Ash vs Walnut Firewood (5 Heat Output Facts You Must Know)

Ash vs Walnut Firewood: 5 Heat Output Facts You Must Know

Choosing the right firewood isn’t just about grabbing the cheapest option. It’s about understanding the specific characteristics of different wood types and how those characteristics translate into heat, burn time, and overall cost-effectiveness. Ash and walnut are two contenders that often get compared, but they possess distinct qualities that make them suitable for different heating needs and budgets.

Fact 1: BTU Showdown – Heat Output Comparison

The most crucial factor when choosing firewood is its heat output, typically measured in British Thermal Units (BTUs) per cord. A BTU is the amount of energy required to raise the temperature of one pound of water by one degree Fahrenheit. The higher the BTU rating, the more heat the wood produces when burned.

• Ash: Ash generally boasts a BTU rating of around 20 million BTUs per cord. This places it in the upper tier of hardwood firewoods, making it a reliable choice for consistent and substantial heat.
• Walnut: Walnut, on the other hand, typically ranges around 17-18 million BTUs per cord. While still a respectable heat output, it’s noticeably lower than ash.

Data Point: According to the US Department of Agriculture Forest Service, ash species, particularly white ash, consistently rank high in BTU charts for firewood.

My Experience: I’ve personally noticed that ash burns hotter and longer than walnut. A single load of ash in my wood stove will keep the house warmer for a longer period compared to the same volume of walnut. This difference is especially noticeable during colder months when consistent heat is essential.

Fact 2: Seasoning Time – The Key to Efficient Burning

Seasoning, or drying, firewood is absolutely critical for efficient burning. Green wood contains a high moisture content, which reduces its heat output, creates more smoke, and can lead to creosote buildup in your chimney.

• Ash: Ash is known for its relatively low moisture content even when freshly cut. This means it seasons faster than many other hardwoods, typically taking 6-12 months to dry properly.
• Walnut: Walnut has a slightly higher moisture content than ash and can take 12-18 months to season adequately.

Data Point: Studies from forestry extension services indicate that properly seasoned firewood should have a moisture content of 20% or less for optimal burning.

My Experience: I once made the mistake of burning walnut that wasn’t fully seasoned. The result was a smoky fire that produced minimal heat and left a sticky residue in my chimney. Since then, I’ve learned the importance of patience and proper seasoning, especially with walnut. I now use a moisture meter religiously.

Cost Implication: Faster seasoning time for ash can translate to quicker availability for use, potentially reducing the need to purchase firewood further in advance, saving storage space and possibly money.

Fact 3: Smoke Production – A Matter of Cleanliness and Safety

The amount of smoke produced by firewood directly impacts air quality and chimney maintenance. Excessive smoke indicates incomplete combustion, meaning you’re not getting the full heat potential from your wood.

• Ash: Ash is renowned for producing very little smoke when properly seasoned. It burns cleanly and efficiently, minimizing creosote buildup in your chimney.
• Walnut: Walnut tends to produce more smoke than ash, particularly if not fully seasoned. This is due to its higher oil content.

Data Point: Research from the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) highlights the importance of burning seasoned firewood to reduce particulate matter emissions and improve air quality.

My Experience: I’ve found that burning ash results in a cleaner chimney and less frequent cleaning is needed. Burning walnut, especially if I’m not diligent about seasoning, requires more frequent chimney inspections and cleaning to prevent creosote buildup.

Cost Implication: Less creosote buildup means fewer chimney cleanings, saving you money in the long run. Chimney cleaning costs can range from $150-$300 per cleaning, depending on your location and the chimney’s condition.

Fact 4: Burning Characteristics – Flame, Coals, and Aroma

Beyond heat output and smoke, the burning characteristics of firewood influence the overall experience of using a wood-burning stove or fireplace.

• Ash: Ash produces a steady, bright flame and leaves behind good, hot coals. It’s easy to light and burns consistently. It also has a relatively neutral aroma.
• Walnut: Walnut is known for its aromatic smoke, which some people find pleasant. However, it can be overpowering for others. It tends to produce fewer coals than ash and can be slightly more difficult to light.

My Experience: I enjoy the smell of burning walnut on occasion, especially during the holidays. However, for everyday heating, I prefer the consistent heat and clean burn of ash. The coals from ash are also ideal for rekindling a fire in the morning.

