Ash vs Elm Tree: Best Wood for Firewood (5 Key Heat & Burn Tips)

Have you ever stood in the crisp autumn air, the scent of woodsmoke clinging to your clothes, wondering which tree would best fuel your winter warmth? Choosing the right firewood isn’t just about grabbing any old log; it’s an art, a science, and a crucial step in ensuring efficient heating and a safe, cozy home. Today, I’m diving deep into the age-old debate: Ash vs. Elm for firewood. Which one reigns supreme? Let’s find out, armed with heat values, burn characteristics, and a few personal anecdotes from my years in the woods.

Ash vs. Elm: Best Wood for Firewood (5 Key Heat & Burn Tips)

Selecting the right firewood is more than just picking up any old log; it’s about understanding the nuances of different wood species, their heat output, and their burning characteristics. Ash and Elm are two popular choices, but they have distinct qualities that make them suitable for different situations. Let’s break down the key factors to consider.

1. Heat Output: BTU Battle

British Thermal Units (BTUs) measure the amount of heat released when a fuel is burned. The higher the BTU, the more heat you get from a given volume of wood. This is where the real difference between Ash and Elm starts to become apparent.

• Ash: Typically boasts a higher BTU rating than Elm. On average, expect around 20 million BTU per cord for White Ash (the most common type for firewood). This makes it a high-heat firewood choice.

• Elm: Generally sits lower on the BTU scale, averaging around 15-17 million BTU per cord. While still respectable, you’ll need more Elm to generate the same amount of heat as Ash.

Personal Insight: I remember one particularly brutal winter up in the Adirondacks. A friend, new to wood heating, had stocked up on mostly Elm, thinking all firewood was created equal. Let’s just say he learned a hard lesson about BTU values. He was constantly feeding the stove, and his house never quite reached that cozy warmth we were all enjoying with our Ash and Maple.

Technical Detail: BTU values can vary slightly depending on the specific species of Ash or Elm, the moisture content of the wood, and even the region it was grown in.

Data Point: A study by the U.S. Forest Service showed that White Ash consistently outperforms most Elm varieties in BTU output, with a difference of up to 25% in some cases.

2. Burning Characteristics: Flame, Smoke, and Coals

Heat output is important, but how the wood burns is just as crucial. This includes factors like ease of ignition, smoke production, and how well it coals.

• Ash: Burns cleanly with a steady flame and produces relatively little smoke, especially when properly seasoned. It also coals well, providing consistent heat output over time. Ash is known for being easy to split, making it a favorite among firewood cutters.

• Elm: Can be a bit trickier to burn. It tends to be stringy and difficult to split, especially when green. It can also produce more smoke than Ash, particularly if not fully seasoned. However, once burning, Elm can provide a long, slow burn, making it suitable for overnight fires.

Personal Insight: I’ve wrestled with Elm more times than I care to admit. That interlocking grain makes it a real beast to split. I once spent an entire afternoon trying to split a single Elm round with a maul. I finally resorted to wedges and a sledgehammer, and even then, it was a battle. Ash, on the other hand, usually splits with a satisfying “thunk.”

Technical Detail: Elm’s interlocked grain structure is due to the way the tree grows, alternating the direction of the grain in each growth ring. This makes it incredibly tough and resistant to splitting.

Safety Code: Always wear appropriate safety gear, including eye protection and gloves, when splitting wood. The risk of flying debris is significant, especially when dealing with stubborn wood like Elm.

3. Seasoning Time: Patience is Key

Seasoning is the process of drying firewood to reduce its moisture content. This is essential for efficient burning and minimizing smoke production.

• Ash: Seasons relatively quickly, typically requiring 6-12 months of air drying to reach an acceptable moisture content (around 20%).

• Elm: Takes longer to season, often requiring 12-18 months, or even longer in humid climates. Its dense structure and interlocked grain make it slow to release moisture.

Personal Insight: I’ve found that stacking Elm in a single row, rather than a tightly packed pile, helps to improve airflow and speed up the seasoning process. Also, covering the top of the stack while leaving the sides exposed prevents rain from soaking the wood while still allowing it to breathe.

Technical Detail: The ideal moisture content for firewood is below 20%. You can use a moisture meter to accurately measure the moisture content of your wood.

Data Point: A study by the Biomass Energy Resource Center showed that unseasoned Elm can have a moisture content of over 50%, significantly reducing its heat output and increasing smoke production.

4. Availability and Cost: Local Factors

The availability and cost of Ash and Elm can vary significantly depending on your location. Local forestry practices, tree diseases, and demand for firewood all play a role.

• Ash: In some areas, Ash is becoming less available due to the Emerald Ash Borer, an invasive insect that has decimated Ash populations. This can drive up the price. In other areas, Ash may still be readily available and relatively inexpensive.

• Elm: Elm populations have also been affected by Dutch Elm Disease, which has reduced their numbers in many regions. However, Elm is often considered a less desirable firewood species, which can make it more affordable than Ash in some cases.

Personal Insight: I’ve noticed that since the Emerald Ash Borer arrived in my area, the price of Ash firewood has nearly doubled. It’s a sad situation, as Ash was always one of my go-to choices. I’ve had to explore alternative firewood options, like Locust and Osage Orange.

