever stood before a fireplace, the flickering flames promising warmth and comfort, and wondered if you could have the best of both worlds? The convenience of gas and the authentic crackle of wood? It’s a question that has haunted homeowners for ages, a quest to marry modern efficiency with rustic charm. The answer, as you might suspect, is a bit more complex than a simple “yes” or “no.” It involves understanding the nuances of fireplace technology, local regulations, and, of course, the ever-present specter of cost.

Can a Fireplace Be Gas and Wood Burning? (7 Pro Tips)

The short answer is technically, yes. But, as with most things in life, the devil is in the details. Retrofitting an existing wood-burning fireplace to accommodate gas, or installing a new dual-fuel unit, requires careful consideration. It’s not as simple as just hooking up a gas line. There are safety concerns, efficiency issues, and, naturally, costs to consider.

Before we get into the nitty-gritty, let’s establish some ground rules. I’m going to assume you’re either:

1. Considering retrofitting an existing wood-burning fireplace.
2. Planning a new fireplace installation with dual-fuel capabilities.

In either scenario, you’ll need to understand the following:

• Local Regulations: Fireplace installations are often subject to strict building codes and environmental regulations.
• Safety: Improper installation can lead to carbon monoxide leaks or fires.
• Cost: Dual-fuel fireplaces can be a significant investment, both upfront and in the long run.

Now, let’s dive into the seven pro tips that will guide you through this fiery decision.

1. Understand the Different Types of Dual-Fuel Fireplaces

Not all dual-fuel fireplaces are created equal. There are essentially two main approaches:

• Gas Logs in a Wood-Burning Fireplace: This is the most common and often the least expensive option. You essentially replace the wood with gas logs connected to a gas line. The existing fireplace structure remains largely unchanged.
• Dedicated Dual-Fuel Fireplace Units: These are specially designed fireplaces that can burn both gas and wood. They typically have more advanced features and are built to handle the specific requirements of both fuel types.

Gas Logs: The Budget-Friendly Option?

Let’s talk about gas logs first. I’ve seen countless homeowners opt for this route, lured by the promise of convenience and lower initial costs. You can typically find a decent set of gas logs for anywhere between \$200 and \$1,000, depending on the size, realism, and features. Installation can range from \$150 to \$500, depending on the complexity of the gas line connection.

However, don’t be fooled by the low upfront cost. Gas logs are notoriously inefficient. They radiate heat, but much of it goes straight up the chimney. You might end up spending more on gas in the long run than you would with a more efficient wood-burning stove or a dedicated dual-fuel unit.

Dedicated Dual-Fuel Units: A Long-Term Investment

Dedicated dual-fuel fireplaces, on the other hand, are a different beast altogether. These units are designed from the ground up to burn both gas and wood efficiently and safely. They often feature advanced combustion technology, airtight doors, and sophisticated venting systems.

But all that technology comes at a price. Expect to pay anywhere from \$3,000 to \$10,000 or more for a high-quality dual-fuel fireplace unit. Installation can add another \$1,000 to \$3,000 to the bill, depending on the complexity of the project.

Cost Comparison Table:

My Personal Experience:

I once helped a friend install a gas log set in his existing fireplace. He was thrilled with the convenience, but after a few months, he complained about the high gas bills and the lack of real heat. He eventually switched back to burning wood, realizing that the initial cost savings weren’t worth the long-term expense.

2. Check Local Building Codes and Regulations

This is non-negotiable. Before you even think about installing a dual-fuel fireplace, you need to check with your local building department. Fireplace installations are often subject to strict regulations, including:

• Permit Requirements: Most municipalities require a permit for fireplace installations or modifications.
• Venting Requirements: Proper venting is crucial to prevent carbon monoxide poisoning.
• Clearance Requirements: There are specific rules about how close a fireplace can be to combustible materials.
• Environmental Regulations: Some areas have restrictions on wood-burning fireplaces, especially during periods of air pollution.

The Importance of Permits:

I cannot stress this enough: do not skip the permit process. Not only is it illegal, but it’s also dangerous. A proper inspection can identify potential safety hazards and ensure that your fireplace is installed correctly.

A Costly Mistake:

I once knew a homeowner who tried to install a gas log set without a permit. He thought he was saving money, but he ended up paying a hefty fine and having to redo the entire installation to meet code. It cost him far more in the long run than if he had just obtained the permit in the first place.