Data Point: Firewood forums and online communities often discuss the subjective preferences for different wood aromas, with walnut being a polarizing choice.

Fact 5: Cost and Availability – The Bottom Line

Ultimately, the cost and availability of ash and walnut will significantly influence your choice. Prices vary greatly depending on your location, the time of year, and the supplier.

• Ash: Ash is generally readily available in many regions, especially where ash trees are abundant. Prices can range from $200-$350 per cord, depending on the factors mentioned above. However, the Emerald Ash Borer is devastating ash populations in North America, which may impact availability and price in the future.
• Walnut: Walnut is often more expensive than ash due to its higher value for woodworking and furniture making. Prices can range from $250-$400+ per cord. Its availability can also be more limited depending on your region.

Data Point: Market research on firewood prices indicates that hardwood prices generally increase during the fall and winter months due to higher demand.

My Experience: I’ve found that sourcing firewood directly from local loggers or landowners can often result in lower prices compared to buying from retail firewood suppliers. However, this often requires more work on my part, such as cutting and splitting the wood myself. I’ve also noticed that prices tend to be higher in urban areas compared to rural areas.

Cost Breakdown Example:

Let’s say I’m considering buying a cord of ash firewood. Here’s a potential cost breakdown:

• Firewood Purchase: $250 per cord
• Delivery Fee: $50 (if applicable)
• Stacking Fee: $25 (if I don’t want to stack it myself)
• Total Cost: $325

Now, let’s compare that to a cord of walnut:

• Firewood Purchase: $350 per cord
• Delivery Fee: $50 (if applicable)
• Stacking Fee: $25 (if I don’t want to stack it myself)
• Total Cost: $425

In this example, the walnut is $100 more expensive than the ash. I would need to consider whether the aromatic smoke and slightly lower heat output are worth the extra cost.

Deep Dive: Cost Factors in Firewood Preparation

Preparing firewood involves more than just cutting and splitting wood. Understanding the various cost factors involved can help you budget effectively and potentially save money. Whether you’re a homeowner preparing firewood for personal use or a small-scale firewood supplier, these considerations are crucial.

Timber Acquisition Costs

The cost of acquiring timber is a primary driver of firewood prices. This cost can vary significantly depending on the source of the wood.

• Purchasing Logs: If you’re buying logs directly from a logger or sawmill, the price will depend on the species, grade, and volume of the logs. Hardwoods like ash and walnut are generally more expensive than softwoods like pine. Prices are usually quoted per board foot or per cord.
  • Board Foot: A board foot is a unit of measurement for lumber, equivalent to 144 cubic inches (e.g., 12 inches long, 12 inches wide, and 1 inch thick).
  • Cord: A cord is a unit of measurement for stacked firewood, equivalent to 128 cubic feet (e.g., 4 feet high, 4 feet wide, and 8 feet long).
• Harvesting Your Own Timber: If you have access to your own land or can obtain a permit to harvest timber from public lands, you can potentially save money on timber acquisition. However, you’ll need to factor in the cost of equipment, labor, and permits.
  • Permits: Harvesting timber from public lands often requires permits from agencies like the US Forest Service or state forestry departments. These permits typically involve fees and regulations regarding the species and volume of timber that can be harvested.
• Free or Low-Cost Sources: Sometimes, you can find free or low-cost firewood sources, such as downed trees after storms or trees that need to be removed for safety reasons. However, these sources may require more effort to harvest and process.

Data Point: Timber prices fluctuate based on market demand, economic conditions, and seasonal factors. Checking timber market reports from organizations like the Timber Mart-South can provide valuable insights into current pricing trends.

My Experience: I once obtained a permit to harvest fallen ash trees from a local state forest. While the permit fee was minimal, the effort involved in hauling the logs out of the woods and processing them into firewood was considerable. However, the cost savings were significant compared to purchasing firewood from a supplier.

Labor Costs

Labor is a significant cost factor, especially if you’re hiring someone to help with firewood preparation.

• Hourly Wages: The hourly wage for firewood handlers can vary depending on experience, location, and the complexity of the work. Typical wages range from $15-$30 per hour.
• Piece Rate: Some firewood suppliers pay workers on a piece rate basis, such as per cord of wood split and stacked. This can incentivize faster work but may also lead to lower quality.
• Your Own Labor: Even if you’re doing the work yourself, it’s important to consider the value of your time. Calculate how many hours it takes you to prepare a cord of firewood and multiply that by your hourly wage to estimate the cost of your labor.

