Cedar vs Hemlock Wood: (5 Key Lumber Tips for Builders)

As someone who’s spent decades felling trees and processing wood, I understand the importance of choosing the right lumber. It’s like picking the right tool for the job – it can make all the difference. Cedar and Hemlock are two popular choices for builders, each with its own set of characteristics. Let’s dive into the world of Cedar vs. Hemlock, offering five key lumber tips that will help you make informed decisions for your next project. And let’s be honest, choosing the right wood isn’t just about aesthetics; it’s about durability, workability, and, ultimately, the longevity of your creation.

Cedar vs. Hemlock: 5 Key Lumber Tips for Builders

1. Understanding the Basics: Cedar and Hemlock Profiles

Before I get into the nitty-gritty, let’s establish what we’re dealing with. Cedar, specifically Western Red Cedar (Thuja plicata), is renowned for its natural resistance to decay and insects. Hemlock, often Western Hemlock (Tsuga heterophylla), is appreciated for its strength-to-weight ratio and versatility. I’ve worked with both extensively, and each has carved a special place in my lumberyard.

Cedar’s aromatic oils make it a natural insect repellent. It’s a soft, lightweight wood that’s easy to work with. Hemlock, on the other hand, lacks these oils and is denser. This difference impacts their applications and longevity in various environments.

Cedar: The Aromatic Champion

Cedar’s heartwood exhibits exceptional decay resistance, while its sapwood is more vulnerable. It’s naturally resistant to moisture, making it ideal for outdoor projects. The color ranges from light amber to reddish-brown, and the grain is typically straight and even.

• Common Uses: Exterior siding, decking, shingles, fencing, and interior paneling. Its aromatic properties also make it a popular choice for closets and chests.
• Pros:
  • Natural decay and insect resistance.
  • Lightweight and easy to work with.
  • Beautiful color and aromatic properties.
  • Dimensionally stable.
• Cons:
  • Softer than Hemlock, making it more prone to dents and scratches.
  • Can be more expensive than Hemlock.
  • Requires proper sealing for optimal longevity.

Hemlock: The Strong and Versatile Contender

Hemlock is a softwood, but it’s denser than Cedar. It’s known for its uniform texture and straight grain, making it a reliable choice for structural applications. While it doesn’t possess the same natural decay resistance as Cedar, proper treatment can significantly enhance its durability.

• Common Uses: Framing, sheathing, subflooring, interior trim, and furniture.
• Pros:
  • Stronger and more durable than Cedar.
  • More affordable than Cedar.
  • Takes paint and stains well.
  • Uniform texture and straight grain.
• Cons:
  • Less decay resistance than Cedar.
  • Prone to splintering if not handled carefully.
  • Requires treatment for outdoor use.

Takeaway: Cedar shines in applications where natural decay resistance and aesthetics are paramount. Hemlock excels in structural applications requiring strength and affordability.

2. Evaluating Decay and Insect Resistance

This is where Cedar truly struts its stuff. Its natural oils, particularly thujaplicins, act as potent fungicides and insecticides. I’ve seen Cedar structures stand strong for decades, even in damp environments, with minimal maintenance. Hemlock, sadly, doesn’t have this natural armor.

The University of British Columbia conducted a study that compared the decay resistance of various wood species. Western Red Cedar exhibited significantly higher resistance to fungal decay than Western Hemlock, even in controlled, high-moisture environments. This difference is due to the presence of extractives in Cedar, which act as natural preservatives.

However, this doesn’t mean Hemlock is doomed to rot. With proper pressure treatment, it can withstand the elements and resist insect attacks. I’ve used pressure-treated Hemlock for fence posts and retaining walls, and it has performed admirably.

Pressure Treatment: Hemlock’s Saving Grace

Pressure treatment involves forcing chemical preservatives deep into the wood fibers, making it resistant to decay and insects. Common preservatives include Alkaline Copper Quaternary (ACQ) and Copper Azole.

• ACQ: A water-based preservative that provides broad-spectrum protection against fungi and insects.
• Copper Azole: Another water-based preservative that offers similar protection to ACQ.

When selecting pressure-treated Hemlock, ensure it’s rated for the intended application. Look for labels indicating the level of protection, such as “ground contact” or “above ground.”

Takeaway: Cedar offers superior natural decay and insect resistance. Hemlock requires pressure treatment for outdoor applications.

3. Assessing Strength and Workability

Hemlock takes the lead in terms of strength. Its higher density translates to greater load-bearing capacity, making it ideal for framing and structural components. I’ve used Hemlock extensively in building frameworks where strength is paramount.

Cedar, being softer, is more prone to dents and scratches. However, its softness makes it incredibly easy to work with. It cuts cleanly, nails easily, and takes screws without splitting. I’ve often chosen Cedar for intricate trim work and detailed carvings.