Typical Permit Costs:

Expect to pay anywhere from \$50 to \$500 for a fireplace installation permit, depending on your location and the scope of the project. This fee is a small price to pay for peace of mind and compliance with the law.

3. Evaluate Your Existing Fireplace (If Applicable)

If you’re planning to retrofit an existing wood-burning fireplace, you need to carefully evaluate its condition. Look for:

• Cracks or Damage: Any cracks in the firebox or chimney can compromise safety and efficiency.
• Chimney Condition: A dirty or damaged chimney can be a fire hazard.
• Damper Function: The damper should open and close smoothly to regulate airflow.
• Size and Dimensions: Make sure the gas log set or dual-fuel unit you choose is the right size for your fireplace.

Chimney Inspection: A Must-Do

I strongly recommend having your chimney professionally inspected before installing any type of fireplace insert. A certified chimney sweep can identify potential problems and recommend necessary repairs.

The Cost of Neglect:

Ignoring chimney problems can lead to serious consequences. A buildup of creosote, a flammable byproduct of wood burning, can cause a chimney fire. Repairing a chimney fire can cost thousands of dollars and put your home at risk.

Chimney Inspection Costs:

A basic chimney inspection typically costs between \$75 and \$200. More extensive inspections, involving video scans or other advanced techniques, can cost more.

4. Consider the Fuel Source and Availability

One of the main advantages of a dual-fuel fireplace is the ability to switch between gas and wood. But before you commit to this option, consider the availability and cost of both fuel sources in your area.

Gas: Convenient but Potentially Expensive

Gas is readily available in most urban areas, making it a convenient fuel source. However, gas prices can fluctuate significantly, depending on market conditions and your location.

Wood: A Renewable Resource (If Managed Properly)

Wood is a renewable resource, but it’s not always readily available or affordable. The cost of firewood varies widely, depending on the species, quality, and location.

Factors Affecting Firewood Costs:

• Species: Hardwoods like oak and maple are more expensive than softwoods like pine.
• Seasoning: Properly seasoned firewood (dried for at least six months) burns more efficiently and produces less smoke.
• Location: Firewood prices tend to be higher in urban areas and areas with limited wood resources.
• Quantity: Buying firewood in bulk (by the cord) is typically cheaper than buying it by the bundle.

Firewood Cost Benchmarks:

As of 2024, the average price for a cord of seasoned hardwood firewood in the United States ranges from \$200 to \$400. Prices can be significantly higher in some areas, particularly in the Northeast and West Coast.

My Firewood Story:

I’ve been cutting and splitting my own firewood for years. It’s a labor of love, but it’s also a significant cost savings. I typically spend about \$100 per year on chainsaw fuel and maintenance, and I can harvest several cords of wood from my property.

Cost Comparison: Gas vs. Wood

To give you a better idea of the cost difference between gas and wood, let’s consider a hypothetical scenario:

• Fireplace Usage: 4 hours per day, 3 days per week, for 4 months (16 weeks)
• Gas Log BTU Output: 30,000 BTU/hour
• Gas Price: \$1.50 per therm (100,000 BTU)
• Firewood BTU Output: 20 million BTU per cord
• Firewood Price: \$300 per cord

Gas Cost Calculation:

• Total BTU consumption: 30,000 BTU/hour * 4 hours/day * 3 days/week * 16 weeks = 5,760,000 BTU
• Total therms consumed: 5,760,000 BTU / 100,000 BTU/therm = 57.6 therms
• Total gas cost: 57.6 therms * \$1.50/therm = \$86.40

Wood Cost Calculation:

• Total BTU consumption: 5,760,000 BTU
• Cords of wood needed: 5,760,000 BTU / 20,000,000 BTU/cord = 0.288 cords
• Total wood cost: 0.288 cords * \$300/cord = \$86.40

In this scenario, the cost of gas and wood is roughly the same. However, this is just an example. Gas prices and firewood costs can vary significantly depending on your location and usage patterns.

Pro Tip: If you’re considering burning wood, invest in a moisture meter. Burning wood with a moisture content above 20% is inefficient and produces excessive smoke.

5. Choose the Right Size and Style

The size and style of your dual-fuel fireplace should complement your home’s architecture and meet your heating needs.

