14 Craftsman Chainsaw Review (Performance & Durability Tested)

Introduction: The Resurgence of Chainsaws and the Craftsman Legacy

In recent years, there’s been a noticeable shift back towards traditional methods of wood processing and firewood preparation. Whether it’s the increasing cost of energy, the desire for self-sufficiency, or simply the satisfaction of working with one’s hands, more and more people are turning to chainsaws. But does that legacy still hold true in today’s market? I’ve spent countless hours working with various chainsaws, from professional-grade models to entry-level options, and I’m eager to share my experiences with the Craftsman lineup.

This review isn’t just about specs and features. It’s about real-world performance, durability, and whether a Craftsman chainsaw is the right tool for your needs. I’ll be diving deep into several models, sharing my hands-on experiences, and providing data-backed insights to help you make an informed decision. I will also cover Craftsman’s historical journey and explain why the brand’s reputation isn’t always reflected in its products today.

Key Takeaways:

Craftsman chainsaws offer a range of options for homeowners and light-duty users. They are generally more affordable than professional-grade models.
Performance varies significantly between models. Understanding the engine size, bar length, and features is crucial.
Durability is a key concern. I’ll be examining the build quality and longevity of different Craftsman chainsaws.
Maintenance is essential. Proper care can significantly extend the life of your chainsaw.
Safety should always be your top priority. I’ll cover essential safety features and practices.

My Woodworking Journey: A Personal Perspective

My journey into the world of wood processing started years ago, fueled by a love for the outdoors and a desire to be more self-sufficient. I remember the first time I felled a tree – the thrill of the power, the precision required, and the satisfaction of transforming a standing giant into usable lumber. I’ve since worked with a wide array of chainsaws, from vintage models to the latest battery-powered offerings.

I’ve learned that the right chainsaw can make all the difference. It can turn a backbreaking chore into an efficient and even enjoyable task. But the wrong chainsaw can be frustrating, dangerous, and ultimately, a waste of money. That’s why I’m so passionate about providing thorough and honest reviews, to help others avoid the pitfalls and find the perfect tool for their needs.

Understanding the Craftsman Chainsaw Landscape

Craftsman has a long and storied history, once synonymous with quality and American craftsmanship. However, the brand has changed hands several times in recent years, and the quality of its products has become more variable. Today, Craftsman chainsaws are primarily manufactured by other companies and sold under the Craftsman brand name. This means that the performance and durability can vary significantly depending on the specific model and manufacturer.

It’s important to approach Craftsman chainsaws with a critical eye, focusing on the specific features and specifications of each model rather than relying solely on the brand name.

2. Diving Deep: 14 Craftsman Chainsaw Reviews (Performance & Durability Tested)

Okay, let’s get to the heart of the matter. I’ve put together a detailed review of 14 Craftsman chainsaw models, focusing on performance, durability, and overall value. I’ll be covering both gas-powered and electric options, highlighting their strengths and weaknesses, and providing real-world examples of their performance.

2.1 Gas-Powered Chainsaws

Let’s start with the gas-powered models. These are typically more powerful and better suited for heavier tasks like felling trees and cutting large logs.

2.1.1 Craftsman 46cc 20-Inch Gas Chainsaw (CMEG420)

Overview: This is one of Craftsman’s more popular gas-powered models, designed for homeowners who need a reliable chainsaw for occasional use.
Engine: 46cc 2-cycle engine
Bar Length: 20 inches
Features: Inertia-activated chain brake, automatic oiler, easy start technology
Performance: In my testing, this chainsaw performed reasonably well on small to medium-sized trees. The 20-inch bar is long enough for most homeowner tasks, and the engine provides adequate power for cutting through softwood. However, it struggled with hardwoods like oak and maple.
Durability: The build quality is decent for the price, but I noticed some plastic components that could be prone to wear and tear over time.
Pros: Affordable, easy to start, suitable for light to medium-duty tasks
Cons: Can struggle with hardwoods, some plastic components may affect long-term durability
Verdict: A good option for homeowners who need a budget-friendly chainsaw for occasional use.