My Experience: I initially underestimated the amount of time it took me to prepare firewood. After tracking my hours for a few seasons, I realized that my labor cost was higher than I anticipated. This prompted me to invest in more efficient equipment, such as a hydraulic log splitter, to reduce my labor time.

Cost Calculation Example:

Let’s say it takes me 10 hours to cut, split, and stack a cord of firewood. If I value my time at $20 per hour, my labor cost is $200 per cord. This is a significant cost factor that needs to be considered when budgeting for firewood preparation.

Tool and Equipment Costs

The tools and equipment used for firewood preparation can range from basic hand tools to expensive machinery.

• Chainsaws: A good quality chainsaw is essential for cutting logs into manageable lengths. Prices range from $200 for a basic homeowner model to $1000+ for a professional-grade saw.
  • Maintenance: Chainsaws require regular maintenance, including sharpening the chain, cleaning the air filter, and replacing spark plugs. These costs can add up over time.
• Log Splitters: Log splitters can significantly reduce the amount of labor required to split firewood. Manual log splitters are relatively inexpensive (around $100-$200), while hydraulic log splitters can cost $1000-$4000+.
  • Rental Fees: Renting a log splitter can be a cost-effective option if you only need to split firewood occasionally. Rental fees typically range from $50-$100 per day.
• Axes and Wedges: Axes and wedges are essential for splitting larger logs that can’t be easily split with a log splitter. These tools are relatively inexpensive but require physical effort to use.
• Safety Gear: Safety gear, such as gloves, eye protection, and hearing protection, is essential for protecting yourself from injury. These costs are relatively low but should not be overlooked.

Cost Comparison Table:

My Experience: I initially started with a basic chainsaw and a manual log splitter. However, as my firewood needs increased, I invested in a hydraulic log splitter. This significantly reduced the amount of time and effort required to split firewood, making the investment worthwhile.

Transportation Costs

Transporting logs and firewood can add to the overall cost.

• Truck or Trailer: If you’re hauling logs or firewood yourself, you’ll need a truck or trailer. The cost of owning and operating a truck or trailer includes fuel, maintenance, insurance, and registration.
• Delivery Fees: If you’re purchasing firewood from a supplier, they may charge a delivery fee. This fee can vary depending on the distance and the volume of firewood being delivered.

Cost Calculation Example:

Let’s say I need to haul a load of logs 50 miles. If my truck gets 10 miles per gallon and fuel costs $4 per gallon, my fuel cost is $20 (100 miles / 10 mpg x $4/gallon). I also need to factor in wear and tear on my truck.

Storage Costs

Storing firewood properly is essential for seasoning and preventing rot.

• Firewood Rack: A firewood rack can help keep firewood off the ground and promote air circulation. Prices range from $50-$200.
• Tarp or Shed: Covering firewood with a tarp or storing it in a shed can protect it from rain and snow. The cost of a tarp or shed can vary depending on the size and quality.

My Experience: I initially stored my firewood uncovered on the ground. However, I quickly realized that this led to rot and slowed down the seasoning process. I invested in a firewood rack and a tarp, which significantly improved the quality of my firewood.

Permits and Regulations

In some areas, you may need to obtain permits or comply with regulations related to firewood harvesting, storage, and transportation.

• Harvesting Permits: As mentioned earlier, harvesting timber from public lands often requires permits.
• Transportation Regulations: Some states have regulations regarding the transportation of firewood to prevent the spread of invasive species.
• Burning Restrictions: Some areas have restrictions on burning firewood during certain times of the year due to air quality concerns.

Data Point: Check with your local forestry department or environmental protection agency to determine the specific permits and regulations that apply in your area.

Budgeting and Cost Management Tips

Effective budgeting and cost management are essential for minimizing expenses and maximizing the value of your firewood.