Strength Comparison: A Numbers Game

• Bending Strength (MOR): Hemlock typically has a higher Modulus of Rupture (MOR) than Cedar. MOR measures a wood’s resistance to bending under load. For example, Western Hemlock has an average MOR of around 10,000 psi, while Western Red Cedar is closer to 6,000 psi.
• Stiffness (MOE): Similarly, Hemlock boasts a higher Modulus of Elasticity (MOE), indicating its resistance to deformation.
• Density: Hemlock’s density is around 29 lbs/cubic foot, while Cedar’s is about 23 lbs/cubic foot.

Workability Considerations

• Cutting: Cedar cuts easily with hand tools and power tools. Hemlock requires sharper blades due to its density.
• Nailing and Screwing: Both species accept nails and screws well. However, pre-drilling is recommended for Hemlock to prevent splitting, especially near the ends.
• Gluing: Both Cedar and Hemlock glue well. However, Cedar’s natural oils can sometimes interfere with adhesion. Surface preparation, such as sanding, is crucial for a strong bond.

Takeaway: Hemlock offers greater strength for structural applications. Cedar excels in workability for detailed projects.

4. Evaluating Cost and Availability

Cost is always a factor, and Hemlock generally wins this round. It’s more readily available and less expensive than Cedar, especially in regions where it’s locally sourced. I’ve seen Hemlock prices fluctuate less dramatically than Cedar prices, making it a more predictable option for budget-conscious builders.

Cedar, due to its slower growth rate and higher demand, commands a premium price. However, its longevity and natural properties can justify the investment in certain applications.

Cost Analysis: A Regional Perspective

• West Coast: In the Pacific Northwest, where both species are abundant, Hemlock is typically 20-30% cheaper than Cedar.
• East Coast: Cedar prices can be significantly higher on the East Coast due to transportation costs.
• Global Market: Cedar prices are influenced by international demand, particularly from Asia.

Availability Factors

• Local Sourcing: Sourcing lumber locally can significantly reduce costs and transportation emissions.
• Mill Relationships: Establishing relationships with local mills can provide access to better prices and consistent supply.
• Grading and Quality: Lumber prices vary based on grade and quality. Select grades command higher prices than common grades.

Takeaway: Hemlock is generally more affordable and readily available. Cedar offers a premium option with superior natural properties.

5. Considering Aesthetics and Finishing

Aesthetics are subjective, but both Cedar and Hemlock offer unique visual appeals. Cedar’s rich color variations and aromatic scent make it a favorite for projects where natural beauty is desired. I’ve built countless decks and fences with Cedar, and the warm, inviting look is always a hit.

Hemlock, with its lighter color and uniform grain, provides a blank canvas for painting and staining. It takes finishes exceptionally well, allowing you to achieve a wide range of looks. I’ve used Hemlock for interior trim and cabinetry, and the results have been stunning.

Finishing Techniques

• Cedar:
  • Sealing: Applying a clear sealant helps protect Cedar from weathering and discoloration.
  • Staining: Cedar accepts stains well, allowing you to enhance its natural color or achieve a different look.
  • Oiling: Oiling Cedar can help maintain its moisture content and prevent cracking.
• Hemlock:
  • Priming: Priming is essential for Hemlock before painting to ensure proper adhesion and coverage.
  • Painting: Hemlock takes paint exceptionally well, providing a smooth, even finish.
  • Staining: Hemlock can be stained to mimic the look of more expensive wood species.

Aesthetic Considerations

• Grain Pattern: Cedar typically has a more pronounced grain pattern than Hemlock.
• Color Variation: Cedar exhibits a wider range of color variations than Hemlock.
• Knot Frequency: Hemlock tends to have fewer knots than Cedar.

Takeaway: Cedar offers natural beauty and aromatic appeal. Hemlock provides a versatile canvas for painting and staining.

Deep Dive: Advanced Considerations and Techniques

Now that I’ve covered the five key lumber tips, let’s delve into some more advanced considerations and techniques. These insights come from years of experience in the field and will help you take your wood processing skills to the next level.

Timber Grading: Understanding the Language of Lumber

Timber grading is a crucial aspect of lumber selection. It provides a standardized system for evaluating the quality and appearance of wood. Understanding timber grades can help you make informed decisions and ensure you’re getting the right lumber for your project.

Common Timber Grades

• Select Grades: These are the highest quality grades, characterized by minimal knots and defects. They are typically used for furniture, trim, and other applications where appearance is paramount.
• Common Grades: These grades contain more knots and defects than select grades but are still suitable for a wide range of applications, including framing, sheathing, and subflooring.
• Construction Grades: These are the lowest quality grades, typically used for temporary structures or applications where appearance is not a concern.

Grading Agencies

• National Lumber Grades Authority (NLGA): The NLGA is the primary grading agency for Western Red Cedar and Western Hemlock in North America.
• Other Agencies: Other grading agencies exist, but the NLGA is the most widely recognized and respected.