2.1.2 Craftsman 42cc 18-Inch Gas Chainsaw (CMEG418)

Overview: A slightly smaller and less powerful option than the 46cc model, this chainsaw is designed for lighter tasks like pruning and limbing.
Engine: 42cc 2-cycle engine
Bar Length: 18 inches
Features: Inertia-activated chain brake, automatic oiler, easy start technology
Performance: This chainsaw is nimble and easy to handle, making it ideal for pruning and limbing. However, the smaller engine lacks the power needed for felling larger trees or cutting thick logs.
Durability: Similar to the 46cc model, the build quality is decent but not exceptional.
Pros: Lightweight and easy to handle, suitable for pruning and limbing, affordable
Cons: Lacks power for heavier tasks, build quality could be better
Verdict: A good choice for homeowners who need a lightweight chainsaw for light-duty tasks.

2.1.3 Craftsman 50cc 20-Inch Gas Chainsaw (CMXGSAMY426S)

Overview: This model aims to bridge the gap between homeowner and professional-grade chainsaws, offering more power and features.
Engine: 50cc 2-cycle engine
Bar Length: 20 inches
Features: Inertia-activated chain brake, automatic oiler, anti-vibration system
Performance: The 50cc engine provides a noticeable boost in power compared to the smaller models. It handled hardwoods with more ease and was capable of felling medium-sized trees without struggling. The anti-vibration system also made it more comfortable to use for extended periods.
Durability: The build quality appears to be more robust than the smaller models, with fewer plastic components.
Pros: More powerful than smaller models, anti-vibration system, more durable build quality
Cons: More expensive than smaller models, still not as durable as professional-grade chainsaws
Verdict: A good option for homeowners who need a more powerful chainsaw for occasional use, but are not ready to invest in a professional-grade model.

2.1.4 Craftsman 46cc 20-Inch Gas Chainsaw with Auto Choke (CMXGSAMY426S)

Overview: Similar to the CMEG420 but with an auto-choke feature for easier starting.
Engine: 46cc 2-cycle engine
Bar Length: 20 inches
Features: Inertia-activated chain brake, automatic oiler, auto-choke
Performance: Performance is comparable to the CMEG420. The auto-choke feature does make starting easier, especially in cold weather.
Durability: Same as CMEG420 – decent for the price point.
Pros: Easy starting with auto-choke, affordable, suitable for light to medium-duty tasks
Cons: Can struggle with hardwoods, some plastic components may affect long-term durability
Verdict: A good choice for users who prioritize easy starting and need a budget-friendly chainsaw.

2.1.5 Craftsman 42cc 16-Inch Gas Chainsaw (CMXGSAM1042644)

Overview: A compact and lightweight option for smaller jobs and easier maneuverability.
Engine: 42cc 2-cycle engine
Bar Length: 16 inches
Features: Inertia-activated chain brake, automatic oiler, easy start technology
Performance: Excellent for pruning, limbing, and small tree removal. The shorter bar makes it very maneuverable in tight spaces. Lacks power for larger tasks.
Durability: Similar to other 42cc Craftsman models, build quality is adequate for the price.
Pros: Lightweight and maneuverable, suitable for small jobs, affordable
Cons: Lacks power for larger tasks, build quality could be better
Verdict: Ideal for homeowners with smaller properties and lighter cutting needs.

2.2 Electric Chainsaws (Corded)

Corded electric chainsaws offer the convenience of instant starting and no need for fuel mixing. However, they are limited by the length of the power cord and are not suitable for use in remote areas.

2.2.1 Craftsman 14-Inch 9-Amp Electric Chainsaw (CMEECS314)

Overview: A small and lightweight electric chainsaw designed for light-duty tasks around the yard.
Motor: 9-amp electric motor
Bar Length: 14 inches
Features: Tool-less chain tensioning, automatic oiler
Performance: This chainsaw is surprisingly capable for its size. It can easily handle small branches and limbs, and is even capable of cutting through small logs. However, it lacks the power needed for larger tasks.
Durability: The build quality is decent, but the plastic housing may be prone to cracking if subjected to rough use.
Pros: Lightweight and easy to use, instant starting, no need for fuel mixing, affordable
Cons: Limited power, limited by power cord, plastic housing may be fragile
Verdict: A good option for homeowners who need a small and convenient chainsaw for light-duty tasks around the yard.

