Stihl Old Chainsaw vs New Models (5 Pro Logging Insights)

Are you standing at a crossroads, pondering whether to stick with your trusty, old Stihl chainsaw, a machine that’s been with you through thick and thin, or to embrace the allure of the latest models boasting cutting-edge technology? It’s a dilemma I’ve faced countless times in my years of logging and firewood preparation, and it’s not a simple one. The answer isn’t always clear-cut, and it depends heavily on your specific needs, budget, and even your personal preferences.

In this article, I will share five professional logging insights to help you make an informed decision about whether to upgrade to a new Stihl chainsaw or stick with your old faithful. We’ll dive deep into the pros and cons of both, covering everything from performance and fuel efficiency to maintenance and overall cost-effectiveness.

Understanding the Basics: Key Terms and Concepts

Before we get into the specifics, let’s define a few key terms that will be essential throughout this discussion:

• Green Wood: Wood that has been freshly cut and contains a high moisture content. This type of wood is heavier and more difficult to cut than seasoned wood.
• Seasoned Wood: Wood that has been allowed to dry, reducing its moisture content. Seasoned wood is lighter, easier to cut, and burns more efficiently in a fireplace or wood stove.
• Bar Length: The length of the chainsaw bar, which determines the maximum diameter of wood that can be cut.
• Displacement: The engine size of the chainsaw, measured in cubic centimeters (cc). Higher displacement generally means more power.
• Power-to-Weight Ratio: A measure of how much power a chainsaw produces relative to its weight. A higher power-to-weight ratio indicates a more efficient and easier-to-handle saw.
• Two-Stroke Engine: An engine that completes a power cycle with two strokes of the piston, requiring a mixture of gasoline and oil for lubrication.
• Four-Stroke Engine: An engine that completes a power cycle with four strokes of the piston, using separate oil and gasoline systems.
• Chainsaw Chain Pitch: The distance between three consecutive rivets on the chain, divided by two. Common pitches are .325″, 3/8″, and .404″.
• Chainsaw Chain Gauge: The thickness of the drive links on the chain, which fit into the bar groove. Common gauges are .050″, .058″, and .063″.

Insight #1: Performance – Bridging the Gap Between Old and New

The Allure of Modern Power:

Newer Stihl chainsaw models often boast significant improvements in engine technology, leading to enhanced performance. This translates to:

• Increased Power: Modern engines are designed to deliver more power with the same or even smaller displacement. I’ve personally seen a noticeable difference when felling larger trees with a new MS 462 R C-M compared to an older MS 460. The MS 462 R C-M, despite having a similar displacement, offers a higher power output and faster cutting speed.
• Improved Fuel Efficiency: Newer models often incorporate fuel injection and stratified scavenging technologies, resulting in better fuel economy. I’ve tracked fuel consumption on both my old MS 290 and a newer MS 271, and the MS 271 consistently uses about 15-20% less fuel for the same amount of work.
• Reduced Emissions: Modern chainsaws are designed to meet stricter emission standards, making them more environmentally friendly. This is important not just for the environment but also for your own health, as reduced emissions mean less exposure to harmful exhaust fumes.
• Smoother Operation: Advancements in vibration dampening and ergonomic design make newer chainsaws more comfortable to use for extended periods.

The Enduring Reliability of Old Models:

While newer chainsaws offer performance advantages, older Stihl models are often praised for their robust construction and reliability.

• Simplicity: Older chainsaws tend to have simpler designs, making them easier to diagnose and repair. I can recall many times when I was able to fix a problem with my old MS 290 in the field with just a few basic tools, something that would be much more difficult with a more complex, electronically controlled model.
• Durability: Many older Stihl chainsaws were built with heavier-duty components, making them more resistant to wear and tear. I’ve seen MS 290s and MS 310s still running strong after decades of use, a testament to their durability.
• Cost-Effectiveness: Used or refurbished older models can be a very affordable option, especially if you’re on a tight budget. You can often find a well-maintained older Stihl chainsaw for a fraction of the price of a new model.

The Trade-Off:

Ultimately, the choice between old and new comes down to a trade-off between performance and reliability. Newer models offer more power and efficiency, but they may also be more complex and potentially less durable. Older models may not be as powerful or efficient, but they are often simpler, more reliable, and more affordable.

My Experience:

I have found that newer Stihl chainsaws are generally better suited for professional logging operations where speed and efficiency are paramount. However, for occasional use around the home or on a small property, an older, well-maintained model can be a perfectly viable option.