Grade Stamps

Grade stamps are markings applied to lumber that indicate the grade, species, and grading agency. These stamps provide valuable information about the quality and characteristics of the wood.

Takeaway: Understanding timber grades is essential for selecting the right lumber for your project.

Sawmill Operations: From Log to Lumber

Sawmill operations are the heart of the lumber industry. Understanding how logs are processed into lumber can provide valuable insights into the characteristics and quality of different wood species.

Sawing Patterns

• Flat Sawn: Flat sawn lumber is cut parallel to the growth rings, resulting in a wide grain pattern. It’s the most common and affordable sawing pattern.
• Quarter Sawn: Quarter sawn lumber is cut perpendicular to the growth rings, resulting in a tighter grain pattern and greater dimensional stability. It’s more expensive than flat sawn lumber.
• Rift Sawn: Rift sawn lumber is cut at an angle of 45-60 degrees to the growth rings, resulting in a straight grain pattern and minimal warping. It’s the most expensive sawing pattern.

Drying Processes

• Air Drying: Air drying involves stacking lumber in a well-ventilated area and allowing it to dry naturally. It’s a slow process but results in minimal stress on the wood.
• Kiln Drying: Kiln drying involves placing lumber in a heated chamber to accelerate the drying process. It’s faster than air drying but can cause stress and warping if not done properly.

Mill Tours

Visiting a local sawmill can provide a fascinating glimpse into the lumber production process. Many mills offer tours that allow you to see how logs are processed into lumber and learn about different wood species and grades.

Takeaway: Understanding sawmill operations can provide valuable insights into the characteristics and quality of different wood species.

Splitting Techniques: Mastering the Art of Wood Cleavage

Splitting wood is a fundamental skill for anyone working with lumber. Whether you’re preparing firewood or creating smaller pieces for woodworking, mastering the art of wood cleavage can save you time and effort.

Hand Splitting

• Tools: Axe, maul, wedges.
• Technique: Position the wood on a chopping block. Strike the wood with the axe or maul, aiming for a natural split line. Use wedges to split stubborn pieces.

Mechanical Splitting

• Tools: Log splitter.
• Technique: Place the log on the log splitter. Activate the hydraulic ram to split the wood.

Safety Precautions

• Wear appropriate safety gear: Eye protection, gloves, and sturdy footwear are essential.
• Maintain a safe distance: Keep bystanders at a safe distance when splitting wood.
• Use sharp tools: Sharp tools are safer and more efficient than dull tools.

Takeaway: Mastering splitting techniques can save you time and effort when working with lumber.

Wood Drying Processes: Achieving Optimal Moisture Content

Wood drying is a critical step in lumber processing. Proper drying reduces the risk of warping, cracking, and decay. Achieving optimal moisture content is essential for ensuring the longevity and stability of your wood projects.

Moisture Content Targets

• Interior Applications: 6-8% moisture content.
• Exterior Applications: 12-15% moisture content.

Moisture Meters

• Pin Meters: Pin meters measure moisture content by inserting two pins into the wood.
• Pinless Meters: Pinless meters measure moisture content using electromagnetic waves.

Drying Methods

• Air Drying: Slow and natural, but can take months or even years.
• Kiln Drying: Faster and more controlled, but requires specialized equipment.

Takeaway: Achieving optimal moisture content is essential for ensuring the longevity and stability of your wood projects.

Safety Procedures: Protecting Yourself in the Lumber Yard

Working with lumber can be dangerous if proper safety procedures are not followed. Protecting yourself from injury is paramount.

Personal Protective Equipment (PPE)

• Eye Protection: Safety glasses or goggles are essential for protecting your eyes from flying debris.
• Hearing Protection: Earplugs or earmuffs can protect your hearing from loud noises.
• Gloves: Gloves can protect your hands from splinters and cuts.
• Footwear: Sturdy footwear with steel toes can protect your feet from falling objects.

Safe Handling Practices

• Lift with your legs: Avoid bending at the waist when lifting heavy objects.
• Use proper lifting techniques: Keep your back straight and your core engaged.
• Get help with heavy loads: Don’t try to lift more than you can safely handle.

Tool Safety

• Read the manual: Familiarize yourself with the operating instructions for all power tools.
• Use sharp blades: Sharp blades are safer and more efficient than dull blades.
• Disconnect power tools before servicing: Always disconnect power tools from the power source before performing maintenance or repairs.

Takeaway: Following proper safety procedures is essential for protecting yourself from injury in the lumber yard.

Case Studies: Real-World Applications of Cedar and Hemlock

To further illustrate the differences and best uses of Cedar and Hemlock, let’s examine a few real-world case studies. These examples highlight how these woods perform in various applications and environments.