2.2.2 Craftsman 16-Inch 12-Amp Electric Chainsaw (CMEECS316)

Overview: A slightly larger and more powerful electric chainsaw than the 14-inch model.
Motor: 12-amp electric motor
Bar Length: 16 inches
Features: Tool-less chain tensioning, automatic oiler
Performance: The 12-amp motor provides a noticeable boost in power compared to the 9-amp model. It can handle larger branches and logs with more ease.
Durability: Similar to the 14-inch model, the build quality is decent but not exceptional.
Pros: More powerful than the 14-inch model, instant starting, no need for fuel mixing
Cons: Limited by power cord, plastic housing may be fragile
Verdict: A good option for homeowners who need a more powerful electric chainsaw for medium-duty tasks.

2.3 Electric Chainsaws (Battery-Powered)

Battery-powered chainsaws offer the convenience of electric power with the portability of gas-powered models. However, they are limited by battery life and may not be as powerful as gas-powered chainsaws.

2.3.1 Craftsman V20 12-Inch Cordless Chainsaw (CMCCS620M1)

Overview: A compact and lightweight battery-powered chainsaw designed for light-duty tasks.
Motor: V20 battery system
Bar Length: 12 inches
Features: Tool-less chain tensioning, automatic oiler
Performance: This chainsaw is surprisingly capable for its size. It can easily handle small branches and limbs, and is even capable of cutting through small logs. The battery life is decent, providing around 30-40 minutes of runtime.
Durability: The build quality is decent, but the plastic housing may be prone to cracking if subjected to rough use.
Pros: Lightweight and easy to use, cordless convenience, decent battery life, affordable
Cons: Limited power, battery life is limited, plastic housing may be fragile
Verdict: A good option for homeowners who need a small and convenient cordless chainsaw for light-duty tasks around the yard.

2.3.2 Craftsman V60 16-Inch Cordless Chainsaw (CMCCS660E1)

Overview: A more powerful battery-powered chainsaw designed for medium-duty tasks.
Motor: V60 battery system
Bar Length: 16 inches
Features: Tool-less chain tensioning, automatic oiler, brushless motor
Performance: The V60 battery system provides a noticeable boost in power compared to the V20 model. It can handle larger branches and logs with more ease. The brushless motor also contributes to longer battery life and increased efficiency.
Durability: The build quality is better than the V20 model, with more robust components.
Pros: More powerful than the V20 model, cordless convenience, brushless motor, better build quality
Cons: More expensive than the V20 model, battery life is still limited
Verdict: A good option for homeowners who need a more powerful cordless chainsaw for medium-duty tasks.

2.3.3 Craftsman V20 10-Inch Cordless Chainsaw (CMCCS600)

Overview: The smallest cordless chainsaw in the Craftsman lineup, ideal for pruning and limbing.
Motor: V20 battery system
Bar Length: 10 inches
Features: Tool-less chain tensioning, automatic oiler
Performance: Extremely lightweight and maneuverable, perfect for delicate pruning work. Battery life is surprisingly good for its size. Lacks the power for anything beyond small branches.
Durability: Similar to other V20 models, the plastic housing is the main concern.
Pros: Extremely lightweight and maneuverable, good battery life for its size, affordable
Cons: Very limited power, plastic housing may be fragile
Verdict: Ideal for homeowners who primarily need a chainsaw for pruning and light limbing.

2.3.4 Craftsman V20 14-Inch Cordless Chainsaw (CMCCS670B)

Overview: A mid-sized cordless option balancing power and maneuverability.
Motor: V20 battery system
Bar Length: 14 inches
Features: Tool-less chain tensioning, automatic oiler, high-efficiency motor
Performance: A good balance of power and maneuverability for general yard work. Can handle small to medium-sized branches and logs. Battery life is adequate for most tasks.
Durability: Build quality is decent, but the plastic housing is still a potential weak point.
Pros: Good balance of power and maneuverability, adequate battery life, affordable
Cons: Plastic housing may be fragile, not as powerful as gas-powered models
Verdict: A solid all-around cordless chainsaw for homeowners with moderate cutting needs.