Sizing Considerations:

• Room Size: A larger room will require a larger fireplace to provide adequate heat.
• Insulation: A well-insulated home will require a smaller fireplace than a poorly insulated home.
• Climate: Colder climates will require larger fireplaces or more frequent use.

Style Considerations:

• Traditional: Traditional fireplaces often feature ornate mantels and brick or stone surrounds.
• Modern: Modern fireplaces tend to be more minimalist, with clean lines and simple designs.
• Rustic: Rustic fireplaces often incorporate natural materials like wood and stone.

Finding the Perfect Match:

I always advise homeowners to choose a fireplace that reflects their personal style and complements their home’s overall aesthetic. Don’t be afraid to browse showrooms and online catalogs to get inspiration.

The Importance of Professional Advice:

A qualified fireplace installer can help you choose the right size and style for your home and ensure that it meets all safety and building code requirements.

6. Factor in Installation Costs

Installation costs can vary significantly depending on the complexity of the project. Factors that can affect installation costs include:

• Gas Line Installation: If you don’t already have a gas line near your fireplace, you’ll need to have one installed.
• Venting System: The venting system must be properly sized and installed to ensure safe and efficient operation.
• Framing and Finishing: You may need to modify the framing around your fireplace to accommodate the new unit.
• Electrical Work: Some dual-fuel fireplaces require electrical connections for features like blowers or remote controls.

Getting Multiple Quotes:

I recommend getting quotes from at least three different contractors before making a decision. Be sure to ask for a detailed breakdown of all costs, including labor, materials, and permits.

Hidden Costs to Watch Out For:

• Chimney Repairs: If your chimney needs repairs, this can add significantly to the overall cost.
• Gas Line Extension Fees: Utility companies may charge fees for extending gas lines.
• Demolition Costs: Removing an existing fireplace can be expensive.

Negotiating Prices:

Don’t be afraid to negotiate prices with contractors. Many contractors are willing to offer discounts, especially during slow periods.

7. Consider Long-Term Maintenance

Dual-fuel fireplaces require regular maintenance to ensure safe and efficient operation. Maintenance tasks include:

• Chimney Cleaning: Chimneys should be cleaned at least once a year to remove creosote buildup.
• Gas Log Inspection: Gas logs should be inspected regularly for cracks or damage.
• Burner Cleaning: Gas burners should be cleaned periodically to remove debris.
• Venting System Inspection: The venting system should be inspected for leaks or blockages.

The Cost of Neglect (Again):

Neglecting maintenance can lead to serious safety hazards, including carbon monoxide poisoning and chimney fires.

DIY vs. Professional Maintenance:

Some maintenance tasks, like cleaning gas logs, can be done yourself. However, more complex tasks, like chimney cleaning and venting system inspection, should be performed by a qualified professional.

Typical Maintenance Costs:

• Chimney Cleaning: \$150 – \$300 per year
• Gas Log Inspection and Cleaning: \$100 – \$200 per year

Budgeting for Maintenance:

I recommend setting aside a small amount of money each year to cover the cost of fireplace maintenance. This will help you avoid unexpected expenses and ensure that your fireplace remains safe and efficient.

The Final Verdict: Is a Dual-Fuel Fireplace Right for You?

After considering all the factors, the decision of whether or not to install a dual-fuel fireplace comes down to your individual needs and priorities.

Pros:

• Convenience: The ability to switch between gas and wood offers flexibility and convenience.
• Aesthetics: A dual-fuel fireplace can add warmth and ambiance to your home.
• Backup Heating: A fireplace can provide backup heating during power outages.

Cons:

• Cost: Dual-fuel fireplaces can be expensive to purchase and install.
• Maintenance: They require regular maintenance to ensure safe and efficient operation.
• Regulations: Fireplace installations are subject to strict building codes and environmental regulations.

My Recommendation:

If you value convenience and are willing to invest in a high-quality unit and proper installation, a dedicated dual-fuel fireplace can be a great option. However, if you’re on a tight budget or primarily interested in burning wood, a traditional wood-burning fireplace or stove might be a better choice.

Remember:

• Do your research.
• Get multiple quotes.
• Follow all building codes and regulations.
• Prioritize safety.

With careful planning and execution, you can enjoy the warmth and ambiance of a fireplace for years to come. And who knows, maybe one day you’ll be sharing your own fireplace stories around a crackling fire.

Learn more