Insight #2: Maintenance – The Devil is in the Details

The Simplicity of Old Chainsaws:

• Easy to Diagnose: Older Stihl chainsaws, particularly those without electronic components, are generally easier to diagnose and repair. I’ve often been able to troubleshoot problems with my old MS 290 simply by visually inspecting the carburetor, fuel lines, and spark plug.
• Readily Available Parts: Parts for older Stihl chainsaws are often readily available and relatively inexpensive. You can typically find replacement parts at local hardware stores, online retailers, or even from other loggers.
• Simple Repairs: Many repairs on older chainsaws can be performed with basic tools and a little mechanical know-how. I’ve replaced carburetors, fuel lines, and spark plugs on my old MS 290 countless times, and it’s a relatively straightforward process.

The Complexity of New Chainsaws:

• Electronic Components: Newer Stihl chainsaws often incorporate electronic components, such as fuel injection systems and electronic ignition modules. These components can improve performance and efficiency, but they can also be more difficult to diagnose and repair.
• Specialized Tools: Some repairs on newer chainsaws may require specialized tools and diagnostic equipment. For example, you may need a diagnostic scanner to troubleshoot problems with the fuel injection system.
• Professional Service: Complex repairs on newer chainsaws may require the expertise of a qualified technician. This can be costly, especially if you live in a remote area.

The Importance of Regular Maintenance:

Regardless of whether you choose an old or new Stihl chainsaw, regular maintenance is essential to ensure its longevity and performance. This includes:

• Sharpening the Chain: A sharp chain is essential for efficient cutting and reducing wear and tear on the engine. I recommend sharpening the chain after every few hours of use, or whenever you notice that it’s not cutting as smoothly as it should.
  • Technique: Use a round file that matches the pitch of your chain. File each tooth at the correct angle, following the manufacturer’s instructions.
  • Tools: Round file, file guide, depth gauge tool.
• Cleaning the Air Filter: A clean air filter ensures that the engine receives adequate airflow, preventing it from running lean and overheating. I recommend cleaning the air filter after every day of use.
  • Technique: Remove the air filter and tap it gently to remove loose debris. If the filter is heavily soiled, you can wash it with warm soapy water and allow it to dry completely before reinstalling it.
  • Tools: Soft brush, warm soapy water.
• Checking the Spark Plug: A properly functioning spark plug is essential for reliable ignition. I recommend checking the spark plug every few months and replacing it if necessary.
  • Technique: Remove the spark plug and inspect it for signs of wear or damage. The electrode should be clean and dry, and the gap should be within the manufacturer’s specifications.
  • Tools: Spark plug wrench, spark plug gap tool.
• Lubricating the Bar and Chain: Proper lubrication is essential for reducing friction and wear on the bar and chain. I recommend using a high-quality bar and chain oil and checking the oil level frequently.
  • Technique: Fill the oil reservoir with bar and chain oil. Check the oil level frequently and refill as needed.
  • Tools: Bar and chain oil, funnel.
• Inspecting the Fuel Lines: Fuel lines can deteriorate over time, leading to leaks and fuel starvation. I recommend inspecting the fuel lines regularly and replacing them if necessary.
  • Technique: Visually inspect the fuel lines for cracks, leaks, or other signs of damage.
  • Tools: Screwdriver, pliers.

My Experience:

I’ve learned the hard way that neglecting maintenance can lead to costly repairs and downtime. I once ignored a clogged air filter on my MS 290, and it resulted in a damaged piston and cylinder. The repair cost me several hundred dollars and kept me out of the woods for a week. Now, I make it a point to perform regular maintenance on all of my chainsaws, and it has saved me a lot of time and money in the long run.

Insight #3: Cost-Effectiveness – Beyond the Initial Price Tag

The Initial Investment:

• New Chainsaws: New Stihl chainsaws can be a significant investment, especially if you’re looking at professional-grade models. The price can range from a few hundred dollars for a homeowner model to over a thousand dollars for a professional logging saw.
• Used Chainsaws: Used Stihl chainsaws can be a much more affordable option, but it’s important to carefully inspect them before you buy. Look for signs of wear and tear, such as cracks, leaks, or excessive vibration.
• Refurbished Chainsaws: Refurbished Stihl chainsaws are typically sold by authorized dealers or repair shops. These saws have been inspected and repaired, and they often come with a warranty. They can be a good compromise between the cost of a new saw and the risk of buying a used saw.

