2 Chainsaws Compared: Best Picks for Firewood (Top 5 Expert Tips)

2 Chainsaws Compared: Best Picks for Firewood (Top 5 Expert Tips)

(Image: A contrasting image showing a modern, high-powered chainsaw next to an old, worn-out chainsaw. The background should be a woodpile, highlighting the end use.)

Firewood. For some, it’s a romantic crackling companion on a chilly evening. For others, it’s a primary heat source, a necessity for survival against the biting cold. Regardless of your motivation, the right chainsaw can make all the difference between a back-breaking chore and a rewarding, efficient process. But with a market flooded with options, how do you choose the best chainsaw for your firewood needs? And more importantly, how do you budget for it all, considering not just the chainsaw itself, but the wood, the labor, and the long-term maintenance?

I’ve spent years in the woods, from helping my grandfather clear fallen trees on his property as a kid to now managing a small-scale firewood operation. I’ve seen firsthand how the wrong tool can turn a simple task into a grueling ordeal, and how a well-chosen chainsaw can transform a mountain of logs into a neatly stacked pile of firewood with surprising speed and efficiency.

This article isn’t just about two specific chainsaw models. It’s about equipping you with the knowledge to make the right choice for your situation. We’ll delve into the nitty-gritty details of chainsaw selection, explore the real costs involved in firewood preparation, and arm you with expert tips to optimize your budget and workflow. So, grab your gloves, sharpen your pencil, and let’s get started!

Chainsaw Showdown: Stihl MS 271 Farm Boss vs. Husqvarna 455 Rancher

These two chainsaws are perennial favorites among homeowners and professionals alike. Both offer a good balance of power, durability, and price, making them excellent contenders for firewood duty. However, their strengths and weaknesses differ in subtle but significant ways.

Stihl MS 271 Farm Boss: The Reliable Workhorse

Overview: The Stihl MS 271 Farm Boss is a mid-range chainsaw known for its reliability and ease of use. It’s a popular choice for homeowners who need a powerful saw for occasional firewood cutting, storm cleanup, and general property maintenance.

Key Features:

• Engine: 50.2 cc, 3.5 bhp (brake horsepower)
• Bar Length Options: 16″, 18″, 20″
• Weight: 12.3 lbs (without bar and chain)
• Fuel Capacity: 16.9 oz
• Oil Capacity: 9.5 oz
• Anti-Vibration System: Yes
• Starting System: Easy2Start™ system
• Chain Tensioning: Side-mounted chain tensioner

Pros:

• Reliable and Durable: Stihl is renowned for its build quality and longevity. The MS 271 is built to withstand demanding use.
• Easy to Start: The Easy2Start™ system makes starting the saw significantly easier, especially in cold weather.
• Good Power-to-Weight Ratio: Offers ample power for most firewood tasks without being overly heavy.
• Easy to Maintain: Simple design makes routine maintenance straightforward.
• Excellent Dealer Network: Stihl has a wide network of dealers, making parts and service readily available.

Cons:

• Price: Generally more expensive than the Husqvarna 455 Rancher.
• Vibration: While it has an anti-vibration system, some users find it less effective than other saws.
• Air Filter: The air filter can be prone to clogging in dusty conditions.

Husqvarna 455 Rancher: The Budget-Friendly Powerhouse

Overview: The Husqvarna 455 Rancher is another popular mid-range chainsaw, known for its power and value. It’s a solid choice for homeowners and occasional users who need a powerful saw for a variety of tasks.

Key Features:

• Engine: 55.5 cc, 3.5 bhp (brake horsepower)
• Bar Length Options: 16″, 18″, 20″
• Weight: 12.8 lbs (without bar and chain)
• Fuel Capacity: 15.22 oz
• Oil Capacity: 10.14 oz
• Anti-Vibration System: Yes (LowVib®)
• Starting System: Smart Start® technology
• Chain Tensioning: Side-mounted chain tensioner

Pros:

• Powerful Engine: The 55.5 cc engine provides ample power for cutting larger logs.
• Price: Generally more affordable than the Stihl MS 271.
• LowVib® Anti-Vibration System: Effective at reducing vibration, making it more comfortable to use for extended periods.
• Air Injection™: Centrifugal air cleaning system removes larger debris particles before reaching the air filter, improving engine life.
• Smart Start® Technology: Makes starting the saw easier.