Case Study 1: Cedar Decking in a Coastal Environment

Project: Construction of a residential deck in a coastal area with high humidity and salt exposure.

Wood Choice: Western Red Cedar

Rationale: Cedar’s natural resistance to decay and insects, combined with its ability to withstand moisture, made it the ideal choice for this project. The coastal environment presented a significant challenge due to the high humidity and salt spray, which can accelerate the deterioration of other wood species.

Results: The Cedar deck has performed exceptionally well, showing minimal signs of weathering or decay after several years of exposure. Regular sealing has helped maintain its appearance and protect it from the elements.

Key Takeaway: Cedar is an excellent choice for decking in coastal environments due to its natural durability and resistance to moisture and salt.

Case Study 2: Hemlock Framing for a Residential Home

Project: Framing of a residential home in a region with moderate climate.

Wood Choice: Western Hemlock

Rationale: Hemlock’s strength and affordability made it the ideal choice for this project. The framing required a strong and stable material to support the structure of the home.

Results: The Hemlock framing has provided a solid and reliable foundation for the home. Proper drying and treatment have ensured its longevity and resistance to decay and insects.

Key Takeaway: Hemlock is a cost-effective and reliable choice for framing in residential construction.

Case Study 3: Cedar Siding for a Mountain Cabin

Project: Installation of siding on a mountain cabin in a region with harsh winters and heavy snowfall.

Wood Choice: Western Red Cedar

Rationale: Cedar’s natural insulation properties and resistance to moisture made it the ideal choice for this project. The mountain environment presented a significant challenge due to the extreme temperatures and heavy snowfall, which can cause significant stress on the siding.

Results: The Cedar siding has provided excellent protection from the elements, helping to keep the cabin warm in the winter and cool in the summer. Its natural beauty has also enhanced the aesthetic appeal of the cabin.

Key Takeaway: Cedar is an excellent choice for siding in mountain environments due to its natural insulation properties and resistance to moisture.

Case Study 4: Hemlock Interior Trim for a Modern Home

Project: Installation of interior trim in a modern home with a minimalist design.

Wood Choice: Western Hemlock

Rationale: Hemlock’s uniform texture and ability to take paint and stains well made it the ideal choice for this project. The minimalist design required a clean and consistent look, which Hemlock provided.

Results: The Hemlock trim has provided a sleek and modern look to the interior of the home. Its smooth surface and uniform grain have allowed for a flawless paint finish.

Key Takeaway: Hemlock is a versatile choice for interior trim in modern homes due to its ability to take paint and stains well.

Actionable Metrics: Measuring Success in Wood Processing

To ensure you’re getting the most out of your wood processing efforts, it’s essential to track key metrics. These metrics will help you measure your success and identify areas for improvement.

• Processing Time: Track the time it takes to process different types of wood. This will help you identify bottlenecks and optimize your workflow.
• Moisture Content: Regularly measure the moisture content of your wood. This will ensure you’re achieving optimal drying levels.
• Waste Reduction: Monitor the amount of waste generated during wood processing. This will help you identify opportunities to reduce waste and save money.
• Equipment Maintenance: Keep track of your equipment maintenance schedule. This will help you prevent breakdowns and extend the life of your tools.
• Safety Incidents: Record any safety incidents that occur. This will help you identify hazards and improve your safety procedures.

Challenges and Contexts: Global Perspectives on Wood Processing

Wood processing practices vary significantly around the world, influenced by factors such as climate, geography, and economic conditions. Understanding these challenges and contexts can provide valuable insights into the global lumber industry.

• Small-Scale Loggers: Small-scale loggers in developing countries often face significant challenges, including limited access to equipment, lack of training, and unsustainable logging practices.
• Firewood Producers: Firewood producers in many parts of the world rely on wood as a primary source of energy. Sustainable firewood harvesting practices are essential for protecting forests and ensuring a reliable supply of fuel.
• Deforestation: Deforestation is a major environmental problem, driven by factors such as logging, agriculture, and urbanization. Sustainable forest management practices are essential for combating deforestation and protecting biodiversity.

Conclusion: Making the Right Choice for Your Project

Choosing between Cedar and Hemlock ultimately depends on the specific requirements of your project. Cedar offers superior natural decay resistance and aesthetic appeal, making it ideal for outdoor applications and projects where natural beauty is desired. Hemlock provides greater strength and affordability, making it a versatile choice for framing, sheathing, and interior trim.

By considering the five key lumber tips outlined in this guide – understanding the basics, evaluating decay and insect resistance, assessing strength and workability, evaluating cost and availability, and considering aesthetics and finishing – you can make an informed decision and select the right lumber for your project.

Remember, wood processing is a skill that takes time and practice to master. Be patient, stay safe, and never stop learning. With the right knowledge and techniques, you can transform raw lumber into beautiful and durable creations.

Learn more