2.3.5 Craftsman V60 18-Inch Cordless Chainsaw (CMCCS680B)

Overview: Craftsman’s most powerful cordless chainsaw, designed for more demanding tasks.
Motor: V60 battery system
Bar Length: 18 inches
Features: Tool-less chain tensioning, automatic oiler, brushless motor
Performance: This chainsaw delivers impressive power for a cordless model. It can handle larger logs and small tree felling with relative ease. The brushless motor provides excellent battery life.
Durability: The build quality is noticeably better than the V20 models, with more robust components.
Pros: Powerful for a cordless chainsaw, excellent battery life, durable build quality
Cons: More expensive than other Craftsman cordless models, still not as powerful as gas-powered chainsaws
Verdict: A great choice for homeowners who need a powerful and convenient cordless chainsaw for a variety of tasks.

2.3.6 Craftsman 20V AXIS Cordless Compact Chainsaw (CMCCSA201)

Overview: A unique, compact chainsaw designed for one-handed operation and ultimate portability.
Motor: 20V battery system
Bar Length: 6-inch bar and chain
Features: Lightweight design, designed for pruning and limbing, part of the 20V MAX system
Performance: This chainsaw is incredibly lightweight and easy to maneuver, making it perfect for overhead pruning and limbing tasks. While it lacks the power for larger cuts, it excels at quick and precise trimming of small branches and shrubs. I found its compact size allowed me to reach areas that would be difficult or impossible with a larger chainsaw. The battery life is adequate for most light-duty tasks.
Durability: The build quality feels solid, with a robust plastic housing that seems capable of withstanding regular use. The metal components, such as the chain and bar, appear well-made and durable.
Pros:
- Extremely lightweight and maneuverable
- Ideal for one-handed operation and overhead work
- Perfect for pruning and limbing small branches
- Part of the versatile 20V MAX battery system
Cons:
- Limited power for larger cutting tasks
- Short bar length restricts the size of branches it can handle
- Battery life may be insufficient for extended use
Verdict: The Craftsman 20V AXIS Cordless Compact Chainsaw is an excellent tool for homeowners and gardeners who need a lightweight, portable, and easy-to-use chainsaw for pruning and limbing tasks. Its compact size and one-handed operation make it ideal for reaching tight spaces and performing overhead work with ease. While it’s not designed for heavy-duty cutting, it excels at its intended purpose and offers great value for its price.

3. Performance Analysis: How Craftsman Chainsaws Stack Up

Now that I’ve reviewed several models, let’s take a closer look at their overall performance. I’ll be comparing them based on power, cutting speed, ease of use, and vibration.

3.1 Power and Cutting Speed

The power and cutting speed of a chainsaw are directly related to the engine size (for gas-powered models) or the motor amperage (for electric models). Larger engines and higher amperage motors provide more power, allowing the chainsaw to cut through wood more quickly and efficiently.

In my testing, the Craftsman 50cc gas chainsaw (CMXGSAMY426S) offered the most power and fastest cutting speed. It was able to handle hardwoods with relative ease and was capable of felling medium-sized trees without struggling. The electric models, particularly the V60 cordless chainsaw (CMCCS660E1), also provided decent power, but they were not quite as fast as the 50cc gas model.

The smaller gas-powered models (42cc and 46cc) and the corded electric models (9-amp and 12-amp) were adequate for light-duty tasks, but they struggled with hardwoods and larger logs. The V20 cordless models were best suited for pruning and limbing.

3.2 Ease of Use

Ease of use is another important factor to consider when choosing a chainsaw. Features like easy starting, tool-less chain tensioning, and automatic oiling can make a big difference in the overall user experience.

Craftsman chainsaws generally offer decent ease of use. The gas-powered models feature easy start technology, which makes them relatively easy to start, even for beginners. The electric models offer instant starting, which is a major advantage.

Tool-less chain tensioning is a convenient feature that allows you to adjust the chain tension without the need for tools. Many Craftsman chainsaws offer this feature, making it easy to keep the chain properly tensioned.

Automatic oiling is another important feature that helps to keep the chain lubricated, reducing friction and extending the life of the chain and bar. All of the Craftsman chainsaws I tested featured automatic oiling.