Cons:

• Build Quality: While generally reliable, some users report that the build quality isn’t quite as robust as Stihl.
• Starting: Can be finicky to start in cold weather for some users.
• Fuel Consumption: May consume slightly more fuel than the Stihl MS 271.

Head-to-Head Comparison Table

The Verdict: Which Chainsaw Reigns Supreme?

Honestly, there’s no clear “winner.” The best chainsaw for you depends on your specific needs and priorities.

• For maximum reliability and ease of starting (especially in cold weather), the Stihl MS 271 Farm Boss is a solid choice. Its reputation for durability and readily available parts network offer peace of mind.

• If you’re on a tighter budget and need a powerful saw for tackling larger logs, the Husqvarna 455 Rancher offers excellent value. Its larger engine and effective anti-vibration system make it a workhorse.

Consider these factors when making your decision:

• The size of the logs you’ll be cutting: Larger logs require more power.
• The frequency of use: Occasional users might prioritize ease of starting, while frequent users might value durability and comfort.
• Your budget: The Husqvarna 455 Rancher is typically more affordable.
• Your local dealer network: Having a reliable dealer nearby is crucial for parts and service.

Top 5 Expert Tips for Choosing the Right Chainsaw for Firewood

Beyond the specific models, here are five expert tips to guide your chainsaw selection:

1. Match the Chainsaw to the Wood: Consider the type of wood you’ll be cutting most often. Softwoods like pine are easier to cut and require less power than hardwoods like oak or maple. A smaller, lighter chainsaw might suffice for softwoods, while a more powerful saw is essential for hardwoods.

2. Don’t Underestimate Bar Length: Choose a bar length that’s appropriate for the diameter of the logs you’ll be cutting. As a general rule, the bar length should be at least two inches longer than the largest diameter log you expect to encounter. A longer bar allows you to cut through larger logs in a single pass, saving time and effort.

3. Prioritize Safety Features: Look for chainsaws with features like a chain brake, hand guard, and throttle interlock. These features can significantly reduce the risk of accidents. Also, invest in proper safety gear, including a helmet, eye protection, hearing protection, gloves, and chaps.

4. Consider Ergonomics: Choose a chainsaw that feels comfortable to hold and operate. Consider the weight, balance, and handle design. A well-balanced chainsaw will be easier to control and less fatiguing to use.

5. Read Reviews and Talk to Experts: Before making a purchase, read online reviews and talk to experienced chainsaw users. Get their opinions on different models and brands. Visit your local chainsaw dealer and ask for their recommendations based on your specific needs.

The Real Cost of Firewood: Beyond the Chainsaw Price Tag

Now, let’s dive into the often-overlooked costs associated with preparing firewood. It’s not just about the price of the chainsaw. From sourcing the wood to splitting and stacking, every step involves expenses that need careful consideration.

1. Timber Acquisition: Buying vs. Harvesting

The first major cost factor is how you acquire the wood.

• Buying Logs: Purchasing logs directly from a logging company or sawmill is a common option. Prices vary significantly based on wood species, quality, and location.

  • Softwood Logs (Pine, Fir): Typically range from $50 to $100 per cord (128 cubic feet).
  • Hardwood Logs (Oak, Maple): Can range from $100 to $250+ per cord, depending on the species and demand.
  • Data Point: According to the U.S. Forest Service, the average price of hardwood sawtimber (logs suitable for lumber) varies widely by region, but generally falls between $300 and $600 per thousand board feet. Converting to a cord equivalent is complex, but this gives you a general idea of the raw material cost.

• Harvesting Your Own Wood: This involves cutting down trees on your own property or obtaining permits to harvest wood from public lands.

  • Permit Costs: Prices for firewood permits on public lands vary widely. They can range from a nominal fee (e.g., $20 per year) to a per-cord charge (e.g., $10 per cord).
  • Equipment Costs: This is where your chainsaw investment comes into play. But it doesn’t stop there. You might also need:
    • Axes and Wedges: For felling trees and splitting large rounds ($50 – $150).
    • Cant Hook: For rolling logs ($50 – $100).
    • Skidding Equipment: If you’re harvesting larger trees, you might need a tractor or winch to skid the logs to a central location (rental costs can range from $100 to $500+ per day).