Operating Costs:

• Fuel Consumption: Newer Stihl chainsaws tend to be more fuel-efficient than older models. This can save you money on fuel costs over the long run, especially if you use your chainsaw frequently. As mentioned before, I save approximately 15-20% on fuel when using my MS 271 compared to my older MS 290.
• Oil Consumption: Proper lubrication is essential for reducing wear and tear on the bar and chain. I recommend using a high-quality bar and chain oil, which can be more expensive than cheaper alternatives.
• Maintenance Costs: Regular maintenance is essential to prevent costly repairs. This includes sharpening the chain, cleaning the air filter, checking the spark plug, and lubricating the bar and chain.
• Repair Costs: Repairs can be a significant expense, especially if you need to take your chainsaw to a professional repair shop. Newer chainsaws with electronic components may be more expensive to repair than older, simpler models.

Long-Term Value:

• Durability: Older Stihl chainsaws are often praised for their durability and longevity. If you take good care of your chainsaw, it can last for many years, making it a good long-term investment.
• Resale Value: Stihl chainsaws generally hold their value well, especially if they are well-maintained. You may be able to sell your old chainsaw for a decent price when you’re ready to upgrade.

Case Study:

I once helped a friend who runs a small firewood business evaluate his chainsaw fleet. He was using a mix of older Stihl MS 290s and MS 310s. We compared the operating costs of these saws to the cost of purchasing new MS 271s. After analyzing fuel consumption, maintenance costs, and potential repair costs, we determined that upgrading to the newer models would result in significant cost savings over the long run, primarily due to improved fuel efficiency and reduced downtime. He invested in three new MS 271s, and within two years, the savings had offset the initial investment.

My Experience:

I’ve found that it’s important to consider the total cost of ownership when evaluating the cost-effectiveness of a chainsaw. This includes not only the initial purchase price but also the ongoing operating and maintenance costs. While a new chainsaw may be more expensive upfront, it can be a better investment in the long run if it’s more fuel-efficient, requires less maintenance, and is less likely to break down.

Insight #4: Ergonomics and Safety – Protecting Yourself in the Woods

Weight and Balance:

• Newer Models: Newer Stihl chainsaws often feature improved weight distribution and ergonomic designs, making them more comfortable to use for extended periods. I’ve noticed a significant difference in fatigue levels when using a newer MS 261 C-M compared to an older MS 260, even though the weight difference is relatively small. The improved balance of the MS 261 C-M makes it feel lighter and easier to control.
• Older Models: Older Stihl chainsaws may be heavier and less ergonomically designed, which can lead to fatigue and increase the risk of injury.

Vibration Dampening:

• Newer Models: Newer Stihl chainsaws often incorporate advanced vibration dampening systems, reducing the amount of vibration transmitted to the operator’s hands and arms. This can help prevent conditions like “white finger” (vibration-induced white finger), a painful and debilitating condition caused by prolonged exposure to vibration.
• Older Models: Older Stihl chainsaws may have less effective vibration dampening systems, increasing the risk of vibration-related injuries.

Safety Features:

• Chain Brake: All Stihl chainsaws, both old and new, are equipped with a chain brake, which is a safety device that stops the chain from rotating in the event of a kickback. It’s crucial to ensure that the chain brake is functioning properly before each use.
• Chain Catcher: A chain catcher is a small metal or plastic piece located near the bar that helps to prevent the chain from flying back towards the operator in the event of a chain break.
• Throttle Lockout: A throttle lockout prevents the operator from accidentally engaging the throttle, reducing the risk of accidental cuts.

Personal Protective Equipment (PPE):

Regardless of whether you choose an old or new Stihl chainsaw, it’s essential to wear appropriate PPE when operating a chainsaw. This includes:

• Chainsaw Chaps: Chainsaw chaps are designed to protect your legs from cuts in the event of a chainsaw accident.
• Safety Glasses: Safety glasses protect your eyes from flying debris.
• Hearing Protection: Hearing protection protects your ears from the loud noise of the chainsaw.
• Gloves: Gloves provide a better grip on the chainsaw and protect your hands from cuts and abrasions.
• Steel-Toed Boots: Steel-toed boots protect your feet from falling logs and other hazards.
• Hard Hat: A hard hat protects your head from falling branches and other overhead hazards.