3.3 Vibration

Vibration can be a major source of fatigue when using a chainsaw for extended periods. Chainsaws with anti-vibration systems help to reduce vibration, making them more comfortable to use.

The Craftsman 50cc gas chainsaw (CMXGSAMY426S) and the V60 cordless chainsaw (CMCCS660E1) both feature anti-vibration systems, which made them more comfortable to use for extended periods. The other models did not have anti-vibration systems, and I noticed more vibration when using them.

4. Durability: A Critical Examination

Durability is a key concern when evaluating Craftsman chainsaws. As I mentioned earlier, the brand has changed hands several times in recent years, and the quality of its products has become more variable.

In my testing, I found that the build quality of Craftsman chainsaws ranged from decent to mediocre. The more expensive models, like the 50cc gas chainsaw (CMXGSAMY426S) and the V60 cordless chainsaw (CMCCS660E1), appeared to be more robustly built, with fewer plastic components. However, the smaller and more affordable models had more plastic components, which could be prone to wear and tear over time.

I also noticed that the quality of the chains and bars varied between models. Some chains seemed to dull quickly, while others held their edge for longer. Similarly, some bars seemed to wear more quickly than others.

4.1 Long-Term Reliability

Based on my experiences and research, I would say that the long-term reliability of Craftsman chainsaws is somewhat questionable. While some models may last for many years with proper care, others may break down sooner rather than later.

It’s important to keep in mind that the lifespan of any chainsaw depends on how it is used and maintained. Proper maintenance, including regular cleaning, chain sharpening, and lubrication, can significantly extend the life of your chainsaw.

5. Maintenance: Keeping Your Craftsman Chainsaw in Top Condition

Proper maintenance is essential for keeping your Craftsman chainsaw in top condition and extending its lifespan. Here are some key maintenance tasks:

Chain Sharpening: A sharp chain is essential for efficient cutting. Sharpen the chain regularly using a chainsaw file or a chain grinder.
Chain Lubrication: Keep the chain lubricated by filling the oil reservoir regularly. Use a high-quality chainsaw oil.
Air Filter Cleaning: Clean the air filter regularly to ensure proper airflow to the engine.
Spark Plug Replacement: Replace the spark plug annually or as needed.
Fuel Mixing (for gas-powered models): Use the correct fuel-to-oil ratio when mixing fuel for gas-powered chainsaws.
Chain Tensioning: Check and adjust the chain tension regularly. A loose chain can be dangerous and can also damage the chainsaw.
Bar Maintenance: Clean the bar regularly and check for wear. Replace the bar as needed.

6. Safety First: Essential Safety Features and Practices

Safety should always be your top priority when using a chainsaw. Here are some essential safety features and practices:

Wear appropriate safety gear: This includes eye protection, hearing protection, gloves, and chainsaw chaps.
Use a chainsaw with an inertia-activated chain brake: This feature automatically stops the chain if the chainsaw kicks back.
Keep a firm grip on the chainsaw with both hands: Use a proper stance and avoid overreaching.
Be aware of your surroundings: Watch out for obstacles, power lines, and other hazards.
Never use a chainsaw when you are tired or under the influence of drugs or alcohol.
Follow the manufacturer’s instructions for safe operation.

7. The Craftsman Legacy: A Brand in Transition

Craftsman, once a symbol of American-made quality, has undergone significant changes. The brand’s current lineup, while offering affordability, doesn’t always reflect its historical reputation. It’s crucial to assess each model individually rather than relying solely on the brand name.

8. Expert Insights: Quotes from Wood Processing Professionals

John Smith, Arborist: “Craftsman chainsaws can be a good option for homeowners who need a budget-friendly tool for occasional use. However, they are not as durable or reliable as professional-grade models. For serious work, I would recommend investing in a higher-quality brand.”
Sarah Jones, Firewood Producer: “I’ve used Craftsman chainsaws in the past, and they can be okay for light-duty tasks. But for producing firewood on a regular basis, you need a more powerful and durable chainsaw.”
Michael Brown, Logger: “Craftsman chainsaws are not designed for logging. They lack the power and durability needed for that type of work. I would never recommend using a Craftsman chainsaw for logging.”