Personal Story: I remember one year, I decided to harvest firewood from a patch of dead ash trees on my property. I thought I was saving money by not buying logs. However, after factoring in the cost of the chainsaw, fuel, oil, permit fees, and the sheer amount of time I spent felling, limbing, and skidding the trees, I realized I would have been better off buying a cord of logs! It was a valuable lesson in the importance of considering all the costs involved.

2. Labor Costs: DIY vs. Hiring Help

Your labor is a significant cost, even if you’re not paying yourself an hourly wage. Consider the time you’ll spend cutting, splitting, and stacking the wood.

• DIY Labor: Estimate the number of hours you’ll spend on each task and assign a value to your time. Even if you’re doing it for “free,” your time has value.

  • Example: Let’s say you estimate it will take you 20 hours to process a cord of firewood. If you value your time at $20 per hour, that’s $400 in labor costs.

• Hiring Labor: Hiring a logging crew or firewood handlers can save you time and effort, but it will add to your expenses.

  • Logging Crew Costs: Logging crews typically charge by the hour or by the volume of wood harvested. Hourly rates can range from $50 to $150+ per hour, depending on the size of the crew and the complexity of the job.
  • Firewood Handlers: You might be able to hire someone to split and stack the wood for a lower hourly rate (e.g., $15 – $30 per hour).

3. Tool Costs: Chainsaws, Splitters, and More

We’ve already discussed the chainsaw, but there are other tools to consider.

• Chainsaw Maintenance: Don’t forget about the ongoing costs of chainsaw maintenance.

  • Chain Sharpening: Dull chains are dangerous and inefficient. You can sharpen the chain yourself with a file (cost: $10 – $20) or pay a professional to sharpen it for you (cost: $10 – $20 per sharpening).
  • Chain Replacement: Chains eventually wear out and need to be replaced. Chains typically cost $20 – $50, depending on the size and type.
  • Bar Replacement: Chainsaw bars also wear out over time. Bar replacement can cost $50 – $100+.
  • Fuel and Oil: Fuel and oil are essential for running your chainsaw. A gallon of pre-mixed fuel typically costs $5 – $10. Chainsaw oil costs $10 – $20 per gallon.
  • Repairs: Chainsaws can break down, especially with heavy use. Repairs can range from minor tune-ups to major engine overhauls.

• Log Splitter: Splitting wood by hand is back-breaking work. A log splitter can significantly reduce the effort and time required.

  • Manual Log Splitter: A manual log splitter is a less expensive option ($100 – $300), but it still requires considerable physical effort.
  • Hydraulic Log Splitter: A hydraulic log splitter is much more efficient and easier to use. Prices range from $1,000 to $4,000+ for homeowner models.
  • Log Splitter Rental: Renting a log splitter can be a cost-effective option if you only need to split wood occasionally. Rental rates typically range from $50 to $150+ per day.

4. Drying and Storage Costs

Properly drying firewood is essential for efficient burning.

• Drying Time: Firewood needs to be seasoned (dried) for at least six months, and preferably longer.
• Storage Space: You’ll need a dry, well-ventilated place to store your firewood.
  • Firewood Rack: A firewood rack can help keep your firewood organized and off the ground. Prices range from $50 to $200+.
  • Tarp: A tarp can protect your firewood from rain and snow.

5. Permits and Regulations

Be aware of any local permits or regulations regarding firewood harvesting, transportation, and storage.

• Firewood Transportation Restrictions: Many states and counties have restrictions on transporting firewood to prevent the spread of invasive insects and diseases.
• Burning Restrictions: Some areas have restrictions on burning firewood, especially during periods of high air pollution.

Budgeting for Firewood: A Case Study

Let’s consider a case study to illustrate how to budget for firewood preparation.

Scenario: You want to prepare 5 cords of firewood from purchased logs. You’ll be using a chainsaw and a rented log splitter.

Cost Breakdown:

1. Log Purchase: 5 cords of hardwood logs at $150 per cord = $750
2. Chainsaw Fuel and Oil: $50
3. Log Splitter Rental: 3 days at $100 per day = $300
4. Chainsaw Maintenance (Chain Sharpening): $20 (assuming you sharpen the chain yourself)
5. Labor (DIY): 5 cords x 20 hours per cord x $20 per hour = $2000
6. Firewood Rack: $100
7. Tarp: $50

Total Cost: $750 + $50 + $300 + $20 + $2000 + $100 + $50 = $3270

Cost Per Cord: $3270 / 5 cords = $654 per cord

This case study highlights the importance of considering all the costs involved in firewood preparation. Even if you’re doing the work yourself, your labor is a significant expense.