• Plan Ahead: Start planning your firewood needs well in advance of the heating season. This will give you time to source wood at the best prices and allow it to season properly.
• Shop Around: Compare prices from different firewood suppliers to find the best deal.
• Buy in Bulk: Buying firewood in bulk can often result in lower prices per cord.
• Negotiate Prices: Don’t be afraid to negotiate prices with firewood suppliers, especially if you’re buying a large quantity.
• Consider Alternative Wood Sources: Explore alternative wood sources, such as downed trees or trees that need to be removed for safety reasons.
• Invest in Efficient Equipment: Investing in efficient equipment, such as a hydraulic log splitter, can reduce labor costs and increase productivity.
• Maintain Your Equipment: Regular maintenance of your tools and equipment will prolong their lifespan and prevent costly repairs.
• Season Your Firewood Properly: Properly seasoned firewood burns more efficiently and produces less smoke, saving you money on fuel and chimney cleaning.
• Store Your Firewood Properly: Storing your firewood properly will prevent rot and ensure that it’s ready to burn when you need it.
• Track Your Costs: Keep track of all your firewood-related expenses to identify areas where you can save money.

My Experience: I’ve found that keeping a detailed spreadsheet of my firewood expenses helps me identify areas where I can cut costs. For example, I realized that I was spending a significant amount of money on chainsaw chains. By learning how to sharpen my own chains, I was able to save a considerable amount of money.

Case Studies: Real-World Firewood Projects

Let’s examine a couple of case studies to illustrate how these cost factors play out in real-world firewood projects.

Case Study 1: Homeowner Firewood Preparation

A homeowner in rural Maine decides to prepare their own firewood for the winter. They have access to a woodlot on their property and plan to harvest ash trees.

• Timber Acquisition: Free (access to own woodlot)
• Labor: 40 hours (cutting, splitting, stacking)
• Equipment: Chainsaw, axe, manual log splitter
• Equipment Costs: $300 (chainsaw maintenance, fuel)
• Storage: Firewood rack ($100)
• Total Cost: $400 (assuming $10/hour for labor)

The homeowner estimates that they saved $300-$400 compared to purchasing a cord of firewood from a supplier.

Case Study 2: Small-Scale Firewood Supplier

A small-scale firewood supplier in Oregon purchases logs from a local sawmill and sells firewood to customers in the surrounding area.

• Timber Acquisition: $150 per cord (logs from sawmill)
• Labor: 20 hours (splitting, stacking, delivery)
• Equipment: Chainsaw, hydraulic log splitter, truck
• Equipment Costs: $200 (chainsaw maintenance, fuel, truck maintenance)
• Storage: Covered shed ($500 amortized over 5 years = $100 per year)
• Transportation: $50 per cord (delivery costs)
• Total Cost: $1050 (assuming $20/hour for labor)

The supplier sells the firewood for $300 per cord, resulting in a profit of $450 per cord.

These case studies highlight the importance of understanding and managing all the cost factors involved in firewood preparation.

Actionable Takeaways and Next Steps

Choosing between ash and walnut firewood involves weighing several factors, including heat output, seasoning time, smoke production, burning characteristics, cost, and availability.

• Consider Your Heating Needs: If you need consistent and substantial heat, ash is the better choice due to its higher BTU rating.
• Factor in Seasoning Time: Ash seasons faster than walnut, allowing you to use it sooner.
• Think About Smoke Production: Ash produces less smoke than walnut, making it a cleaner-burning option.
• Weigh the Cost and Availability: Compare prices and availability in your area to make an informed decision.
• Budget Effectively: Plan ahead, shop around, and track your expenses to minimize costs.
• Prepare Your Firewood Properly: Season and store your firewood properly to ensure efficient burning.

Next Steps:

1. Assess Your Firewood Needs: Determine how much firewood you’ll need for the upcoming heating season.
2. Research Local Firewood Suppliers: Contact local firewood suppliers to compare prices and availability.
3. Evaluate Your Equipment: Assess your current tools and equipment and determine if any upgrades are needed.
4. Create a Budget: Develop a detailed budget that includes all the cost factors discussed in this guide.
5. Start Preparing Your Firewood: Begin sourcing, cutting, splitting, and stacking your firewood well in advance of the heating season.

By following these steps, you can make informed decisions about choosing and preparing firewood, ensuring a warm and cost-effective winter. Remember, a little knowledge and planning can go a long way in the world of wood processing and firewood preparation. So, get out there, get your hands dirty, and enjoy the warmth of a well-prepared fire!

Learn more