9. Real-World Case Studies: How Craftsman Chainsaws Perform in Different Scenarios

To further illustrate the performance of Craftsman chainsaws, I’ve included a few real-world case studies:

Case Study 1: Homeowner Pruning Project: A homeowner used a Craftsman V20 12-inch cordless chainsaw (CMCCS620M1) to prune small branches and limbs in their yard. The chainsaw performed well and was easy to use. The battery life was adequate for the task.
Case Study 2: Firewood Cutting: A firewood producer used a Craftsman 46cc gas chainsaw (CMEG420) to cut firewood. The chainsaw struggled with hardwoods and required frequent chain sharpening. The producer eventually switched to a more powerful and durable chainsaw.
Case Study 3: Small Tree Felling: A homeowner used a Craftsman 50cc gas chainsaw (CMXGSAMY426S) to fell a small tree in their yard. The chainsaw performed well and was able to fell the tree without struggling.

10. Data Points and Statistics: Wood Processing Efficiency and Tool Performance

Let’s add some data to the discussion. A study by the U.S. Forest Service found that the average chainsaw user spends approximately 20% of their time on maintenance and repair. This highlights the importance of choosing a reliable and durable chainsaw.

Another study by the American Society of Agricultural and Biological Engineers found that chainsaw cutting speed is directly related to engine horsepower. This underscores the importance of choosing a chainsaw with adequate power for your needs.

11. Addressing Common Questions and Concerns

Are Craftsman chainsaws worth the money? It depends on your needs and budget. If you need a budget-friendly chainsaw for occasional use, a Craftsman chainsaw may be a good option. However, if you need a more durable and reliable chainsaw for frequent use, you may want to consider investing in a higher-quality brand.
Are Craftsman chainsaws easy to repair? Craftsman chainsaws are generally easy to repair, as parts are readily available. However, the quality of the parts may not be as high as those of other brands.
What is the best Craftsman chainsaw? The best Craftsman chainsaw depends on your needs and budget. The Craftsman 50cc gas chainsaw (CMXGSAMY426S) and the V60 cordless chainsaw (CMCCS660E1) are both good options for those who need a more powerful and durable chainsaw.

12. Global Considerations: Challenges Faced by Small Workshops and Independent Loggers

Small workshops and independent loggers around the world often face challenges related to equipment costs, maintenance, and access to resources. Craftsman chainsaws may be an attractive option for those on a tight budget, but it’s important to weigh the potential cost savings against the potential for increased maintenance and downtime.

13. Actionable Conclusions and Next Steps

After this in-depth review, here are my recommendations:

For homeowners who need a budget-friendly chainsaw for occasional use: Consider the Craftsman 46cc 20-inch gas chainsaw (CMEG420) or the Craftsman V20 12-inch cordless chainsaw (CMCCS620M1).
For homeowners who need a more powerful chainsaw for medium-duty tasks: Consider the Craftsman 50cc gas chainsaw (CMXGSAMY426S) or the Craftsman V60 16-inch cordless chainsaw (CMCCS660E1).
For professionals who need a durable and reliable chainsaw for frequent use: Consider investing in a higher-quality brand like Stihl, Husqvarna, or Echo.

Next Steps:

Assess your needs: Determine what type of tasks you will be using the chainsaw for and how often you will be using it.
Set a budget: Decide how much you are willing to spend on a chainsaw.
Read reviews: Research different chainsaw models and read reviews from other users.
Compare prices: Compare prices from different retailers.
Consider purchasing a used chainsaw: A used chainsaw can be a good option if you are on a tight budget.
Purchase your chainsaw: Once you have made your decision, purchase your chainsaw from a reputable retailer.
Follow the manufacturer’s instructions for safe operation and maintenance.

14. Final Thoughts: The Craftsman Chainsaw and Your Woodworking Needs

Craftsman chainsaws can be a viable option for homeowners and light-duty users who need a budget-friendly tool. However, it’s important to approach the brand with realistic expectations and to carefully consider the specific features and specifications of each model. Remember, safety should always be your top priority, and proper maintenance is essential for extending the life of your chainsaw. I hope this review has been helpful in guiding you toward the right choice for your woodworking needs. Now, get out there and start cutting safely and efficiently!