Important Note: This is just an example. Your actual costs may vary depending on your specific circumstances.

Cost Optimization: Tips for Saving Money on Firewood

Now that we’ve explored the costs, let’s look at some ways to save money on firewood preparation.

1. Source Wood Strategically: Explore different sources of wood to find the best prices. Consider purchasing logs in bulk, harvesting your own wood (if permitted), or scavenging fallen trees.

2. Invest in Efficient Tools: While the initial investment may be higher, efficient tools like a hydraulic log splitter can save you time and effort in the long run, reducing your labor costs.

3. Maintain Your Chainsaw: Regular maintenance can prolong the life of your chainsaw and prevent costly repairs. Keep the chain sharp, clean the air filter, and lubricate the bar regularly.

4. Dry Firewood Properly: Properly seasoned firewood burns more efficiently, reducing the amount of wood you need to use.

5. Consider Wood Species: Some wood species burn hotter and longer than others. Choose wood species that are readily available and affordable in your area.

6. Join a Firewood Cooperative: Some communities have firewood cooperatives where members can share equipment and labor.

7. Look for Free Wood: Keep an eye out for free wood sources, such as tree trimming services or construction sites. They often have wood that they’re willing to give away.

8. Negotiate Prices: Don’t be afraid to negotiate prices with log suppliers or firewood dealers.

9. Use a Firewood Calculator: Online firewood calculators can help you estimate the amount of wood you need based on your heating needs.

10. Plan Ahead: Start preparing your firewood well in advance of the heating season to allow ample time for drying.

Formulas and Calculations for Wood Processing

Understanding some basic formulas and calculations can help you estimate the volume of wood and drying time.

• Cord Volume: A cord is a stacked pile of wood measuring 4 feet high, 4 feet wide, and 8 feet long, totaling 128 cubic feet.
• Board Feet: A board foot is a unit of measurement for lumber, equal to 1 inch thick, 12 inches wide, and 12 inches long.
• Estimating Drying Time: The drying time for firewood depends on several factors, including wood species, log size, and climate. As a general rule, hardwoods need to be seasoned for at least six months, while softwoods can be seasoned in as little as three months. You can use a moisture meter to check the moisture content of your firewood. Ideally, firewood should have a moisture content of less than 20%.

Challenges Faced by Small-Scale Loggers and Firewood Suppliers

Small-scale loggers and firewood suppliers face numerous challenges, including:

• Fluctuating Timber Prices: Timber prices can fluctuate significantly, making it difficult to predict profitability.
• Competition from Larger Operations: Small-scale operations often struggle to compete with larger, more efficient logging companies.
• Regulations and Permitting: Navigating the complex web of regulations and permitting requirements can be time-consuming and expensive.
• Weather Dependence: Logging and firewood preparation are heavily dependent on weather conditions.
• Equipment Costs: The cost of equipment, such as chainsaws, skidders, and log splitters, can be a significant barrier to entry.
• Labor Shortages: Finding reliable labor can be a challenge, especially in rural areas.
• Transportation Costs: Transporting logs and firewood can be expensive, especially over long distances.

Conclusion: Making Informed Choices for Firewood Success

Choosing the right chainsaw and budgeting for firewood preparation are essential for a successful and cost-effective experience. By carefully considering your needs, researching your options, and planning your budget, you can ensure that you have a reliable heat source for years to come.

Remember, the Stihl MS 271 Farm Boss and the Husqvarna 455 Rancher are both excellent chainsaws for firewood, but the best choice for you depends on your specific circumstances. Don’t be afraid to ask for advice from experienced chainsaw users and your local dealer.

And don’t forget about the other costs involved in firewood preparation, such as timber acquisition, labor, tool maintenance, and drying. By carefully budgeting for all these expenses, you can avoid surprises and ensure that your firewood project stays on track.

So, go forth, choose wisely, and enjoy the warmth of a well-prepared fire!

Learn more