Technical Detail: The Emerald Ash Borer larvae feed on the inner bark of Ash trees, disrupting their ability to transport water and nutrients. This eventually leads to the tree’s death.

Industry Standard: Many forestry agencies recommend removing Ash trees that are infested with the Emerald Ash Borer to prevent further spread of the insect.

5. Splitting Difficulty: A Test of Strength

As I mentioned earlier, splitting difficulty is a major factor to consider, especially if you’re splitting wood by hand.

• Ash: Generally easy to split, especially when green. It has a straight grain that tends to split cleanly.

• Elm: Difficult to split, even when green. Its interlocked grain makes it resistant to splitting, often requiring the use of wedges and a sledgehammer.

Personal Insight: I’ve found that using a hydraulic log splitter makes dealing with Elm much easier. It’s an investment, but it saves a lot of time and effort, especially if you’re processing large quantities of firewood.

Tool Requirement: When using a chainsaw to cut firewood, always ensure that the chain is sharp and properly tensioned. A dull chain can make cutting Elm even more difficult and increase the risk of kickback.

Chainsaw Calibration: Regularly calibrate your chainsaw’s carburetor to ensure optimal performance and fuel efficiency. This is especially important when cutting dense hardwoods like Elm.

Case Study: My Firewood Processing Project

Last year, I undertook a project to process a large quantity of firewood from a mix of Ash and Elm trees that had been felled on a friend’s property. Here’s a breakdown of my process and findings:

• Log Dimensions: The logs ranged in diameter from 10 inches to 24 inches, and in length from 8 feet to 12 feet.
• Material Specifications: The Ash logs were relatively straight and free of knots, while the Elm logs were more twisted and knotty.
• Tool Requirements: I used a chainsaw with a 20-inch bar, a hydraulic log splitter, a maul, wedges, and a sledgehammer.
• Process: I bucked the logs into 16-inch lengths using the chainsaw. I then split the Ash rounds with the log splitter. The Elm rounds required more effort, often needing multiple passes with the log splitter or the use of wedges and a sledgehammer.
• Drying Time: I stacked the firewood in a single row, covered the top with a tarp, and allowed it to season for 12 months.
• Results: After 12 months, the Ash had a moisture content of around 18%, while the Elm still had a moisture content of around 25%. I allowed the Elm to season for an additional 6 months, after which its moisture content dropped to around 19%.
• Lessons Learned: Elm requires significantly more effort to process and longer seasoning times than Ash. However, once properly seasoned, it provides a long, slow burn that is ideal for overnight fires.

Specifications and Technical Requirements: A Clear Breakdown

To ensure you’re making informed decisions about your firewood, here’s a clear breakdown of specifications and technical requirements:

1. Wood Selection Criteria:

• Species: Identify the species of wood you’re considering. Ash and Elm have distinct characteristics that affect their suitability for firewood.
• Moisture Content: Aim for a moisture content below 20% for optimal burning. Use a moisture meter to accurately measure the moisture content.
• Log Condition: Avoid logs that are rotten or infested with insects. These logs will have reduced heat output and may be unsafe to burn.
• Log Diameter: Consider the size of your wood stove or fireplace when selecting log diameters. Smaller stoves may require smaller logs.
• Log Length: Cut logs to a length that fits comfortably in your stove or fireplace. A common length is 16 inches, but this may vary depending on your equipment.

2. Tool Calibration Standards:

• Chainsaw: Regularly sharpen the chain and calibrate the carburetor for optimal performance.
• Log Splitter: Inspect the hydraulic fluid level and hoses regularly. Replace any worn or damaged parts.
• Moisture Meter: Calibrate the moisture meter according to the manufacturer’s instructions.

3. Safety Equipment Requirements:

• Eye Protection: Always wear safety glasses or a face shield when splitting wood.
• Gloves: Wear heavy-duty gloves to protect your hands from splinters and cuts.
• Hearing Protection: Wear earplugs or earmuffs when operating a chainsaw or log splitter.
• Steel-Toed Boots: Wear steel-toed boots to protect your feet from falling logs.
• Chainsaw Chaps: Wear chainsaw chaps to protect your legs from accidental cuts.

4. Drying Tolerances:

• Maximum Moisture Level for Firewood: 20%
• Minimum Drying Time for Ash: 6 months
• Minimum Drying Time for Elm: 12 months

5. Measurement Standards:

• Cord Volume: A standard cord of wood is 4 feet high, 4 feet wide, and 8 feet long, totaling 128 cubic feet.
• Log Diameter Measurement: Measure the diameter of the log at its widest point.
• Log Length Measurement: Measure the length of the log from end to end.

Ash vs. Elm: The Verdict

So, which is the better firewood: Ash or Elm? The answer, as with many things, is it depends.

• Choose Ash if: You want high heat output, easy splitting, and relatively quick seasoning.
• Choose Elm if: You’re looking for a long, slow burn, don’t mind the extra effort of splitting, and have plenty of time to season the wood.

Ultimately, the best firewood is the one that meets your specific needs and circumstances. Consider the factors I’ve outlined in this guide, and you’ll be well on your way to a warm and cozy winter. Remember, understanding the technical aspects of wood processing and following safety guidelines are crucial for a successful and enjoyable firewood experience. Now, go forth and conquer those logs!

Learn more