My Experience:

I’ve witnessed firsthand the importance of safety when operating a chainsaw. I once saw a logger who wasn’t wearing chainsaw chaps accidentally cut his leg with a chainsaw. He suffered a serious injury that required extensive medical treatment. I always wear appropriate PPE when operating a chainsaw, and I encourage everyone else to do the same.

Insight #5: Application – Matching the Saw to the Task

Light-Duty Tasks:

• Examples: Pruning small branches, cutting firewood for occasional use, clearing brush.
• Suitable Chainsaws: Smaller, lighter chainsaws with shorter bar lengths (14-16 inches) are typically sufficient for light-duty tasks. Older models like the Stihl MS 170 or MS 180, or newer models like the MS 171 or MS 181, are good choices for these tasks.

Medium-Duty Tasks:

• Examples: Felling small to medium-sized trees, cutting firewood for regular use, storm cleanup.
• Suitable Chainsaws: Medium-sized chainsaws with moderate power and bar lengths (16-18 inches) are suitable for medium-duty tasks. Older models like the Stihl MS 250 or MS 290, or newer models like the MS 261 C-M or MS 271, are good choices for these tasks.

Heavy-Duty Tasks:

• Examples: Felling large trees, logging operations, cutting large amounts of firewood.
• Suitable Chainsaws: Larger, more powerful chainsaws with longer bar lengths (20 inches or more) are necessary for heavy-duty tasks. Older models like the Stihl MS 460 or MS 660, or newer models like the MS 462 R C-M or MS 661 C-M, are good choices for these tasks.

Wood Type Considerations:

• Softwoods: Softwoods, such as pine, fir, and spruce, are generally easier to cut than hardwoods.
• Hardwoods: Hardwoods, such as oak, maple, and hickory, are denser and more difficult to cut than softwoods.
• Green Wood: Green wood is more difficult to cut than seasoned wood due to its high moisture content.
• Frozen Wood: Frozen wood can be extremely difficult to cut and can dull the chain quickly.

Case Study:

I was once hired to clear a large area of land that was overgrown with a mix of small trees, brush, and vines. I initially tried to use my MS 261 C-M, but it was too small and underpowered for the task. I switched to my MS 462 R C-M, and it made the job much easier and faster. The larger saw had the power and bar length necessary to cut through the dense vegetation quickly and efficiently.

My Experience:

I’ve learned that it’s important to match the chainsaw to the task at hand. Using a chainsaw that is too small or underpowered can be frustrating and inefficient, while using a chainsaw that is too large or powerful can be dangerous and tiring. Consider the types of tasks you’ll be performing and the types of wood you’ll be cutting when choosing a chainsaw.

Conclusion: Making the Right Choice for You

Choosing between an old Stihl chainsaw and a new model is a personal decision that depends on your individual needs, budget, and preferences. There is no single “right” answer.

Here’s a recap of the key insights we’ve discussed:

• Performance: Newer models offer improved power, fuel efficiency, and reduced emissions, but older models are often simpler and more reliable.
• Maintenance: Older models are generally easier to diagnose and repair, while newer models may require specialized tools and expertise.
• Cost-Effectiveness: Consider the total cost of ownership, including the initial purchase price, operating costs, and maintenance costs.
• Ergonomics and Safety: Newer models often feature improved weight distribution, vibration dampening, and safety features.
• Application: Match the chainsaw to the task at hand, considering the size of the trees you’ll be felling and the type of wood you’ll be cutting.

Next Steps:

1. Assess Your Needs: Carefully consider the types of tasks you’ll be performing and the types of wood you’ll be cutting.
2. Set a Budget: Determine how much you’re willing to spend on a chainsaw.
3. Research Your Options: Research different Stihl chainsaw models, both old and new, and compare their features and specifications.
4. Inspect Used Chainsaws Carefully: If you’re considering buying a used chainsaw, inspect it carefully for signs of wear and tear.
5. Consider a Refurbished Chainsaw: A refurbished chainsaw can be a good compromise between the cost of a new saw and the risk of buying a used saw.
6. Prioritize Safety: Always wear appropriate PPE when operating a chainsaw, and ensure that the chainsaw is in good working order.

Ultimately, the best way to decide whether to stick with your old Stihl chainsaw or upgrade to a new model is to try them both out and see which one feels best for you. Visit your local Stihl dealer and ask to test out different models. Talk to other loggers and firewood cutters and get their opinions. With a little research and experimentation, you can make the right choice for your needs. And remember, whether you’re using an old faithful or a brand-new machine, always prioritize safety and responsible forestry practices. Happy cutting!

Learn more